In Pursuit of an Aikido Fitness

Martial arts originated from Japan
137 followers
Several days back, I was listening to a video called Secrets of Japanese Wrestling, revealed
by the Wrestling Mindset YouTube channel. I will link that video in the description.
For those unaware, Japan has been an Olympic wrestling powerhouse for a pretty long time in
the grand scheme of things. I believe they took home eight medals in wrestling this past cycle.
Most of the video that I watched was devoted to breaking down the DNA of that phenomenon.
Something came up, though, that I've always been aware of, but I really haven't made a video on it
despite this rekindling the urge. So, to paraphrase, the Americans have an emphasis
on teaching their wrestlers tactics and moves, and then more tactics and moves, and finally,
even more tactics and moves. The result is that a huge number of American wrestlers end up with
injuries across their professional careers despite the very high level of fitness that they passively
develop. By contrast, the Japanese and Soviet wrestlers start with fitness. Tactics and
techniques are conceptualized as arising organically out of a specifically capable,
honed body. Now, again, this isn't to say American wrestlers are unfit somehow or that Japanese
wrestlers don't get taught plenty of techniques and tactics. It is mostly a matter of emphasis
and starting point, although I will say that there does appear to be a correlation between
injury prevention and the Japanese approach. At any rate, I mentioned that I was already well
aware of this perspective. I first became explicitly aware of it reading one of my
favorite old-school manuals, The Method of Chinese Wrestling by Tong Zhongyi as translated by Tim
Cartmel. 124 pages of the 229-page volume are dedicated to fitness with an emphasis on specificity
to the practice of shuai jiao. Techniques are given a relatively paltry 64 pages, and the
remaining 41 are a range of discussions from rules to etiquette to acknowledgments in the forward.
This isn't an isolated incident, either. Plenty of early Judo literature deals with the concept
of a Judo body, and yes, an Aiki body is something that I will be touching on in a
bit because it also exists in the literature. Taking my Listening to Wrestling Mindsets video
as a bit of a cosmic oracle, compounded with my prior knowledge on this fitness-first tradition
in East Asia, I set out to do a deeper dive, and what I came across was this study.
Physiological Characteristics of Aikido Practitioners and Aikido Workouts.
Again, link in the description. Now, I don't claim to be a fitness expert,
and I did have to read and re-read and re-read again this paper to triple-check my understanding
about what the stats inside it meant. I'm pretty sure I have a handle on it, but I would recommend
you do your own due diligence here. What I uncovered, though, was frankly worse than I
imagined. If you were casually skimming the study in isolation, it seems mostly positive,
or at least neutral. But reading it carefully and then comparing the data to other sports,
the image it conveys is remarkably bleak. First off, the study seems to use cardiovascular
benefits as its flagship benefit for Aikido practice, as represented by the value VO2 max.
The issue I have with this is that I looked up other sports, too. Every single one I compared
to Aikido had superior cardiovascular benefits. Now, some of this might have to do with the sample.
In one study, for example, they were looking at extremely elite athletes, and I'm not trying to
hobbyist Aikido people to Olympian-level athletes. That's not a very charitable comparison,
but I did want to know what the top end looked like. In another example, however,
they were just looking at high school-age wrestlers who weren't necessarily all that elite,
but they were also outperforming the Aikido people in this area. I know some may say,
well Aikido people skew older, and that's true, but if we take the study to mean that it's
targeting an average, and that's kind of the average view of Aikido, then we still have a
problem. Because I'll be extremely charitable here and just assume that Aikido at its current
modern peak levels is comparable in cardiovascular benefits to other combat sports.
This still isn't really a reason to choose Aikido over something else, though, because it seems like
you could walk into any sport club of any variety and have a very solid chance of getting exactly
the same or better cardiovascular benefits. And remember, we're just talking about cardiovascular
benefits at this point. There are so many other benefits that Aikido doesn't give you
that virtually any other sport, it seems like, does.
The next thing the study leans on for positive representation is flexibility of the upper limbs,
and in this area, I don't have a whole lot to say. It does seem like Aikido is somewhat unique in
this particular spot, and it makes sense given the kind of practice that Aikido is, but is it
enough to set it apart from other options? I'd argue not.
