Why I Stopped Using Running Power

sport and travel
205 followers
A few years ago, running power became a thing. It was touted as runners finally getting the
thing that cyclists have had for years, a metric that could reliably be used in training and racing
to quantify the effort level. In fact, we did a video on it about five years ago. Has this
changed running forever as running power was introduced? Well, five years later on, and it's
safe to say that no, it hasn't really changed forever or at all. You really don't see that many
runners using power. More are using it now than five years ago, but it certainly hasn't done to
running what cycling power did to cycling because you do see every serious cyclist now using a
power meter on their bike. Yes, so what gives? Is running power really a thing? Does it just need
a bit more tweaking or is running power dead? What is running power? We're going to explain
it to you, but before we do, hit that thumbs up button to support the channel. Don't forget to
subscribe so you don't miss the rest of our videos. It really does help support the channel
and allow us to make this kind of video. Running power meters attempt to provide an objective
number which a runner can use to assess how hard they are working at any point. Previously, the
best way to do this for running was with heart rate. The higher the heart rate, the more effort,
but heart rate has some serious limitations. It is affected by many external factors like heat,
hydration, fatigue, etc., and it has a lag or a delay between the effort and the heart rate
response, but running power meters can't actually measure the amount of force a runner is applying
to the ground. Even if they could, it would be of far less value than a cycling power meter
as much of a runner's energy actually goes into vertical, lateral, and rotational forces
instead of actual forward motion. Running power meters actually use sensors,
accelerometers, gyroscopes, speed sensors, along with a host of other metrics like
pace, your incline, your air resistance, and ground contact time, all processed in a tiny
little powerful computer using equations relying on Newtonian physics to estimate the power a
runner is producing in almost real time. Now, as you can probably work out if you managed to follow
that explanation, a bark power and run power, whilst both using the word power and both using
watts as their units, are not actually measuring the same thing or measured in the same way.
In fact, sports watchmaker Coros has moved away from running power as a metric almost entirely.
They've opted instead to use effort pace, which uses the same data from a host of sensors and
your own history to give you a pace number, the speed you would be running if all factors
were perfectly equal. Essentially, the speed you'd be running if you were on a perfectly flat
running track. Effort pace is designed to be more actionable than running power,
and is particularly useful when you take your runs off-road onto trails.
Now, arguably, this is what all running power meters should do. The notion of power as an
absolute metric has been copied from cycling, but any variation in the algorithm, and every device
out there has its own algorithm, drastically skews the power numbers. What can you use the
power numbers for? You may have been running using pace and heart rate for years, and maybe sitting
there scratching your head thinking, okay, why do I need power, and what can I use it for?
That's actually a good question. At its core, it's an effort measurement,
and so you can use it to accurately assess your current effort level.
You can also use heart rate for that, though. So why use power? Well, the main selling point
is that it's instantaneous. Where your heart rate will take 30 to 90 seconds to respond to a change
in effort level, power will be almost immediate. The other main selling point is efficiency. You
can tell if you've improved your efficiency by running at the same pace and the same heart rate,
and noting any changes in power. So less power for the same pace means that you are more efficient.
Now, the first one is obviously useful for shorter intervals. It's hard to use heart rate
as a guide for those because of that heart rate lag. But over time, you can actually get to know
your heart rate response and use heart rate pretty effectively, even for very short intervals.
Power promises to be instant, but the thing is, you also need to get to know your power meter,
and your power meter needs to get to know you, which can take many months. So it's not as
immediately useful as it might appear. Anyway, enough talking about what it all is. Let's head
outside and test this all out. Okay, so we're going to test this power thing. Mark and I both
have power meters. Mark has got the Stride foot pod on his foot, and I've got the built-in KOROS
one on my KOROS watch. What we're going to do is we're going to run two one-kilometer reps,
one hilly, one flat, and we're going to set a target power for those. Then we're going to take
a little rest, and we're going to do the same two reps, one-kilometer reps, and we're going to set
a target heart rate for those. Then we're going to compare afterwards what our pace did and how
easily we could control our effort levels using those two different metrics. While I'm warming
up, I'm going to explain to you what you can't use your running power meter for. You can't use
running power meter to compare to your cycling numbers. As I've already explained, your running
power is just an algorithm, whereas your cycling power is an actual measure of your power.
