#ancientcoins#numismatics#coincollecting How did Rome’s elites protect their wealth when prices surged? In this video, we show why senators, generals, and merchants turned to gold, from the aureus to the solidus, as a hedge against polical uncertainty, state fraud, and as an insurance policy.
This video is kindly sponsored by L5. The New Marketplace for Ancient Coins! Check them out at "https://l5.com/"
Subscribe to our newsletter, never miss the latest updates on the channel, numismatic news, ancient coin market reports, and more: https://subscribepage.io/classicalnum...
SEO Tags: ancient coin collecting, upgrade your coins, bronze vs silver coins, coin collecting tips, budget coin collecting, Roman coins collection, numismatics, 12 Caesars coins, Caligula coins, Claudius coins, silver ancient coins, Roman coin upgrades, coin investment, building a coin collection, collecting rare coins, ancient coin hobby, collecting ancient numismatics, upgrading ancient coins, best ancient coins to collect, ancient coin buying guide, collecting Roman history, Caligula bronze coins, investing in ancient coins, Roman coin collectors, historical coins, coin collecting for beginners, ancient coin sets, ancient Roman coin collection, how to collect ancient coins, buying bronze coins, silver Roman coins, ancient coin value, coin trading, rare ancient coins, coin collecting for fun, ancient coins collection tips
Gold has a way of calming our nerves when the world seems to be going in the wrong direction.
It's portable and practical, it doesn't tarnish or change, and anywhere on earth you may go,
there's someone who will accept it on trade. That's why people have for thousands of years
used it as a safe haven or simply as a way to diversify their assets.
And back in ancient Rome, the Roman elites had the same idea about this metal.
I'm talking about senators, important merchants,
those who fought for Rome and its legions. They all kept portions of their fortunes
in gold coins and objects, not just because of the reasons I just mentioned, but especially
during the imperial period because they knew gold was a great way to protect themselves
financially when the emperors started resorting to some unorthodox methods of manipulating the
And the more I study Rome's relationship with currency manipulation and inflation,
the more I think we're headed in a similar path.
So, in today's video, we're going to look at how the Roman elites used gold
to protect themselves from inflation, to protect themselves from the ups and downs in Rome's
economy and political dramas, and, I don't know, we might even learn a thing or two about the
timeless nature of gold as real, tangible money. Let's get started.
Gold in the shape of coins entered Rome's monetary life relatively late. During most
of the republican period, silver was the only precious metal in circulation, with
gold coins being made only in very specific emergencies, as the supply of silver was not
enough for war expenses. Gold was simply too scarce to support a large regular issue.
As an example, during the Second Punic War, as Hannibal ravaged the Italian peninsula,
Rome issued a series of special gold coins, very likely using gold seized from its temples as a
desperate way of raising as much cash as possible to make a stand against the Carthaginians.
The situation changed as Rome became a Mediterranean power, expanding into regions
rich in mines such as Iberia, Gaul, and Britain, and as its expanded territory granted them easier
access to places like Egypt, North Africa, and the Middle East, where gold was more easily
obtainable through trade. The result was a visible increase in available gold beginning
in the first century BC. And that's the time period when we see the first truly large gold
issues being made in Roman territory, first under people like Sulla and Julius Caesar,
and a few decades later, the first emperor, Augustus, formalized Rome's gold coin, the aureus,
as a part of the monetary standard and a regular gold denomination that was made at the mince.
He set up a bimetallic system in which gold and silver circulated together at a legal rate of 25
silver denati to one gold aureus, implying a gold to silver ratio of roughly 12 to 1.
Despite being a rare coin only seen in major transactions within the elite or as an instrument
of savings, the high purity of both gold and silver coins meant both coins could be found
in circulation and transacted at their face value stipulated by law. This situation endured for
a couple of centuries, until the very end of the 2nd century AD. Unfortunately, the situation
started to destabilize around the end of the 2nd century and especially in the 3rd century.
A series of structural problems started to disturb the equilibrium of the Roman economy.
First, Rome had a constant deficit of gold through trade. The purchase of luxury goods
from places like India, China and the Arabian Peninsula generated a permanent outflow of gold,
with Pliny the Elder complaining that India was the sink of the world's gold as far back as the
1st century AD. As Rome stopped its wars of expansion in the mid-2nd century, this also
led to a steep reduction on the influx of gold into the empire from spoils of war. Adding to that,
the slow exhaustion of the gold mines inside the empire's territories and gold started becoming
rarer and rarer due to this structural deficit of the metal. We see this reduction of the supply
of available gold manifested in festivals such as the Liberalitas. In this event, emperors displayed
their largesse and generosity by distributing money to the public. This was a very common way
to boost his popularity. Coins of all metals were made specifically for these occasions.
They even had special designs on the coins, marking these coins as gifts, and people from
all social classes received something. From the 2nd century onwards, we start to see the Aureus
in these ceremonies being replaced by the Cinarius Aureus, a smaller coin, worth half an Aureus.
