2021 Workshops in Archaeology: African American Archaeology in Philadelphia

Museum of African Archeology
16 followers
Oct 5, 2025 #Museumofafricanarcheology #historyandculture
Yes, our next speaker is going to be Douglas Mooney, and he's going to talk about African-American
archaeology in Philadelphia. Doug is a senior archaeologist from AECOM, and he has been a
professional archaeologist in cultural resource management for more than 30 years. For the past
20 years, Mr. Mooney has worked almost exclusively in Philadelphia and the surrounding parts of
Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and Delaware. Doug, you can start. Thank you, Kurt, and thank you to
everybody for inviting me to be a part of this workshop today. The presentations so far have
all been really excellent and fascinating. As Kurt mentioned, I'm going to sort of present a
whirlwind tour through some of the most important African-American archaeological sites
that have been found and excavated in Philadelphia.
There's quite a bit of information that I want to cover in this, so I'm just going to
jump right into this. The image that's up on the screen now shows the locations of numerous
archaeological investigations that involved significant African-American components. They
may not be the only investigations that were African-American that involved African-American
occupations, but involved significant African-American components, and these are the
only ones that at least that I am aware of. Perhaps unsurprisingly, the vast majority of
these sites were cemeteries or burial sites, and they include, included in this, are the
the two African, First African Baptist Church cemeteries, the Potter's Field in Washington
Square, the burial site of the amazing Reverend Stephen, Stephen Gloucester, the Block-Leong's
House site, and the African Friends to Harmony Cemetery in West Philadelphia. Unfortunately,
we just don't have enough time here today to delve into all these sites. What I'm going to
do is focus on a smaller subset, in particular the sites of the National Constitution Center site,
President's House site, and the Bethel Burying Ground in Waco Square.
These sites are more varied in form and have the ability to speak to a number of different themes,
such as African-American domestic life and material culture, slavery in the people's house,
and the Black community's struggle to create independent institutions and sacred spaces.
These also happen to be ones that I was fortunate enough to be able to take part in.
We're going to start right away with the National Constitution Center site.
This site is located in the northernmost block of Independence Mall in the heart of
Center City, Philadelphia. It was investigated between 1999 and 2003 as part of a compliance
work. The National Constitution Center was receiving substantial funding from the federal
government, so this work was carried out as required under Section 106 of the National
Historic Preservation Act. The site itself covered virtually an entire city block,
so this is a huge investigation. The excavations of the site uncovered the well-preserved remains
of an entire 18th and early 19th century neighborhood. It encompassed 115 separate
house lots and covered approximately one million Native American and historic artifacts.
During the late 18th century, the block was populated primarily by Quakers and recently
arrived German immigrants, but during that time it was also home to an unusually dense
African-American population in this part of the city at that time. For most of these Black
families, we still know very little about their lives and personal histories. Three individuals
in this group stand out. Robert Venable, Israel Burgo, and James Orinoco Dexter,
all of whom were founding members of the African Episcopal Church of St. Thomas,
one of Philadelphia's first independent Black congregations. The area in this site which really
is the most intriguing is represented by this central area right in here.
This area was exceptionally well preserved with vast stretches of intact ground surfaces
preserved there, and that contained, among other things, what I think is maybe the most unique
artifact assemblage that's ever been found in Philadelphia, at least based on my experience.
And this is an assemblage that seemed to share numerous similarities with certain material
culture characteristics that have been documented at the occupations of enslaved Africans
on plantation sites throughout the southeast United States and the Caribbean,
and in some cases may also have analogs in traditional West African cultures. Among the
artifacts that fall into this category were literally hundreds of glass trade beads scattered
throughout the backyard spaces in there. It also included a number of cowrie shells,
several of which have been intentionally modified to allow them to be strung on cords and worn as
an ornament or an article of decoration. Other artifacts that fall into this category include
sherds of historic ceramics that appear to have been intentionally modified or mapped
to create different tools, and also examples of European coins that have been perforated
to allow them to be strung again as probably an article of jewelry or something similar to that.