Then the study slips in some slam dunks against Aikido. Practice offers zero benefits to grip
strength or grip endurance, and zero muscle development. The findings on grip strength are,
well, concerning in a grappling art, to say the least. Even outside of that niche,
a person's grip, it turns out, is a meaningful biomarker for overall health. In other words,
strong grip strength tends to indicate overall fitness, and this study found it's no different
from doing zero training at all in Aikido. But I decided to double-check this against other combat
sports just to be sure. Wrestling does get some minor grip benefits, and Judo, predictably, also
enjoys quite a bit. At this point, I decided to have some fun with it and just check something
random. Tennis. Guys, I hate to report this, but tennis players get more grip benefits from their
sport than Aikido people, which is a grappling martial art. I don't know what to say other than
that's freaking embarrassing. Now, the lack of muscle development in Aikido didn't surprise me
at all, but again, it highlights this issue that people can pick virtually anything else in the
martial arts world and get more benefits just by showing up. I also want to point out what the
study did not bring up. It didn't even care to mention development of the legs, I assume because
it was either under the umbrella of the whole zero muscle development conclusion or because it
obviously was underwhelming, but keep the legs in the back of your head, it's going to reappear
later in this video. It's at this point that I want to slow down and help my audience frame what
all this means. First, if you're in the camp that does Aikido for fitness, it turns out you're
better off picking almost anything else on average. Of course, there are outlier dojos and
outlier practitioners and outlier teachers, but on average, it seems like Aikido is only just
barely a fitness activity. You could just go for a run and get many of the same benefits.
Second, if you're in the crowd that wants to do this art for self-defense, you should be mortally
concerned. Even if you're in the crowd that bafflingly believes it's an art dedicated to
dealing with only untrained people, you still need to be concerned because, basically across the board,
you are only as fit as an average person if you're an Aikido person. So, unless you plan
to subdue villains with your superior arm flexibility or really hope the obesity epidemic
hits the criminal underworld particularly hard, in which case, I guess keep doing what you're
doing, then Aikido will serve you well, but if you have any inclination to be more fit than the
average Joe, it's not really the best route to doing so. I know I cite them a lot, but I do want
to keep in mind, too, that the backdrop to all of this is a rapidly aging demographic, and I'm not
blaming older folks for being old here. Please don't take it that way. Age comes for us all. But
I am saying that we have a rapidly aging art, which the already vastly outnumbered young crowd
isn't getting fit in, which means when they inevitably inherit the art, do you think they're
going to enforce a disciplined fitness routine and culture? Probably not. Additionally, I also
came across a mention of an article written way, way back in 1997 by Stanley Pranin which apparently
noted a pattern of early deaths in Aikido instructors, perhaps correlated with a decrease
in their training activity. Now, full disclosure, I've only seen this article cited. I'll link the
place I found it in the description below, but it seems like the original piece might no longer be
available. So, what we have here is just another sign of the times, I suppose, but apparently,
much to my chagrin, I also have to be careful now about saying it's alright to do Aikido for
fitness because apparently it, on average, doesn't even really appear to deliver on that promise.
At this point, I need to address a couple elephants in the room. The first is the old
I'm-just-a-hobbyist-bro line of rhetoric, and look, I get it. I'll spoil you a bit on the rest
of this video and tell you that the moral here is not that every single Aikido person
needs to be some kind of phenom athletic freak of nature, but I would point out that there's
surely a crowd that needs to carefully assess their training. If you are doing Aikido for
self-defense or other martial purposes, you should always aim to be more fit than the average person
your age. There really is zero excuse because being in better fitness is like stacking the
deck in your favor before a hypothetical altercation ever even happens. And by the way,
I don't mean be more fit than the average American citizen or something like that. Don't cheat. I
like my country, but we are infamously unhealthy. I won't sugarcoat it. We're fat. When I say be
better fit than the average person, I mean be in better shape than someone who reasonably takes
care of themselves but also isn't necessarily in the gym all the time. I'd also point out here that
there's a huge optics issue. If you take a look at some other grappling systems, Brightest's most
famous sons, they all look like they train and train hard. While I know muscle mass isn't
everything in martial arts, it's sort of like wearing a suit to an interview versus not. Compared
to these guys that I have coming up on screen, where's Aikido's ambassador? Who do we have?
I was not born on a ******* turn-up truck, man. And I was not born at night.
I was born in a bright ******* sunny day, man. I've been doing this for a long time.
Need I really say more than this? All I want to add is that, again, I'm not advocating that every
single Aikido person in the world has a Greek god body. But I am saying that when people think of
Aikido, they don't think of people who actually are fit. They don't even think of people who look
fit. And that's a problem that we need to address. The other elephant in the room here is the group
of people who are out to find the so-called internal power. Because one of the things that
I've noticed when I bring up fitness in Aikido is people will use this as kind of a shield,
so they don't really have to focus on the real fitness. And that's not to say that internal power
isn't real necessarily. I'll give it a fair shake here as much as I can. There are things that
health science is really only just beginning to understand. For example, fascia might be one source
of the elusive internal power. That said, though, everything I've read about fascia points to it
contributing some extra strength, but certainly not enough to account for superhuman feats or
that sort. Personally, if we are ever going to uncover something akin to internal power,
I suspect it would be something closer to the old Max-Alding system or Maxic system.
