Maximizing Returns in Luxury Hotel Investments | INSPIRE Luxury Hospitality Conference

Invest Insight
9 followers
#Finance #PesonalFinance #InvestInsight #MaximizingReturns #LuxuryHotelInvestments #LuxuryHospitalityConference
Good morning, everyone.
All right.
I see both of these have got good participation, so they all want to hear about growth.
Siva Selvam.
I spent about 30 years in the hospitality, in the Starwood core, and then last 15 years
I worked for four seasons in price optimization.
Now I work for Long & Foster, which is a affiliate of Berkshire Hathaway.
They are obviously not Berkshire, and we are the East Coast entity, and we're also a member
of the Forbes Global Properties.
I specialize on family office investments, luxury, affluent owners who are now trying
to invest into hotels, so I represent more on our website.
I'll let the group introduce themselves.
Go ahead, Jay.
Okay.
Thank you.
I'm Jay Neumann, one of the five partners in the Athens Group, and before I tell you
a little about Athens Group, the five of us have been together since the year 2000.
In this business, and we're a luxury hotel development company, I find that incredibly
remarkable, and I think it's a tribute to just what we really excel at, and that is
really relationship.
We really view this business as a relationship business, and development, especially luxury
development, is I think one of the most complex development product types that you can do,
but it's incredibly rewarding, and I am proud to say this will be a quick commercial.
So we've just opened up our first lifestyle luxury hotel, which is the Asher Adams in
Salt Lake City, and it's actually an adaptive reuse of the Union Pacific train station downtown,
and we actually have also a Live Nation concert hall, 225 rooms.
So if you come to Salt Lake City, hopefully you'll stop by and see it.
I think you'll really be excited about what we did.
We are going to open in about a month or two a Ritz Reserve in Papagayo, Costa Rica, and
that's 106 rooms, 37 luxury branded residences, and three glamping tents.
We're going to do some tree houses.
We haven't figured out the tree house and how it works for luxury.
We're going to get there eventually, but we did our toe in the water with the tents, so
that'll be pretty good.
If you've gone on safaris, things like that, you've probably experienced the tent camping.
And then actually, we're connected, as you were saying, with just what you're doing now,
because we have a project in Naples, Florida, and that's a Four Seasons, slated to open
next Labor Day, 216 rooms.
And the reason, Steve, and we are involved is we have 80, excuse me, 141 residences,
58 on the beach.
We've got 1,000 linear feet of white sand beach, and so we have 58 residences there,
and then we've got, what is it, I can't even do the math anymore, like 70 plus, 78 plus
on the golf side.
And so we're a total of 141 condos.
So I'll turn it over to you now.
Thanks, Dave.
I have a son at University of Utah, so we're excited to spend a lot of time at your hotel.
I'm Sarah Eustace, founder and CEO of Main Street Hospitality.
We are based in Massachusetts.
We specialize in luxury and boutique destination properties that are all high character, some
of them historic.
This is a family business of which I'm the third generation, and we like hard, we like
difficult projects.
But I spent, grew up in my family's business, but also spent 20 years in big retail outfits
like Ralph Lauren and Gap Inc. and Limited Brands, and then brought that back to our
family business a little over 10 years ago.
I was an art major in college, so I don't really know what I'm doing on this panel,
but I'll try to keep up with these finance real estate guys.
And it's a privilege to be here and see what we can share.
We're growing.
We have eight properties currently in the family, growing and opening in Boston, and
another one in Newport, Rhode Island, where we have another property.
So growing slowly and selectively and working with great partners.
Great.
I'm Mike Metcalf.
I'm president of HQ Hotels and Residences by SBE.
You may be familiar with SBE from Sam Nazarian, who was the creator of SLS and then eventually
bought Morgan's Group, which included Delano, Mondrian, and numerous other brands.
And Sam sold that company to Accor in 2021, spent two years really coming up with a new
business plan, and subsequently launched HQ Hotels.
And then in September, we actually launched the Estate, which is an ultra-luxury blank
brand.
And to the extent of the partnerships, we definitely are focused on that SBE.
We have one partner who's Mark Anthony.
We're very much focused on Latinos, Gen Z, and millennials.
And then in the Estate, which is the wellness brand, really, it's a partnership with Tony
Robbins, who is the king of wellness now.
And he's been very heavily involved and engaged, so we're very excited about it.
Prior to joining Sam, I actually was chief operating officer of a very large third-party
management company that focused on upper-upscale and luxury hotels.
So very excited to be here, because this is my hometown.
This is where I live.
