Around the world, forests are in trouble. Thanks to climate change and modern logging practices, they are being harvested faster than we can replenish them. It’s a critical problem of our modern age, but some believe traditional knowledge could be the answer.
An indigenous community in Wisconsin is setting an example for a better way. Host Baratunde Thurston journeys into the Menominee nation, where hundreds of thousands of acres of forest are tended according to ancient traditions. And those traditions have guided the local logging industry for generations.
Can the Menominee's sustainable practices be adopted elsewhere? Discover the wisdom of their timeless approach to logging, the unique culture that sustains it, and why outside visitors are coming to study the Menominee way.
This spring I was in the woods of Oregon, struggling to reach the top of an 80-foot maple.
I'll admit I only made it halfway up, but that's all it took to remind me of the extraordinary power
of trees. There's something about trees that just changes your perspective. The problem is
around the world, forests are in trouble. We depend on them for cooling, shade,
and the literal air we breathe, but we often repay them with a chainsaw. Is there a better way?
Could a solution already exist? If it does,
it might live in the ancient wisdom of a native tribe called the Menominee.
Pozo, for all you non-native Menominee speakers, that means hello. Welcome to the land of the
Menominee Indian tribe of Wisconsin, an indigenous community that maintains their spoken language,
practices their own traditions, and celebrates their five clans. At the center of their culture
is the land. 230,000 acres of pristine forest that they continue to manage today.
These old growth trees have been their lifeblood for hundreds of years.
But this isn't just a forest. We give every one of these things a spirit.
You know, our trees are spirits, our rocks are spirits. To us, everything has a spirit that you
have to take care of so it'll take care of you. According to the Menominee, unlike many forests
that are suffering as a result of commercial logging practices, theirs has actually been
thriving, even though they log it for their own lumber mill. Their secret? They follow a tradition
passed down by their ancestors. Menominee forestry is based on a teaching from one of our chiefs
from long ago, Chief Oshkosh. The Chief Oshkosh quote, sorry you have to read this,
want to get it right. Yeah, start from the rising sun and work towards the setting sun. Take only
the sick, the mature, and the downed trees. The trees that are dead, the trees that are dying.
When you reach the end of the reservation, turn, start over, and cut from the setting sun to the
rising sun and the trees will last forever. Trees will last forever. The Menominee only take the old,
fallen, sick, and dying trees for lumber, plus those at risk of disease. They leave the young
and healthy ones to grow and reproduce. You look, this one would be marked, he's got a big defect on
this side right here. Big John oversees the lumber operations in the forest. Yeah, this is, this is
considered a defect all the way along the side up there. You can see cankers and knots and deformities
on them. Those are the ones that we would go after. You'd leave the, the beautiful straight
trees alone. That's radically different from standard logging, where market value drives
which trees get cut. In order to get the best market value out of it, you're going to want to
pick the most beautiful tree that you can find. The tallest tree, the straightest tree, the
healthiest tree, the most robust tree. That's going to get you the most money. Jasmine is a
graduate of the College of Menominee Nation and studied wild plants in the forest. Even though it
seems like a good business practice right off the bat, what you're actually doing is taking all the
trees that you could be growing that could be just as healthy, if not more so, further down the line.
Instead, what we do is we take the older trees, we take the dying trees, the trees that by and large
are probably going to be gone soon anyway. That way, all that we're leaving are the healthiest
and the youngest and the most robust. Those are the kind of trees that you're going to want to
make sure that you're propagating their genetic line for the health of the forest. Their approach
has made this small community famous around the world.
Forestry professionals from all over flock to Wisconsin to learn the Menominee's secrets.
And those secrets don't just maintain the forest, they also produce some of the highest quality
wood. Case in point, some of the most important basketball games in the world are played on
Menominee lumber, from March Madness to the NBA Finals, even the Olympics. You can see that the
Menominee forest is different even if you just look at a satellite view of Wisconsin.
Greg is a forest ecologist and silviculturalist with the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources.
And a lot of people don't know what silviculture is, but it's really the science and considered an
art of how we manage the structure and the function of our forest. What makes the Menominee
forest special, it's much more intact, boulder and diverse from the rest of the forest in Wisconsin
because it didn't experience the same cutover of the European settlement period the rest of
Wisconsin did. Some of their methods and techniques have influenced our guidelines that we develop
this blending of traditional ecological knowledge with modern forest science.
