‘Salvator Mundi’ is a painting surrounded by mysteries. In this talk, Professor Martin Kemp FBA explores evidence that it is indeed a work of Leonardo Da Vinci, the painting’s key components, and the alleged whereabouts of the ‘Salvator Mundi’ today.
Speaker: Professor Martin Kemp FBA, Emeritus Professor of the History of Art, University of Oxford; Honorary Fellow, Trinity College, Oxford
The British Academy convenes research insights from across the disciplines we represent. The views expressed in our videos are those of the contributors and do not reflect the views of the British Academy.
Comments are open to viewers and are governed by the policies of YouTube. We do not monitor or moderate comments and will not reply to them.
Subtitles, also known as closed captions, are available on our YouTube videos. You can access them by clicking on the 'CC' button or gear icon on the video. The 'CC' button and gear icon are usually located at the bottom of videos.
Images included in this video: 0:33 - Salvator Mundi attributed to Leonardo da Vinci c.1490-1519, oil on panel, private collection. (Photo by VCG Wilson/Corbis via Getty Images)
01:41 - Anonymous, Salvator Mundi (Cristo Redentore benedicente), first half of XVI century, Worsey Collection.
01:41 - Salvator mundi prima del restauro, c. 1499, Cook Collection 1913.
01:41 - Salvator mundi, copy, from the Ganay collection.
01:41 - Gerolamo Alibrandi, Studio di Leonardo, Cristo come Salvator Mundi, c.1519, Museo di San Domenico Maggiore. Fondo Edifici di Culto -Ministero dell'Interno.
01:41 - Anonymous, Christ as Salvator Mundi, Zurich, Private collection, former Viktor Stark Collection.
01:41 – Copy, Christ as Salvador Mundi, Circle of Leonardo da Vinci c. 1452–1519.
01:41 - Cesare da Sesto, Salvator Mundi (1516–1517). Wilanów Palace, Warsaw
01:41 – Salvator Mundi, copy, Gian Giacomo Caprotti, 16th century.
03:10 – Leonardo da Vinci c1472-c1519. From The Literary Works of Leonardo Da Vinci, Vol. 1 by Jean Paul Richter, PH. DR. [Sampson Low, Marston, Searle & Rivington, London, 1883]. (Photo by The Print Collector/Getty Images)
09:06 - Christie's To Auction Leonardo da Vinci's "Salvator Mundi" Painting. Photo by Eduardo Munoz Alvarez/Getty Images
Hello, my name is Martin Kemp. I'm Emeritus Research Professor in the History of Art
at the University of Oxford and Fellow of Trinity College.
You may think a senior academic has a rather quiet and desirable life,
sort of reading the odd book and going to the odd conference and pottering in the garden.
This, because of Leonardo, is absolutely not what's happened to me at all.
If you're involved with him, it's a pretty turbulent passage on the whole.
What we're going to be looking at today is the Salvatore Mundi, the saviour of the world.
It's a very disputed painting with masses of stories.
Almost daily there's some sort of story about where it is and what's happened to it.
What I'm going to begin by doing is looking at the painting itself,
but of course I can't ignore the fact that this is the most expensive painting in the world.
15th November 2017, it sold for 450 million dollars at Christie's.
A world record price for a painting.
Or it's in a way not for the painting, it's a world record price for Leonardo
for participating in the myth and the extraordinary presence of Leonardo as a cultural figure.
Let's ask the question initially, did Leonardo paint a Salvatore Mundi?
The answer is yes, almost certainly, or he certainly designed a Salvatore Mundi.
He got two red chalk drawings at Windsor for the drapery.
He's still manoeuvring the drapery a bit but it's basically preparatory studies for the Salvatore
Mundi. Very typical in red chalk is Leonardo. The other one which suggests it's a famous
painting is copies. What you can see here are seried ranks of copies. I think we're
now up to about 50 of them and because it was a prestigious image it was much copied and that
indicates that early on it was regarded as something very special.
The first documentary reference we have of it is in the list of the possessions of his
rascally pupil, Silai, who stole anything that was not tied down. Leonardo had a great affection
for him. He died in 1525, which is six years after Leonardo, and he had a series of paintings,
seemingly Leonardo or maybe good copies of Leonardo, in his possession.
One of these pictures in 1525 is called Uno Cristo in modo di uno Dio Padre,
a Christ in the manner of God the Father. Rather a nice title because God the Father
was often shown blessing and holding a globe, so this is imagery which has migrated into the
Salvatore Mundi, which wasn't the title of the picture at this time.
What I'm going to do is to look at three aspects of the picture as a picture to say this is why
it's Leonardo and it's not somebody else. This is not standard connoisseurship. It's actually
got a lot of content. The first one is watery hair. Leonardo was a great studier of why things
looked like they did and he had a theory about the physics of hair, as I call it,
and he compared it with water. If you've got a rushing column of water, you've got the weight,
the direction of the water, you've got the weight of the hair. Water hitting water revolves in
itself and hair curls because of its curling propensity. In both cases it makes a helix.