And so it's always nice to stay home for a few days and get to meet people that are
coming to our city.
And we appreciate your business, because it keeps us economically sound with all these
people here.
You also said we're going to be a post-conference breakfast at your house.
Thank you.
So first, I want to talk about the trends in luxury, especially the emerging markets.
When we represent any owners, LPs, GPs, private equity, they're all asking the same question.
So I want to put this to the panel.
Where is the emerging market?
The whole operative word of iBarrier comes up.
So 2019, post-COVID, our office phones will ring.
All these people look for sunbelt destinations, looking for property, disposition, conversions,
whatnot.
Today, industries have stabilized.
Hotels have stabilized.
Businesses have stabilized.
So let me start with Mike.
If I were to explain to investors, hey, these are markets we should really diversify and
look for.
If you want to invest, you just tell me, and I'll find a place for you.
Really, I would say, we've heard a lot about it actually in the last day and a half already.
It's not so much about emerging markets as it is emerging experiences.
And one of the things the brands have done very well, and Jay mentioned a couple of locations,
is they're literally out, and developers, literally out scouting places where they can
actually create the market.
So when you look at places like in Vietnam and Thailand and Costa Rica, places that you
wouldn't normally look at as being high-demand locations, typically these locations don't
have a lot of air left.
I'm looking at a deal in Greece right now.
The only way to get to the island is by helicopter or boat.
But it'll have hotel residences and wellness all combined in one location.
And we expect it to be very successful because it's going to be a place where the traveler
of today, and more importantly, the traveler for the next 10, 20 years, will want to go
and experience that location, but also the things that you create there.
I think the real trick is to be involved in that community and make sure that the amenities
that they have to offer are a big part of the experiences.
It's not just about ziplining through the jungles.
It's also about the food, the culture of the people, the markets that they provide.
And I think these are the types of places that developers and the brands are looking for.
The other urban locations will always continue to be popular.
I know Scottsdale right now has been really heavy in the United States.
New York has always been popular and will continue to be.
China is a huge luxury market right now for development.
These are all big cities, and with those, most of those are going to have a residential
component that go with it, which makes the overall project more attractive to capital.
I really do think it's about finding places where there are unique experiences, unique
cultures that people can get ingrained with that community for however many days they're there.
Or you're going to be in a heavy-duty urban environment where there's going to be
a pretty significant residential component.
On your independent space, I know you're building your little asset empire,
so is there anything you want to add to these emerging markets you're looking for,
especially where your properties are concentrated?
I like what you started with, Mike, because I think it's almost like luxury.
You are going to be sick of that word by the end of this conference, by the way.
It can happen anywhere, if the conditions are creative.
What's interesting to us, and this is not to be self-serving, but we still see an enormous
amount of opportunity in the Northeast, or maybe the Atlantic and North,
just because that's our stomping ground.
In markets that are adjacent to bigger cities, and maybe in that circumference,
we are right now, I would say, a year or two of stabilization of a beautiful
luxury property in the Hamptons, but it's Hampton Bay.
It's closer to New York City.
For those who aren't familiar with the region, it is the less sexy Hamptons,
but it's closer to New York, and it has this amazing story to tell.
With some of my partners in the room today, it's harder to ramp up,
the underwriting is harder to predict, ramp up is tougher,
but we're using all those tactics that you just endorsed,
in order to make this a destination, and weaving in what I think,
you said it, but maybe didn't use this word, which is culture.
You're talking about the fact that there's a Live Nation thing
happening right next to your new hotel.
Looking at these places, and for us, even Hudson Valley,
or the wilds of Vermont, where a lot of these luxury properties
are popping up, looking at where, and how to put your finger on
where there might be unmet demand.
Even in places outside of Boston, and suburban locations,
where there are a lot of high net worth people,
but not the right resource.
We're looking at interesting markets like that,
and it takes a little bit more to convince our capital partners,
and do the underwriting with authority,
and it takes a little bit of belief, and creating a story,
if that makes sense.
Let me just add to that, we approach this in a very organic way,
but we've also found another good approach,
is we follow Goldman Sachs.
Goldman Sachs has gone to Salt Lake City,
and the amount of jobs, I think,
the jobs that Goldman Sachs is now exporting,
and they're doing it in Dallas also, we have a project in Dallas,
and having that kind of validation of the market,
the job growth it creates, that's just one way to do it.