You can't use running power to compare to other runners or even to compare to running power norms.
That is because it is based on how the algorithm interprets how you run and also just on how you
run. Your running power numbers are really just yours.
Mark Threlfall You're right. Let's do it.
Blake Shepherd Okay. Three, two, one, go.
Turn around.
That's 1K. Well, that's one done. Mark was significantly faster than me at a lower power,
which is understandable. He weighs a little less than I do. Now we're going to try and do it with
heart rate and see if we can keep it as smooth. Well, I don't actually feel the mountain was that
smooth. I did a lot of watch-watching. Mark Threlfall
Yes. I think because I'm not as in tune with it, I found myself checking a lot. I was quite
anxious the entire time. Another kilometer. Blake Shepherd
Yes. This time to heart rate. Mark Threlfall
All right, James. Blake Shepherd
Ready, Mark? Three, two, one, go.
Time to turn. Halfway and my heart rate's finally gone up to the target.
That was within two seconds of the last one. Okay, hilly kilometer loop, 1K.
Blake Shepherd In theory, the power
should come into its own when it's more hilly. Mark Threlfall
We will see. Blake Shepherd
We will see. Hilly kilometer loop coming up. Mark Threlfall
All right. Blake Shepherd
Let's go. Mark Threlfall
Three, two, one, let's go. On to downhill. Try to keep the power up.
How do you keep power up on a downhill? Doing okay, actually.
Okay, on to the flat section in the middle. Quite cool, actually. Instantly on the power.
The uphill again. Here we go. Keep that power down. Here we go. Nice.
All right, first rep down. That was with the power. Now, on to the heart rate. Let's see how we get on.
Definitely fallen into a trap of running a bit too hard along the flat here.
My heart rate's still not quite there. Oh, but now it is. Over 170.
Whoopsie. Weirdly, I'm actually almost leaning more towards enjoying the power
on those hilly reps. Maybe I haven't given power a benefit of the doubt and tried it enough.
All right, we're back from our tests. Mark, first, subjectively,
how did you find running with the power? Mark Threlfall
So, yes, a number of years back when I guess running power was starting to make waves
in running, I did say I was going to go and test it. I did, maybe not religiously enough because
I wasn't sold on it enough at the time. I just don't think I invested enough time into it,
and so it just didn't stick for me. To be honest, this is my first experiment with
actually looking at it while I'm running, trying to judge my pace on it.
I've never really had a watch that instantly showed you power. It always had to
add a stride footpod or something, and I just never bothered. This was my first experiment
with it. I did find, and this will probably go away I suppose if you use it more, that I was
quite a slave to my numbers. I was just running like this. Apparently, that's exactly what you're
not supposed to do because that changes the actual reading because it's taking your movements and
stuff into account. 100%, I found myself just constantly lifting my wrist up because I didn't
know what that power felt like, so I had to check constantly, whereas when we were on the heart rate,
I very much just found myself just running and enjoying because I felt like I knew what
that should feel like. Interestingly though, saying that, my power actually sparked way higher
and way lower when I was just looking at heart rate than it did when I was looking at power,
and I was actually able to judge it a bit more evenly, which is one of the selling points of
power. If I compare my two that I did with power and I did without with looking at heart rate,
my peaks and troughs are way lower on the power side. My pace peaks and troughs are also
less when I was looking at power than they were in heart rate. Mostly, that is down to heart rate
lag. I found myself the same either initially or any sort of climb. I would push just that bit too
hard for too long, and then suddenly before I knew it, oh my goodness, my heart rate is now too
high. Then knowing your heart rate, you're like, well, it's going to take 20 seconds to get it
down, so I can ease right back for at least 20 seconds here. It becomes this power roller coaster
where you're going up and down and up and down trying to get your average heart rate to where
you want it to be, which you don't have in the power because it's instantaneous.