Leonardo knows the physics of hair. If we look at one of the copies, the copyist,
rather about the best copy of the picture on the right doesn't really understand how hair curls,
how it works. It curls for the use of rather than really got a structure. Leonardo being Leonardo
has to classify the spirals, a convex one, a flat one, a concave one and a rather muddled up one.
This is very typical. Nobody else did that. They just didn't think it was worth that kind of
level of investment. The second aspect is the crystalline sphere which Christ holds in his left
hand, which is recognisable as a sphere of rock crystal. It's not glass. It's not bubbles in
glass. It's rock crystal and it's got lots of inclusions, as they call it in geology,
little spaces when it's being formed under enormous heat. This is a little bit of rock
crystal I have which compares rather nicely with the crystalline sphere. This becomes of interest
because it introduces a new content. Salvatore Mundi is the saviour of the world and previous
Salvatore Mundi's old globes, or maybe even a proper fully formed globe of the earth as such.
This is the crystalline sphere of the heavens. It's the outermost reach of the universe. There's
nothing beyond that other than heaven, which we can't really know. So this is a very characteristic
move and enhancement of the subject matter of the picture. Raphael on the ceiling of the
Sanse delle Sennature here, you've got a Urania who's looking at the crystalline sphere of the
heavens with the signs of the zodiac, which Leonardo obviously doesn't do. But this is definitely
the sphere of the heavens and not the earth. The third argument detail is how the eye works.
Leonardo has to ask about everything. How does it work? Why does it do this? How does it look like
that? His model of the eye late in life comes from Islamic science from Ibn al-Haytham. It's a very
complex optical instrument which refracts the light in such a way that it will form an image.
He looks at the primary ray coming straight into the eye and saying that registers most clearly.
But there are lots of other rays which come in, so you've got a blurred edge. You don't have an
absolutely definite knowledge. He writes at one point, the eye does not know the edge of any body.
As I say, you never see anything absolutely perfectly clearly. If you look at late images
by Leonardo, these have what is often called sfumato, this smoky or blurring effect. It's
not Leonardo's work, but it's become rather entrenched. Here you've got the Salvatore Mundi,
this very soft, elusive depiction of contours and a detail from the Saint John the Baptist
and the Louvre, exactly the same. This is optical ambiguity, but it's also spiritual
in that it's evoking a world we can't see. Christ and Saint John know the secrets.
He wrote, I leave the definition of the soul to the minds of the friars, father of the people
who by inspiration possess the secrets. I let be the sacred writings, for they are the supreme
truth. I don't have any irony in that. There is a realm we can't know about, and it's this realm
which this ambiguous glance that Saint John and Christ and the Salvatore Mundi share.
So the elusiveness is spiritual elusiveness and optical elusiveness. Again, none of the boys,
none of the people who follow Leonardo get that at all. Recent stories, I'm not going right back
to the discovery and sale of the first sale of the work, but looking at the instrument which
brought it before Christus. What happened was that the Salvatore Mundi was in the free port
in Geneva owned by Yves Bouvier. This is a port in which things can change hands for money without
tax. One of his customers was Dmitri Rybaloflev, a Russian oligarch, and he sold the Salvatore Mundi
to Rybaloflev for $127.5 million, which given the fact that Bouvier paid $80 million is rather a
big markup. By accident, Rybaloflev got an idea how much Bouvier was paying for these paintings
and how much he was charging him. He decided to sell the Bouvier pictures, including the Salvatore
Mundi, which came up at Christus. And here we've got a shot of the auction at Christus. It's pure
circus. The people on the cell phones phoning in bids, the auctioneer pausing as if it's sold,
and it's conducted in an incredibly theatrical manner. It's not so much a quiet auction as a
piece of financial theatre. What happened to the Salvatore Mundi? It was meant to be exhibited in
the 2019 exhibition in the Louvre to celebrate the 500th anniversary of Leonardo's death.
It was due to come. They had a space for it. It didn't come. What happened was that the Louvre
undertook a scientific examination of the picture, which appeared very briefly as a small book in the
Louvre bookshop, but went off sale as soon as they decided they weren't going to show it.
Very rare book. I've got a PDF electronic version of it, which is rather a rare thing.
And the technical examination gave full weight to it being consistent with Leonardo.
The book says the examination of the Salvatore Mundi seems to us to demonstrate the work was
indeed executed by Leonardo. Where is it now? There are guesses. Probably the best educated
guess is it's owned by Mohammed bin Salman, but we can't be certain. As a historian, I want
documented facts. And as you said, do I know where it is? The answer is I don't, but it's
something that's worth looking at. How about that? It's not, as you might imagine, actually
the real thing. This was made for an earlier event at the British Academy. Anyway, it's the
best we can do at this moment.