A Beginner's Guide To African Art: Helping to Understand History & Value

Museum of African Archeology
16 followers
Have you ever looked at a piece of African art, maybe a mask, a sculpture or a textile and wondered
what the stories behind it could tell? Who made it? Why? What did it mean to the people who first
held it, first used it? As an antiques dealer I've noticed how buyers and traders feel unsure when it
comes to African art. They found it confusing, maybe even intimidating. In this video we're
going to tackle some of those challenges. What should we call it? What are those stories? How
do we age and value these works? So whether you're curious or already fascinated this will be a video
worth sticking around for. Okay well thank you for clicking on to the Taliesin Antiques YouTube
channel. As a way of a quick introduction my name is Kieran Hughes-Jones. I am an antiques dealer based
in South Wales. If you want to see the type of pieces I sell which are what I find to be
interesting items from across the world you can go to my website which is taliesinantiques.com.
So to give you a bit of a backstory about why I'm making a video on African art I've built up
quite a bit of a backlog on items from across the African continent. They're masks, wooden sculptures,
even a weapon, all sorts of different things and I've been hesitant about uploading them and putting
up for sale because to be honest I was quite concerned about not giving them the due respect,
misattributing them, maybe not even understanding their true value. I wanted to do some research
first and try my best to at least get a beginner's understanding of everything that gets everything
involved with African art and the history behind it and I think that's an opinion maybe view a lot
of people share. When I go into a lot of antique shops I see items from Africa that just says
African carving and the price. I wanted to do a bit more than that and I think I want to hopefully
try and bridge that gap. So this video isn't effectively a beginner's guide just into the
history of African art and the different stories involved and I suppose some of the key challenges
and questions that we have to confront and try and be aware of I think in the west. So
that's what we're going to do today. As I said this is a beginner's guide. I am a beginner,
I am by no means an expert, very far from it. I try my best to make sure any information I give
is accurate and fair however I'm open to all feedback and opinions so if there's anything
you think that I've missed the ball on just let me know in the comments and I will do my best to
update the channel when I make new videos. Before I go any further though I do want to highlight
that if you want to help this channel grow, if you are interested in antiques, reselling,
even if you just like this type of content whatever this might be, you can help the channel grow A by
watching the videos which you're already doing so thank you for that. B you can subscribe to
the channel just click the subscribe button below and you can like and comment the videos
on videos as well so if you can do that that's great. So I guess that's it let's get started.
First topic I want to tackle is the immense diversity of African art. We'll have a look into
that. To understand African art in my opinion we first need to grasp the size of the continent
and the amount of different cultures and peoples within it. So Africa is the second largest
continent on earth covering 30 million square kilometers. To put that into context that's bigger
than the United States, China and India combined. It's an absolutely massive place but here's
something important to keep in mind. The map of Africa as we know it today doesn't reflect the
continent's cultural and tribal boundaries. Many of the country borders were drawn up by European
colonizers during the late 19th century often with little regard for the people who lived there.
These artificial lines cut across regions where ethnic groups or tribes naturally spread
and it's divided communities and lumped others together. This history is vital when we're looking
at African art. Many of the artistic traditions we admire today don't fit neatly within these borders
you see on the modern map. Not necessarily good enough to say this is an antique from Nigeria
because there are many tribes in Nigeria and tribes that transcend those borders. So again this is very
important when thinking about the items that we have. The traditions are more connected by the
geography so whether that be the landscapes and environments where they were developed. So this is
important when we're looking at the pieces and trying to identify exactly where they originate.
It's a continent with contrasting landscapes. In the north you have the huge Sahara desert.
If you go further south you will find rainforests and you will find sprawling savannas.
Where the people live will influence the materials they use and the techniques they use
in their art. For instance in desert areas like where the Tuareg people live their artistic
traditions are dominated by silver and by leather. So when you start moving generally south of the
Sahara you start moving towards more forested regions. This is where wood is more abundant
and you will find more wood carvings of masks, sculptures and other pieces used in that material.
In terms of the cultural and linguistic diversity Africa is home to over 2,000 languages and over
3,000 ethnic groups each with their own artistic traditions. They're going to be steeped within
their own history, their own cultures, their own beliefs and the environment that they live in.
