Pollyanna (1960) tells the story of a young girl whose unwavering optimism quietly transforms an entire town. Orphaned and sent to live with her strict and distant aunt, Pollyanna introduces a simple habit she calls the “glad game”—the practice of finding something to be thankful for, even in difficult circumstances.
Rather than sentimentality, the film offers a gentle meditation on character, kindness, and moral influence. Through patience and sincerity, Pollyanna’s outlook softens hardened hearts and reminds those around her that joy is often a choice rooted in gratitude. Anchored by a memorable performance from Hayley Mills, this beloved classic continues to resonate as a timeless reminder that hope, when lived out, can be contagious. “Reel Thoughts with Tiffany and Rebekah” is a weekly film review show hosted by Tiffany and Rebekah. They dive into traditional and classic films, covering everything from mainstream blockbusters to indie gems. Each episode offers thoughtful analysis, diverse perspectives, and an engaging experience designed to connect with and entertain viewers. #moviestar#talkshow#classicalmusic#Americantraditions#Hollywood#theatermagic#cinematic#entertainment#celebrity#moviefacts#classicfilms#drama#artshow#performance#movieanalysis
Early one morning just as the sun was rising I heard a maiden sing in the valley below
Oh don't deceive me, oh never leave me How could you use a poor maiden so?
Oh gay is the garland, fresh are the roses I've called from the garden to bind on thy brow
Oh don't deceive me, oh never leave me How could you use a poor maiden so?
Hello Aunt Polly, I'm so very glad to see you today.
See here child, when will you learn to enter a room like a lady?
Oh I'm sorry, I do so want to be a lady but it's such fun running through the hall and
it's such a beautiful day I couldn't help feeling glad about it.
What's all this glad business? That's the second time you've used that word since coming in.
Well that's the game.
The game?
Yes, father made it up once when I got crutches in the missionary barrel instead of a doll I'd
Whenever something bad happens you try to think of something to be glad about
and now I've gotten so I can't help thinking of glad things.
What's there to be glad about a pair of crutches?
Well that's what I said too but father said we could be glad we didn't need them.
You really are a most extraordinary child Pollyanna.
I'm Rebecca Brannan.
I'm Tiffany Brannan.
Welcome to Real Thoughts on Cinema.
Many classic works of literature have had such a big influence on culture
that they've actually added terms to the language.
True.
Many of these expressions and their sources are still an active part of culture but some
have become more of a thing of the past.
A good example of this is one popular children's book from the early 20th century
which inspired a beloved family film Pollyanna from 1960.
This film was made by Disney and it stars Hayley Mills,
Jane Wyman, Richard Egan and Carl Malden.
It was directed by George Swift.
Pollyanna is the story of a little girl who changes a whole town through her sunny disposition.
Young orphan Pollyanna Whittier goes to the New England town of Harrington Town
to live with her wealthy aunt Polly Harrington
who is a bitter spinster who controls the whole town because her father had so much money
that he instituted many of the local businesses and institutions.
Polly seems to enjoy controlling everything from the orphanage to many of the shops in town
and people are afraid to contradict her.
She is unsettled by the rambunctious but love-filled attitude which Pollyanna brings to her household.
Everyone in the Harrington household, all the servants and Polly herself,
are grumpy and grouchy when Pollyanna first arrives
but that doesn't stop the young girl from showing them love and above all gladness.
Using the glad game which her father taught her,
she shows people that you can find something about which to be glad in every situation
and before long she's making friends with local orphans,
showing a bitter old woman that she has a reason to live and helping people make friends.
Meanwhile, aunt Polly is unsettled by the reappearance of a former suitor, a doctor,
who now is becoming a very active part in the growing movement to host a bazaar
to raise funds which will help remove Polly Harrington's control of the town.
We mostly, of course, focus on films made between 1934 and 1954.
That's right.
When the Motion Picture Production Code was enforced by the PCA,
the Production Code Administration.
Yeah, we really consider this the golden era of Hollywood because it was a golden age for decency.
These movies were all very wholesome and because they were supervised by the Motion Picture
Production Code but after Joseph Green was replaced with Jeffrey Sherlock in 1955,
you see a sharp decline in the moral content of American films.