Another way to look at it is like Costa Rica, where we're building,
we've got another project in Costa Rica that we're working on,
and I don't know if you're familiar with Papagayo,
if you get a chance, it's just terrific,
but there's other areas that are the next Papagayo,
and you're getting this critical mass, like you have in Cabo,
and the other thing you look at, sometimes when you look at these markets,
the sales price per square foot,
for the residential branded product in Cabo,
not Cabo, excuse me, Costa Rica,
it's Costa Rica, not Cabo,
is over $3,000 a square foot,
and that's Americans coming down,
because going back to the whole experiential thing,
what you can do there,
and that's another kind of like data point you look at,
look at that residential market,
you say, look at the money that's coming into this place,
and these people want luxury,
but they want a certain kind of luxury,
whether it's the whole wellness side of things,
but you're right, it's that experiential,
so there's different ways to arrive at this,
and then you also look at markets where you say,
they don't have any great product,
the question is, can you find the right site,
for you to create that great product,
that's the other thing,
sometimes your site constraints,
and the old adage of location, location, location,
when you're doing luxury,
you want what we call beachhead sites.
I think around Salt Lake City too,
those academic destinations,
and cultural destinations,
are really interesting places,
to study the hospitality market,
and see if there's enough,
and see if there's the right product there,
which may not be.
So next I want to change the subject,
into alternative accommodation,
I think it's a great example,
of what OMI has done at Kenyan Equity,
and if anybody knows,
they have the Amangiri,
and if you look at the portfolio,
they went and built a select service hotel,
and if you listen to OMI,
everybody says that was a bad idea,
but I'm going to ask this group again,
because I have investors now saying,
do I get better cap rate,
if I build a multifamily,
because lenders are easy to underwrite,
do I get better rate,
if I do a BTR, built to rent,
or the Gen X,
they want to not rent a condo,
they want a townhouse to rent,
do I get better cap rate,
if I build the adults daycare,
I don't know if they heard about,
these are assets coming out,
trying to get better creative cap rates,
so question to the leaders here,
do you see alternative accommodation,
such as all the assets classes I said,
would be traditionally,
the luxury hotels are going to get into the space,
how do you differentiate luxury operators,
from these assets,
where it'll make financial sense,
for underwriting and so forth,
I'll start with you.
Okay, well as a developer,
and as I said at the outset,
this really is a very difficult,
but very rewarding asset class,
there's a lot of headwinds that you have,
and one of the biggest headwinds you got,
is what it costs,
on a cost per key basis,
it used to be,
if you spent a million dollars a key,
you would be laughed out of the bankers offices,
now we've got projects,
that are doing two million dollars a key,
three million dollars a key,
we try to stay below two,
but we're also trying to deliver the best product,
so how do you make it financeable,
and what's really challenging,
in this part of the world,
is when you get your construction loan,
your equity goes in first,
and your construction debt is 50% to 65%,
if you're not doing any of the hot money,
like mezzanine financing,
and when you say okay,
let's just say we have a 250 room luxury hotel,
on the larger side,
and it's gonna cost me a million and a half a room,
that's 375 million,
let's just say you're doing 40% equity,
right there you've got $150 million,
and how does that dog hunt,
and the way you can make it hunt,
and I can't speak to the luxury rental market,
or the extended,
what I speak to is the branded residential,
and sometimes you say gee,
I don't want a brand,
and the lenders love a brand,
because a brand brings you a whole distribution network,
it brings you customers,
it also brings you anywhere from a 40 year,
to a 70 year contract,
and it is tough to break that contract,
something had to have gone radically wrong,
so you'd say all things being equal,
why do I need a brand,
well your lender wants it,
sometimes your investors want it,
and then when you're selling real estate,
people will pay a premium,
when I say selling real estate,
they have condos that are serviced by the hotel,
either next to it,
part of the hotel,
with that brand,
it's like a good housekeeping award,
because we are brand conscious people,
and what that enables you to do,
is give your equity comfort,
and it gives your lender comfort,
because the premium that I think anyone would say,
is probably a minimum 25% premium,
that you get for this luxury branded residential,
attached to the hotel,
and in our situation,
we average 75% to 100%,
so we're doubling the sales price in the marketplace,
for that residential,
and in certain markets,
like what we have right now,
for four seasons in Florida,
we're taking 50% deposits,
so when you're looking at,
over a billion dollars worth of real estate,
closer to going up,
and you can get half of that money,
in a deposit,
that you under Florida law can utilize,
that becomes that equity,
that you have to put in first,
so this branded residential,
makes these projects sing,
and then you get,
I hate to use the phrase,
the synergism,
all those people live in your residences,
they have friends,
they come,
they use the hotel facilities,
but they're also getting the benefit,
of hotel services,
that they are paying for,
so it is the perfect marriage,
to have luxury residential,
that's branded,
with a luxury hotel,
especially on the development side.