We're always looking at whatever's coming out, the best technology available, we have to.
As the forest manager, Ron works to keep the forest healthy in an ever-changing world.
Don't get my feet because I don't have my boots on.
We use drones, apps, satellite imagery and all those things. We manage on the old principles of
the Chief Oshkosh quote. We still do our things, you know, traditionally, but in order for us to
meet the challenges that lie ahead, we need to adapt and we're always looking. It's all about
keeping our forest healthy. This commitment to the forest is deeply woven into the Menominee
community. It's so important to us. The forest is really what defines us. It's our whole identity.
Even people who don't work in it directly have some sort of connection to it that you wouldn't
really be able to find anywhere else. Logging is so integral to people's lives here, they even
created their own mill language, a way for workers to stay in sync when the saws are buzzing. There's
sign language, it's called mill talk. You'll have time, all the time, one, two, three, four, five,
we have six, we have seven, and you have number eight. To us, everybody loves the number eight.
I was a tribal school flag football coach and I missed my opportunity because we went eight,
no, and I wanted them to go like that to the camera because they had learned mill talk there.
I was saying, hey coach, I know how to do number eight. I left here for four years, I went into
service, I came back. When I started going to lumber inspection school, I got to visit different
sawmills and see the size of their logs and kind of laugh at myself, you know, laugh to say, hey,
we do got something unique. So it seems like the Menominee have this figured out, right?
I mean, the question is, can their practices be applied everywhere? Realistically, could all
forest lands across the globe be managed this way? The important thing to remember there is not all
lands have similar objectives. A paper company, for example, may use very intensive practices to
grow wood fiber. Intensive practices like cutting down a tree while it's still young. And they can
still do that, hopefully in a sustainable way. Sustainable forestry can be quite diverse
and practices may look different depending on those landowner objectives. So it's not a one-size-fits-all.
So if your main objective is producing paper, there are methods you can follow to do that
sustainably. And you can continue to produce paper off your land long into the future.
But what sets the Menominee apart is that sustainability is the objective.
But that commitment comes with a cost. It's not very profitable to do what we do.
Our philosophy is always the forest, the community, and profitability. And on the outside,
it's profitability, the community, and then the forest. You know, forest to them is always last.
Recently, the Menominee's commitment to the forest has faced a new and unexpected threat.
The old-timers always said they had an abundance of loggers come winter and fall time. The farmers
are the ones that used to come off, you know. After they've harvested all their crops, they
came to the woods. They would pick up the chainsaws. Nowadays, there's a lot less farmers.
There's a lot less individuals that want to work. And we still need to harvest all these trees,
which is becoming a huge obstacle that we're facing.
I grew up working hard labor. I didn't want my kids to do this. I wanted them to be better than me.
It's really hard to see yourself being a part of that tradition and being something that's
necessary to keep that going. Certainly, my generation and all the generations around us
really thought of success as you go to college, you get a degree, you go and you work for some
sort of white college job. But what you lose in this sort of idea of prestige is the actual
prestige that's kind of all around you. You're essentially taking care of our legacy. You're
taking care of something that has sustained our people for thousands of years and will sustain
it for longer. When I was a kid, I didn't imagine I'd be out here. Seemed kind of like
pretty hard work, you know, but I got sick of working other jobs. I decided to give it a try
and it stuck. Went from being a job into kind of being a career.
All righty, there it is. You get hooked. You love the people. You love the work. Even as hard as it
is, you just love the atmosphere and the environment you're around. It's indescribable.
Unless you go outside of this place and leave this place for a little while, you don't understand how
beautiful this place really is. You have to get away from here in order to realize what you're
missing. It took care of my grandfather's generation and, you know, his father before him.
So hopefully, my children and their children will be able to get some sort of a living out of it as
well. Rather than just pretending that there's no tomorrow, we're focused entirely on tomorrow.
When I see the beautiful straight trees, I tell the generations of the past,
job well done. Hopefully, I can do the same.
If we want to save the trees, we all need to stay focused on tomorrow
and take time to appreciate the nature all around us.
Maybe someday, I'll go back to Oregon and finish climbing that maple.
Thank you so much for watching. For more fascinating tales from the great outdoors,
tune in to the second season of America Outdoors with Baratunde Thurston. You can find it in the
PBS app or your local PBS station. Check the link in the description below for more information.