We're going to really look at this site at the two occupations associated with Israel,
Burgo and James Ornoco Dexter. I'm turning first to Burgo. We don't know much about Israel Burgo,
unfortunately. We know that he was a wood sawyer, so someone who cut and cut firewood for a living.
He would have been at the lower end of the economic scale among even African Americans
at the time. We know that he probably was born sometime around 1740 and died in poverty in
South Philadelphia in 1818, and we know that he lived on this site from approximately 1791
until at least 1811, and it's kind of interesting. He lived in a home that was located on the property
and to the rear of the home of a Quaker schoolmaster, Benjamin Cathol. So Burgo's site
continues to have these very interesting material culture expressions that are found
in the site, and that starts really with the home that he lived in. Surviving historic documents
and the excavation of his home reveal that he and his family lived in a small one-story wooden
post-and-ground, earth-fast structure, and that was a very common building style in many West
African cultural traditions and unique among all the house lots excavated at the National
Constitution Center site. Other artifacts and interesting artifacts that were found in direct
association with Burgo's home include large numbers of colonoware pottery, which were recovered from
the wall trench of his house, and in the privy just outside of his home, we found large numbers
of modified ceramic discs, sometimes referred to as gaming pieces, at least one of which has
been drilled and may have been worn sort of as an article of adornment. And then some of the other
things that we really don't know what function they serve, but were again unique to what was
found on his site, and that's a series of small animal bones which have been incised with Roman
numerals, and the Roman numerals represented on these bones go from 1 to 15. It's been speculated
that potentially these also were some sort of gaming pieces or counters or something else. We
don't really know what the function of those artifacts were. Turning now to James Orinoco
Dexter, Orinoco being the name that was given to him by his original owner Henry Dexter. So
Dexter was born into slavery sometime around the year 1730, grew up in the home of a Philadelphia
merchant, Henry Dexter, and later in the household of his son James. In the 1760s he was able to
purchase his own freedom and shortly thereafter the freedom of his future wife Chris as well,
and for the next 30 or so years he worked as a coachman for the prominent Quaker abolitionist
John Pemberton. Dexter first received or achieved historical notoriety in 1782 when he was one of
six men to draft and submit the first ever petition by African Americans to the Pennsylvania
state government. You can see that petition here and his signature among the six individuals.
In this particular case they sought permission to fence in the Negro section of the potter's field
in what is today Washington Square. By the early 1790s he'd become a leading figure in efforts
to establish the African Episcopal Church of St. Thomas and in fact the very first
organizational meetings to create that church were hosted by Dexter in his north fifth street home.
He later played a central role in acquiring building materials to construct St. Thomas'
first house of worship and served for a time as one of that congregation's first pedestrian.
Dexter's house within the National Constitution Center site was located over on the fifth street
side. It probably looked very similar to this 18th century home that comes from a different part of
Philadelphia. He rented it from his neighbor Ebenezer Robinson, a Quaker brush maker. The
house itself was situated in an area that was eventually to be covered by a bus parking lot
and turnaround for the National Constitution Center and initially when his home site was
looked at it was pretty clear that the construction that was going to occur here was relatively minor
and would not impact any potential archaeological deposits that was associated with his home and so
in accordance with Park Service policy the initial plan of action here was that Dexter's home site
would not be excavated but would be preserved in place. But as information about Dexter's life,
the background information and historical information became better known about him and
in particular about his role helping to found St. Thomas' and the organizational meetings that
he hosted on the spot. The Park Service changed course and decided that well maybe we need to
think of this his property as sort of a traditional cultural property and maybe we need to seek
consultation with members of the local African American community and others. The consultants
that were brought together to discuss this project eventually included representatives from St.
Thomas' church, from Mother Bethel AME church, from the Philadelphia Multicultural Affairs
Congress and representatives from city government. When they looked at this situation they believed
that well you know Park Service policy about preservation in place here isn't really an
absolute and in fact there are exceptions that can be made in the cases of sites that have extreme
public interest or are associated with very significant historical events. And they felt
that this site certainly fit that bill. They argued their case to the Park Service and
ultimately were able to convince them that was true and to change course and the dig was on.