I think structurally,
in terms of these deals,
you guys have more experience,
than I do,
but that's why I think,
synergy is a great word,
Jay.
It's used a lot.
That's what we're looking for.
Is there an iconic in here?
Yeah,
and we're experiencing that right now,
as we integrate,
a whole series of residences,
at Canoe Pits,
that were previously managed,
by Inspirato,
and we're bringing them in,
under our management,
integrating with our,
food and beverage partner,
and I do think,
not only can we still,
create the conditions,
for a luxurious experience,
I don't think that,
it dilutes that at all,
it's like,
we're the clubhouse,
right,
in the hotel,
and everybody gets to be part of it,
they come in,
they get a shot of energy,
but they have,
a different experience,
and a different kind of way,
of using,
using their space.
I'm heading,
to Sea Island,
in a couple of weeks,
with my family,
a place that I love,
that has built that model,
over time,
super successfully,
and I think financially,
you know,
risk,
it's a risk management,
play,
that probably,
probably makes a lot of sense,
I think,
you know,
when you go back,
to talking about,
alternative accommodations,
and we heard a little bit about it,
in this last session,
and you're seeing it,
like the Orient Express,
is being revitalized,
and so,
you know,
it first started,
with what Homie,
was talking about yesterday,
I think glamping became,
pretty popular,
several years ago,
when I heard him say,
it costs a million dollars,
a tent,
I'm thinking about,
you know,
having grown up in a place,
where you went camping,
every summer,
we wouldn't pay,
more than $50,
for a tent,
you know what I mean,
but,
at a million dollars,
a room,
and what Jay's pointing out,
is,
is like,
a hotel room,
is going to cost you,
two to three million,
and if somebody's willing,
to pay,
the same amount of money,
for a unit,
that's only a million dollars,
you're way ahead,
right there,
and I think,
but all of those,
whether it's the yachts,
the tents,
or the trains,
I'm sure,
you know,
barges,
there are all different types,
of luxury experiences,
now,
and that will continue,
to grow,
no doubt,
I'm sure,
that they will figure out,
how to get a balloon,
to lift you up,
and stay there,
people will want it,
and I think it's,
it's a matter,
of really having,
a conviction,
about that particular,
type of experience,
you're going to provide,
and being able,
to sell it to,
both equity,
and debt,
because ultimately,
you know,
that's going to be,
the thing that's going,
to give you,
the opportunity,
to get these deals done,
but I do think,
there are already,
enough examples,
of it,
how it does work,
I mean,
there is,
you know,
sort of the poster child,
for glamping,
and you know,
you can take people,
and show it,
two of them,
and they can experience it,
I think,
you know,
you get the right lender,
on board,
and the right equity partners,
on board,
and you'll have a,
a programmatic approach,
to future projects,
not just in that,
glamping necessarily,
but that's when,
you know,
you go to the,
the other alternative,
type stuff,
the extended stay,
piece of it,
I know you mentioned that too,
I think that one's,
a little more,
that goes almost,
back to the residential,
at that point,
you know,
where people are buying,
these units,
and then they're renting them,
for you know,
whether it's short term rental,
or long term rental,
because of the amenities,
and the brand name,
that goes with it,
so if it's a rich residence,
or a four seasons,
something like that,
they put those things,
in the pools,
and people stay there,
because of it,
and they know,
they're going to get a home,
and not just a,
hotel room,
so.
It's interesting,
you have an add on,
Jay?
I'm just going to.
It just made me think,
of a colleague.
No, no,
you go,
I said enough,
but I just want to,
talk about glamping,
for a moment,
but go ahead.
Well,
mine's on glamping too,
it's kind of adjacent,
but a colleague,
who founded Auto Camp,
not in the luxury space,
specifically,
but these airstreams,
kind of out in,
and you know,
amazing ramp up,
and a tough plateau,
and just partnered,
with Hilton,
reservation system,
to sell Auto Camp,
so there's something,
in this alternate space,
that even the big brands,
are tapping into.
