Xiaomi 17 Pro Max review - Apple are you seeing this!?

Mobile Arena
1 follower
So I've been testing Xiaomi's next-gen flagship phone.
And you know sometimes one phone company will copy another one,
but change it up a little bit.
Well, I've never seen a company change less than Xiaomi has here.
They've adjusted the numbering on their phones to call them the 17s.
They've shifted their naming structure to Pro and Pro Max.
They've announced the phones a month early in September,
all while featuring a very familiar-looking camera plateau design.
Now, clearly, this is a marketing trick.
This is all to make absolute sure that when you think about the iPhone 17 Pros,
that you also think and maybe even come across Xiaomi.
And part of me thinks this is really not a good look.
That this kind of cheapens a brand that is otherwise clearly capable
of making unique tech of their own.
But then part of me completely gets it.
Because when you actually take the bait and you put these phones side by side,
it draws attention to the really unique things that Xiaomi's doing that no one else is.
Like, oh yeah, did I mention Xiaomi's camera plateau is also a full-on second display.
So if you bought a 17 Pro, this is what you'd get.
A super tall box with a charger.
A 100-watt charger, casually in the box.
The USB-C cable.
And a little insert, which has the case.
A lightly frosted hard shell.
That's a pretty high-tier package.
And then this is the Pro Max, which has all the same stuff inside.
So the weird thing about this phone is it looks, almost intentionally,
like a knockoff iPhone, right?
With the naming and the design.
And to be fair, even the user interface.
Like the home screen's got Apple-style icons.
You pull down from here, you've got Apple's control center.
I'm pretty sure I've even seen some iOS 26 liquid glass inside of here.
I give them a year before they tell us their CEO is now also called Tim.
But the thing is, it doesn't feel like a knockoff.
The display is bright and super high-end.
The borders around it are every bit as thin and even as other top phones.
Every time you press things and click buttons, the haptics are phenomenal.
Very satisfying experience to type and navigate.
Or, let's just try something for a second.
This Pro over here is a pretty tiny phone, right?
It's got triple cameras on the back.
It's got not one but two displays.
How big of a battery do you think they've managed to fit into here?
6,300 milliamp hours.
That's a 25% bigger battery than the iPhone 17 Pro Max
and even the Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra.
And so the Xiaomi 17 Pro Max?
7,500.
50% bigger than those other phones.
And it translates.
It is giving me stupid levels of endurance.
I feel like I'm a kid again and I go into the candy store
and my mum hands me $50 to spend.
You could buy everything.
And because it's achieved using a silicon carbon battery
with the highest concentration of silicon so far,
it's not made the phone any thicker or heavier.
In fact, when you pick it up, the first thing you notice
is that it's actually lighter than the iPhone 17 Pro Max.
Okay, fine.
But they have had to compromise on the performance to get to this.
Psyche.
These phones have 16 gigs of the fastest RAM I've ever seen on a phone.
They've got the fastest storage
and they're basically the first phones
to have the new Snapdragon Elite Gen 5,
which is the chip that will power most Android flagships next year.
I tried a whole load of tests and benchmarks on it
and while I wouldn't call it a transformational leap,
it is firmly ahead of this year's crop of Androids
like Samsung's S25 Ultra.
It can get quite hot on the sides,
but not once have I noticed that actually affecting sustained performance.
So at least it is effectively getting heat away from the chip.
So it's pretty clear.
The phone's fundamentals are crazy good,
but that's what makes this magic back screen all the more interesting.
Because clearly, Xiaomi didn't need to do this.
The Xiaomi 17 Pro and Pro Max are not one-off gimmick phones.
They're not part of a sub-brand.
They're not niche concept devices that are only going to be released as a test.
These are Xiaomi's mainline 2025, 2026 flagship phones
that they will most likely release in all their regions,
which makes them like the one launch that they wouldn't want to be adding
a potentially expensive to produce, potentially gimmicky toy to.
And so the fact that they've decided to go for something so unconventional
makes me think one of two things.
That Xiaomi are either,
A, using this as a very expensive piece of marketing,
something to get people talking and go viral on TikTok,
because they know that once someone considers their phone,
they will become impressed by all the other things that it does.
Or B, that they are actually confident that the second screen
is the future of the smartphone
and that it's going to stick around for good.