The other thing, obviously, when you look at a hilly route versus a flat route,
we can compare how hard we're working on each of those things, whereas with just heart rate,
it's much harder to compare how hard you're working on those. Your heart rate's going to
go higher on the hills even for a lower pace. You can't really tell whether you're working the same
effort level. That is quite interesting to see how much that correlates to how hard you're working,
I guess. It's quite a lot more experience. Mark Threlfall
Interestingly, this is just subjective, I felt more controlled on the hilly effort with power.
Looking at power. Yes, which is exactly what you expect, but it did. It just felt more controlled.
I felt quite comfortable. When you're looking at heart rate,
you're trying to predict where you're going to be in 30 to 60 seconds and judge your pace on that.
When you're going up a hill, that's really hard to predict because suddenly it starts
sparking. You go, oh, I've gone way too hard up this hill. Maybe there is. There are some people
who are already convinced in power. One of them is Sam Proctor, a coach to the pros.
I've got Sam Proctor with me here now. Total disclaimer, this is from me stalking some Strava
activities. I noticed on a couple of your athletes, and notably you coach India Lee,
I noticed that they're talking about hitting certain powers for their run sessions, which
I'm guessing you've prescribed to them. Is that right?
Yes. We use Stride, which is a foot pod. It goes on your shoe. We've been using that now.
I've been using it with Mark Pierce at Intelligent Triathlon Training for around four or five years.
As time has gone on, they've brought out the newer generations and we've been using it
certainly for the last couple of years with our professionals and age group
athletes. Yes, we've really enjoyed it. Are you collecting power data from their
running purely from an analysis point of view, or are you also actually prescribing and setting
the sessions and saying, right, you need to hit 300 watts for this 10-minute effort,
and so on and so forth? When do you implement it, I guess, into the training if you do?
Yes. If athletes have a power meter on their foot, we prescribe their sessions by power.
That ranges from VO2 max right down to easy aerobic runs. The easier aerobic runs get,
there's not so much of a stress on what the power number is because we tend to go off of feel and
heart rate, etc. We're collecting data from that, but the sessions, because we use training peaks,
are prescribed to get a TSS score because that's generally how we prescribe a week's
training or a month's training is through TSS. We just find the data coming back a lot more
reliable than, say, heart rate, pace. Certainly, when the course is undulating,
the power is a lot easier as a metric to collect the data from and set the sessions from.
So clearly, you're focusing quite heavily on the power. Are you still paying attention to
pace and heart rate? Does power sit above them in priority with a metric that you're paying?
In training, yes. Obviously, fundamentally, the training leads to a race, so we still need to
have that element of a pacing structure. What we've found is certainly over a long course
is that Ironman's long course triathlons that you've probably seen it yourself is we never
really have a problem telling people to speed up when they come out of transition. It's actually
the opposite. It's slowing them down. So we just find having that power metric number to go to is
that there seems to be a lot better in pacing through the longer races because they're not
trying to hit a pace immediately or trying to find your pace out of transition. There's still
a zone, so it might be coming out of transition and aiming with 340 watts to 360. There's still a
metric like there would be on the bike. There's still a range, but we try and gather data through
training to get a pace and a power number to stick to. Well, a ceiling more than anything.
It's a bit like cycling. You have a functional threshold power and that's how we work it off of,
so x percentage would equate to this time of running, for example, same as the bike really.
Mark Threlfall And is there anything in, are you looking at
the power from an efficiency standpoint as well? I think in a triathlon running off the bike is
really interesting, right? You might see a change in the power due to your run form.
Is that something you monitor and pay close attention to or get the athletes looking at
whilst they're doing a session or during a race? Certainly not during a session. We would sit down
and look at it afterwards running. We can get a lot from a run economy, efficiency,
cadence. You can get that in ground contact time, that sort of stuff as the runs get longer. Yes,
that's something we can look at for our long course athletes. Again, that would help us
describe what power we believe you can sustain for, say, your marathon or your half marathon.
