Why You Don't Matter Anymore ........... (Economically Speaking)

Global Finance News
11 followers
Late last week, the US shocked economists with a report that contained results they
were not really expecting.
The economy had grown at a shocking 3.8% pace in the second quarter, seemingly putting to
rest all of the concerns that the naysayers had about a softening job market, trade wars,
the cost of living, skyrocketing defaults, declining labor force participation, sector-wide
crises, and slowing productivity.
Sounds great, right?
Well, as you might have already guessed, there is A LOT to unpack from these numbers.
GDP isn't a flawless measure, even in normal times, and I am sure you have probably noticed
there is a lot going on at the moment.
But if you do what nobody else wants to do, and actually read the data behind these figures,
it tells three very interesting stories that challenges a lot of assumptions that we have
about how our economy should work.
This goes well beyond just simply growing inequality, that's not exactly shocking
news anymore.
But if you are looking for a sign of just how healthy and balanced the current market
is, a new report has revealed that there are now more private equity firms in America than
there are McDonald's.
And the reason is very simple.
If all of these numbers needed a headline, it would probably be, you don't matter anymore.
Economically speaking, of course.
Trillions of dollars are pouring into the United States for investment purposes.
The US economy grew faster than expected between April and June.
So yeah, that wasn't a typo.
There are now 19,000 private equity funds in the US, and only 14,000 McDonald's locations.
The statistic was originally highlighted by Elisa Wood, a partner at one of the biggest
private equity firms in the world.
Ironies aside though, the reason this is happening is because there is just more opportunity
in serving investment products to a few thousand ultra high net worth individuals and institutions
than there is in serving burgers to millions of everyday Americans.
As an economic participant, you really only have 3 jobs as far as these numbers are concerned.
You can work, you can invest, and you can consume.
So do keep this in mind as we jump into the numbers because there are really 3 big problems
with a lot of our assumptions.
The first problem is what this impressive economic growth figure is actually based on.
GDP is normally calculated by summing together household consumption, investment, government
spending, and exports and then subtracting total imports.
When the Bureau of Economic Analysis says that the economy is growing at 3.8%, they
do this calculation for a quarter, compare the difference to last quarter, and then multiply
it by 4 to get an annualized figure.
If you were so inclined, they published the individual breakdowns of all of these numbers,
and if you did look closely at the most recent report, there is one number buried deep in
the data that really puts this promising headline into perspective.
In Q1 of this year, imports into America spiked by over 38% from the quarter before.
This was mostly because big retailers wanted to stock up on inventory before tariffs took
effect so they could remain cost competitive for a few more months.
But in Q2, after they had already filled all of their warehouses, they didn't need to
bring in more inventory from overseas so imports dropped by over 29%.
Now remember, when the economists do their calculations, they subtract imports, so on
paper, a crash in import volume is actually good for GDP numbers.
In reality though, international trade swinging this wildly over 6 months in the biggest economy
in the world is… not great.
But it gets worse.
Within this same report, it is noted that this large drop in imports actually bolstered
GDP by over 5%.
What this means in plain English is that if we ignored the wild swings in import volumes,
GDP would have actually shrunk by 1.2% at an annualized rate.
Now as a small little side note, two consecutive quarters of negative GDP growth, I'm sure
the comment section can tell you what that's an indication of.
Now you might think a little glitch in the reporting process still shouldn't have this
much of an impact on the performance of the entire economy, right?
And you would be absolutely correct.
Over two thirds of the American economy depends on just this part here.
Personal consumption now accounts for 68% of all of our economic activity, well above
most other advanced economies, which is clearly not ideal, but it has given us two pieces
of false confidence.
The first is that since so much of the economy relies on consumer spending, we can't let
those consumers fall too far, or else there will be nobody left to sell stuff to, right?
Wrong.
I have mentioned this statistic before, but for those who haven't heard it, 50% of all
consumer spending is now done by just the top 10% of households.
Now that's a scary statistic by itself, but what it doesn't mention is that the
bottom 60% of households now collectively account for less than 20% of the spending,
and a growing share of that is being supported by risky consumer debt.
The companies that have been performing best over the last 5 years have been in industries
catering to wealthy consumers or to investor hype.
Ferrari is now worth twice as much as Honda, and even Walmart is changing its business
model to cater to more upmarket shoppers.
More than 200 million people could drastically cut their spending tomorrow, and the total
drop in economic activity could be covered over by increased spending on things like
AI.
In fact, it's kind of already happening.