To give some more examples we have this beadwork from the Maasai people who were living in modern
day Kenya and Tanzania in East Africa. They were known for this intricate work which conveys social
status and identity. Then in West Africa you have the Ashanti people who were better known for their
metalwork such as these gold dust boxes. Okay well I wanted to show you a piece from the collection
of items that I'm now selling on my website because it does include one of these Ashanti
gold dust boxes. So made of bronze and cast using, I mean I didn't refer to them, but using the lost
wax technique which is an older style of casting bronze. This one would almost certainly be from
the 19th century in my opinion based just on the aging. You see there the green there if you didn't
know already that's the degree which develops it's like oxidization on the metal that develops over
time. It's a really nice example and you can see it there just all the geometric patterns on the
top you have this finial. My understanding this is a known as a Sokofa bird or a Sankofa bird
and this symbolizes learning the lesson from the past to I guess frame your future decisions.
So a very interesting piece with a lot of history and symbolism and gives you an insight into the
people who made it. I also want to feature another piece that I have available at the moment for sale
on my website because I thought this was quite interesting and it really does highlight the point
I think that we do often make the mistake in the West of looking at African art through a single
lens mistakenly perceiving it to be one style when in fact there is a huge amount of different diverse
cultures, stories, meanings and purposes behind each piece. Even if you think they look the same
on your first interpretation there could be a totally different reason why it was made. So this
is the piece I wanted to show. Now I believe this comes from the Yoruba people who are mainly in Nigeria
but they've also in other regions such as Benin and today the Yoruba people are one of the
largest in Africa is my understanding. Now they made lots of different carvings for fertility
for different rituals, different reasons. This one I think is known as an Ibiji figure
which was made to honour a twin. Now in Nigeria in that region twin birth rates are one of the
highest in the world and twins are revered believing to have a unique spiritual energy.
If one passes away a figure like this could be made as a way to maintain that connection between
the living and the departed and I think that type of story is exactly why it's worth spending some
time trying to try our best to understand this artwork and the purpose behind it. And it leads
to my next question which is when we're talking about this category what's the best way to refer
to it? Is it African art? Is it tribal art? Or is there something else? During the colonial era
African art was often categorised by European collectors and institutions as tribal or
primitive. This reflected the prevailing Eurocentric attitudes of the time. This would
often take them out of context referring to them as ethnographic curiosities rather than art. So is
tribal art a term which is still acceptable? And there is a debate around this through not just
academics but people interested in art in general, from politicians, from people from
the countries where tribal art is referred to their historic artwork. And it's important to
point out as well that that term is not just used to refer to African pieces it's used to refer to
anything indigenous where it's being made by hand usually with the materials from around them. So
the question is is that a fair term and are the connotations too strong to the time I was just
talking about where people from different parts of the world from different races were seen as
inferior and more primitive? It's also a question of is it too broad and not respecting the pieces
and I suppose the vast differences between them. So if you're looking at sculptures whether they
be wood carvings or bronzes from West Africa is that the same as a Zulu shield made in South
Africa. So what's the alternative? We could stop using that term. A lot of people will
argue against that. They will say they're just overthinking it and calling it tribal art is not
saying it's inferior or you know it's not it's more primitive it's just calling it for what it
is. It has come from the tribe and there's nothing wrong with that. So that debate continues on.
I guess it leads to the next question which is is there a better term? Now
African art is what I've been using in this video. I think it's the best that we have
at the minute and it does in my opinion it does respect the heritage
and the meaning behind these artworks. However there are critics of that. First of all again
just saying Africa. Do we call Asian art Asian art? Do we call European art European art?
Not usually. Usually we're more specific than that. You know if I had a piece of Chinese porcelain
I wouldn't call it Asian porcelain usually. I'd identify it for what it is. So is that do I do
the same with African art as well is the question. There's also critics of using that term art
because art is kind of a Western idea. In Africa these items were made for purpose for use whether
that be spiritual ritual use or for actual functionality. So this is a conversation which
will continue continue going. You know in my opinion just to end this section that I use
African art I think it's a it's a fair term I think you know in general in a general sense.
However what I think the best thing to do is what I've been trying to highlight in this video is
that we can we can be more specific than that rather than just say this is a piece of African
art. I'm trying to go down the line now of learning about the piece. Learning its history
its purpose. I'm looking over here because this this figure is still there. Learning about
its history its meaning and presenting it for what it is and being more specific where possible.