Right, but in the early 60s, Walt Disney Pictures, which was previously just really
known as an animation studio, started to make these wonderful live-action family films
and long after any other studio was really trying to make anything that the whole family could enjoy,
there are these beautifully wholesome Disney films that I know Disney has such a bad reputation now
but this was really kind of a golden era for Disney when they made these beautiful films
that really adhered to the guidelines that the code had in place all those years.
That's true. In the mid to late 50s, Disney started dabbling in full live-action because
before that they had mainly included a blend of animation and live-action.
But these early live-action Disney films were technically British films.
They filmed them in England.
Interesting.
But right around the late 50s, early 60s, you have movies that were fully live-action
American films and these included actors like Fred McMurray, a lot of comedies,
really fun movies, often animal-centered and Hayley Mills was also a big part of that.
She made six very successful beloved movies at Disney in the 1960s.
I know these movies are ones that we just really grew up with.
I remember from our earliest years seeing these films and
I considered Hayley Mills always kind of the face of those Disney films from that period.
She made some really great ones and this was her first.
She was a young British girl and this was her first American movie.
She'd only really made one movie before this in 1959
and when Disney was preparing to make this film, they looked at hundreds of little girls
but they ended up seeing her in that movie and realizing she would be the perfect person.
Even though it's technically an American character and she's very much British,
she embodied that character, that spirit.
Her father was also an actor, the very well-regarded Sir John Mills
and they were interested in his becoming an actor for the studio as well.
So they ended up coming up with a deal that both father and daughter would make a movie at Disney.
He made Swiss Family Robinson and she made Pollyanna.
And her mother, I believe, was a rather successful author.
Yes, she was.
Hayley Mills actually starred in a British film adaptation of one of her books,
Whistle Down the Wind.
Hayley Mills was an immediate hit and she just endeared herself to the hearts of the public
and everyone was enchanted by her charming presentation
but also her dramatic acting performance in this role.
And she received the last juvenile award that the Academy Awards would give out.
Really?
One thing which I find really interesting about this movie is
the vast amount of great classic stars in it.
I know.
And watching it again, being more familiar with earlier movies, I appreciate that even more.
Like this was my first introduction to Adolf Mongeau
who plays the grumpy old Mr. Pendergast in actually his last feature film.
Really?
But he was a huge star back in the 30s.
Right.
And he's just one of many actors who are big names.
You've got, of course, as Aunt Polly, Jane Wyman.
She's a wonderful classic actress.
Very successful at Warner Brothers, mainly in the 30s and 40s.
But then she worked for other studios.
She was in a lot of musicals.
She was a good singer, dancer.
Well known for being the first wife of Ronald Reagan.
And this is a very serious, sort of against type role for her
because she usually played more cheerful or...
That's right.
She was usually more of a Pollyanna herself.
Yeah.
But in this, she's very stern as Aunt Polly.
But she does a brilliant job of playing in such a way
that she never seems like she's being unkind
even if what she's saying is harsh
because she's a very refined lady
and she knows how to use sort of a gentle tone
while being quite strict.
And of course, one of her main opponents,
a man who's the mayor,
who's trying to get people to not be afraid of her.
And he's actually played by Donald Crisp,
who was one of the very important character actors
at Warner Brothers in the 1930s.
Yes, I didn't remember 30s in this film at all.
And it's quite amazing that he is
because he didn't seem to be a young man back in the 30s.
And he's not young here at all,
but he plays a very important role.
Agnes Moorhead,
who made her film debut back in Citizen Kane in 1941,
gives a great performance as the grouchy old Mrs. Snow,
who is insistent that she's dying the whole time.
And Pollyanna tells her,
don't think about dying,
you need to focus on living.
And she encourages her to stop picking out her coffin
and instead make a patchwork quilt
to raise money for the orphanage.
And she just gives her a new lease on life.
Of course, the young leading lady, if you will,
is the maid Nancy,
who's played by Nancy Olsen.
Right, she was very notably in Sunset Boulevard
with William Holden and Gloria Swanson.