Personal consumption contributed less to economic growth than data-centered construction in
the last reported quarter, and a majority of that consumption was done by just 10% of
households anyway.
Steve Eisman, of big short fame, did an extended interview on this a few days ago, and it goes
into depth on a lot of the specifics, so I will leave a link to that down below.
But in brief, this is more than just regular old inequality.
Today we have something arguably worse, indifference.
The lords of old at least needed their serfs to keep their empire operating.
Today not so much.
As far as the economy is concerned, your ability to be a good little consumer is just a rounding
error, and that leaves only your ability to work and your ability to invest.
So it's time to learn how money works to find out why you don't matter anymore.
To the economy.
This week's video is sponsored by Gamma, the tool that's changing the way people
build presentations and content.
If you haven't used it yet, Gamma makes it effortless to turn ideas into clean, professional
decks without touching PowerPoint or Google Slides.
Over 50 million people use it.
It's basically the go-to workspace for modern presentations.
They've just launched Gamma Agent, your built-in co-pilot that helps you work smarter, not
just faster.
Agent doesn't just format slides.
It researches, rewrites, and even fact-checks your content automatically.
It can pull competitor insights right inside your deck, or summarize a full article into
polished slides in seconds.
I tried it on one of my own decks, dropped in a URL, and within seconds, it summarized
the article into slides with citations already linked.
I didn't have to open a single tab.
It even suggested counterpoints to strengthen my argument, which saved me a ton of time
prepping for a client pitch.
It can also personalize a presentation for different audiences or reframe your tone,
from casual to executive-ready instantly.
It's like having an editor, researcher, and designer built into one tool.
You can try Gamma and see what Agent can do for your workflow using the link in the description.
One important detail about your relationship with the economy is that, yeah, sure, your
success might not mean that much to the economy anymore.
But the success of the economy also doesn't mean that much to you anymore.
Over the last 40 years, personal productivity has doubled, even accounting for inflation.
That means the average American is now producing twice as much as they were 40 years ago.
And this has given even average people access to comforts, conveniences, and experiences
that they just wouldn't have had back then.
And yet, when asked, slightly more than half of you that responded still said you would
prefer to live back then.
So we are all remembering history through rose-tinted glasses, or has this doubling
of economic output actually been totally irrelevant to average people?
Well, as you might have guessed, our per capita production doubled, but incomes did not.
Adjusted for inflation, median wages have increased by just 20% over the last 40 years,
which is not great, but it's still not nothing.
The median isn't skewed by the uber-rich like the average is, and that's 20% after
inflation, so we should theoretically be 20% better off.
And we are, but only in areas that don't really matter.
Travel, technology, on-demand services, clothing, furnishes, and even food are all much more
accessible today than they were back then, by a pretty wide margin.
However, more essential items like housing, education, and healthcare have become far
more expensive.
So while you can, in theory, buy more stuff today with a perfectly middle-of-the-road
income, it's not exactly the stuff that you need to build a comfortable life.
The things that we wanted became cheaper, but the things that we needed fell out of
reach.
Which means, for a lot of people, their strongest tangible connection to economic prosperity
is the car they are paying off over the next 84 months.
But there is one much bigger factor which is a lot harder to capture with these numbers,
and it's how people have earned that money.
Your consumption may not matter to the overall economy, but the overall economy hasn't
made it easy to consume the things you want.
But something that has lost its relevance even faster is the work we are doing.
40 years ago, most jobs garnered far more respect from both employers and employees.
Most workers in skilled or semi-skilled professions stayed with their employers for a long time,
and laying off staff or getting fired was a massive deal.
Today, losing your job at some point is the expectation.
A lot of young workers treat it almost like a joke to make content out of, although this
could be some kind of brain rot coping mechanism that I don't fully understand.
Anyway, modern technologies have made a lot of jobs far more productive, but they have
also made them far more user-friendly.
As an example, a few decades ago, most large offices would have a small army of semi-skilled
secretaries to put together presentations and information for reports.
Something like making a graph in the prescribed corporate style would take a lot of time,
but also take some level of training to learn.
Today, the company can just have an excel template, and as long as someone can copy
and paste two rows of data, they can do what used to be hours of work.
Bank managers used to be highly respected professionals with a deep understanding of
business finances, their local economy, and their extensive list of clients.
Replacing one of these guys could take a full year of direct mentoring.
Today, bank managers are glorified loan salesmen because credit reports and extensive electronic
databases have taken the skill out of their jobs.
Travel agents, junior analysts, stockbrokers, and an array of other jobs all mostly followed
the same trend.