So, which is it?
Well, let's be very clear about one thing right off the bat.
We have seen rear screens before.
We've never seen them like this,
because this rear screen has the exact same display characteristics
as the front screen.
It's got the same 3000 nits of brightness,
the same 1 to 120 hertz refresh rate,
the same touch responsiveness,
the same cover glass.
It doesn't feel tacked on.
And the fact that Xiaomi has heroically pre-applied a screen protector
to not just the front screen,
but also the back screen,
has meant that I have not once worried about
putting it down on a surface like this.
But as beautiful as it may be,
no one's catching up with the latest MrWho'sTheBoss videos
on the three inches between the cameras.
So what can you do with this
that you would actually want to do with this?
And this bar over here can summarize
how convinced or unconvinced I am by the thing as we go.
So level one, I guess, is personalization.
Xiaomi were telling me that a big part of the appeal of this phone
will be the ability to express yourself like never before.
And I wasn't ready for how hard they went with this.
So you've got a whole load of different clock faces,
and this is already pretty cool.
You've got really intricate mechanical ones.
You've got simple ones that you can recolor yourselves.
And then even this one with a step counter built in.
So pretty similar to a smartwatch homepage.
And speaking of smartwatches,
this stretch face feels like it is
literally taken straight from Apple's source code.
You've got pets that kind of interact as you touch them.
Decorate with a spunky little sheep.
Pretty sure that ain't a sheep, pal.
But these are also really high-res
and surprisingly not that tacky.
Like one of them is this really awesome butterfly card
that can actually swim behind, in front of,
and even through the current time.
And then if you don't like any of those,
you can build your own.
You can choose whether you want a clock or just text.
You can write whatever text you want
and change the color, the font size, the thickness.
Then with the background,
it's not just a pre-selected gallery,
you can also generate with AI.
And I've never seen it done like this.
This lets you turn any image
into a realistically animated video,
custom designed for this rear screen
in any one of these styles.
I have fed this thing all sorts of
absolutely terrible photos of things,
but each time it comes back with something
that is shockingly usable.
From my favorite little plant that I turned into a plushie,
to a selfie that turned me into an anime villain.
This is such an excessively extra piece of software.
But I think that's exactly what this needs
because it's such an excessively extra piece of hardware
that you need to justify it.
So, so far, I'm impressed,
but far from convinced.
Because whatever you set on this display,
it's going to spend 99% of its time dim like this.
And then it's only when you tap it that you wake it up.
Thankfully, it does do more than this
because then you can swipe down
and you've got a music player,
which honestly, I think looks stunning.
And I can see the use case of it.
You've got some friends over,
you're playing music,
you want to control it,
but you don't actually want to be on your phone.
You can pin things.
So let's say you needed to remember to buy milk.
You can pin the note for that
or a photo of milk.
That's how you roll.
They have made it pretty convenient
because you can even just circle things
and the phone will extract the text from that thing
and create this permanent note.
It's like the 2025 equivalent
of writing something on your hand.
I think of all the things you could do with this.
I guess you could pin a QR code
that you want people to scan
or you've just started a business
using it as free advertising.
It's like a tiny little billboard.
It feels like every company now
has added some sort of second space
to their phone software
to give you small updates
like Dynamic Island on the iPhone
or the Now Bar on Samsung.
And clearly, Xiaomi are trying to make
the second screen their version of this.
So they want this to work
with all the meal delivery apps
and the flight tracker apps.
But right now that's all quite limited
because it's not launched globally yet.
So the only thing I have now for app integration
is if you set a timer in your clock,
then the back of your phone
can carry that timer on
with this liquid actually depleting
along with your time.
It's actually kind of stressing me out.
There is also a notifications aspect too,
which I guess a very similar concept
to nothing phones
where when you're out to dinner,
you can stick your phone down
so that you're present,
but knowing that if someone calls you
or texts you that you can still see it,
then actually, look at that.
It automatically answers on speaker,
but this is just not a very good way
to be handling your call.
Can you hear me?
It's pretty clear.
It's got that standard underwater vibe.
Underwater vibe.
So even maybe while my phone's propped up there.
Hello?
Yeah, in terms of clarity, I can hear you.
Okay.