The system originates from the early 1900s and essentially posits that the key to extreme
strength is the complete relaxation of antagonistic muscle groups during exertion.
So, for example, if you're pushing something and activating your triceps,
your biceps need to be completely disengaged, and therefore this will allow those triceps to
recruit 100% of the muscle. On paper, to me, this always sounded a lot like traditional descriptions
of internal power. That being said, the Max-Alding system seems to have fallen into disuse,
partially scooped up by the bodybuilding crowd for aesthetic purposes of muscle control,
and otherwise just languished in old books. We do know that proponents of this system
back in the day were indeed athletic freaks for their time, but it's unclear to me if
anyone is still around that can really teach the system in full. Despite having books,
my sense is that if it is legitimate, and I'm not completely sold on it, but if it is legitimate,
it would almost certainly be something you'd want a solid coach in the room for.
I'd also point out here that if we do assume that internal strength is a real thing,
I have found zero literature, traditional or otherwise, that posits that you can't be both
internally powerful and externally powerful. In fact, I know internal martial artists who say
that it's just a matter of starting point. External starts with muscle and then moves
towards internal skills and internal martial arts or vice versa. Yet, in Aikido, for some reason,
people think that it's all internal and we need to focus 100% on it. I completely disagree with
that, and again, I'll be thrilled if we do find something out about internal power, but
you can label me as a skeptic at the moment. What I'm getting at here is that I'm not
necessarily discounting what many refer to as internal power as a complete impossibility.
No, I don't think it will enable you to disable men twice your size with paced breathing and a
heavy hand on their shoulder or something, but sure, there are places I could realistically
see such a phenomenon growing out of. My issue with internal power as far as this video is
concerned, however, is ultimately threefold. First, there currently isn't a whole lot of
proof for it. Scientists have occasionally tried to measure it in people who supposedly
have the ability, and they have not found all that much, quite frankly. It therefore doesn't
really seem to have much credible academic work attached to it, and that's not really a great
look. Second, even if we assume it does exist, we don't understand it well enough to replicate it
in average, everyday people. In that vein, third, Aikido itself clearly is not pumping out internal
power masters left and right. If it were, we wouldn't be in the position that we are right now.
So while I'm open to the possibility of something that is roughly internal power being discovered
and even then incorporated into training, we definitely don't have that right now in a general
sense, and Aikido certainly isn't specifically delivering on it either. But maybe all of these
numbers and all of the science and the Steven Seagal memes leave you wanting. Maybe you're that
staunch traditionalist type who, for some reason, hangs on every word that an old dead guy said
somewhere. Obviously, I have deep criticisms about the whole go-back-in-time-to-progress ideology so
prominent in modern Aikido, so much so that I've done at least two whole videos rejecting the
I'm very much for using tradition as inspiration as a starting point, so let's take a look at that.
I want to start here with the many, many stories of the founder's quote-unquote
vice-like grip. I believe I first encountered such a story in Ellis M. Durr's Dueling with
O'Sensei book, but I'll link to an old thread discussing such tales. It devolves a bit into
notions of the aforementioned internal power, but you already know where I stand on that.
What I want to focus on here is the fact that we have several accounts of the same gripping
strength in Ueshiba. Compare that to our aforementioned study of modern Aikido people,
where there is no grip strength there at all relative to the average person. In a similar vein,
Shioda Gozo regularly defeated Masahiko Kimura in arm wrestling when they were students,
and if you've ever seen what Kimura looked like, you'll know that isn't a feat of a man with weak
arms or weak grip strength. I want to say on all of this, too, that the only other tradition I've
heard of that actually produces people with this extreme grip is the karate-style Uechi-Ryu.
While not everyone has it, apparently some have, historically. Unlike the hazy reasons for
Ueshiba's gripping power, though, it seems clear as day to me how Uechi-Ryu guys could achieve
such an ability. They conditioned their bodies almost to the point of fanaticism. It should be
noted, however, that Ueshiba was a frontiersman in the wilds of Hokkaido and did plenty of physical
labor. This is an often-overlooked fact. From here, I'd like to quote an article I
found on the Sangenkai blog about Yukiyoshi Sagawa of Daito-Ryu and his teachings on
developing a so-called Aiki body. The following are his words.