That's a perfect lead in,
so I'm familiar,
with Auto Camp,
I've stayed at Auto Camp,
they're incredible,
but I'm not a tall guy,
and I'm cramped,
in an airstream trailer,
and so I think a lot of this,
is novelty value,
and when you,
when you go to Africa,
you want to be in a tent,
and you know,
but there are trade-offs,
in those tents,
you're not going to get,
the same insulation,
that you might otherwise get,
it can get pretty cold,
even if they're insulated,
as much as they can be,
and there's a lot of charm,
the question is,
how am I going to keep going,
to the tent,
or am I going to come back,
to more brick and mortar,
because that brick and mortar,
has a lot of experiences,
and that's what I'm really into,
so I think it's,
to me,
it is a bit of a novelty,
but the market's deep,
because most people,
have not experienced it,
and so we'll be interested,
to see what happens,
with our Costa Rica project,
because we got three tents,
but we also got,
106 regular rooms,
you'll probably be building,
more tents,
yeah,
the tree house,
is the one that's got me,
Jay,
we got to do tree houses,
we will do that,
there's one outside,
of the Portland,
that used to be,
I can't remember,
at a resort,
that they had tree houses,
I think that is,
ultra cool,
I think Mexico,
we want to pivot,
into these,
I think we heard this,
throughout the conference,
the generational,
wealth transforming,
into the younger generation,
I can tell you,
we do about,
north of 20 billion,
in total transactions,
within the residential,
primary sector as well,
single family,
the first time buyer,
also we are seeing,
the same thing,
the parents,
and the grandparents,
are giving money,
for down payment to buy,
so we've seen that,
money's already happening,
on that space,
so the question,
for the first time,
and the leaders again,
as you are developing,
these rooms,
and units,
and luxury space,
how are you factoring,
this next generation,
because I remember,
when I was working,
for four seasons,
there was a brand,
brought some of these,
millennials,
into a workshop lab,
in Bethesda,
one of the big brands,
and they asked him,
to do a UA team,
to find out,
you check into this room,
tell me what you like about,
what you don't like about,
and they learn from that,
to design the next generation,
because you see today,
a lot of hotels,
don't have big working desks,
that all came from,
those UA teams,
so Jay,
I want to start with you.
Okay,
yeah look,
I have a couple millennials,
and I'm going to give you guys,
a quick little factoid,
so we have this project,
I mentioned in Naples,
Florida,
and it was an existing hotel,
on the beach,
with a golf course,
that Jack Nicklaus,
had done the second round on,
and we're working,
for the first time,
in,
right now,
but we were wondering,
in light of this,
what do millennials want,
and they want,
they want to be environmentally,
sustainable,
they want farm to table food,
they don't want formality,
but yet,
they want to be recognized,
they don't want,
to wait in line,
for all those who waited in line,
recently,
they're very impatient,
and the question is,
how does that fold,
into something like a golf course,
and we went out,
the three of the time,
top golf course designers in the world, and Fazio was the one we ended up working with,
and they came up with concepts.
Every one of them came up with the fact that most people don't have six hours, especially
this generation, to spend on a golf course.
So you start coming up with other things that they can do with their families, so you do
what they call the Himalayan putting course.
It's an extreme putting course where you can sit there with a cigar, a bourbon, your kids,
your barefoot, getting into that experiential with what has been a very traditional sport,
having a whole short game area, having teaching areas, and the family part of it is really
coming into play.
That's just one example where, is there really life for an 18-hole golf course?
You can do a...
We got guys doing 9-holes and 12-holes, and say if they want to play 18, the guy who just
played 12, he just goes and plays another 6, so you have another set of tee boxes.
It was really interesting because a golf course is 106 acres.
That's a lot of real estate, and if we can wring out other experiences that is unique
that other places don't have.
But ultimately, you got to get rid of your plastic bottles, you got to have refillable
bottles.
I mean, across the board, all the brands are doing this, and I'll let these people speak.
One last thing is, what's really surprising me is, we're doing this Four Seasons, I saw
on the Four Seasons guys, and the Millennials are treating the hotels like Starbucks.
So they are in the hotel lounges, they're in the seating areas, and they're on their
computers, they got their ear buds in, and they're exporting it from their room into
the public areas because that's how they do things.
So now you're looking at greater public areas just so they can sit there and hang out on
their computer.
So, more ideas from this part of the world that we're doing.
No, Jay, those are really interesting points, and it's making me think about something that's
been on my mind lately as it relates to sort of the sustainability of our business and
sort of of our industry, and it's, listen, trying to be all things to all people is never
usually a winning strategy, right?
So you say, okay, who's my target customer, how am I going after them, is it Gen Z, Y,
X, whatever, I don't even know which one I am.
But what I've been interested in is this idea of sort of intergenerational life inside the
hotel, right?
And at our hotels, probably at yours too, Bruce, historic hotels, the red line in Stockton
Castle, I don't know if anybody's ever been there, in this room, however, we see, and
what we're trying to do in this 250-year-old building that my family's owned for 55 years
is create the conditions for three, four generations to have a great time in the same hotel, right?
