Best rifle magazine pouch (AR-15)

Uniform & Arms
3 followers
4 Video Views·Oct 22, 2025
If you're wearing Socos or Sofis or you've ever worn them in the past, go ahead and hit that
subscribe button, like, comment, do all that good stuff because it really helps me out.
So what is the best belt-mounted rifle magazine pouch? That is a great question. Now you have to
realize that best is very subjective. Best for a competition shooter is going to be very different
from best for a dude doing Halo ops or a dude doing maritime security or contracting work or
police work. So realize that there is a whole lot of gray area in there when it comes to best.
But what we're going to do is we're going to talk about magazine pouches that perform well in duty
slash professional setups. So may not be the best for you, but I found that in my time with them,
they've worked quite well. So when it comes to our magazine pouches, we're going to be dealing
with open top designs because we're going to be working mostly from emergency reloads, that type
of stuff since it's running off the belt. Now for a police officer, that might be a primary mag.
Just realize you're going to have some variation based on what you do.
But in any case, let's talk about the different types of mag pouches we'll be using.
So we'll be talking about the HSGI Tacos, the G-code Scorpions, the STAC Kiwis,
and finally the ITW Fast Mag. So we're going to be rating these on a scale of three in blocks
and it's going to be retention, so how well they retain the magazine, the amount of noise they make,
so when they're bumped into the type of material they're made of, and finally the ease of the mag
draw. So those will be our criteria and now of course there are other things to consider as well,
but we'll do our best to rate these. So we'll start off with an oldie and still a goodie,
which is the HSGI Taco. So the HSGI Taco is a piece of Cordura that's secured with bungee
and that bungee provides that tension on the magazine. Now what's good about it, simple design,
they last quite a long time. I've had this one for probably about four years and it still works,
now the problem with it is that there's, because you just have Cordura on the inside, no type of
synthetic material to kind of grip it, these do come out fairly easy. Great smooth magazine draw,
however there's a higher chance you're going to lose them because it doesn't secure them as hard
as some of the newer designs out there. So still works, I think that there are better designs out
there. So when it comes to rating the HSGI Taco, we're going to go ahead and rate it on a one for
retention. Now realize that this is all comparative to the other magazine pouches within this video.
The HSGI Taco does do a lot better than almost every other magazine pouch out there,
but we're going to give it a one in block out of three for retention. We're going to give it a one
in block out of three for noise, which is good because there's not a whole lot of plastic, not a
whole lot of stuff to bump into. These magazine pouches don't make a whole lot of noise when
you're moving around and that's always good for you. Finally for ease of draw, these are probably
one of the fastest, smoothest draws of the magazine pouches that we have out there, so I'm going to
give it a three. So again, not great retention, great noise reduction, and also really good on
that fat for those fast magazine changes. So HSGI Taco does pretty good overall. Let's talk about
some of the others that we have out there. So right here we have the G-Code Scorpion. Now full
disclosure, I was given the G-Code Scorpion for free from G-Code because they wanted me to take
a look at them. Now some of you might say, oh man, you're a sellout, that means you're going to give
this a good rating. Now I'm going to give this a good rating, but not because it was given to me,
but rather because I like it. I like being given products because I like free stuff, but also
because I have no bias towards it. I didn't purchase or spend any of my own money on it. I feel
no obligation to try to defend my purchase. So I'm going to wreck stuff just as equally whether I
bought it or got it for free. So I try to have as little bias as possible when it comes to stuff,
just full disclosure, these were given to me. But anyhow, the HSGI Taco versus the G-Code Scorpion.
You see this a lot because they're very very similar in design. They both use bungees and
they both have some type of cloth slash material wrapped around a magazine to keep it in place.
However, I think that G-Code did a really good job and outpaced HSGI Taco due to a couple factors.
Now I want to point out that the G-Code has gone over a couple revisions and I've seen some people
say that hey these G-Codes don't hold in magazines very well. They slip out really well. I have not
found that to be the case with the ones that I was given. So they have a really
grippy material on the inside that holds those magazines in place very well. In fact, of the
magazine pouches here, this retains them about second best. So pretty good overall. So what it
has is it has a little exoskeleton here on the outside and that provides rigidity for the magazine
pouch as well as protecting the bungees to some extent or another. On the inside you have that
grippy material. Really keeps it in place. So I'm a big fan of the HSGI Scorpion. If you have a choice
between these two, I definitely recommend the Scorpion. When it comes to rating this out of our
inbox, we're going to give it a two and a half on retention. We're going to give it a one on noise.