But it's still just a slightly worse way
of answering the call
on the front of your phone
because there's no mic at the back here.
So this part of the phone's functionality,
I'm not really sold on,
especially considering that Xiaomi
actually has their own version
of Dynamic Island
for secondary things like this,
but the camera experience.
Which does also involve this rear screen is...
Oh my God.
Okay, so the cameras on this phone,
I wouldn't call them a breakthrough in themselves,
but they're really good.
The photos it takes are actually
pretty much always as detailed
as the iPhone 17 Pro Max's,
if not sometimes more,
with also incredible dynamic range.
Though it does do something very strange
with my skin tone
that even if I disable every beauty setting,
I cannot get rid of.
But my suspicion is that's because
this model currently being China only
means that they've tuned it to Chinese preferences.
The ultrawide camera
is this tiny little reject at the bottom,
and it's kind of like you'd expect,
not particularly good in low light,
but it keeps up during the day.
And the zoom is really powerful.
A little heavy handed on the AI image enhancement
when you zoom in a lot,
but nonetheless,
it's hard to argue the results aren't impressive.
Here's the thing though,
when you've got a set of cameras
that are already really good
compared to other 2025 phones as rear cameras,
then that is going to completely obliterate other phones
when you compare it to their front cameras.
I mean, look how three-dimensional
and depthy the Xiaomi shot looks here
compared to the iPhone's brand new revised front camera.
And the way that the second screen is implemented here
is awesome.
Because if I'm using the camera on my front screen
and I want to turn it around,
all I have to do is to turn it around and swipe.
And then when the camera's active on this rear screen,
the front screen switches to now needing a swipe,
which straight away almost completely eliminates
the accidental presses problem.
But the other thing that's really impressive about this
is when you're using this back screen,
you basically retain complete camera functionality.
So I can take normal photos,
which look crazy good.
I can go to all my different zoom magnifications.
So 2X, I can go to 5X
for if you want to capture
an absolutely harrowing amount of detail in your face.
I'm actually so sorry for showing this to you.
You can use the ultra wide camera,
which is actually a tiny bit wider
than the widest setting on the new iPhone's front camera.
Plus also you've got portrait mode.
You can take video
and you can take that video in any quality.
So I've been shooting selfie video in 8K resolution.
And yeah, it does look a little over sharpened,
but there is absolutely zero doubt in my mind
that this is the highest quality selfie video
I have ever taken.
And it's all finished off with this photo collage mode,
which is so thoughtfully designed.
You take a few photos back to back
and it puts them together into a Polaroid,
very much like a photo booth
that then lets you hit one button over here
to actually print.
I'm just so taken aback by the amount of effort
that's gone into custom graphics and animations
for this one tiny feature on this one tiny second screen.
Now this isn't flawless.
I wouldn't say that this is a completely intuitive gesture
that you're gonna wanna do 15 times a day.
And if you think about it,
modern day flip phones can do the same thing
with their rear cameras on the front,
but straight away the moment you take them out your pocket,
but then none of them have cameras this good.
I will say the camera experience here is such a big perk
that it straight away on its own
takes me to quite close to the fence.
And then the strangest cherry on top ever,
you can even game on this second screen.
Xiaomi have actually gone as far
as to create a completely bespoke case
that is a working controller for the phone
that is wirelessly powered by the phone
to be able to game on this sub three inch display.
So the case clips onto the back of here
and you hold this power button, it turns on
and the back screen recognizes it immediately.
And then it's got this entirely bespoke gaming interface
Why does it look so good?
So let's just load up Angry Birds
and even the controls feel really good
for buttons that have like a two millimeter travel distance.
They've even built bespoke tutorials
designed around the buttons Xiaomi's using here.
It's such a strange little gaming experience.
It's this tiny little screen,
but the game looks and runs fantastic.
I'm so in awe while also knowing
that I will never ever actually play like this.
So on balance, I'm nearly convinced by this back screen,
but not quite.
I think the camera stuff is majorly useful.
I think the music control
and the sheer level of personalization is so cool,
but most of the rest of the stuff does feel like filler.
And this gaming case is like the definition of
let's do something crazy
because it will make for great headlines
and YouTube shorts.
But this whole thing has successfully
drawn my attention to the phone.
And now my attention is on the phone.
I like what I see.
