Crossbow or Longbow? What's Better for Defending Your Medieval Tower?

The Saga of Past Longbows
6 followers
12 Video Views·Oct 17, 2025
When you are hanging out in your medieval tower and get besieged, do you reach for a crossbow or a longbow? In the hands of skilled archers which will allow you to shoot closer to the base of the tower?
And of course the opposite is true; how close should you get to be safe from overhead archers?
Joe Gibbs is back shooting his 140lbs longbow and Tod is back (well I am always here to be fair), shooting his 860lbs crossbow off the battlements of Harcourt House.
Yeah all right. What I'm finding interesting is I thought
I would be all over you with this. Yeah. I thought I'd really have the edge.
Hi it's Tod from Tod's Workshop and Tod Cutler here and I am back
with Joe Gibbs. Hello. At Stanton Harcourt Manor House.
This amazing place that was besieged by a bunch of archers
in 1450. Now we just did a film where we're shooting for distance
It significantly improved things from shooting up there
but of course an attacking force is not going to be 300 yards in the distance
they're going to be up close. So we've got crenellations today that
we can go and play with and all those questions we want to know about
can you shoot straight down? Can you shoot over there? Is a crossbow better?
Is a longbow better? What are the practical implications
of shooting from that very place where they were shooting in 1450?
Shall we go find out? Let's do it. It's actually amazingly awkward because the
windlass handles are pretty much dragging over the stairs
at the front. It's also quite tiring.
Oh well it's got properly awkward now because the roof is coming in
and this thing's actually about 1.2 meters long, about four foot long
so I'm just going to swap it. It's also heavy.
Anyway see you up there. We're back on top of Pope's Tower here
in Stanton Harcourt and we have three of our knights set out in the garden there
below. So there's one about sort of 20 odd yards
away and then getting closer. Now the reason for that is of course we
know that you can shoot as we saw in the last film
at long distance but what happens when the guys come in close? The thing is
this is not a castle, it's not even a fortified manor house.
These are effectively decorative but they were used in the siege of 1450.
You know people shot from here were shot at from here. We do need to bear in mind
as we try things out that actually castle walls are very often a lot
thicker than this. So who's first? You or me? I think you
should go first yeah because you love heights.
Yeah as ever there's a little bit of preparation with these things.
This is where Joe is just standing in the back laughing and laughing.
Okay we're in but you know today is a day
to try and work out a little bit what these were all about.
Now you can shoot downwards, this is a bit awkward because
health and safety wasn't going to be an issue in 1450, it is a little bit now.
Right Joe, I think it must have hit a big bit of timber in the target but
it was basically shoulder. Sounded good though. Sounded good.
Right your turn. So I've got to be careful of my limbs
on there and on the floor. I mean it is awkward, the whole thing is awkward.
It's very awkward especially with a heavy bow.
Yeah all right. Just in his stomach. Yeah so nice one.
Okay that's interesting. I mean I had to stand right back
and the whole thing is just it is difficult. Yeah it was very difficult for me actually.
I think I'm going to really struggle with the next two.
You know I watch you shooting in a field and you are going through a very particular set of
movements. This is restricting you like heck. Yeah there's a lot of stuff going on in the way
and I'm not used to it and also the whole point of coming right down.
You want to keep as straight a back as possible and I'm having to bend right over and start
bending the spine and it's going to be hard work.
What I would say is you know don't hurt yourself. I don't know maybe they use lighter weight bows or
something like that in this situation. I don't know because obviously they're going to know
that it's a problem. Right centre chest. Did you get it? Oh nice shot. Okay but you know what though
again arrows versus armour trials that would have bounced off would have done nothing. Yeah
yeah that's true. You know we've seen it does nothing. Face shot that's what I wanted and
actually that's what I missed. Okay let's have a go.
Just over. More to the point though how did you feel? I mean if I said to you right one another 30
of them. Not another 30 but I would like to just do one more. Really same guy? Yeah. Take it away.