And what does that mean to technology?
It's got to be right, I get it, but we have a speakeasy downstairs where the bourbon selection
is amazing and a lot of the hipsters are hanging out, their grandparents are upstairs having
a great meal, we're sitting on the front porch, the children are doing something else.
And to me, that's when we win.
It happens at community places too, we're not obsessed with youth necessarily, although
we want to capture them and keep them with us so they grow with us, right?
But I think when I get excited about looking at our demographics, who's spending, what's
going on, it's this idea of intergenerational life, which I also think is kind of healthy,
right?
We get these families and people communicating with each other of different ages and backgrounds,
that's also a good outcome.
So it doesn't answer your question super specifically, but it says that I think in a great hotel,
you can foster that in a way.
Older people have maybe more time and money, younger people need a place to do leisure,
whatever they're doing, and you can, especially in luxury properties that have a lot of dimensions,
I think that's an interesting thing to strive for.
I know, Mike, your brand is really hounding on this.
Laser focused on it.
I'm sure you just...
Yeah, you know, like I was talking about, you're putting a luxury property in a location
where people can come and experience the area.
But then when they get done for the day, they're going to come back to the hotel, and that's
when you have the opportunity to continue that experience for them.
And they don't just go to bed.
They're not going to have room service, most likely.
And so to Jay's point too, it's like the lobby, the activations that you have going on in
the resort or the hotel are incredibly important to them.
And you need to create places where they can have their Instagram moments, where they want
to share with their families or their followers the experiences that they're having.
And honestly, this is free PR.
So it just helps further your ability to drive more business.
And really, from our standpoint, we have restaurant and bar concepts, both day life and night
life, in addition to speakeasy brand, every other kind of cuisine you can think of.
And those brands will be a big part of it because when they come to the hotel, they'll
recognize it.
They'll actually want to stay there because of the food and beverage that we have, even
though they will most likely be out experiencing the local area all day long.
They know when they come back, they're going to have something to do.
We're going to entertain them basically the entire trip.
So I really think millennials and Gen Z over the next five or six years are going to end
up representing almost half of the retail spend in the world, not just the U.S., everywhere.
And capturing their money is going to be a key to success.
And the way you do that, to me, it's like you look at every square foot of your property
and figure out how do you get something that they want to spend money on, whether it's
a cup of coffee or a cheeseburger or $100 steak.
You need to have the ability for them to spend money because they will.
They won't if you don't give them the opportunity.
And it's got to be something that is very overt, not covert, like it's right there that
they want to do it.
They can't wait.
They don't care what it costs.
So I think focusing on creating those experiences when they're inside of the hotel, out of their
rooms, it's incredibly important, the overall profitability.
There's no question that technology is a huge component for them.
We were joking about it yesterday.
It's like the one click.
I don't know if you've ever tried to sign up for LinkedIn Premium.
I got to click eight and said, close the app.
I'm not doing this.
I couldn't believe it.
I got so annoyed by the ad asking me to join.
I was on a call and I decided to do it.
And I literally got to the eighth question.
I'm like, I'm not trying to buy a house.
I just want to join your program for $10 a month.
And I just said, forget it.
I'm not doing it.
Here's a question.
Maybe this is just a follow-on question.
In getting people to triggering desire and more spending during the stay, communicating
with people while they're there, does that feel, are we doing it in a luxury way?
Does that feel luxury?
We're all doing it in different ways.
But, hey, we're so glad you're here.
Come down for XYZ that's going on.
Or, oh, can we book you a massage in the middle of it?
Does that feel on brand in terms of the luxury experience that we're talking about?
Well, to me, the texting is important.
A lot of people have tried to do the app.
And if you're Marriott with Bomboy, that's fine.
We've got 120 million members.
It's the same thing with all the other major brands.
So you're going to have the app.
But if you're going into a one-off location, the idea of adding another app to your phone
is just not exciting.
But I do think that it's like you can't find them anyway.
And they don't work most of the time.
But I think the idea of communicating with them on a service standpoint and not, you
know, so like you check in.
And I can tell you, living here, I've done a lot of staycations here.
You check into a hotel, and you're very likely to get a text a few minutes later saying,
you know, I'm your butler.
I'm your concierge.
Anything you need, please, you know, let me know.
And by the way, you know, the cocktail at 5 o'clock is, you know, done by our mixologist.
You know, please make sure you stop by.
And that's the kind of stuff that really gets them excited.
And they'll come and they'll spend $25 for that cocktail.
