Download Dashlane for free on your first device by clicking here http://bit.ly/2RC3J9f and automatically get a 30 day free trial of premium! No credit card required at signup!
In this documentary on ancient warfare we look specifically at artillery. We review the evolution of ancient artillery in the west before covering the history of its adoption by the Roman army. Next the documentary turns to the types of torsion artillery from the humble scorpion to the impressive ballistas capable of shooting up to 1 km. Finally we conclude by looking at the historical use of artillery by the Roman army in battle. This sheds light on the historical accuracy of films like Gladiator which often depict massive artillery barrages in combat.
Literary Sources: "The Roman Army" by Adrian Goldsworthy "Greek and Roman Artillery" by Duncan B. Campbell
I love the movie Gladiator and its opening scene is truly one of my favorites in Hollywood
history.
The might of the legions is on full display as it advances under the protective cover
of an artillery barrage.
You can see this type of sequence in many other films where the director is clearly
looking to craft an epic shot.
The siege of Winterfell is one such example where the cool factor was dialed up so high
that it strained credulity.
This made me wonder how powerful and how prevalent was ancient artillery, and more specifically,
was it used in pitched battles as we so commonly see depicted in Hollywood?
In this video, we'll be using the Roman army as our primary subject for discussion.
As always, I'll provide you with tons of context.
Feel free to refer to the following timestamps if you want to jump ahead.
Basically we'll start with the evolution of artillery, then talk about the types of
While making these videos, I spend a lot of time on the web purchasing books, subscribing
to scholarly journals, and watching history documentaries.
All of this requires me to input all sorts of sensitive information, which poses a risk
to my online security.
Luckily our sponsor Dashlane has a solution that I've found very helpful.
Dashlane is your one-stop shop for bringing together all of your online information under
one safe roof.
The software basically allows you to create a single account with a master password that
The digital wallet lets you quickly autofill details for shopping, while the password manager
makes remembering passwords super easy.
A particularly awesome feature actually allows you to generate new, complex passwords automatically
on the fly, which get remembered by your master account, so you don't have to manually keep
a list by your desk, or try to remember which version of that same password you used for
this specific website.
Honestly, it's been a lifesaver for me, and I can't recommend it enough.
Dashlane is available for free on your first device, so click the link in the description
below and get an additional 30-day free trial of Premium to unlock more devices and features.
Best of all, no credit card is required at signup.
Alright, let's start with an overview of how this technology was developed.
For starters, it should be stated that artillery in the West was largely an invention championed
by the Greek world.
The first pioneers in this field appear to have gotten started by seeking to upgrade
the bow.
In the 5th century BC, the efforts of engineers in places like Miletus, Tarentum, and Syracuse
essentially led to the development of large composite bows with immense power.
The initial problem here was to devise a way to draw such devices.
Some simply called for the user to rest the weapon against the ground and push down with
their whole body weight, an act which earned them the name belly shooters.
However, the breakthroughs would start to come as engineers devised various forms of
winched pull-back systems.
In these matters, it appears that the tyrant, Denysius of Syracuse, took quite an interest.
His fortified city was often the target of attack and had been waging a number of wars
against the Carthaginians in Sicily.
He therefore made great efforts to import talent from across the Greek world and to
patronize the development of new weapons of war.
It is here, in about 400 BC, that we see the early bow machines get developed into something
more robust that went from being a bulky hand weapon to a true crude artillery piece.
Soon after, it appears that this technology began to seep across the Greek world.
The arms race was on.
In the years that followed, many militaries were carrying out demonstrations of the weapons
and even began incorporating them into their defenses.
Archaeology, for instance, indicates that early artillery fortifications were being
built in mainland Greece by the mid-4th century BC.
As adoption of the technology increased, so too did the pressures to innovate.
The next breakthrough appears to have been in rethinking the means of storing energy.
Previously, this had been done through the deflection of the bow arms, which acted as
massive springs.