Full-weight silver denarii, however, were still given. This might indicate an austerity move to
conserve gold, which must have been in short supply. The thing is, what really caused major
problems to the Roman economy was the constant debasement of its silver coinage. Silver coins
formed the bulk of the monetary supply, so even though Rome operated under a bimetallic system,
in practice, it functioned like a silver standard, with gold playing the role of a
concentrated store of value. Starting in the 2nd century AD, emperors started reducing the silver
fineness of the denarius, in order to keep the army and the state funded, despite not having
enough silver to do it. The reduction was gradual and very hard to notice at first.
From 100 to 200 AD, the denarius fell from about 90% under Trajan to roughly 75% under Marcus Aurelius
and Commodus. The Aureus, on the other hand, did not see its gold content reduced, retaining a
high purity of 95% plus for most of the time it was issued, and there were plenty of reasons to
justify that resilience of gold. First and foremost, one of the ways the elites had to
preserve their wealth was with gold. Silver could be debased in order to stretch the state budget,
but since gold was used to buy the support of powerful allies, conduct high-level transactions
amongst the elites and as savings for the powerful, it never saw its purity reduced.
And the luxury products they purchased also had to be bought using high-purity gold. Foreign
merchants rejected the bad gold coins, so they had to use high-quality gold in order to access these
goods. The poor denarius, however, just kept losing more and more of its silver. After the
disastrous reign of Commodus and the civil war that followed it, inflation in the basement of
coinage really picked up pace. In just 17 years, between 193 and 210, the denarius dropped from
about 75% fineness in the early reign of Septimius Severus to roughly 50%. Gold began to trade at a
premium against the new denarius of lower quality, breaking the old 25 to 1 relation.
Spending gold simply became irrational, so people either hoarded their gold or demanded
more denarii for their gold coins. In 215, Emperor Caracalla tried to fix the situation by
cutting the aureus weight from 7.3 grams to roughly 6.5 grams. This was done in an attempt
to put gold back in circulation by making coins of lighter weight that were more in line with the
silver coins of lesser fine content. However, the adjustment seems to have been largely ignored and
hoarding just continued. What Caracalla seemed to have ignored is that people were hoarding
not just because there was an environment of economic uncertainty and blatant manipulation
of the currency. People were afraid of the instability of roman politics. Caracalla's father
came to power through violent means. He himself killed his own brother and co-emperor.
And it's not like people were paying attention to the silver to copper ratio on the coins in order
to decide how much to hoard. They were doing it because political violence had become normalized.
As the third century progressed and the empire plunged into a period of crisis,
silver coins kept being debased more and more as usurpers and short-lived emperors
tried recruiting as many troops as they could to fight for the throne. This led to a complete and
final disconnection between gold and silver. Gold was then transacted based on its metal weight,
its face value was ignored and it lost any relation to the now untrustworthy low-grade
silver coins of this now dysfunctional monetary system. Auries struck under the emperors of the
third century crisis are extremely rare, mostly because these were only issued to pay for troops,
as prizes for generals or as stores of value for the powerful. Gold was not seen in circulation.
The weight of the auries during this time also started becoming increasingly erratic. During
the worst moments of Rome's monetary collapse, under Gallienus and Claudius II, between around
265 and 270, auries fluctuate wildly in weight, between 5 and down to 1.7 grams. This shows these
coins were not part of the monetary system anymore, which by that time was entirely made out of
coppery looking coins with as little as 2% silver in them. This variation in weight indicates these
coins were transacted purely by its bullion value. The fact it had the emperor's face in it
was mostly as a way of these elites knowing that this gold came from the emperor they were
currently maintaining in power. Gold coins had become the only reliable way of saving,
and basically a parallel monetary system, mostly reserved for the military, the aristocracy and
maybe the important merchants who provided these people with the goods they needed.
And today's video is brought to you by L5, the new ancient coin marketplace. L5 is a platform
developed by coin collectors for coin collectors. It offers the lowest transaction fees on the
market, from 5% down to 0. No listing fees or undisclosed reserve prices, and you can choose
between buying and selling coins through its auctions or its fixed price lists. The most
important idea behind L5 is generating an environment of trust between people. You can buy,
you can sell, you can do both if you want to, all within a system of transparency and accountability
between its users and the platform. Apart from a lifetime guarantee of authenticity in case
any coin sold on L5 turns out to be a counterfeit, the platform works with a group of renowned
experts on different fields of ancient numismatics and a body of expert moderators, with the objective
of creating an environment of high trust where every single coin is reviewed by more than one
person and curated by an input from the community. I think their concept of collaborative accountability,
low fees and transparency is a revolution to the ancient coin market, and I can't recommend L5
enough. Give them a look. I personally think this is a wonderful concept that the ancient
coin market was in need for. Visit L5.com. As we leave the 3rd century crisis, in which
Roman miraculously survived it, we move into what we know as the Late Roman Empire, that's the 4th
and 5th centuries AD. We see this two-tiered monetary system was officialized and normalized.
Emperors like Diocletian and Constantine both conducted monetary reforms, and both had one
thing in common. The value of gold coins was disconnected from the other, lower valued coins.
A gold solidus, the name of this new gold coin of the late empire, was worth its weight in gold.