Usually this comes down to intent. Not everyone has the time or access or interest that I have.
You know with antique dealers we sometimes just get a lot of stuff that we didn't necessarily
want all of it and then we just sell it on. Now if there's an antique dealer who's not that
interested in African art they wanted other pieces then they're not going to go into the
amount of depth that I will if I own the piece. So as long as the intention is fair and you know
people respect the item for what it is I think then we should we should be okay. So we'll go
into the next section now which is probably the most challenging which is how do we date when a
Many of Africa's historical artifacts were made of organic materials like wood and leather.
These materials are highly perishable especially in the extreme climates that you do find across
the continent. Cultural practices also led to many of these artifacts being destroyed as they were
not intended to last forever. They were created for a very specific ritual or ceremony. Once they
fulfilled their purpose they would often be intentionally left to decay. In some cases even
burned such as some ritual masks which were burned to release the spiritual energy they contained
ensuring they were not misused or mishandled. Another reason why you don't see as many African
items which are over 100 years old is because Europeans during the colonial era understood their
artistic and cultural significance very early on. This led to widespread acquisition often
outright looting of these works. One infamous example is the British expedition to the kingdom
of Benin in 1897 during which British forces ransacked and destroyed the city palaces
seizing countless cultural artifacts. All of these reasons have led there to be a small amount of
antique African art found outside of museums or major collections. Some argue, some experts argue,
that little to nothing remains within Africa itself in terms of true antique artwork.
This is of course why there are such significant efforts from African countries to
have these artifacts returned to them. So if you or I come into possession of a piece of African art
what are the chances of it being a true antique? Right then so it leads me back to that question
which is how do we actually date these items based on all those factors? As I said I find
this the most challenging and I think from what I can tell it takes a lot of experience,
interest, dedication, education to be able to do this effectively. Although there are people who
are able to do it there are some good Facebook groups for example where people will help you
date your artwork and you know they know more certainly more than I do. Just to give you a few
pointers that I use and without carbon dating you know a lot of this is interpretation and just
trying our best to get this right. I'm going to use this figure here as to help me make these
points. Now I believe this to be from the Lager people, a female statue or carving rather and
Lager people were based around the Congo rainforest. Now I believe this was made for
the Buwami society. I hope I am saying that right and there are a lot of different societies when
you read about African history there's a lot of different societies to be aware of as well.
I believe just society helped in terms of moral guidance and wisdom. Now in terms of age in this
piece there's quite a few things I can look at here. So first of all the patina
I suppose and service wear. Now on wood patina is usually caused by handling. So on our hands
we have oils which react usually with wood and lead to a bit of gloss and sometimes you see some
wear you know you can see here some wear to the wood. I'll give you the top view as well.
You know the condition is another factor here which I think shows the age. So you are seeing
across the piece. Now that happens over time we already talked about the climate but it usually
happens over decades when you start to see these splits in the woods that's a good sign
of a certain amount of age. So you've got that surface wear that patina on the wood
you know darkened surfaces some areas then from handling exposure you know you're just
seeing different colours and grains across the piece. Now I believe this is a mid 20th century
possibly earlier in the early 20th century. The reason I don't think it's older is I think there's
a bit of fine detail on the piece which suggests it probably wasn't going into the 19th century
on the eyes the mouth and the hands for example. It just looked like a finer tool has been used
a more consistent tool. However that's my opinion. There are other things you can look at
of course you can look at tool marks if you're able to look into that detail. You know I mentioned
that just on that piece you can see the precision that was used obviously as we come closer to our
time today the more precision and possible I suppose the quality of the work in terms of
how accurate it is does get better when you see more machinery develop.
Lots of different things and of course it depends on the material we already looked at the gold dust
box which had signs of oxidization on the piece. On leather you'll see wear and wear and tear as
well from age. You look at those type of things I suppose the key point for me is just to bear
in mind because of all those factors of degradation and looting and you know items being destroyed
age is relative when we look at African art. A piece from the mid 20th century
doesn't negate it. It doesn't mean that it's not of good quality or worth owning or have a good value.