However, without a better understanding of material sciences or advanced manufacturing,
it proved hard to get these arms strong enough to withstand additional forces.
The major advance came when the composite bow was replaced with a torsional spring.
Here it was found that you could actually store more energy more efficiently by twisting
elastic rope bundles.
All of a sudden, you could build devices which were both smaller and more powerful.
Now, with a new technological avenue to explore, the Greek world exploded with activity.
Throughout the 4th century BC, engineers experimented endlessly with artillery trial and error,
writing manuals on construction, calibration, and operation.
But there was no better incubator for innovation than a good old-fashioned war.
This came to the Greek world in the 4th century BC with the rise of Macedon and the conquests
of Alexander the Great.
Here we see the first real evidence of artillery being a part of the army's baggage train
and being used repeatedly in sieges to suppress the defenders.
The ensuing wars between Alexander's successors ensured that artillery technology continued
to develop.
At this point, it became more of a science as people tried to figure out the best way
to optimize their torsion springs.
Over the centuries, all sorts of formulas were devised relating the ratios of projectiles
to spring diameter and spring height, with new materials and methods of manufacturing
being infused into elements of the design.
It's at this point that we will introduce the Romans to our story.
As we stated previously, artillery was something championed by the Greeks and the other major
powers of the Mediterranean.
The Romans, for much of their early history, were excluded from this group as a minor power
of little significance.
As such, they had little access to the latest in military tech.
However, this would begin to change as they expanded across the Italian peninsula, adopting
the equipment and expertise of others.
A particularly important development came when the Romans won the Pyrrhic War.
As a result, the Romans gained control of the Greek cities of southern Italy and could
now call on these new subjects to supply the latest in military equipment such as
naval vessels and artillery pieces in times of war.
For the moment, however, both of these contributions played a rather small part in Roman military
affairs.
Things would change with the outbreak of the Punic Wars, a colossal, century-long clash
of civilizations with Carthage which brought about dramatic military evolutions for Rome.
Admittedly, the artillery side of things got off to a bit of a slow start in the first
Punic War which saw Rome focus primarily on the naval department.
While we do hear mention of Roman ships and besiegers having some pieces of artillery,
it was always on a small scale.
These pieces were likely all requisitioned from Greek allies on an ad hoc basis and were
not integrated into the legions as would be the case with later professional armies.
The second Punic War, on the other hand, was primarily land-based and saw greater demand
for artillery as both sides found themselves in a large tug-of-war over cities in both
the Italian, Sicilian, and Spanish theaters of war.
In these matters, Rome once again was forced to rely on its Greek allies for the requisition
of artillery.
However, over the course of its campaigns, Rome would increasingly get its artillery
from the Carthaginians.
This occurred when the legions managed to capture major military bases and thus secure
their stockpiles of war material.
When New Carthage was taken, for instance, it yielded 120 large catapults, 281 small
catapults, 23 large ballistae, 52 smaller ballistae, and an assortment of arrow throwers.
The capture of Syracuse two years later brought a similar haul.
This large influx of captured material and experts would be used throughout the Punic
Wars and beyond.
Over the following years, the Roman Republic would add to its military arsenal by bringing
the war to the Hellenistic world.
Here they seized increasingly large numbers of artillery pieces, which were in turn used
to take down yet more of the fortified cities of the East.
By the first century BC, the Republican army had become more professional.
As a result, it appears to have moved away from the previous ad hoc use of artillery
to a more standardized approach.
This becomes apparent in the campaigns of Julius Caesar, where artillery is a pretty
common piece of equipment, and lightweight arrow throwers regularly accompany the legions
on duty.
The use of artillery is also notable here, in that Caesar uses it more imaginatively.
Rather than simply restricting this equipment to sieges, we see him use it in the defense
of fortified camps, advanced hilltop positions, and in the support of amphibious landings.
Thus, we get our first hints that these Hollywood scenes aren't pure fantasy.
