Analys: Framtidens maktbalans i Mellanöstern | NTD NYHETER

NTD Sverige
111 followers
NTD diskuterar om president Trumps undertecknande av ”Fredsavtalet för Gaza” och utvecklingen i Mellanöstern framöver med Gregory Copley, ordförande för International Strategic Studies Association och författare till "The Noble State: Governance Options in an Ignoble Era." Intervjun spelades in den 14 oktober.
#USA #israel #fredsavtal #gaza
Se mer: https://ntdtv.se/
peace deal and the dynamics in the Middle East going forward is Gregory
Copley. He's the president of the International Strategic Studies
Association and author of The Noble State, Governance Options in an Ignoble
Era. Gregory, thank you so much for joining us. Always good to have you. Now
historic day today as we saw the living Israeli hostages reunited with their
loved ones back home. Now Egypt honoring President Trump with its highest
civilian medal in Israel, nominating him for theirs world leaders including some
Trump detractors praising him for this achievement as well. Talk to us about
just how significant today is. What was it about President Trump and his
administration that allowed this to happen? Well, it was the force of
President Trump really which was so critical to bring this about. He used
unprecedented amounts of effort as he did to create the Camp David Accords in
his first term. So this is really about a passion of his. He is absolutely
committed. He was up against enormous odds and by the way, still is. This is
not over yet. He faces I think even greater challenges going forward. Very
important point. I want to dig into that. But first, you know, we saw President
Trump and world leaders in Egypt today, but there was one notable absence
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Now his office says it was
about an upcoming Jewish holiday, but some reports point to an alleged push
by Turkey to block his attendance. How significant is Netanyahu's absence?
It's very significant. You had the two major combatants in this war,
Hamas and Israel, absent from the signing of the peace accord. That makes you
wonder how long this accord will last. It was deliberate that Prime Minister
Netanyahu was kept away from the Sharm el-Sheikh peace talks and the signing,
largely by the President Recep Tayyip Erdogan of Turkey. President Erdogan is
really at war with Israel. He told President Sisi of Egypt that he would not
come and he would make sure some Arab leaders did not come to Sharm el-Sheikh
if the Prime Minister of Israel was there in attendance. So Benjamin
Netanyahu actually pulled back from that. He didn't want to stop the whole
ceremony. But what we see now is that this is President Erdogan of Turkey trying to take
center stage, and yet he is still at war with Israel. He is the one who basically organized,
financed and ran Hamas. Hamas is a Muslim Brotherhood organization. Erdogan's
in Turkey is a Muslim Brotherhood government. So this war is going to go on in another fall.
Erdogan has been attempting to control the new government of Syria, which is right at Israel's
doorstep, of course, right on the border. So Turkey is there continuing this war against Israel. It
will continue to be a problem. Erdogan will continue to find a way to stimulate renewed
conflict and violence. If he doesn't, he is basically out of business because his whole
credibility at home depends on being a winner. And right now, the Turkish economy is in the
nadir of its existence, really. So Erdogan is going to be a problem going forward for both
President Trump and Prime Minister Netanyahu. And yet, President Trump has bribed Erdogan to
come along to this event by promising him F-35s and other US high-tech weaponry.
A lot to unpack right there. I want to go back to your earlier point, though,
to when it comes to a blasting peace. Now, Hamas has a history of not keeping their end of the
ruling power. How likely are we to see the deal hold up this time, and what's required from
different stakeholders in ensuring this? Well, the first thing that Israel knew it had to do
was it had to eliminate Hamas as a credible fighting force. It went a long way down the
track to doing that. But now, of course, part of the peace deal is releasing a lot of Palestinian,
particularly a lot of Hamas fighters, who will now go back into the fray in one form or another.
Yes, they may be inhibited from using much of the land mass of Gaza to do that, but they will find
other ways to do it, and they will be and are being financed by President Erdogan of Turkey.
Not so much by Iran. Everyone's worried about Iran's role as a financier of Hamas,
but Iran is not the main player in this at all. Iran, in fact, is now withdrawn largely to a
large degree from that. It's a Shia country, and Hamas is a Sunni Muslim Brotherhood organization.
Expanding on that, there are already some concerns that Hamas isn't following through
with its commitments. What is the Trump administration's approach to handling this
issue, or what should it be? Well, it's going to have to be
fairly tough. It's going to have to support a clear management of the Gaza region going forward,
which will mean eliminating any presence of Hamas in the new administration.
Unfortunately, I think President Trump has allowed people such as the former British
Prime Minister Tony Blair to be part of this board of peace running, if you like, the new
Gaza administration. That's going to be a problem because Prime Minister Blair is not really a
supporter of Israel in any shape or form. He's there, I would say, for his own personal reasons,
which are not necessarily in the interest of long-term peace. So you've got a huge number
of problems. Israel will have to be tough. President Erdogan of Turkey is there to make sure
that Israel is seen to break the peace agreement when he's once again challenged by Hamas through
military and terrorist activities. A lot there for sure. Looking ahead,
though, what are you watching for in the Middle East, whether it's the expansion of the Abraham
Accords or perhaps an increasing bid by communist China to influence the region?
I don't think communist China is right now in a position to influence the region.
It may be after the October 2023 fourth plenary session of the Communist Party,
but the Communist Party in China is facing its own meltdown and is fighting for survival. So
they're out of the picture in many respects in the short term. They could come back later if
the Communist Party survives. Xi Jinping certainly won't. So basically, we're worrying about Turkey
facing a lot of the region, not just Israel, but also Iran itself. They'll also be
challenging Greece and Turkey. They're challenging Egypt to a large extent. So
the big problem going forward is going to be Turkey. And the question is, how are the regional
states plus the United States going to cooperate with Israel in containing Turkey? And a lot of
them want to. Sounds like a lot for another discussion. But Gregory Copley,
as always, thank you so much for joining us. Thank you.