It's very quiet compared to some of the magazine pouches I've dealt with. And then on ease of draw
for a magazine, we'll put it at about a two out of three inbox. So a really solid design. I'm very
happy with it. Now, in my mind, it typically comes down to this versus the S-TAC Kiwis.
So they kind of both are kind of middle of the road. They're not really good at something, but
they're not terrible at anything, but they kind of have a different design philosophy. So as you can
see here with the Kiwis, they're a little bit shorter as far as where they hold the magazine
compared to the G-Code Scorpion or the HSGI Taco. What that allows you to do is it allows for a very
smooth draw from the S-TAC Kiwis. Now the S-TAC Kiwis are a really cool design. They use a Kydex
insert to put tension on the magazine. And then on the outside, they have a Cordura wrapping.
What that does is it really keeps that noise level down as well as making it very small,
simple, robust, that type of stuff. I've never had these fell on me and I've used them for quite a
while. So as you can see here, when you pop it in, hear that little click and it's pretty secure.
Now it's not as secure as the G-Code Scorpion in my opinion. So when it comes to our S-TAC Kiwis,
I'm going to go ahead and I'm going to rate it at a two for in blocks out of three for retention.
We're going to put it at a one for noise level, because again, not a whole lot of plastic to make
noise or anything like that. It's all covered with that Cordura. And finally for the mag ease
of draw, we're going to put it at a two and a half in blocks out of three. So compare that to the
Scorpion, where the Scorpion is at two and a half, one, two. So you can see they're very similar,
just kind of a different design influence. So if you're considering getting one of these,
kind of figure out what your priority is and what you really need and then go with that.
But I don't believe that you can go wrong with either of these. I think they'd serve you very
well. So we have our S-TAC Kiwi. Finally, at the far end of the spectrum when it comes to retention,
noise, and ease of draw, we have the ITW Fast Mag. So this is a really cool design. It kind of
departs from a lot of the other designs that we've talked to up to this point. It's got all polymer,
uses a tension band right here to hold the magazine in place. Now, you can move that
tension band up and down to increase or decrease the amount of tension on the magazine. Now,
in the case of being mounted on your plate carrier or something like that, or belt mounted or upside
down, you probably want to have that band all the way up. Belt mounted, you can probably actually
move it a little bit down. I'm going to go ahead and double back on that one. But these are very
secure. I've seen a lot of guys mount these upside down on the plate carriers. Is that the best
option to do? No, probably not. Now, when I say guys who have mounted those, I've done it before,
but when it comes to being in theater, I've seen guys also have these upside down. But
these are very secure, but nonetheless, gravity always wins. So I'm not a big fan of mounting
these upside down. Just realize that they are secure enough to where you can actually do that.
The problem with these is that because it's all polymer, with anything bumps into these,
it does make a whole lot of noise. So depending on what you're doing or kind of what your priority
is, it might not be the best option. At the same time, if you're looking for some pretty secure
retention, it's hard to go wrong with the ITW Fast Mag. So when it comes to our Fast Mag,
as far as rating it, we're going to go ahead and we're going to give it a three out of three
in-blocks for retention. We're going to give it a three out of three in-blocks when it comes to
noise. And then finally, we're going to give it a two for ease of draw. Because while it is
fairly easy to draw, it's about on the same level of the G-Code Scorpion. So it feels about the same
to draw them. So you kind of have that tension all the way through on that pull as you draw that
magazine. So those are our four magazine pouches we've talked about. Again, you know, I tend to
lean towards the G-Code Scorpion and the Estetca Ibis, both excellent products. But if you want to
go to the far left or right on that spectrum, you have the HSGI Taco and ITW Fast Mag. All great
magazine pouches. You can't go wrong with any of them. It just depends on what you're doing.
So I hope this was a good primer for you guys. I hope it kind of made you either think about
your belt setups and specifically what pouches you're using. Or if you don't have anything,
maybe steer you away from a bad purchase or a good purchase, that type of stuff.
And obviously when it comes to magazine pouches, if you don't look cool, nothing matters.