So the excavation itself sought to recover any kind of physical evidence, archaeological deposits
that could shed light on Dexter's personal history, the members of his family and
potentially other members of the African American community that occupied this spot.
The excavations began on February 25, 2003 following a brief convocation ceremony
conducted by the then ministers of St. Thomas and Mother Bethel AME. The excavations were also
conceived because of the public interest that was generated by what was learned about Dexter's
life. The excavations were conceived of from the beginning as an exercise in public archaeology,
although on a fairly small scale. So there was a small viewing platform that was erected right
next to the site where people could come and members of the public could come in and watch
the excavations, interact with the archaeologists as the site was being excavated and see the
discoveries as they were coming out of the ground firsthand.
Excavations here found a number of historic features including four brick-lined shaft
features. Unfortunately, all of those had contained deposits that were associated with
people that lived around Dexter and either predated or post-dated his time. Dexter lived
on the block during that decade of the 1790s. But one feature in particular was identified
that had the potential to be associated directly with Dexter and the members of his family.
That was about a five-foot square diameter wood-lined barrel privy. It was fairly
jam-packed with the material culture that we believe was actually can be attributed to Dexter
and his family. The fill within this feature was kind of interesting in that rather than
representing, you know, sort of a quick accumulation of debris and rubbish thrown into
this privy, into this pit, it rather was consisted of a series of thin overlapping layers that
appeared to represent slow gradual accumulation of material. And it was interpreted initially
that maybe what we're seeing here is evidence of a material being deposited in here as part
of yard sweepings, which again was a common practice in many West African, traditional West
African cultures. The artifacts that came out of the privy here included many average day-to-day
artifacts that spoke to daily life in the Dexter house like wooden toothbrushes, buttons, and
clothing fasteners, sewing needles, and thimbles, and a whole manner of other artifacts. It also
included a number of ceramic sherds associated with what would have been more expensive imported
tablewares. Most members in the African-American community at this time probably wouldn't have
been able to afford the purchase of these items, but clearly Dexter was able to provide
nicely for his family and set a fine table for his family and also for the guests that he invited
into his home. There was also a significant numbers of food remains that were found within
the privy, and that included animal bones that indicated that he and his family enjoyed a broad
diet including beef, lamb, pork, fish, and poultry. And a significant portion of these bones indicate
that he was able to afford the more choice cuts of meat when feeding his family.
But also what was found in here were large numbers of bones from pig's feet. Pig's feet were
a common component in the diet of enslaved individuals in other parts of the country,
and in this instance how they were interpreted would, you know, even though Dexter could afford
nicer and more eye-on-the-hog cuts of meat, that maybe these bones represent a form of comfort food
that may have invoked a sense of identity and family for Dexter and the members of his household.
So while the excavation of Dexter's home produced no real earth-shattering new discoveries,
they were considered to have been a success and worthwhile undertaking by all parties.
Not only did the dig focus substantial attention on Dexter's previously unknown
personal story and achievements, but also created an opportunity for members of the public,
or many for the first time, to learn about the 18th century birth of Philadelphia's free Black
community and of the group of Black founding fathers who helped create the bedrock social
institutions that made that possible. And today the stories of Israel Burgo, Dexter, and others
are included in one of the most popular exhibits within the National Constitution Center, and as
well as 3D printed replicas of some of the artifacts that were recovered from their individual
properties. So in a larger context, and getting ready to move forward to the next site too,
the excavation of Dexter's home established the essential groundwork for community activism
and publicly oriented archaeology that ultimately achieved much fuller fruition
a few years later in the excavation of the President's House site just a few blocks away.
So the President's House, which is depicted in this painting from 1830, was located just two
blocks to the south of the National Constitution Center site on Block 1 of Independence Mall,
and was located right at the southwest corner of the intersection of Market Street and 6th Street
in really what is one of the busiest intersections in all of Philadelphia in terms of foot traffic
and whatnot being associated very closely with Independence Hall just to the south.