And then quite a few years later,
I remember the first time I saw her
was in the Disney film Snowball Express.
Yes, she did make multiple Disney films.
I think these actors lend a timeless quality
to the whole film.
This was not the first adaptation of the 1913 book Pollyanna
by Eleanor H. Porter.
It was adopted firstly on the stage in 1915.
And then it was made into a silent film in 1920
with Mary Pickford,
who was very famous for playing child roles,
even though she was a full-grown woman.
So she was the first on-screen Pollyanna.
That's interesting.
And then this was the next film adaptation, wasn't it?
Since 1920?
Yes, it was the first one.
There were some, I believe,
telenovelas or something along those lines,
but this was the second feature film of it.
So that's a 40-year gap there,
which is quite impressive
because I believe it was a very popular story.
Yes, it was.
And the overarching message of this film,
which comes from the book, of course,
is positivity, smiling through difficult times.
And these themes became very popular
in the hard times which America would face
shortly after the book was released.
The next year, World War I started.
And then there were difficult,
strange changing times in the 1920s,
then the Great Depression of the 1930s,
the World War II in the 1940s.
And the term Pollyannaism became quite popular.
For instance, with Herbert Hoover,
who was president at the beginning
of the Great Depression,
he kept saying,
things are going to turn up,
the depression will be over soon.
And a lot of people referred to this as Pollyannaism,
like being almost-
Not really in a positive way,
would you say that's true?
No, it also was used in a negative way,
partly because she is a very young girl.
And I think some people thought that in his case,
he was trying to act like everything was fine,
but everything wasn't fine.
But Pollyannaism would often be used
in a positive way.
And that just shows
what an overarching theme it had.
I think it's interesting that this book
was not made into a movie during the 1930s,
when I think it would have been very timely.
Yes, so true.
Like I could see Shirley Temple doing it.
Or a little bit later,
Margaret O'Brien in the 40s, yeah.
But for whatever reason,
maybe because Pollyannaism
had almost become a negative term,
that's why they ventured away from it.
I know you read the book recently.
How would you compare it to the film?
So it struck me as kind of fascinating
that quite often when you compare a book
to its film adaptation,
the number one thing that's lost in a film adaptation
would be a certain amount of introspection
that you can get into in a book
and more getting into the psyche of the characters.
And I have to say,
it's actually totally the opposite in this case.
Really?
Because the book,
while it's not told from Pollyanna's point of view,
it is sort of showing the world through her eyes.
So the other characters
are kept a bit more of a mystery to her.
Like we don't find out more about them until she does.
While in the film,
I think it focuses more on,
here's this town and then this girl comes in
as this influencer,
even though she is still the main character.
So we earlier on see inside the characters a little more
and kind of their complicated relationships.
Obviously, some things were cut down,
but in a lot of ways,
I felt some things were expanded.
As is often the case with books,
they can be quite episodic.
So that, all right,
this chapter is about how she had an influence on this person.
And then this chapter is about this person.
This chapter is about this person.
And in the film,
I think they kind of expanded some of the characters
to make it more cohesive in a way.
Sort of a through flowing story
instead of a bunch of different incidents.
Most notably, I would say with the minister
played by Karl Malden in the film,
he is just a very brief chapter,
probably about three pages in the book
about how she points out to him
that her father found these 800 glad passages in the Bible.
And that's a very important plot point in the film
of that even the church is being influenced
by Polly Harrington and kind of her negativity
that he's preaching hell and brimstone constantly.
And that really, it was there in the book,
but not nearly as strongly.
And I found that was one of the biggest things
I thought was so far superior, honestly, in the film.
I thought the message of faith
and actually of religion was made much stronger.
And a fascinating detail that was not included
is that Mr. Pendergast is Mr. John Pendleton in the book.
And he takes such an immediate liking to Pollyanna,
not just because she's such a sweetheart,
but because he was actually in love with her mother.
So he sees her as sort of being just like her mother.
And he actually asks her to come live with him.
Is he younger?
He seems to be a bit younger, I think, yes.
He's not quite a bunch of an old man.
It's more that he acts old, but he's not as old as he seemed
because he's just being a crotchety old man.
