The Truth About Granaries

Prehistoric Architecture
281 followers
Hello everybody Ben Woodruff here and in today's video we are going to be talking about granaries
and what their significance is why and how they were used and the possible spiritual implications
as told by modern tribes. Might not seem like an exciting subject but it's actually very interesting
we want to have a good idea and as best understanding we can of kind of the history of
the ancient southwest and northwestern Mexico. Granaries are a big part of that something doesn't
get talked about very much. So first of all I gotta say with an online audience you have
a broad range of people and when I say granary people have gone online and said you're saying
it wrong it's granary and when I've said granary people in the comments have said you're saying it
wrong it's granary. Now all the archaeologists I have affiliated with have always said granary
and looking it up online it's claiming that that is the proper pronunciation. So if you say granary
it seems like it's doesn't really matter either way which way you know you prefer but if I say
granary I understand if you're saying it granary that that's going to be very grating to you.
I want to acknowledge it and I apologize ahead of time if that's the way you say it but we're
going to jump into this. To understand granaries and granaries first of all we have to jump back
and say all humans as a species everywhere in the world we are hunter-gatherers. The default setting
of the modern human homo sapien is a hunter-gatherer. We hunt animals we gather plants
that's just the default setting. We like protein we need some protein so we gotta do some hunting
and that was more viable especially during the ice age but plants also. Then humans become agrarian.
Agrarian agriculture that's where you switch and you start instead of hunting you start to ranch
and instead of gathering you start to farm. Ranching and farming have different problems
that come about so if you're a rancher so you're going to domesticate something or domesticate
sheep or you're going to domesticate camels or cattle you know from wild oryx well when you're
doing that now you have to stay with your herd and your herd has to always move because they
are going to overgraze an area so you have to be nomadic. You know maybe you were before but even
more so now you move where the herd moves and you have to guard them from other animals. You have a
source of food always there's always food right there year round doesn't matter summer winter boom
there's an animal that you can kill instead of having to hunt for it but you also are now going
to have to fight other people regionally for water rights and grazing rights and that's where you have
a lot of issues anciently that have spilled over today where different people this is our territory
this is our territory well it's not really about territory it was about grazing rights and water
rights and that's where you get the religious ideas of my deity figure promised this water
area for me no they promised it for me because people normally aren't violent but when you're
having to defend yourself how can you justify killing somebody else well if you're like well
my deity figure promised this water area for me so i'm right to defend it to the point of death
it's kind of weird so that's one of the problems that arises with agrarian culture with with
agrarian uh ranching cultures now agrarian uh farming cultures are different because now you
are investing heavily in a crop and you are domesticating this crop species and domesticating
it to be more productive so now you're tied to the land so the bad thing is somebody comes to
attack you you can't run and you're investing everything into these crop fields and these
crop fields they might you could have famine you could have you know a big old drought you could
have insects come and eat them and how do you battle bajillions of grasshoppers coming and
eating your crops you have other animals that want to come in and eat your crops they're like
oh hey this smorgasbord's left out for me so there's a lot of problems that come with being
agrarian in in the farming end of things the plus is that you can invest in a structure you're no
longer nomadic so you start to build houses that are more permanent in the case of southwest
we have adobe structures they got bigger and bigger and bigger more elaborate until you have
full-on cities like in chaco canyon new mexico just epic pueblos huge hundreds of people
thousands of people hundreds of rooms and and all over the world farming agriculture is what led to
cities the ability to store food for later uh plant food so in the case of the southwest northwest
the thing that did everything was corn corn is the most magical plant and if you're not aware corn
is grown more than any other crop on earth including rice they might say really because
i think that you know rice intake well yeah and here's the reason why because not only is it grown
for humans dent corn is also grown for animal feed from cattle to your dogs and cats look at
the ingredients of your dog and cat food it has corn in it and they also use it to make biofuels
and they also use it the byproducts of it for things like bad stuff like high fructose corn