And this is the site where Presidents Washington and Adams during that 10-year window when
Philadelphia served as the temporary capital of the United States,
where those two presidents literally invented what it meant to be an American president.
And it's also a house where it was later discovered George Washington during his
tenure on the site at various times brought as many as nine enslaved Africans up from Mount
Vernon to serve in the household staff of this executive mansion of what was the White House
of its day. Despite the significance of this site, the fact that it was, you know, the White
House of its day and associated with Presidents Washington and Adams, this is a site that its
very existence and even location was almost completely removed from public memory over time.
And that's for, you know, fairly obvious reasons. The house itself was heavily modified after
Adams left the house in 1800. In 1832 it was torn down and replaced by a series of larger
commercial buildings, all of which had deep underground basements. Those buildings were
in turn demolished in the 1950s in order to create Independence Mall. And in the 1960s
sort of the final indignation occurred here when a public toilet was built directly over top of the
So the site itself was rediscovered in around 2002 when a local historian named Ed Lawler
published what was essentially an architectural history of the site that described details of
what the house looked like, how it evolved over time, where exactly it was located,
and the images here sort of give you a sense of where all that was situated on the site.
Almost as an afterthought, Lawler's research also included that information for the first time
about the enslaved individuals that Washington brought here into the house. The information
about the new rediscovery of the President's house and particular the discovery of Washington
having kept slaves in the house really sparked a public outcry with people throughout the city
calling for something to be done to commemorate this site, to mark it, and also to see if anything
could be learned at the site about the enslaved individuals that Washington brought here.
Lawler's research also made clear that the President's house itself was actually a complex
of buildings. There was the main house that fronted on Market Street which served state
functions and administrative functions, and then a whole series of more functionally oriented
back buildings that stretched 180 feet back into the block. Some of the areas of the President's
site are now at the time sealed beneath the Liberty Bell Center. The one piece of information
here that really shook people was Lawler's discovery that a small structure that Washington
had built to house his enslaved stable workforce and that sort of became known widely as the
slave quarters was situated directly beneath the entrance to the new Liberty Bell Center.
So anybody going into the center to see the very symbol of American freedom and liberty
first had to cross over the site where people were held in bondage on this property.
When all this information came out there were a variety of groups that formed
to protest and to try to get something done to tell the history of the enslaved Africans
that were here. That included groups like one group was called Nations Unlimited,
but the principal one was the Avenging the Ancestors Coalition of Attack.
For two and a half years or so, these groups marked staged protests, cajoled, argued with
park service and city officials that it wasn't enough to simply commemorate
the President's house and Washington and Adams with anything that was going to be erected on
the site. That instead more needed to be done to flesh out the lives of those enslaved individuals
who were brought here against their will and specifically like with the occasion at the
Dexter site, Attack and others argued strenuously that there needed to be an archaeological
investigation of this site even though anything that might have been preserved in the ground
was not originally going to be impacted by any kind of memorial construction or anything like
that. They argued that this again was one of those exceptional situations where preservation in place
was not sufficient and they argued for archaeological excavation even though
even the Park Service's own assessment of the site gave it at best a low to moderate potential
for containing any sort of archaeological deposits that could be directly associated with
that period when the site served as the executive mansion of the President's house.