He's kind of locked himself up
because he couldn't have this woman he loved.
And not to cast any dispersions on the book in any way,
of course, but that's a rather kind of tried and true plot idea
of if you love the parents,
then you have this love for the child.
And I think by not including that in a way,
it kind of let Pollyanna just stand on her own a little more
that he just loves her because she's so lovable.
And the character of Jimmy Bean,
the little orphan, while he is featured in the book,
he enters the story much sooner in the film
and is kind of stronger.
The relationship between Pollyanna and Jimmy Bean,
who's played by Disney favorite Kevin Corcoran,
is really touching.
I remember I always loved this cute little Jimmy Bean,
this rascally little orphan,
but he's also a very sweet and nice little boy.
He's not too much of a troublemaker.
Even though I didn't remember this film that well
because we didn't watch it as much as some of the others,
I always knew this boy as little Jimmy Bean
because that's what we would call him.
It's like, I don't know what the actress name is,
but this is Jimmy Bean.
He came from quite an acting family.
Really?
He had two sisters and two brothers,
all of whom were actors as children,
but he was definitely the most successful.
The theme music is really compelling in this movie.
You can tell if you're familiar with Disney films of this era
that it was the same composer who did Parent Trap
because they're the same themes.
Not exactly the same melodies, but similar usages.
But it can be very dramatic, very touching.
It weaves in some popular songs of the day
to help cement it in that time period.
Speaking of the time period,
I think they did a great job of really making
this little American town come to life.
I know they did some of the footage on the Warner Brothers lot,
which had one of the best Main Street,
Anytown USA sets and soundstage areas.
They also did a lot of location footage,
mostly in Northern California,
even though this was set in New England.
But they just captured this sort of timeless...
And they don't really specify...
They don't specify what state it is in the movie
because it's not really important.
Harrington Town could be any town.
The movie wants you to see that this is just any town
where that spirit of goodwill could change people.
The costumes are really good.
They really capture that just before World War I look
of the more drop waist.
Sometimes this is called the Belle Epoque.
Sometimes it's a little later than Edwardian
and it's more American,
but it's got big hats and longer skirts,
but moving away from the exaggerated silhouettes
of the Victorian era.
And it really, with the hairstyles and everything,
helps cement it in that time.
My outfit is based on the first costume
you see Polly Harrington wear.
It's a dark color with black, with longer sleeves.
She has her little watch pinned on.
And in at least one scene,
she wears a very large hat like this
when she goes to church,
as well as simple black shoes.
My outfit is inspired by the fashion of Pollyanna,
who being younger is tending more
toward the modern styles of the drop waist,
which would become very popular in the 20s.
She always wears a necklace,
which her father gave her with the saying engraved on it,
as well as the high button boots of the era
and a charming little hat.
Many people have said that this book is worth reading
to learn about the glad game.
And it's definitely a running theme in the movie,
talking about how her father taught her
how to be glad about really any bad situation.
And if one could have that attitude,
certainly would go through life better
to really look at everything there.
There is some reason to be glad about every situation.
One thing that struck me very strongly
when we watched the movie recently, again,
was the fact that,
although they don't go into these details too much,
clearly Polly Harrington really did not like Pollyanna's father.
Right. That's explained more in the book.
I think they did a great job of making that clear
without talking about it at all.
Because her sister was obviously part of this privileged family.
She left to be an impoverished missionary's wife.
And Polly resents that.
She resented the man who took her sister away.
And she didn't agree with his particular brand of religion.
But the first time you see Polly,
she's talking to the minister and she tells him,
here's something my father said.
That's almost one of the first things you hear her said.
She's talking about her father.
Her whole life is influenced by things her father started,
things her father taught her.
Yet anytime Pollyanna mentions her father,
she's like, I don't want to hear about your father.
She's rude about it.
That's like the meanest she is to Pollyanna.
She's like, don't keep talking about your father.
But we see she's talking about her own father.
The most hypocritical thing about Polly Harrington.
And you see that Pollyanna wants to share
this love she had for her father and all the things he taught her.