It didn't have a face value. A solidus was worth a solidus. There were also intermediate silver
coins of high purity that were introduced for the sake of practicality, as one solidus was a
lot of money, and these were valued as fractions of the solidus. One of the most common ones was
the Siliqua, also called Kerathion in the Greek-speaking parts of the empire. 24 of these
kerathia made one solidus. By the way, that's where we get our word carrots from, used today
to describe the purity of gold. 24 kerathia made up a solidus, and 24 carats today means
something made out of pure gold. The unit we use is a direct inheritance from the Romans.
And, you know, we might have imagined that the nasty years of hyperinflation of the 3rd century
would have taught the Romans their lesson about the dangers of debasement, monetary fraud, or
coming up with money out of thin air. No, nothing further from the truth. After so many years of
civil wars, and external threats, and just chaos, the empire that emerged from this chaotic period,
the empire from the 4th and 5th centuries, was a very different institution compared to that of
the 1st and 2nd centuries. The emperor was no longer the approachable princeps, the first
citizen. He was now analogous to a king. He was your dominus. He was a powerful general,
and a man sanctioned by divine will. And you were not just a Roman citizen anymore. Actually,
this didn't mean a lot. You were a subject of the empire, first and foremost. At around 300 AD,
a complete monetary reform was enacted, and a new unit of account, the denarius communis,
was introduced. It was used to tariff the lower value denominations. These were new coins issued
in different weights and varying proportions of mostly copper and a little bit of silver.
These were the majority of the money in circulation. Whenever a civil war broke out,
or a foreign invasion required increased military expenditure, or the state simply
needed more money to fund itself but did not have the available cash, the imperial office could
simply launch an edict that re-tariffed these low-valued coins, raising their face value,
and issuing more of these now overvalued coins to fund whatever they needed. Of course,
this was a highly inflationary move, but the thing is, times were different, and this new
authoritarian nature of the imperial office had been normalized. The emperor simply could
do such things. If that level of monetary manipulation was attempted back in the first
or second centuries, the senators or the plebs would have certainly complained,
if not straight up risen and armed revolt. But in the late empire? The emperor was your dominus et
deus, your lord and god. He had the god-given sanctioned right to do so, so he just did it.
The late empire's inflationary numbers really put anything made in the 3rd century to shame.
For you to have an idea, in 300 AD, a numus, a 10g coin with 5% silver in it, so a fine content of
0.5g of silver per coin, was worth 25 denarii comunis. That means each of these
units of account was the equivalent of 0.02g of silver. By 330 AD, under Constantine the Great,
his numus coin, now called a centennialis, or coin worth 100, that is 100 denarii comunis,
it had fallen to a weight of just 3.4g in a silver purity of 2.5%. That's a staggering
reduction of weight and silver purity in relation to its face value. Under Constantine,
each denarius comunis was worth 0.00085g of silver. If we assume this level of devaluation of the
we get a cumulative inflation of 2250% over the course of 30 years, or around 11% of yearly
inflation rates. Imagine living under 11% inflation for most of your life. Pretty horrible, no?
That's why in the late empire, so many low-ranking soldiers, or anyone not wealthy enough to have
their savings in gold, they would prefer to be paid in kind, in the everyday products they needed,
and a significant part of the economy devolved to barter. So how did Constantine not lose his
head after scamming the lower strata of his people that much? Well, his troops, his court,
the upper echelons of Roman society, everyone who had physical access to him, they handled mostly
gold solidi and silver siliquae, and these never lost its value. The solidus established by
Constantine was so stable in its weight and gold purity, that it kept being issued in the same
weight, 4.5g, and the same 95 to 97% purity for centuries. The last high purity solidus was made
around 1040 AD, more than 700 years after it was introduced. It was one of history's most
stable coins. So when looking at all of this evidence, from across the republican period and
its emergency issues, to the early imperial standard and the aureus, to its resilience as
money during endless crisis periods, through the age of the solidus, and its continuation in the
roman empire throughout the middle ages, we're talking about over 1200 years of the use of gold
as a store of value. I don't know about you, but if something has kept its reputation as being
synonymous with money and savings for over a millennia, I would say that makes the point that
gold is a pretty amazing form of money. Maybe not the only form of money, but certainly a pretty
good one. And mind you, we've only looked at the case of the romans in this video. Gold is mentioned
all over the world, throughout history, whenever a monetary system meets hard times. Now, I know
gold has just crossed $4,000 per ounce, and I don't know if we will return to a gold standard
one day, but at least the romans left us a nice lesson. Any durable monetary system anchors its
value in real assets, not numbers on a ledge, bits on a computer screen, or even worse, some abstract
concept that can be manipulated by some politician. So, what do you think? Do you think the roman
elites were right in using gold as a store of value? Would you use, maybe, silver instead? I
would love to read what you think in the comment section down below. I hope you enjoyed this
episode. Remember to leave a like, share, and subscribe if you did. Happy collecting, and I'll see you soon!
Let me give a special thank you to all of my amazing channel members and Patreons for their
generous support. This channel would not be the same without your help, and if you would like to
be part of this list, have early access to my videos when they are uploaded to YouTube, and a
series of other perks, make sure to check out my Patreon page and my Members tab on YouTube. Thank
you very much!