Ultimately, these groups prevailed. The city agreed that yes, this needs to be excavated
and the city put forward the money to to make that happen. This also built again on the lessons
that were learned in public archaeology from the Dexter site and again it was always conceived of
as an exercise in public archaeology although on a much grander scale. So this time there was a
large public viewing platform that was built directly on the edge of the site and again
this afforded the people who visit the site an opportunity to view the excavations, to see
what was coming out of the ground in real time. Back with the archaeologists about the discoveries
here. Now, what was found? Ultimately, this project succeeded beyond anybody's wildest expectations
and that was despite the fact that the site proved to be, in a sense, artifact poor and
meaning that there were 19,000 artifacts that were recovered from the site and a number of deep
brick-lined shafts and privies and whatnot that existed below those deeper later 19th century
basements but all of the artifact deposits recovered from the site postdated the President's
House time period. No artifacts in here could be directly tied to Washington or any members of his
enslaved workforce but where it did succeed was most unexpected because it did recover
again unexpected in some cases previously unknown fragments of the President's House itself
and that those fragments ultimately connected both with the office of the President and with
the enslaved individuals kept here by Washington. Among the fragments of the house itself
that were found, this curving wall right here which is the foundation of a two-story
semicircular room that Washington had added on to the back of the main house,
the back of the state dining room, something similar to this house in Hill State,
so it's sometimes called a bow window but really it was a two-story semicircular room.
Never knew that it actually had foundations that extended down to the basement level
which is what this represents. This is the back wall of the main house,
window foundations. Both Presidents Washington and Adams used this curving space in this room
to greet guests in the state dining room and at other official functions and both used that space
to help create one of the first visible symbols of the office of an American President.
Modern historians of the White House down in Washington DC do believe that it was the shape
of that space that influenced the construction of the Oval Rooms in the present-day White House
including the President's Oval Office. So in a very real sense this was sort of
the original Oval Office. Other fragments of the house that survived and again against all
expectations were parts of the back buildings behind the main house including, outlined in
blue here, the foundations of the kitchen which is where, among other things, Washington's enslaved
chef Pericles Posey, renowned chef, produced sumptuous meals for Washington's family and
household and the guests that he entertained. There was also a smaller sub-basement within
the kitchen which probably served as a root cellar or cold storage facility
and then again previously unknown the remains of an underground passageway
that connected the basement of the kitchen with the basement of the main house and would have
allowed Washington's workforce, both enslaved and free, to move back and forth between those spaces
without being seen or disturbing the guests up in the main house. That was not an unusual feature
for some of the large manor houses of this time but again it was not something that was previously
known about the house itself. The discovery of all these different fragments
really provided visitors to the site with a real connection. It gave them a real sense of time and
place, enabled them to transport themselves back to this location into these spaces and really
sympathize with the individuals that were on this property and with the residents themselves.
It allowed them to get a really visceral connection with this house and the importance of the site.
And the people came. This was a huge outpouring of support for this project. The site itself
was open only for four months. As a matter of fact, it's one of the only projects, the only project,
that I've ever worked on in my life when our client, the City of Philadelphia, twice told us to
slow down and make this last longer. That never happens. But over the course of that four-month period
there were more than 300,000 people that visited this site and that stood on that
viewing platform to see the site and to learn about the history of the enslaved individuals here
and to come to terms themselves with what that meant, to develop their own interpretations of
what that meant. A very powerful moving experience. This story was also picked up by more than 400
individual media outlets throughout the world, which helped spread this story to an even greater
audience. And one of the things, pieces of information that was spread through all this
news and whatnot, was it was eventually learned that the plan for when the excavation was done
would be to backfill this site and to build the memorial on top of that. And of course it was
necessary to backfill the site to some extent in order to preserve those very fragile fragments
of the president's house that were exposed. But there was an outcry, an outrage among the public
that this was going to be backfilled, that you would not be able to see anything again after this.
Many people wanted to look at the site, the entire site left open in perpetuity.
In the end it forced the city and their design team to completely rethink the design of this memorial
and ultimately to incorporate a glass vitrine viewing window into the site,
which was climate controlled and which allows visitors to this day to look down
into what was considered the most important part of the site. So people can see
that fragment of the bow window, the foundations of the kitchen where Hercules worked, and that
underground passageway that connected both the main house and the kitchen.
So again, that public activism saved the day and produced really tangible results.
The last site that I'm going to get to today is the burying ground at Weckett.
I'm going to give you a time check, Doug. Where are we at?
You're pretty much done. Okay, I'll wrap this up real quick. Okay, sorry. Thank you, though.