She mentions her mother occasionally,
but really her father made a very big influence on her.
Yes. And in the book, that was even more of a strong theme.
She goes around the whole town and tells everyone about the glad game.
But she never dares to tell her aunt
because she has to tell them the whole story
about the doll and the crutches and everything first.
And she couldn't without mentioning her father.
And she's been forbidden to mention her father until the very end.
Finally, everybody's telling Polly about,
oh, tell Pollyanna that I've learned to play the game.
And she finally asks, what are they talking about?
And she tells her and then she says,
I'll play the game with you now, Pollyanna.
And there is, of course, near the end of the film,
a very dramatic turn.
There's an unexpected tragedy that takes place.
And I was quite shocked by how different it was in the book.
And I have to say, as I felt about a lot of things in the film,
I think they honestly improved, at least from a dramatic standpoint.
It's done much more dramatically in the film.
The movie is so touching.
It's really heartwarming.
And like I said, partly because it does have some sad elements,
we didn't watch it as much as some of the other Hayley Mills films,
but there are parts which just vividly remember
the little song that she and Nancy sing,
the folk tune, Early One Morning.
I very strongly remembered Angelina, the grumpy other maid,
who interestingly was not in the book at all.
They totally made up that character.
But I really remembered her.
And then just little fragmented moments.
And then the funniest thing to me,
whenever I watch a movie that we watched when we were very young
or haven't for a while, there'll be like lines in it
that we like to kind of quote.
Everybody had no idea that they were from this movie.
So it's kind of funny to me.
You're wearing a necklace to replicate the necklace
that Pollyanna has, which is from her father.
And she shows it to the minister and it says,
it's a quote from Abraham Lincoln.
If you look for the bad in people, you will surely find it.
Now, after this film was released,
all these necklaces with that quote on it
began being manufactured.
David Swift was very distressed when he found that out
because he made up that quote.
The correct Abraham Lincoln quote is,
we looked for the good in them and we found it.
And the minister quotes that in his sermon.
Wow.
But David Swift, when he said that,
it's like, hmm, I don't remember that.
Okay, that's why it wasn't in the book.
Yeah, because David Swift made that.
And it's interesting that he chose to use the negative,
is that if he could have easily put on the necklace,
we looked for the good in them and found it.
But I think in that point in the film,
he wanted Pollyanna to show the minister
that he is looking for the bad in people.
Of course, there's the counterpart.
That's implied by Lincoln's actual quote.
Of course.
But I did think that was sort of an interesting quote.
That's interesting.
That's how things like that get started.
There are so many famously misquoted things
just because one person said it wrong.
But this is a very relatable film, I think, for modern viewers
because it's a period piece made in a much later time.
So it uses some more modern cinematography.
I know, I think 1960 isn't exactly modern.
But, you know, compared to 1935, it is.
I think the quality about films of this kind from the 60s,
particularly the Disney live action,
that because they were making them in a family-friendly way,
they were, I think, more of an accurate look at the time,
even though this isn't set in that time period,
of more like how regular people were at the time it was made, even.
Yes.
The 60s.
Well, as opposed to the ones that were trying to be a little more daring,
I think sometimes it's not an accurate portrayal.
Just your average person in a small town was...
Still very old-fashioned and decent.
Old-fashioned and decent, exactly.
And the same thing you see in the films before the code,
in the early 30s, when everything's just like wild.
So this movie is something I think which
all modern audiences could appreciate.
Obviously, it's great for families and young children
because it was made with that in mind,
but you can enjoy it at any age
because it's a very intelligent, emotional, deep, moving film.
This movie, of course, is widely available as are all Disney films.
It's...
If you have a Disney Plus subscription, you can watch it for free.
It's also sold or available for rent on Amazon Prime Video,
YouTube, and other streaming services.
As we've said, Pollyanna is all about trust and finding the good in people.
However, just as many fairy tales teach us wariness as well as kindness,
many classic films show us to be careful of putting our trust in the wrong person.
Join us next time as we talk about a film in which a young woman
almost loses her sanity and ultimately her life
by putting her faith in someone before she truly knows him.
Thank you for watching.
Goodbye.