A lot more important is the hands who made it the purpose who made it
does it represent a tradition and history of the people where it comes from or is it a piece that
was made for decorative purposes. Now whether that be again by the people who made it or was
it made by artisans who are not from the culture who just know that there's a demand and a market
for African artworks who make pieces to fulfill that market and that is known usually as the
tourist trade. So we're going to look into that next of all how big is the tourist trade and how
do we identify pieces. The tourist trade has grown significantly since the colonial times when
European travellers began buying simplified versions of traditional artworks as souvenirs.
Over time this demand has grown and has led to mass production of items tailored to the foreign
tastes. You can find markets now in countries like Kenya, Ghana and South Africa absolutely
I believe there are distinctions to be made within the term the tourist market the tourist
trade when it comes to African art so when people say is that a tourist piece yeah I don't think
it's as simple as that. So the tourist trade as I've already talked about has been going on for a
long time and a lot of the people were making when they were getting visitors from the west
it was clearly showing a big interest in their history and their culture and wanted to take a
souvenir away they were making items which was still representative of their culture
and selling it to them. I think that's you know a really positive thing it's great it's good when
it was done ethically where the westerners were actually paying their way rather than just taking
items or paying below what their value were there is actually something positive about that. Now
that trade has gone on and still goes on to this day and I think there's a difference between
a tourist item that was made for a western visitor you know say in the mid-20th century
by the tribes themselves compared to an example which is made later on by somebody in a workshop
who is just making African looking items I suppose and doing that because they understand
there's a market and some people just buy them without knowing a lot of the history of them.
I'm going to show you two examples of the latter these two maps I believe are tourist trade
probably made in the same workshop and made a bit later on I just want to talk to you about some of
the reasons I believe that so these are two masks there we go so on the right here we have what I
believe is a Fang people inspired mask from Gabon that area and I believe this is an Igbo people
mask to Nigeria region that was made again later on. Now what I am spotting and what I'm looking
out for is first of all just see that wear in the paint which is an aging which you would expect
with age however I'm going to just put this one down to make a point I think this has just been
done artificially just rub down you can imagine that process can't you it doesn't to me look
that natural also there is a smell on these two I think a smoky smell so what happens
as part of the aging process is a lot of these masks are put over a fire to be smoked
is to give that that smell making people believe that it's part of it was part of a ritual
and also given you know I brought these two together I knew what they were when I was buying
them and I'll tell you why I bought them now you can see that even though they come from two
different regions to me it looks like the pigments used so the paint is exactly the same color so
that is a bit of give away to me now what I will say there is still a good value to these these are
decorative items people buy them knowing what they are they still look good on a wall if you're
into that type of thing they're great interior pieces often you know why not why you might
how's this worse than buying a modern picture from Ikea for example to decorate your wall
it's the same thing so there's still a value for these they're still actually you know they're
still well carved nice to look nicely made and still at least represent the African
culture that they are trying to imitate now what I'm going to show you is what I believe in the
mask that was again was made for the tallest tree I believe it was made I believe this one was made
by the people themselves and this is probably mid 20th century that might say it's earlier
than that might say it's later you're welcome to tell me your opinion so this again is from
there's a full history on this item on my website I think that the wear on this one is more natural
and is inconsistent it's where you might expect it to be that the pigment is flaking off
you know it's well carved there's a lot more detail on there there's a huge headless as well
no artificial smell at all so again I would say I think this is a later
when I say later I'm referring to maybe mid 20th century but at least made by the people
themselves and that as a result will have more value and more interest and more of a following
because it was made by people who understood these cultures and from that you know it's
a third-hand example so there we go that's the that's a couple of examples when it comes to
the tourist trade so look still worth buying after one price just understand what you're looking at
understand how you how to sell it how to sell it and how to present it what I'm going to go on to
next is more the authentic pieces and how we go about valuing it to help answer this question
we're going to look at a interesting case from France which happened quite recently in 2021
a couple sold a lot of items they had in a second home in southern France to an antiques dealer
now a few of those items came from an ancestor which they believed not to be of much value
and one of those items was an old African mask
carved in wood now as part of the sale the agreed price for the mask was 150 euros
it would later emerge that those items that they had sold belonged to an ancestor who was a French
colonial governor his name was Rene Victor Romier I believe that's how you say it and he has served
