Lost Del Sarto Painting Found! Madonna and Child

Andrea del Sarto
1 follower
4 Video Views·Oct 19, 2025
Madonna and Child” found in a church attic in West Newbury, Massachusetts
The painting was discovered in All Saints’ Episcopal Church.
Seacoast Online
It had been donated to the church in 1935, but was thought to be a copy.
Seacoast Online
In 2000, experts using infrared analysis determined it was an original by Andrea del Sarto.
In northern Massachusetts, up by the New Hampshire border,
it's a small Episcopal church that was showing its age.
All Saints in West Newbury was nearly 100 years old,
and the small congregation was having trouble keeping up
with the much needed repairs.
The front steps were cracking, the brickwork
was falling apart.
The new rector, Bill Murdock, was rummaging in his office
closet one day when he discovered an old painting that
had been stored there.
It was only hanging in the church
briefly for a short period of time, roughly around 87, 86.
And the people's opinion of the painting when it hung up
was that it was pretty ugly.
A parish history referred to the painting
as a 19th century copy of Madonna and Child
by the Italian Renaissance painter Andrea del Sarto.
Apparently, a lot of the parishioners
did not like the painting.
They thought it was an ugly painting.
So they decided they wanted the painting taken down.
The painting had also been hung in the church once before,
decades earlier, but met with the same disfavor
on the part of the congregation.
About 40 years ago, it appears that it was taken down
from hanging in the church and was stuck
in the attic of the rector's house.
Actually, one of our parishioners who was going up
there and helping clean the attic, she found it.
And I came across this painting that was on the floor.
First, it didn't seem to be a painting.
It looked like a big board.
And I stood the painting up and looked at the other side.
It was a beautiful painting.
It was covered with dust.
But I also noticed that there was a beautiful gold
frame separated from it on the other side.
That gold frame looked like it belonged to this painting.
When it was rediscovered in the mid-'80s,
after 25 years in an attic, I think it looked kind of musty,
but it was hung up behind the choir in the church again.
And from what I understand, it wasn't long after that
that some people said, you know, I really don't like that there.
It really doesn't go with the rest of the church.
And that's when it wound up in the rector's closet.
When Murdoch found it, he decided to have it appraised.
And a local art dealer confirmed it
was a copy that was probably done in the 19th century.
Value?
About $45,000, money they badly needed for the church repairs.
But before selling it, Murdoch decided
it would be prudent to have a second opinion
and sent pictures of the painting
to the New York auction houses.
At Sotheby's, they were reviewed by Christopher Apostle,
director of Old Masters.
It had been recorded in the church archives
as a gift given by a friend of the parish
as a 19th century copy of an Andrea del Sarto,
of which there are many in the United States.
He was highly admired.
But Apostle knew that the Del Sarto Madonna and Child,
which was in a Canadian museum, the one that
was believed to be the original, was in fact a copy.
And I could tell that there was something very
intriguing about the situation.
It was an old church.
You know, they weren't sure what they had.
They had an idea that it could be something good,
but they weren't sure.
And I just knew that I had to get on a plane.
The first auction house that came to the parish
and actually saw it walked through the door
and literally took his breath away.
Then he took out of his valise a book
that had Del Sarto on the cover,
and it was the life history of Del Sarto and his work,
and flipped open the page and then showed me
the painting of the Madonna and Child by Del Sarto
that's hanging in the Metropolitan Museum in Ottawa.
And I said, oh, so this is a copy of that painting.
And he said, no, the painting in Ottawa we know is a copy.
And what we don't know is we've never
found the original until now.
Who was Andrea Del Sarto?
Not the most famous painter of his generation.
He spent most of his life in Florence,
the capital of Renaissance Italy,
where his contemporaries were Michelangelo and da Vinci.
And so there was no question in my mind
that it was 16th century,
and very possibly by Andrea himself.
I am always very cautious in saying these things right out
because I knew that I'd have to do the research
and prove my case.
The painting was removed from the closet
and taken to Sotheby's,
where Christopher Apostle and his staff
went about the job of authenticating it.
In this particular case,
we found several scientific techniques very useful.
We were able to use infrared reflectography
to look through the paint surface itself
and see the original carbon underdrawing of the artist.
And there are several very interesting signs
and sort of clues to how and who painted the painting.
The underdrawing is the preliminary sketch
an artist usually makes before starting the painting.
Since there are many good examples
of other Del Sarto drawings available for comparison,
the reflectography showed that the underdrawing
below the painted surface of the Madonna and Child
was clearly by Del Sarto.
This painting, which had been tossed in the attic,
collecting dust for decades,
was in fact an original Del Sarto.
There is some record in our memorial book
about the painting being touched up,
if you will, by local house painters.
We don't know what they did, okay,
but maybe we shouldn't say that, I don't know.
After the rediscovery of the Del Sarto
here in February 1999,
I realized that for four years
I had been keeping the original Andrea Del Sarto's
painting of the Madonna and Child in this closet
and hanging my coat over it.
All Saints operates on an annual budget
of $188,000 a year.
The last Del Sarto to go to auction brought almost $400,000.
The painting, which had been hidden away
because nobody much liked it,
could turn out to be a much needed windfall
for the small church.
The very best use and stewardship of this piece of art
would be to sell it, not only for the monetary value,
but also for the possibility of it making its way
to a museum where it could be publicly displayed
and enjoyed by a variety of people.
So Reverend Murdock and 25 or so members
of the congregation traveled to New York for the auction.
The auction itself was filled
with excitement and anticipation.
It was such a high moment for us
that it felt almost surreal to me
and to many other folks that were there.
When the actual auction was beginning for our painting,
I was a nervous wreck.
Lot number three, the Andrea Del Sarto.
Start the bidding at $600,000.
$600,000 now at 625.
$650,000 now at 650.
75, $700,000 now at seven.
At 725, 750, $775,000.
At $775,000 now, any further bids?
Any further 800 we have?
At $800,000 now it's selling at 800.
At 825 I have 850.
875,000 now, 900,000.
View at 925 in the second row.
We have 950, 975.
At $1 million for it now, 1 million.
Any further advance then?
Fair warning then, 1 million.
Sold 1 million.
The church's long forgotten 16th century painting,
Madonna and Child by Andrea Del Sarto,
sold for $1.1 million, including buyer's commission.
It took just two minutes for the bidding
to fetch a new world record price for a Del Sarto.
The value of the painting is in fact five times
the annual budget of the parish as we now have it.
So the work has already begun on fixing up the church.
The brick is being repointed,
and there are plans for a completely new front entry.
But that's the least of what they're doing with the money.
Let's create another email in addition to this
and send it to India so that they know
the progress that we've made,
and that they can anticipate this check
for the purchase at home for the lepers there.
And now after the sale of the painting
we have an entirely new opinion of the painting.