March 14, 1966
You cannot do technique if you do not have a developed body.
October 21, 1968
It is necessary to concentrate power in the forearms. Exercises like swinging a
hoodie bow are effective, but there aren't any results for six months to a year.
May 24, 1964
In order to become strong, it is necessary to strengthen the grip of your left hand.
October 24, 1969
In the end, cultivating the body is the most important thing.
January 9, 1970
The most important thing in Aiki is the legs. You must build muscle in the necessary areas
of the hips and legs through training the legs in Henko.
December 28, 1970
When conditioning, if you do not think of what your goals are, what you are going to move,
and why and the reason for doing it, there will be little result.
July 23, 1971
The way that I built my body was through push-ups.
It is important to continue each training method for at least three years.
April 5, 1971
It's no good if you don't have thick thighs. Conditioning yourself and becoming strong
means that you're building muscle.
July 1970
The muscle on your hips and abdomen must be thick, and you must begin to move from there.
Technique done with slim hips will not be effective. However, thickness from fat is no good.
September 3, 1968
The Aiki body. Unity of the forearms, body, and legs.
He says plenty more and elucidates on a couple different things in the original article. I'll
link them below, but I think you kind of get the picture here.
I want to note on a few things.
First, notice how very not mystical all of this is. It's just classic muscle building.
Second, it all has a very, very specific focus.
The workouts being done correlate with the martial art.
This isn't just generic power. It's not generic strength.
A type of fitness specifically built around the features of Daito-ryu and Aiki,
which reminds me a lot of the wrestling manual that I opened with because
all those pages devoted to fitness deal with very specific exercises for Shuaijiao.
Third, what is being described is basically an antithesis to the earlier study of Aikido.
What is essentially being described here is not merely a suggestion,
but the necessity of muscled legs, arms, and core.
It's the piece that was considered the weakest
in the previously looked-at academic study of modern Aikido people,
yet it is considered the very heart of practice here.
And again, notice that concept that I opened the video with is here as well,
and that is don't even bother with technique until your body is adequately honed.
Now, having said all of that, I have my criticisms of Yukiyoshi Sagawa's fitness model here.
I didn't quote it above, but he leans heavily into super high rep ranges of sword cuts and the like.
These, in my mind, could likely be updated with more modern exercises and more digestible rep
ranges. Similarly, I'm not really an advocate of only doing fitness stuff for new students.
It isn't really why they are there, and it will bore them into quitting.
Now, maybe I would feel differently if it was a specialty course or something across six months,
but those are for people who have already decided that they're very serious, right?
For the average person, I don't think this is sustainable.
But I would advocate for being very clear that what we do requires fitness, and that two to three
of our class sessions in the given week isn't likely to get people to where they need to be.
We tend to have this thing in reverse nowadays, where people come to the martial arts class for
fitness, but I've really grown over the course of my studies to think that this is wrong.
Fitness does need to come first. You don't go to martial arts to get fit, you go to martial arts
to learn the techniques and the tactics. Martial arts assume that you are already fit and are
keeping up with your fitness. And that is sort of the state of Aikido fitness at the moment.
Basically trash. Trash by modern scientific standards, trash by traditional standards,
and trash by general martial arts standards. I think many of the people in Aikido are spending
a lot of time innovating on techniques, at least the people that want it to be more martial.
And that is a legitimate problem. I very much, in fairness, would agree that the techniques do
need to be adapted and changed. And I'm also thinking along those lines, just look at my video
backlog. But at the same time, we might be overemphasizing the wrong end of the problem
here slightly. Divine technique doesn't mean much in the hands of people with poor fitness.
And yes, yes, I know of the whole, but it's a style that uses technique to overcome size and
strength. But come on, guys, every martial art uses that marketing line. Fitness can only help
out even more. Now, I know there will be people who twist themselves into pretzels rationalizing
why this is a line of training that should not be pursued. There always is, and I feel like I've
heard every excuse in the book at this point, ranging from time constraints to something,
something, the founder said something, something. And fine, I wish those people luck being
functionally martial with their slightly above average arm flexibility. I, on the other hand,
have decided to approach this more directly. As viewers know, I am in between dojos at the moment
for a litany of real-life reasons, but I have plenty of free time to work out. And I really
need to because my workout consistency was very much disrupted and just straight-up murdered by
my transition from America to Japan. Somewhere in between all the paperwork of getting set up here,
I just kind of lost track. I'm basically back to baseline fitness, which is something I really
need to rectify. So here's what I'm going to do. I'm going to take some inspiration from tradition
and develop a workout around it. Just to be very clear, this isn't the beginning of some radical
shift into being a fitness-themed channel or anything of that nature. If you're here for my
other style of content, don't worry, it's still going to be the main style of content. But I do
plan to post updates about my fitness training from time to time. And the reason I'm doing that
is because I hope to eventually get around to having a program that is approachable for all
Aikido people, no matter what their level is. Because this is, frankly, a piece of the tradition
that we've clearly greatly neglected, at least as much as the technical side of things. And
because I am invested in updating and making Aikido relevant, we have to deal with this,
too. So let me give you a rough sketch of what I'm beginning to look at.
