iPhone 17 Pro Max vs Galaxy S25 Ultra vs Pixel 10 Pro XL: The Black TEST

Mobile Arena
1 follower
Hey guys, Thunder E here,
and welcome to another camera comparison
between the iPhone 17 Pro Max,
the Galaxy S25 Ultra,
and the Pixel 10 Pro XL.
And I deem this the black test.
Yes, I like to call it the black test
because for years, smartphone cameras
have not really done a good job
with people with my skin complexion
in balancing that out in terms of imagery,
and also balancing it out with other people
in the same photo.
Now, I've been doing this at least
for about a year and a half or so,
and I've seen some very interesting imagery
across the board from devices like the iPhone,
the Galaxy, and the Pixel.
Now, last year, the iPhone just did not do a good job.
It did a good job with the photo overall,
but it made me just one shade
of what I like to call chocolate, right?
And that's not what I am.
We all have different shades on our skin,
and it shows in different areas.
Even my face right now,
they're darker underneath my eyes
because I have got bags.
It's a bit lighter on the top,
you know, darker underneath my neck.
You get the idea.
And also, you know, when I'm taking pictures
with friends who are lighter skin,
it makes them look pale.
So what has happened this year,
and what has Apple done?
Apple really stressed about the fact
that they've done a lot with the imagery this year,
especially with their triple camera system,
the 48 megapixel cameras at the back of the iPhone,
and also the new sensor stage camera in the front.
So we're gonna take a look at a couple of images,
not a lot, and see how well they handle this year,
because I think we will be pleasantly surprised.
So starting off with the sensor stage photo
and the camera on the iPhone,
this is a good representation
of what the iPhone is doing right now.
And my skin tone is already a huge improvement
from last year.
There's better shading
between the different color textures of my skin tone.
MJ looks pretty good.
Our clothing looks like the right color.
Also the background, that's my buddy MJ.
Go check out his channel, Gadget Match.
And I think we are gonna get a better representation
of the iPhone this year.
Now, as we look at it stacked up to the other devices
with the Galaxy on the far left,
Pixel on the far right, iPhone in the middle,
all three images look good.
I think the Galaxy does the better representation
of my skin tone here, and also MJ.
Even though MJ looks a little bit on the lighter side,
while in the iPhone, MJ is a bit more saturated.
I think he's maybe the best in the Pixel.
The Pixel makes me look a little bit darker,
more contrast, extra shine.
But I think overall, all three images are good.
I would lean closer to the Galaxy here,
but the iPhone, again,
has done a huge improvement from last year.
And that extra contrast on the Pixel clearly shows.
It's a nice shine altogether,
but it's the extra contrast.
Now, this is an image of MJ.
You can see him across the board.
And you can see on the iPhone,
he's got a little bit more saturation to his skin tone.
The Galaxy is a little bit more on the faded side,
I see, or more on the flatter side, correctly.
While I think the Pixel is a bit more balanced here.
Now, his shirt color is better represented
on the iPhone than anything else.
But I think all three images are good.
It depends on your preference here.
But I would lean closer to the Galaxy for this,
just because it's on the flatter side.
Now, when we take a look at this photo here,
the iPhone clearly wins, just off the bat,
because my shirt is black, jet black.
iPhone is closer to that color.
The Galaxy and the Pixel makes it look
like it went through a wash.
Also, my skin tone is just not the same
on either the Pixel or the Galaxy.
Both of them look a little bit more on the flatter side,
while the iPhone has just better color tone.
And also the background itself has better colors here.
So the iPhone definitely wins
with this image here quite clearly.
Now, here's another image here
where the iPhone, I think, does a really good job
with the overall photo.
Also, the clothing looks good.
My skin tone generally looks good.
I think the iPhone wins here.
I do like the way the Pixel looks.
It's a little bit brighter on my skin tone.
But the Galaxy is just too flat,
and also the background is a bit,
just blown out altogether.
So the iPhone does a good job of representing me
in this environment quite well.
And the skin tone representation is very good.
So huge improvements from them this year with that.
Now, as we move over to a photo here
with my buddy Mark Linsingham,
go check out his channel as well.
This is one where, if you look at all three,
he's more saturated, Mark is more saturated on the iPhone,
and is a bit on the flatter side on the Galaxy
and on the Pixel.
I think the Pixel is the better photo here.
You can see the better balance between both of us there
and the background compared.
And the Galaxy is still the worst here.
The iPhone's a bit more saturated,
even with my own skin tone as well.
But again, actually all three photos are still really good.
This one is interesting.
This is a front-facing photo.
We're taking myself, Danny, Danny Winget.
