Lady Macbeth | The limitations of white feminism (Video Essay)

The Florence Pugh Hub
7 followers
5 Video Views·Oct 17, 2025
William Oldroyd’s LADY MACBETH (2016) is largely praised as a feminist film by critics, despite its heroine's gross mistreatment of another woman.
Join me in exploring how the act of looking in LADY MACBETH challenges the idea that certain women are more deserving of freedom than other women
So William Goldroyd's adaptation of the Russian novella Lady Macbeth
of the Matinsk District takes place in rural England during the 19th century.
The film centers on Catherine, a young woman given in marriage to an older man
as part of a package deal involving land. And like so many period dramas about a
white heroine's struggle against male domination, Lady Macbeth
engages conventional feminist themes related to women's physical,
So far so conventional, right? Well, story dynamics are changed by the addition of a
whole new character, Catherine's mate Anna. This, combined with colorblind casting,
offers a rare opportunity to wrestle with questions about race, class, gender, and feminism.
Throughout the film, blocking shows how Catherine's father-in-law manages the ways
the women relate to each other, visualizing how patriarchal systems provide a basis for gender,
racial, and economic discrimination. Quite often, our attention is also drawn to a series
of exchanges between the women, and the ways that looking, and looking back, can telegraph
relations of power. A number of scenes show how indifferent Catherine is to Anna's experiences
of oppression, and when she discovers that a groomsman has assaulted Anna,
her response is to develop a flirtation, and then a sexual relationship with him.
Now what makes the film's attention to Anna's gaze so striking is that it gives us lots of
opportunities to consider how stories about women's quest for self-definition
and self-liberation might preserve and conceal other modes of discrimination.
In an interview, Lady Macbeth screenwriter Alice Birch describes making a key change to the story's
ending as a feminist act, because it allows Catherine to chart her own path and have another
life. But the fact that Catherine's freedom comes at the expense of another woman challenges this
claim. Throughout the film, we've seen Anna's gaze drawing attention to and evaluating Catherine's
behavior. Now, unable to defend herself from Catherine's mistreatment, we see Anna resigning
herself to death, ultimately presenting a critique of feminisms that enact their own systems of
And so, perhaps without meaning to, the camera's focus on Anna's gaze in the film's conclusion
reveals a thematic richness that exceeds the filmmaker's intentions.