So the Bethel Burying Ground, it occupies a little over a quarter of an acre beneath what
is today Weckett Playground. It was a cemetery purchased by the Reverend Richard Outt in 1810
and was actively used up until about 1864. Over the course of that time period, it's estimated
that perhaps as many as 5,000 members of the early 19th century African American population
of Philadelphia were buried on this site. It was, again, another site that was lost to time,
in part because the cemetery was sold in 1889 to the city of Philadelphia so that the congregation
could fund the building of its new church. The city turned it into a public park. For a time
in the early 20th century, it was transformed into a public garden, and then ultimately,
after 1912, into a playground. The site was rediscovered by the work of a local historian
named Terry Bucklew, who did a tremendous job documenting the names of individuals known to
be buried here. He now has about 2,500 names of people that were known to be buried.
Archaeological investigations were conducted in 2013 when the city was in the process of
trying to renovate the playground. The purpose of the archaeological investigations was to try
to determine were there still burials present and about how far down below the ground surface.
Pretty quickly, they were able to determine that, yes, in fact, there were. This is one of the
trenches that was excavated, and then about two feet down, in a space that measured five feet by
eight feet in total size, there was evidence of no fewer than 19 individual grave shaft outlines
that could be picked up in the soil of the site. So this is a very, very full cemetery to this day,
and the remains of these individuals do still exist on the site.
Other excavations at the site were able to identify the outer walls of the cemetery,
so its exact placement could be determined. One of those small fragments of a headstone
that commemorated the life of Amelia Brown, who died in 1819 at the age of 26, was found
covered from the site. After the excavations were done, again, huge public outpouring. The city got
involved, formed an essentially a hearing committee to try to determine how the site should be
commemorated, and what form, who was going to be involved in that. That process took years, involved
a search for a public art installation. That was finally awarded last year to this artist, Karen
Olivier, a local Philadelphia artist, and her installation named Her Luxuriant Soil is planning
to be built over top of the location of the cemetery this coming summer. So this will be
incorporated into the site. It'll incorporate, among other things,
decorate like others found on 19th century cemeteries, plantings, and other things that
actually will invite members of the local community to become involved in the upkeep of this site.
So I'm going to end this presentation now just with a plea.
This overview hopefully has shown that Philadelphia possesses a tremendous potential for informing us
about its historic African-American population, and providing insights into the lives of both free
and enslaved Black individuals, who are largely ignored by the historic record in life.
We need help. Given the tremendous building boom that Philadelphia has experienced over the past
several years, an unknown number of historically significant sites, some of which are no doubt
associated with people and events important to the city's African-American heritage, are being
irreparably damaged or destroyed every single day. Now more than ever the kinds of public action and
engagement discussed here are needed now in order to prevent yet undiscovered and irreplaceable
archaeological sites from being lost forever. Thank you.
Thank you, Doug. That was really an excellent presentation and certainly a necessary plea at
the end. There's no question that these resources are being lost at this time. I don't know,
Sherry, do we have time for any questions? We don't have any specific to Doug's presentation.
The general consensus that I keep seeing in the Q&A is how do we get community activism started?
How do we raise the awareness? How do we get volunteers? And how do we get our legislature
to care and act upon some of our cemetery laws and improve our preservation of cemeteries across
the commonwealth? So those are some things that whether you want to address those right now,
Doug, or we want to save those for the end of the day. Well, I will just say the one thing that can
be done in Philadelphia specific, you know, right now there is the main preservation body in
Philadelphia is the Historic Commission and there are currently no archaeologists that are part of
that organization. So the preservation and protection of archaeological resources inevitably
takes a back seat. That is a situation that can be easily remedied by the mayor and it really just
takes that kind of activism and arguments and cajoling to try to get the mayor to ratify that
situation. At least then there will be people in city government that are actually looking for
sites and that's a necessary first step to ultimately protect them.
Thank you. Thank you. It's interesting they had a pretty active,
the city had a pretty active archaeological program I guess in the early 80s.
Right, but then when that person left in the late 80s they were never replaced.
Right, very important.