So I'm going to say our nearest guy certainly and I'm and this is clear as you like our nearest guy
if I was a bit worried a bit sweaty a bit people are shooting at me I'm not going to be able to
hit him because you know I've got stuff around here it's all gonna it will go wrong so actually
I I'm just going to back out that that nearest guy is which is he's still 12 yards from the
edge of the tower 12 12 meters and I can't touch him actually now if I lent right out the
crenellation yeah yeah but then my whole body is exposed I'm having to wind myself out and my bow
nobody's going to do that no so next time I besiege a castle you're gonna stick close to the walls
yeah but I suppose there's there's going to be that sweet spot isn't there far enough away people
can't dump stuff on you yeah um you know but close enough they can't adequately shoot you
so can you shoot that that guy near us a bit like yourself I can't I could if I had a lighter bow I
could probably hang out and uh and do a cheap sneaky little shot through there but with this
one yeah I can't lean out of there not a hope but I might just give it a go from here if I can just
if I can just get it down yeah I want to have a go what what I'm finding interesting is I thought
I would be all over you with this yeah I thought I'd really have the edge and I don't the advantage
that I thought I'd really have by shooting closer I haven't got no actually it's a disappointment
for me let's give that a closer one ago whoa hold on a minute I couldn't quite get low enough
no I can't do that though one just can't get that angle interesting yeah he's got whole
whole shoulders are offline and everything it's probably with a like a hundred pound bow 80 pound
bow yeah yeah could just about do it but not with this so looking at that document as well they say
over that six hour period thousand arrows shot but only one guy was killed really yeah which is
like pretty rubbish return really on your investment in arrows but it does mean that
the guy's sheltering here um must have been sheltering quite well you know how would you
defend this place to not get shot so obviously I'd load up put it on the string and then you'd
have to step out into into everyone's field of fire really wouldn't you uh and then pick your
target draw up aim and go that's that's you know second second and a half yeah because you've got
all the fumbling around of stepping out looking and then coming back down that's that's a long
time and then I suppose you probably had a quick couple of peaks generally so you know where you're
going to be going maybe I don't think I'm really going to be that much different so I'm you know
I slightly have an advantage although it's slower I can actually sort of crouch here but
but even doing that I've still got a massive exposure there and there you know it's not like
I'm hidden um so you know I'd be more inclined to to to go away from the edges really because
you know arrows are still going to come in there um and then once I am actually spanned
and then you can crouch down where I'm basically immune from shot and then you can stand up bam
and down and that's probably the quickest way that I can do it you're not going to be able to do that
so at least that's one slight advantage but it's not the game-changing advantage that I thought
crossbows might have in a situation so yet again audience explain to me why they were so good
struggling even though I love them so I think it's a pretty straightforward conclusion really
if depressing for me so I thought I'd have this one in the bag and I would be able to do things
here that you can't and that's actually not the case so there might be a very slight advantage in
in me being able to have cover when I'm shooting but not that much I have to expose myself too
I can't shoot down like actually I thought I probably could not not realistically I'm going
to be hanging out and be a beautiful target I can shoot basically the same targets that you can
shoot maybe I can go a bit longer because with your heavy bow you are going to end up hurting
yourself yeah it's not going to matter to me and you are not going to have unlimited missiles either
so the fact that you can shoot 10 shots in a minute doesn't matter because you're not going to
so I think that's probably where the advantage comes I can keep up awkward shooting actually
that is probably where it is I can keep up awkward shooting better than you can keep up
awkward shooting maybe it's just as simple as that really it was very awkward for me to be honest
and that's with skinny walls not even fat walls like you get on a castle I think I'll settle on
that as a conclusion I can do it for longer than he can do it um not as exciting an outcome as I
wanted anyway right let's um have another last go at that far guy there we're going to go for
accuracy this time accuracy right then so 10 pints for a face shot two for a chest shot okay
what did you get I got him here oh no but not here that's a the bottom limb oh really yep you can see
the uh little scratch to see the scratch look where yeah so that's put that otherwise that
shot would have been perfect is that right okay well I completely got that so Joe for the very
first and probably last time in my life I have just actually well done brilliant guys thank you
very much anyway uh for us it's definitely been an education so Joe thank you it's been great
thank you see you again