We want you to be running as efficiently as possible for as long as possible, not just,
right, let's do the first half at this pace and then hold on. There has to be that element of a
race, but there also has to be getting you to the finish line from A to B as quick as possible.
We can look at all those metrics to try and achieve that essentially.
I think I know the answer to this then. I was going to say, is running power the future? Do
you believe it's the metric that you need to focus on or is it more just another great tool
to add to the kind of the locker of metrics? For us, yes, we certainly would advocate that
you can run to power. We've seen great results from it. I think it goes back to one of the
biggest results we've got was in the Miami last year. She looked at solely power on that whole
run and within a watt she was there and it got her the win. We can't ask fairer than that,
but obviously there has to be an element of there's a race involved, but we're just finding
a better metric to rely on through the course of a race. Training, we could dive into lots of
things, but consistency in training is not trying to... If you're doing a run rep and you're chasing
pace but you're fatigued, are you running too hard? With power, you have a range and we could
be at the bottom of that range today because we're tired. Just getting that consistency in
is something we're finding that using the power just helps create that rather than chasing
something that you might not be able to reach on a headwind, a tailwind, an undulating course,
for example. Unfortunately, it still requires doing a bit of a threshold test, so that's quite
fun. What are our conclusions on running power? Why is running power not the most used and most
talked about metric in running today? Well, personally, I think it's like all new things
and new tech, it takes time for it to be ingrained into our daily life. Cycling power actually was
the same where it initially came out. I remember there were forums that people would trawl over and
just trying to figure out how to use this new metric. Then also the devices and the technology
that came with that had to evolve. Initially, they were incredibly heavy, incredibly expensive,
they needed to be calibrated constantly. You almost needed a PhD just to be able to use one
of these things. For that reason, it took a long time for even that to be caught.
Yes. Well, running power has come a long way. You no longer need a foot pod. It's built into
a lot of sports watches. Now, like our Corosport sports watches, you can see running power,
but the algorithms that work out that power do need refining. I think the industry as a whole
probably does need to come together and figure out what is the gold standard on how you work
this up because each company has its own one. In fact, some companies even moving away from
running power, they still do show it like Coros, for example, they do show running power,
but they've actually moved away to a more useful metric, what they call effort pace,
which is a similar individual algorithm derived number, but it's more useful, more intuitive
than a running power that you have to learn what 350 means for you. The effort pace just takes all
those individual parameters and metrics, including your speed and the distance and the elevation
gain, et cetera, and puts it into an effort pace, how hard you are running if this was
a perfectly fit course. A Garmin has something similar, the grade adjusted pace, which really
only takes into account the grade that you're running it, but they all have the same idea
they just haven't all arrived on the same terminology, I guess, for what running power is.
Probably to answer our initial question, yes, I feel like running power is dead,
albeit interesting to hear that Sam Proctor is using it with some of the pros. I do feel like
there is some advanced metric that is, as you say, yet to be refined or used universally because,
yes, we're seeing running power, effort pace, and various other names for these terms which
go beyond just using your usual pace and heart rate. Personally, I am drawn towards this effort
pace because it's a metric I already understand, and therefore, it's easy for me to integrate and
utilize that in my day-to-day training. I feel the same. I think that is where we're
going to go. I think in 10 years' time, no one is going to be using pace or heart rate
to judge their effort in a run. They're going to be using some, I don't know what it'd be called,
running power, effort pace, whatever the industry decides, but they'll be using some metric that
takes all of these things into account that your watch is measuring and gives you how hard you're
running. I don't think, though, that it'll be called running power in 10 years' time.
I'm going to agree with Mark and say running power maybe is dead, but the metrics certainly
aren't. What do you guys think? Leave a comment down below if you think running power is the
future or whether you think you agree with us and running power is infected.
Either way, we all just enjoy running.
