2025 Sets New Record High For Home Purchase Cancellations

Housing Market Breakdown
1 follower
Oct 21, 2025
Need a Real Estate Agent? Get one for FREE: https://homeandmoney.com/michael/
DISCLAIMER: This video content is intended only for informational, educational, and entertainment purposes. Michael Bordenaro is not a registered financial advisor. Your use of Michael Bordenaro’s YouTube channel and your reliance on any information on the channel is solely at your own risk. Moreover, the use of the Internet (including, but not limited to, YouTube, E-Mail, and Instagram) for communications with Michael Bordenaro does not establish a formal business relationship.
Today I'm walking on Almenar Drive in Greenbrae, California, and I want to talk about some
interesting things that are going on in the housing market. Because over the past couple
of years, I have made a few videos talking about how every single time we reached a record amount
of homebuyers backing out of transactions. And we just seem to keep smashing those records year
after year. And I think this is like kind of the last straw that sort of solidifies
that we are now in an official buyer's market in the United States. And traditionally speaking,
prior to now, a buyer's market was more defined by how much inventory was on the U.S. housing market.
But now it seems like a buyer's market should be defined by how buyers are actually acting
and what's happening with home prices. Because even without having a full six-month supply of
inventory on the U.S. housing market, home prices are still going down in about half of the country
right now. And sellers also outnumber buyers by about 500,000 people, guys. That is kind of insane,
which means that sellers have lost most of their leverage that they have had over the past five
years. Not everywhere, but a lot of places that is now true. And at the same time, sellers are
failing to adapt to this new era of selling a home. They're failing to adapt to homebuyers'
concerns. They're failing to adapt to new pricing that makes sense and what's in line with reality.
And it shows by the amount of purchase agreements that have been canceled. As of August, 56,000
U.S. purchase agreements were canceled, which represents 15.1% of homes that went under
contract. That's the highest share for August deals falling through going back to 2017. And
that's when they started keeping track. And basically what's happening is there's a disconnect
between buyers and sellers, and they're just not on the same page. And that's why these deals are
falling apart at record numbers. In a survey of Redfin's real estate agents, 70% of them said that
inspection or repair issues were the cause of canceled contracts by far as the top reason.
And that was followed by almost 28% who said that the buyer financing fell through, which suggests
that 30% of folks right now are having a hard time qualifying for a mortgage in today's environment.
21% also cited not being able to sell their current home as the main reason for canceling
the contract. And 15% said there was a change in the buyer's financial situation. And 13% said the
buyer had found another house that they preferred instead. And some of the other reasons were
concerns about the current economy. And actually 11% of the time, the seller's the one who backed
out. Also, low appraisals have been an issue. There's also been insurance issues as well as
high mortgage rates being at the bottom of the list. But it's really not high mortgage rates
that's the problem. It is the price of the house. And ultimately when somebody sees what their
payment's going to be for the house, they can get some sticker shock because they can't believe
their monthly payment's going to be that high. And a small percentage of people blame mortgage rates,
but mortgage rates could be 10% or 15% and it wouldn't matter if the median home price was
100 grand. Now it's not really a surprise that Florida and Texas had the highest cancellation
rates across the country because the supply of new listings in these states have been
absolutely crazy. And meanwhile, sellers still think that their homes will command the high
asking prices that happened back in 2020 and 2021 and 2022. That was forever ago.
So many sellers are having a hard time adjusting to this new reality, the fact that it's no longer
a seller's market, the fact that most people are not paying over asking price anymore,
and homes are not getting multiple offers in many cases anymore either. This recent Redfin report
also pointed out that the lower price homes are in the greatest demand, which is not really a
big shocker. But also those lower price homes also have the highest amount of issues that come up
during inspections, which makes it more likely that the buyer's going to cancel the contract.
Because a lot of times these listings just look too good to be true, guys. You see a house that's
in your budget, looks great, neighborhood's fantastic, whatever. And then you go look at it
and it's a pile of garbage. Everything needs to be renovated essentially. The plumbing and electric
hasn't been updated. And it's basically a money pit. Not to mention people have to fight higher
insurance premiums. Here in California, they even have an insurance contingency on their for sale
contracts to make sure that you are okay with the amount of insurance that you're going to be paying
on that new home as one of your outs for the contract. Because insurance is such an issue
here, just like it is in Florida. In fact, pending home sales actually fell in September for the
first time in about three months, even as mortgage rates continue to drop. And I just remember,
I don't know how many hundreds of times I read in different stories that, oh, as soon as mortgage
rates drop, we're going to see everybody come rushing back into the market. And in fact,
it has been the opposite. 2025 is slated to be the worst home sale year on record since 1995.
Once again, topping the record from 2023 and 2024. A Fannie Mae survey that came out earlier
this month also showed that 70% of Americans believe the economy is headed in the wrong
direction. And 73% think it's a bad time to buy a house. And I pride myself in being directly
responsible for part of that sentiment, guys. I am happy to know that my channel has probably
influenced hundreds of thousands of people out there to think this way, because it's the right
way of thinking. It's the realistic way of thinking. It's not a coincidence that 73% of
people think the economy is heading in the wrong direction. People are feeling it in their wallets.
They're seeing it in their monthly payments for everything spiking, all while not seeing their
income go up anywhere close to the amount necessary to keep up with any of it. And to
give you the idea of the kind of thing that's happening out there right now, here's a little
quick real estate story. One agent says that they worked with a seller who received 78 repair
requests from a buyer following the inspection. And that was after the seller had already agreed
to lower their asking price by $25,000 because the house needed some improvements. The buyer
came back and said they would handle the cost of repairs, but only if the seller was willing to
lower the price by another $100,000. The deal didn't work out. And I see that a lot here, guys.
I go to a lot of open houses when I'm here in California. There seems to be so many of them
all the time. And you can tell certain places, man, they just need a ton of work, especially
some of these older properties here that haven't been touched or noticeably updated in at least
30 or even 50 years sometimes. And then those sellers think that they can command top dollar
in the market. Who are they kidding? I don't blame this buyer at all for asking for an additional
$100,000 in repair costs because it costs a ton of money to make these repair costs. And even
besides the repair costs themselves, the amount of time and effort and energy it drains from you
is exhausting, guys. Meeting with repair people, getting estimates for everything,
dealing with contractors not showing up on time or deadlines being delayed,
living in shambles once you actually own the house and don't have anywhere else to go,
and you're living through a construction nightmare. Who wants to go through that?
I know I don't. And then the sellers don't want to budge and don't want to give people
extra money off the sales price to accommodate for not only the extra costs, but the massive
inconvenience of living there during the time. When you hear about stuff like this, it's basically
a guarantee that this housing market is going to remain broken for years to come. Until prices come
down back to earth, it's going to remain like this at least for probably two or three more years,
I would imagine, before enough sellers realize that if I want to sell, this is the right price
and others are going to be in a position where they have to sell,
so you can't afford the house anymore with the ever-increasing cost of living.