Over the following decades, Rome's armies would spread across the Mediterranean, absorbing
the military expertise of others and adapting to new situations.
From this point on, artillery would become a staple of the Roman war machine, playing
an important role in the military of the empire and undergoing continued technological developments
over the centuries.
So in this new world of artillery, what might we expect to see?
Well the first thing to understand is that the majority of these weapons derive their
energy from the same general source, torsion.
The basic idea here being that by twisting something elastic like rope, you can store
mechanical energy for later use, such as the launching of some projectile.
Therefore all of these torsion artillery had the following key features.
A torsion spring to store energy, a drawing mechanism to input energy, a releasing mechanism
to release energy, a projectile slide to hold and aim the projectile, and a support structure
to simply hold it all together.
Thus, one of the main ways to categorize artillery is by the number of springs, which in turn
drives its behavior.
Artillery with just one set of springs have an arm that swings in an arc upon release.
This sort of launch is more conducive to objects whose aerodynamics don't really care which
way they are facing, so basically rounded stones.
The typical design involved a horizontal spring with an arm in the vertical, at the end of
which was attached a sling.
The structure included a padded element to catch the arm, and a wide base for stability.
In the Roman military, this primarily came in the form of the onager, so named due to
the catapult's reputation for bucking like a wild mule when fired.
Though fairly simple to build and operate, they had rather poor accuracy and needed a
lot of room to fire.
They were therefore mostly used against fixed targets like fortifications.
Let's now take a look at the other category of artillery, which had two springs.
The main difference here was that the sweeping motion of two arms could actually be translated
into linear motion by running a string between the two ends to make a giant bow.
The springs here would be vertical, with the projectile being released horizontally at
some desired angle.
Because the motion was more controlled, you could now launch not just stones, but bolts,
both of which had far greater accuracy.
The horizontal launch also meant that these devices could more easily be used whilst in
cover or in tight quarters like the deck of a ship or on the battlements of a wall or
siege tower.
As a result, they were far more commonly used in the ancient world.
These two spring artillery pieces were known as ballistas and could be seen in all shapes
and sizes, ranging from the small to the gargantuan.
Their design would match the type and size of projectile being fired.
For instance, the engineers had a whole system of ideal proportions based around the caliber
of ammunition measured in minas.
The smaller devices were sometimes called scorpions.
These were light, portable, and easy to use by a small team.
As such, some sources suggest that each imperial Roman sentry of about 80 men was issued one.
Regardless of their precise quantities, they were quite common and saw a lot of development
over the years.
Improvements included sealing in the water-sensitive springs, introducing stronger components for
greater reliability, and adding some advanced mechanical elements to improve reload rates.
Some texts even point to auto-feeding and reloading artillery capable of rapid fire.
Combine that with depictions of cart-mounted artillery on Trajan's Column, and it's easy
to get carried away imagining some sort of ancient vehicle-mounted machine guns.
While this extreme situation is not very accurate, it does attest to the degree of sophistication
we're talking about here.
And if the technology doesn't impress you, then perhaps the size will.
We've only really talked about small shooters.
Medium-sized ballistas were apparently standard issue at the cohort level of around 500 men,
with even larger pieces coming in at the legionary level.
When the situation called for it, Roman engineers could also build even larger monstrosities
to take on fortifications such as at the Siege of Jerusalem in 70 AD.
Thus we see that at its peak, the artillery of the Roman army was capable of striking
at enemies anywhere from 100 meters to almost 1 kilometer away.
The types of munitions used included rounded stones and iron-tipped bolts for use against
enemy combatants, and heated clay pots or javelins to cause fires.
So pyrotechnics aside, that scene in Gladiar is not so far-fetched.
But what about the nature of that engagement?
To answer this question, let's now finally turn to the application of these weapons in battle.
The primary use of artillery was during sieges.
They could be used by the defender to shoot at approaching infantry, or to damage incoming
siege engines.