in Africa during the late 19th and early 20th centuries in March 2022 the item would go for
sale the wooden mask that is would go for sale in an auction in Montepelier it sold for 4.2
million euros the auctioneers described the mask as an extremely rare 19th century mask
part of a secret society of the fan people in Gabon so it's an ethnic group and only 10
of these masks are believed to still be in existence so the couple who weren't aware
of the significance and value therefore of the mask sued the dealer alleging deception
a court ruled in the favor of the dealer saying the couple hadn't done their own due diligence
to assess the value of the mask to complicate the matter further the Gabonese government
also sought return of the mask also going to court for that however this was dismissed
so then what made this mask so valuable now first of all they've got the confidence
the buyer that is the confidence of the provenance it came from a French colonial
collection they know the date that he was serving in Africa and when he would have acquired it
you know how he acquired that is a different matter but that's what they do know in terms
of provenance the age therefore is confirmed as 19th century we talked earlier on about
the rarity of items from antiquity and of course there is a rarity involved with this
mask we know that only around 10 at most exist most of them will be in museums it's also worth
noting the cultural significance of this specific mask so it was part of a secret guild so NGIL
society and used for initiation ceremonies and justice rituals and there was a strong symbolism
around protection and fighting manoeuvring forces within the mask so you've got that
you've got that link as well I also believe that the society was banned during the colonial period
so they've got this again a strong history on top of that you know you can have the appreciation of
the making of the mask of the mask itself the carving the skill of the worker how important
it was to the people when it was made and the you know the painting the clay used so
all this you know all this history rarity the symbolism the craftsmanship and you know the
symbolism I think I just said that but this all comes together to make extremely valuable item
for 4.2 million euros you might say that it could have gone for more a lot of buyers might
have been put off by the potential for there being a a court case which would go against them
however 4.2 million you know it's a lot of money so I guess that leads to it that you know that's
going to be not common we're not all going to find a mask like that and be able to sell it for that
sort of price but what do you value pieces for now the first thing here's a couple of tips that
I would advise the first thing and the key thing and it's the whole point of this video is to put
the work in to try and identify the piece the history of it where it came from and what the
purpose was now how I do that is I have reference books I use I use Google Image Reverse that is
absolutely fine to use but you just need to know how to use Google Image Reverse properly if I put
this figure up on Google Image Reverse I mean now it'd probably come up with my one because it's
the same one but the other results will not necessarily give me the right answer so much
African art is misattributed and not identified correctly that if I just went based on the first
results then I probably wouldn't get it right I try and use academic sources wherever possible
so whether that be museum examples or people who have written books or you know you do get
specialist dealers as well who are very knowledgeable about the pieces that's where I go to
first secondly then I will use the major auction houses such as Sotheby's Christie's Bonhams there's
a few more as well now these auction houses the attributing it correctly is paramount you know
it goes strongly against the reputation if they didn't do it properly they also have specialist
departments and academics who work for them to help you do this so generally they are a
once you have identified it and you think you've got that result to value it I just go by sold
results and have a look into that now I usually use eBay and I just go on the sold results on
eBay as I have a shop on eBay I have access to three years of sales results and I use that as
a way to bump up my value usually you know I usually go slightly below what the highest is
and over time I might drop my expectation from there depends on how it plays out now if you
wanted to sell you know if you think you've got a piece which is worth a lot of money and
you wanted to get the full value for that your best option is I think your best option is to
go to one of the major auction houses try and sell through there or find a specialist sale
for African art at an auction because a lot of buyers of this type of African art are usually
going to be they're going to spend their money they're going to do it somewhere like that I
believe rather than say eBay so there we go that's how I do it that's my advice when it
comes to valuing the piece and we will just conclude the video with this final message
okay that's the video today thank you so much for watching I hope it was to some degree
interesting and informative if there's anything that I said that was unclear or you disagree with
please leave a comment I'm more than happy to hear any feedback
and to action take action on the back of it look we've already done subscribing
liking if you like the content if you can do those things that'd be great if you didn't
just leave it so that's it today if you can you can also go to my website which is
tallysnantiques.com that's where I'm selling my items you can have a look there all the items
that I found recently the collection I was referring to all up for sale if you head over
there you'll find some more photos and just the description and all that type of stuff so
there we go that's it today thanks again and I will see you next time goodbye
