What is the most difficult specialty insurance line to sell - and how can that be changed?

Business Insurance
4 followers
2 Video Views·Oct 19, 2025
At the BIBA Conference 2025, industry experts shared their take on one of the toughest challenges in insurance—selling complex specialty lines.
From waste and recycling to other misunderstood sectors, speakers explained why certain markets remain difficult and what it will take to change that. Insurance Business UK was there to get the inside perspective.
The Biba Conference 2025 brought together the insurance sector's top executives
and Insurance Business UK was on site to ask the industry's biggest questions.
In this edition, we ask, what is the most difficult specialty insurance line to sell
and how can that be changed?
Just speaking from experience, waste and recycling is particularly difficult, always has been.
I think a lot of that comes from the lack of understanding of that particular market
and I think it needs a very specialist approach.
I think from a risk management and surveying point of view,
you need to be working with not just somebody with a clipboard who looks at it like any other
difficult commercial risk, but somebody who's got extensive experience in that sector.
Again, within Innoventum Group, we have securities risk management who work hand-in-hand
and hand-in-glove with the broker and the MGA side of the business.
The waste and recycling industry is 20 billion sterling in the UK.
It's a huge opportunity but those people really need that
insight and that risk management to look at how can they look at things like fire suppression,
storage.
Certainly, waste is one that I would have as an example.
Then speaking to our guys on the broken side, I think some of you non-standard property as well.
A Lloyd's broker's role really is to go and find those markets, put those programmes together.
It's not about going to one market anymore and try to get that risk done,
but how can they layer a programme and get the right terms and the right outcome for the client.
With my history in marine, my first thought goes towards marine cargo insurance.
Some estimates say that as much as 60% of the ocean world's cargo is currently uninsured,
which I just find incredible, especially if you consider that our clients could have a loss.
Even if there's no physical loss or damage to their products, this happens in general average.
If you imagine if you had a container on board the Ever Given when it was stuck in the Suez Canal,
you would have to contribute to that loss even though there's no loss to your products.
If I think further afield to other clients, then perhaps terrorism.
Selling our commercial products versus the usual route to market can provide challenges.
Whilst I think the risk is well understood in the cities of major conurbations, perhaps not
so much further afield. So if you think about tourist destinations, for example.
But for me, cyber is the big one. Despite headline grabbing news, as we saw just last
week with the Lahore National Retailer, many SMEs do not see this as a perceived risk.
How do we engage with them in this? Education, education, education. I think we have a role
to play here, educating our brokers and clients to show them the risk they face.
Well, in the financial lines sector, I think the most difficult product to sell is the management
liability product. Management liability product is a blended D&O, employment practices liability,
corporate legal liability and crime product. We think that only about 10% of UK limited companies
actually purchase ML and those are with turnover of less than 250 million. So that's not a really
good hit rate. Despite that product providing really critical coverage for directors' personal
assets and other management liabilities that the board faces on a day-to-day basis.
So I think the solution is really to increase the value of the product in the eyes of the client
by moving away from a sort of one size fits all online portal approach to a more underwriter
fronted approach. And then what you do is you put the technology behind the underwriter, which
allows for speed of delivery and reduces things like misrepresentation and broker E&O risk.
It basically ensures that underwriting is done on a case-by-case basis, so clients get proper
breadth of coverage, that the brokers who are often generalists in the regions get help with
the best way of selling that product to their clients. And then finally, if you add on some
like a portfolio monitoring tool, you actually allow the broker to get closer to their clients
by allowing them to talk directly to their clients about issues that may be affecting
their policy on a day-to-day basis. Well, I work in engineering insurance. I would say
engineering insurance is one of the most difficult specialty line to sell. We're typically 11th on a
list of 10 things for most brokers. So our challenge is to make sure that our covers
are seen alongside the main core covers of said property. So our main cover, engineering breakdown,
really important cover. Often most brokers think they've got covered in their commercial combined
or their property insurance, but actually engineering can add to those covers. Often
people think they've got that covered within their maintenance agreement. But again, the cover can
provide for major loss or major breakdown. So it's really just raising the whole profile, educating
and making sure our brokers and our customers are aware of the value of our specialist products.
So the most difficult insurance to sell in my view, of course, is niche products like ours,
which are non-compulsory. It's about convincing companies to understand the need of something
they don't have to buy. And that's all about training and education. It's really helping
them get access to the market that they previously couldn't do. And again, it's something that we're
really pushing to help with. We have the lowest minimum premiums in the market. We're the only UK
regional product recall insurer. And that means we're creating that accessibility, especially to
SMEs that really need the coverage. And so through that, we're really helping them understand,
learn, especially the brokering community, how the coverage works and how we can help.