The attacker, on the other hand, usually had fewer targets given the obvious defensive
nature of enemy walls.
One would think that of course they had ready targets, the walls themselves.
However, we must remember that artillery in this period really didn't have the capability
of single-handedly bringing down stone fortifications.
Wooden palisades and small towers maybe, but never the main defensive walls.
Instead, their role was one of suppression, where they could target a specific portion
of the defenses, clearing them of defenders, which would then allow for the attackers to
breach them with more conventional methods such as a ram.
To this end, we have plenty of evidence of their use in sieges, and to great effect.
The sieges during the Great Jewish Revolt are great examples of this.
Here, Josephus tells us of their horrific damage.
Multiple soldiers being impaled by bolts, heads being knocked off, and body parts being
flung hundreds of feet.
It was brutal.
We also have evidence of this destructive power being used in other situations.
In naval combat, for instance, ships often carried small scorpions to clear enemy decks
at a distance or attempt to set them alight.
Vessels thus equipped could also fire ashore.
This was pretty common practice during sieges of naval harbors.
But even more impressive are cases where the ship-borne artillery were used to provide
covering fire during amphibious assaults.
During Caesar's invasion of Britain, for example, the general used the ships on the
flanks of his beach landing to ward off enemy warbands contesting the assault.
But what about pitched battles?
Were artillery used in cases where armies straight up duked it out on relatively even
terrain as depicted in that opening scene of Gladiator?
It turns out that, while not particularly common, this did in fact occur.
For instance, during the Gallic Wars, Caesar is reported to have quickly moved around small
artillery pieces to hilltop positions so as to pepper enemy armies on the approach.
Arrian also discusses how when fighting against the cavalry heavy Allens, it is best to deploy
artillery on the flanks to fire at the enemy and contest the ranged fight from a secure
position.
Often, such tactics were accompanied by the digging of trenches and the building of barricades
to further fortify the flanks.
Alright, so artillery were used asymmetrically in some situations.
But what about when two armies with artillery met?
Did they just bomb each other to smithereens?
Well, unfortunately we don't really have any evidence of this before the age of gunpowder.
The closest we might get in the Roman era is artillery shooting at each other from defensive
positions prior to the start of battle, but nothing really of consequence.
A smaller anecdote of some relevance does occur in 69 AD when during the Second Battle
of Cremona, one of the two Roman armies is said to have inflicted quite heavy damage
with its stone thrower until it was later disabled by enemy infiltrators.
So why don't we see artillery in field battles?
Well, the main reason is that one of the major advantages in war comes from maintaining mobility.
Artillery and in particular heavy artillery inhibit this.
Once in battle, the legions could do the heavy lifting.
It's only really in cases of fighting against fortifications or mounted enemies that they
needed help.
As you get past the Roman era, the size of armies declines alongside the ability to even
deploy advanced pieces of equipment.
You are therefore less and less likely to see artillery in field battles as time goes
on until the advent of powder weapons.
However, what you do see a lot in the medieval period are sieges.
This means that artillery still get a chance to shine.
This is especially true in the later medieval period when counterweight trebuchets make
their way to Europe with the ability to throw larger stones than ever before and actually
take down stone fortifications for the first time.
In closing, let's turn back to that initial question about the historical accuracy of
ancient artillery in movies.
Well, if the scene is set in antiquity, then you can definitely expect to see a lot of
torsion ballistas of all sizes during sieges.
Their presence in pitched battles is even somewhat plausible so long as you discount
fire arrows and explosions and recognize that any good commander would avoid the dangers
of friendly fire.
In medieval settings, artillery is less likely to be present besides when you're looking
at sieges, in which case expect only trebuchets to be doing the damage against walls.
Anyways, thanks for watching and I hope you enjoyed.
Please let me know what other topics you'd like to cover next and stay tuned for a lot
of the awesome content we have in store.
See you in the next one.