These people became far more productive, but also far easier to replace.
User-friendly and standardized technologies meant most people could get up to speed with
a job within a week or two, as long as they knew how to use a suite of software.
The promise or threat of AI, depending on who is asking, is that it could render your
ability to work completely obsolete.
But even if it simply continues this trend of standardizing roles, it will ultimately
make workers more of a commodity that could be easily traded around an open market.
Again, this raises the argument that if nobody can find a job anymore, then there will be
nobody left to buy all of the stuff that companies are making, but once more, this is simply
not true.
Profit-motivated companies aren't going to hand over their valuable resources for
nothing in return.
For normal people, what they typically exchange for those goods and services is the hours
in their day through something like a job, a contract, or maybe even working in their
own business.
But if these working hours are no longer valued by the market, then over time, companies are
just going to start selling their products to people who can get their money through
their investments, kind of like what is happening right now.
In some tragic irony, this trend has gone so far that even multi-millionaires are being
pushed out of coveted goods and services by billionaires with more purchasing power.
I appreciate that because people don't think about the millionaires, right?
Like we get lumped in with the billionaires, but the millionaires really have it rough.
Why are you guys saying f*** you?
Alright so your consumption and your labor might not matter to the economy, but what
about your ability to invest?
It sounds like things are pretty sweet for those guys, right?
Well yes, except for the fact that investments into productive capital, like all of the technology
that's making you really easy to replace, is even more consolidated than consumption
and income.
Increased high interest consumer debt also makes a lot of investing done by everybody
else counterproductive.
According to data from the Fed, the top 10% of households own more than 93% of corporate
equities in America, but those same households only account for 5.4% of non-mortgage consumer
debt.
It's great that more people are getting into the market, but if you are paying off
a 20% APR car loan and putting $500 a month into Robinhood, you are not an investor.
You are just really bad at allocating capital.
Now what all of this means is that most economic participants don't really participate in
their own economy.
In the past, when average people struggled, the economy struggled, and wealthy people
riding on that economy struggled too.
Today, we could very well be in a situation where the majority make up such an insignificant
share of market activity that even severe problems for them can be effectively drowned
out by the party being had by a very small handful of people.
isn't great.
But for the economy, it gets worse.
We could see a situation where unemployment rises dramatically, but the economy continues
to grow, because all of those laid off people didn't contribute much to overall consumption
or investment.
In that case, taking action like lowering interest rates or giving out stimulus to help
the unemployed would risk further inflating already overinflated asset markets that didn't
feel the pain to begin with, which would only make this problem even worse.
Even the Fed essentially admitted that it was increasingly hard to enact policy that
would help ordinary workers without helping out wealthy asset owners even more.
But it gets worse.
Average people might not have that much skin in the stock market game, but the 10% that
are doing all of the spending do.
The reason they are spending so much and keeping entire industries alive is because they feel
wealthy thanks to their booming portfolios.
If these asset markets falter, there is not going to be much left to prop everything up,
Now this is normally the point where I would say to put away the tinfoil hats, because
this is all the result of broken incentive structures and flaccid regulations, rather
than some kind of deeper conspiracy.
But the reality is, this all sounds very familiar.
In 2006, a series of reports were leaked from Citigroup's asset management team dealing
specifically with ultra high net worth clients.
In these reports, they described a plutonomy, a combination of plutocracy and economy where
In a plutonomy, there is no such animal as the US consumer or the UK consumer, or indeed
the Russian consumer.
There are rich consumers, few in number, but disproportionate in the gigantic income and
consumption they take.
The rest are the non-rich, the multitudinous many, but only accounting for surprisingly
small bites of the national pie.
Now the actual intention of this report was to encourage Citigroup's wealthy clientele
to invest in companies that catered exclusively to other wealthy clientele.
Because the analysts predicted that they would eventually be the only ones worth selling
stuff to.
And remember this report was published way back in 2005.
Now Citi has tried really hard to scrape this report off the internet, so I am going to
go ahead and leave a link to it below.
It's a dense investment thesis, but also genuinely very scary.
Now of course, there is still one way that you matter in the economy, and this report
covered that as well.
Whilst the rich are getting a greater share of the wealth, and the poor a lesser share,
political enfranchisement remains as was, one person, one vote.
In plain English, the biggest risk to their clients was that votes were somewhat evenly
distributed.
Fortunately for them, we are really bad at spending them wisely.
Go and watch this video next to see just the latest example of people clearly voting against
their own best interests, and don't forget to like and subscribe to keep on learning
how money works.