So let me just add to that.
And I really want to comment on what you were saying about intergenerational.
Because we are all over that.
And we're actually, as we design these luxury condos, and we were having this huge internal
analysis with our partner, which is BDT, MSD, and Naples.
And the question is, gee, who's your audience?
Who's your buyer?
How big should it be?
We went with average 5,000 square foot residence.
We had very few residences that are less than 20, less than 3,000.
Smallest like 2,300.
We went larger because of what we view as intergenerational living.
And just down the street in our Salt Lakes, our Park City project, the montage, Deer Valley
that we did.
And this goes back to what you were saying.
We created in the basement something we call dailies.
It's got a pizza oven.
It's got a bar.
It's got a four-lane bowling alley.
And it's got like shuffle boards.
But like most shuffle boards do, and not the kind where you're using your legs and everything.
It's just the finished wood shuffle boards that you see in most sports bars.
But now you're doing it with your kids.
And maybe you're doing it with your grandkids.
And everyone is in on it.
You're grabbing pizzas and burgers.
You're getting local brews and all that.
And we don't even sell it.
It's word of mouth.
And like meet me at dailies.
And that's where everyone congregates for after they ski or when it's off season and
you've been hiking and everything.
It's just the spot.
And now we're in our Naples project.
We're doing another four-lane bowling alley next to our restaurant on the golf course.
And some of these things are just, I think, they just transcend generations.
But the ability that people get together, gather, and just have a good time.
And then, of course, turns into an Instagram moment.
And you know grandparents will spend anything.
Oh, yeah.
So we have one more segment, then we'll open up a question.
I think this is probably everyone's interest too.
The Fed's impact on the build and development and conversion.
So I pulled up some data points from JLL.
Year-to-date is September 2024.
The global hotel transactions and conversion volume anywhere $41 billion.
And if I go back and look at four years after the last recession, we are about $39 million.
So we are right at par four years after recession.
Today, four years after COVID.
Looking at the developers, if I have to explain to an investor,
hey, how do I get better return on investment considering the build cost, development cost,
acquisition cost, labor cost, and whatnot?
What are the things that a hotel luxury brand can make the owners or investors at ease?
Are you able to go through this notion of interest rate?
And obviously, there are some light at the end of the tunnel.
Well, look, to me, the factors, as I said earlier,
you want to have great real estate if you're at the top of the market.
There's no doubt that a declining interest rate environment is your best friend.
Because as I was talking about your debt, which could be 50 to 65 percent,
and like I said, ignoring all the other hot money products,
that debt is tied to something called the SOFR curve.
And that SOFR curve is a variable curve.
And so when interest rates go up, your SOFR curve goes up.
And that means your interest costs go up.
And it takes basically three years to build one of these things.
So when you started with that construction loan,
you got three years where you're not getting any income.
You may have an interest reserve.
You may have bought an interest rate cap.
But besides the fact that you have got three years of construction,
you've got another three years of stabilization.
So it's six years.
And that's where these risk profiles come in.
And so if interest rates are dropping,
well, that's good because your costs have now dropped.
What is bad, and what's going to be interesting as we enter into this next phase,
is inflation.
Because inflation raises costs.
And ultimately, inflation reverses the direction of interest rates.
Because the Fed, as they just did, will use interest rates to choke off inflation.
So if the Fed gets it wrong,
then you go into an expansionary cycle with inflation.
You can get crushed.
Because you're exposed for six years with this debt.
So it can be your best friend.
It can also be ultimately your enemy.
And so real quick, the other factors you've got to take into account,
besides the markets, assuming the market's great,
is your construction costs.
And construction costs have slowed down,
but they're still very high.
Costs in construction, with labor, materials, they never go down.
So you're managing a lot of variables here.
And interest is one of the most important.
So ultimately, I believe it's a good thing for the next hopefully 12 months.
But we'll see how much the Fed eases further.
I mean, it's great to sit up here with an economist
who can really get into all that.
I mean, we're living a project right now
with some great partners that we did.
We actually took the flag off of a property
and took it independent.
It's adjacent to an amazing art museum.
It's very, very tertiary, to be kind, market.
But it's an interesting place.
And got stuck right in the middle of everything we just talked about.
And so construction, we opened it last year in June.
But the previous two years financed and developed it.
And so the underwriting that we have is now very different.
And it's just going to take a little more patience.
And we're investors in this project also.
So it is a different path.
Stabilization process is just different than we anticipated.
And it's hard.
It's not huge numbers in the way that you guys are doing it.
But it's meaningful to our partners.