First, most of what I'm going to be doing to start with is bodyweight calisthenics. This isn't
because I hate weights or have anything against them or think they couldn't be adapted to achieve
similar goals. My reasoning is really just down to that I think calisthenics are a lot more fun
and they're free to do in the park and Japanese gyms are typically pretty bad with rules against
like headphones and no free weights at all. It's a whole thing. But generally, I do think that no
matter what workout you do, whether it's Aikido specific or not, you should at least enjoy it
because if you don't, you're much more likely to quit. Therefore, I'm just going to be doing
bodyweight calisthenics. Now, there are exceptions to the whole gym thing here in Japan, but I'd
take a five-minute jog down the street to the park, then get on a train, and then have to
ride to the nearest freeweight gym, which I will then have to pay for.
Second, I'm going to be focusing quite a lot on body control. What that essentially means to me,
at least, is strength through a flexible range of motion. I might chase a few bodyweight skills,
but really just to use them as clear goals. My impression of most martial artists is that
their flexibility is basically crap. There are outliers to that, of course. As always, Taekwondo
and demonstration wushu come to mind, but broadly speaking, it seems like martial artists are always
crazy stiff for no real practical reason. I'm decently flexible in my upper extremities,
except my hamstrings are terrible, so I'll be focusing on those. That's what happens when you
sit in a chair for most of your life. And third, I'm going to be focusing primarily on legs,
in fact. I know that sounds funny since calisthenics guys aren't exactly known for their
legs, but I'm in agreement with Sagawa in regard to their importance to Aiki. I plan on spending
a lot of time with deep squats, single leg squat variations, sissy squats, duck walks,
deep lunges, and plenty more. This isn't to say I won't be doing upper body stuff at all, though.
Pushing has long been my strongest area because I've just been doing sets of pushups off and on
since I was like 5, literally. But I'd really like to start experimenting with more difficult
variations as my fitness gets back to where it really should be. I'm much less of a pooling guy
relative to my pushing exercises, but I can still hammer out like 7 or 8 pull-ups. Not where I want
to be, so I will be working on that in the background, too. Finally, although I'm not
going to jump into it immediately, I do have a vague plan to pick up a mace bell. If you don't
know what those are, they're basically weighted metal maces that you do exercises with. I'm mostly
getting one because they look fun, but I also have a suspicion that they will be a good replacement
for sword work and it has the benefit of being able to be progressively overloaded, which is
something that the traditional suburi and ken swings just don't really have. Yes, there is the
hoodie bow, but eventually you're probably going to outgrow that. All of this could change, of course, too.
But for now, my goals are really pretty simple. Get back to an acceptable fitness level, open up my
extremely tight hamstrings, strength through flexible range of motion, and a heavy focus on
legs. When will a video of me in the park come out? Well, uh, when I have progress worth showing
it will be coming. I'm telling you this mostly to keep myself accountable, actually. I have started
this process already, but I don't really have that much to report. And like I said, this isn't going
to turn into a fitness vlog channel. It's really going to be one of these things where I do some
exercises for a month or two and then come to you about how I think I'm progressing and does it have
any translatability into aikido practice. And again, I want to stress that none of this is
to suggest that the normal video is going to disappear on this channel. It's not. It isn't a
replacement. It's an addition. If you could care less about this fitness journey that I'm going on
as a side quest, by all means skip that content when it hits the channel. My hope, though, is that I
can hammer out a program that is accessible, understandable, and specifically directed at aikido
people because I really don't want our fitness legacy to be slightly more flexible than average
arms. Not to mention that fitness and martial function do go hand in hand. So if you're just
doing aikido as a community or cultural thing, by all means continue what you're up to. But if you
want the practice to have that great fitness angle, if you want it to be martial, this is something
that you should probably care about and consider addressing yourself. Anyway, that is all from me
for now. I want to thank everyone for watching. As always, it has been a great pleasure and there is
no Tengu channel without your support, so I am very grateful for your attention and your
subscriptions and your engagement. But for now, I'll see you all in the next one. Peace!