He's got great camera comparisons.
Go check him out as well.
And I think the Galaxy has the best photo here,
especially when it comes to my own skin tone representation.
It's not as saturated as, say, the Pixel here,
or as contrasty as the iPhone.
And I think there's a better balance between myself,
Danny, and Mark in this photo altogether.
So again, a nice balance from the Galaxy.
But again, you can see it's not as separated.
It's pretty close images altogether.
This is not a center stage photo with three of us here.
The iPhone does a good job here.
So you can see, again, this is something
where I think all three cameras are really close
in doing what they need to do.
But this, again, is the front-facing camera here.
So these, those two photos you just saw
from the front-facing camera.
Now, here is a shot of both just Danny and Mark together.
And you can see here that all images kind of look similar.
The Galaxy's a little bit too flat for me here.
So it's making them look a little bit paler
than they should, while the Pixel
also has some of that flatness.
I think I like the iPhone, although the iPhone
just punched up a little bit of that saturation
in their skin color.
The clothing, in terms of the clothing color,
it is the best on the iPhone.
You can see the blacks from Mark's clothing,
and also Danny's as well.
And also some nice kicks there, Danny.
Now, this photo here is another good one
where the iPhone does a really good photo compilation.
That's something the iPhone really does well.
So it makes the whole photo look really good.
I think the, you can see the bricks
really kind of pop out a little bit more.
Not as much, let's say, as the Pixel.
And in terms of skin tones here,
I do like the Pixel more.
The iPhone's a bit darker.
Although the Galaxy's also nice, but just, again, flatter.
Galaxy's photo signature this time is just a flatter look,
which is good if you wanna actually edit the photo
and do more with it.
Now, you can see more of that flatness
with the Galaxy as well here when it comes to this image.
Now, with my jacket, my Yankees jacket,
the color green is actually more represented correctly
on the Pixel.
The iPhone's a bit more saturated.
You can see that saturation pop out
while the Galaxy's flat.
All three photos look good.
I do kind of like the skin tone representation
on the iPhone a bit more than the Pixel.
The Pixel just seems a little bit brighter,
and again, the Galaxy seems flat right here.
So, interesting imagery.
Now, here is a 5X telephoto portrait photo here
with the Galaxy and the iPhone.
As you can tell, the iPhone has more of that saturation.
It's a better-looking image
while the Galaxy's a bit flatter.
Makes it look like I haven't put on lotion that day.
Honestly, that's just what it looks like.
I would take the iPhone's photo.
It just really stands out more
and adds more to the scene
while the Galaxy just feels flat.
So, it's a 4X versus 5X here.
4X on the iPhone, 5X on the Galaxy.
Now, this is a shot here of MJ outside,
and I like all three photos.
My favorite photo is the Galaxy.
I think it just represents his skin tone
a little bit better.
It's a bit flatter, less that saturation,
but all three photos still look good, honestly.
I think they do stand out well
and do a really good job representing him.
And this is the only photo I've got to take nighttime
while trying to shoot this for you guys.
I apologize.
This is a rough one.
I think all three of them look okay.
They're not the, it's not the best photo,
but it wasn't a rush photo.
I actually stood and spent time taking this.
But you can clearly see the light
on the far left there is shining
and really gets punched in on the Galaxy,
making the Galaxy look like I have just a bright light
on my right side, aka the left side of the photo.
The iPhone looks, makes me look darker.
I do have this darker overall skin tone look.
While the Pixel is the best and most balanced here,
you can see the light on my face,
but at least balanced skin tone
and also representational across the board.
Also the background as well is better lit on the Pixel
compared to the iPhone and definitely the Galaxy
just kind of washed out with all that light.
So hopefully this gives you an idea
of what the cameras can do with skin tones
for all of these devices.
Well, it seems Apple has done a great job
with the iPhone this year,
really balancing out skin tones quite well across the board.
There's a little bit more saturation
than I would like on the iPhone,
which is something is kind of new for me to experience.
But I do like the fact that it's there.
I also like the fact that across the board,
I looked really good,
which is something at least I'm looking for
in the images that I take,
and I'm sure which is what you'll be looking for
in the images you take.
But also I love the fact that when I was taking a picture
with friends with different skin tones,
it gave us a balance there.
And I like the fact that it also gave me
the best representation of a centered image
than any other phone, which I do like.
So I think the iPhone has done a really good job this year
with skin tones, and yes, they did pass the black test.
So if you guys have any questions or comments,
or you think some of the other phones are better,
the Pixel or the Galaxy, leave your thoughts down below.
Don't forget to like, share, subscribe,
and always enjoy your entertainment.