And so it just takes a lot of accountability,
a lot of hard work to kind of get through this phase.
But I think we are, you know, we're simply liking it.
Yeah.
You know, it's funny because, Jay, you mentioned the six years,
you know, that it takes.
And so let's just say everybody believes now interest rates
are going to drop right now.
So now's the time to go get started.
Okay.
So if you start today, you will probably open the property
maybe in six years, probably more like eight,
which means that you're going to open just in time
for the next cycle to end or start.
That's a realist right there.
Yeah.
But the point is, is like you almost have to ignore all of it.
Focus on the location and your business plan
and having the confidence that it's going to work
no matter what.
And because, you know, Las Vegas just yesterday,
you know, they're still trying to get the ballpark built here
for the Oakland A's to come here.
Okay.
The A's are out.
They're going up to Sacramento to play a minor league team.
And supposedly they're going to be here in 2028.
Well, today they have a city council meeting
to hear that the cost went from $1.25 billion
to $1.5 billion.
Now, I look at that and I go, it's only $250.
And by the way, only about $300 million
of that's actually got financing.
And so, but the news is broadcasting this like,
it's no big deal.
I feel sorry for the guy who's got to sit there
and talk to the city council today and explain to them
where this other billion dollars is actually going to come from.
But the reality is, is that it will get done
and they will find the money for a project like that
because there is enough belief in it.
But it's the same thing with any hotel project.
And I do not know a project I've ever done
that you started eight years ago
and it cost what you said it would then.
And I can also be willing to bet
that the numbers you did on the projections
are also entirely wrong.
Actually, what I've seen over time,
the numbers, while the construction costs go up,
the actual revenues and profit also increases.
And I've been accused so many times
of being overly aggressive in writing pro formas.
And my first question to them, as I say,
is, okay, it's 11 o'clock in the morning.
What's going to happen at three o'clock this afternoon?
Do you know for sure what's going to happen at three o'clock?
No.
How are you going to tell me
you know what's going to happen in five years from now
if you can't tell me what's going to happen in four hours?
Nobody knows.
You have to actually believe in the project
that you're putting together,
the location, the business plan.
And honestly, you've got to have a lot of luck as well.
And it's the timing of it, you can't control it.
You do not know.
Who would have thought in 2019,
when the economy was slowing down a little bit,
that in March of 2020,
the global economy would just shut down?
Like, never in our lifetime
would we have ever expected that to happen.
And certainly from that point forward to today,
every day is a whole new ballgame.
And we still have the tsunami effect of that,
although we don't talk about it anymore.
But the reality is the world changed.
And so now we're on that upswing,
even with interest rates being higher.
And I would argue that when the interest rates go up
and the competition will drop.
So if you want to do a project,
that's the time to get it done.
Because the second the interest rates start dropping,
everybody and their brother
is going to be going after that same deal.
Whether it's capital, debt, land, existing buildings,
you're going to have a lot more competition.
And if you time it right,
and you buy it at the top,
and interest rates are eight or nine percent,
and two years from now, they're back to five,
you're refinancing,
you're three years ahead of everybody else
who's trying to get in the game at the five.
Five years from now, it's going to be back to eight,
and they're going to be in trouble.
Mike, I want to bring you to those meetings
with my partners in Africa.
I want him to be my financial partner.
I was going to bring you along and say what you just said.
It's amazing.
But he's right.
If you're a contrarian in this business,
that's where you make money.
When things are the worst,
if you can get your deals financed
because there's no competition,
and then you're going to come into the market
when things have radically improved,
that is the right approach.
But I do want you as my financial partner.
When a quarter of a million is not money.
A quarter of a billion is not money.
A quarter of a billion.
I used to sit on the receiving end
of the revenue management at the hotels,
where they say,
how come the projections are not able to deliver
what you said six years ago,
so I can't receive what you said.
It's just hilarious.
When somebody asks me that question,
I look at them like,
I'm not the great Karnak.
How am I supposed to know
what's going to be happening in five years?
I do know you've got to go clean.
We are almost at time.
Before we wrap up,
any questions for the panel?
There you go.
Go ahead.
That's an interesting question.
Did everybody hear that?
Yeah.
It's a great question.
I'm not sure I can answer it, though.
Go ahead.
I would probably pause.
We are almost cutting into time,
but you can grab them
and get those answers during the break.
Unfortunately, we are...
It's such a great question.
It's a great question.
You're dodging the question.
No, I'm not.
I'm just getting signal.
Is that the Department of Government Efficiency dodge?
Thank you very much, Mike.
Wow.
Thank you.