syrup so it is a very versatile plant it's not a plant of america meaning north america it is not
now you might think what could be more american than like corn on the cob yeah we're gonna have
corn on the cob and you know boil it and have it for the fourth of july buttered up salt and pepper
and then of course uh in mexico the tradition all my mexican friends do the most amazing things
cooking corn by the fire they'll cook corn on the cob roast it next to the coals and they'll put all
these flavorings and all these cool sauces on it and it's to die for it's wonderful but corn comes
from mexico now we're getting to the granaries but you have to understand corn to understand
granaries so corn did not start off the way it looks today corn came from a plant called teosinte
now teosinte i grow it every year in my yard i've got some that i'm about to harvest right now
teosinte it smells the leaves look just like corn leaves it smells like corn but the individual ear
of teosinte it looks like a rattlesnake rattle it's just ding ding ding ding ding side by side
and the kernels rock hard they're never soft now you can pop it like popcorn i've done it
it's kind of crazy you can grind it up into a corn meal i guess it would be teosinte meal
you can make tortillas out of it no different than corn chemically it's basically the same
but genetically it's different because we selectively bred it we meaning humans we
selectively bred it over the years and it could if there's evidence that it seems
people in mexico central mexico started domesticating teosinte as far back as potentially
7 000 years it's pretty wild that it might be that far back that they were harvesting it and then
starting to work with it that's pretty crazy now we've selectively bred it into everything we have
you know of course your standard yellow corn but there's all different kinds of corn there's white
corn i raise almost exclusively the rainbow corn the gem corn love it it's incredible stuff
tastes really good too i'm actually going to do a video i've never done this but i'm going to
try grinding it up and making it into tortillas and see what that's like but uh the rainbow corn's
great blue corn has a great cultural significance there are tribes here in the southwest that even
to today blue corn is where it's at i love blue corn i grow it every year but i've never gotten
to grow well i can grow big old huge full ears and every time i do it it just kind of grows like
you know kind of like about the size of a twinkie but still really cool and this is made into if
you've ever had like blue tortilla chips that's from that blue corn uh you know making uh anything
out of it one of the things is piki bread there is a tribe that makes piki bread and piki is
it's very thin it's kind of like a crepe and piki is uh it's ceremonial it's a gift it's like you
make it up and you just have it and just giving some of that to somebody it can be stored yeah
cooked it can be stored that way and you can eat it later on and so it's it's kind of a great gift
a great offering to share with people piki is very special so all different types of corn red
corn blue corn rainbow corn there's all these different amazing breeds of corn today and we're
still making new breeds of corn but corn is great fresh we eat it raw we eat it cooked we
we can it you know you have to buy a can of corn fine but the real strength of corn is the fact
that it can be dried and stay for you know you know a decade you just dry it out so you can dry
it right on the stock that's what i usually do right now in september my ears of corn are drying
in my yard i'm just letting them die letting the corn die and then letting the let it just dry out
on the stock it dries out better than pulling it off and drying it inside you can also hang them up
you can do that as well and i've done that as well but they seem to dry better right on the stock
then you take them you know about october you take them and you store them now we have homes
that we try to keep insect and rodent proof today in the old days that was not the case you would
have things that could come in and eat your corn but that's not the biggest worry the biggest worry
is other people stealing your corn so what we see in the southwest we see granaries come about
they want to store your corn and you want to store it not i mean airtight would be great but you want
to store it insect proof and especially rodent proof because rodents getting in not only will
rodents get in if they get into a granary and they start eating the the corn they're also going to
rodents they mark everywhere they go it's saturated with their it's highly acidic and
that's going to ruin the corn as well so even if they're only eating a couple of years on top
they're going to destroy all of it it's going to get saturated with that and that's not good
so what we see in the southwest uh granaries typically would have um they'd usually have
an opening on top or in the front and they'd usually have one rock that was a slab to cover it
but it was also sealed up with adobe clay so whether your door is in front or on the top
you got to seal it up because you don't want little things to get in there now in the southwest
we kind of there's a couple of peoples that i usually am spotlighting one are in the kind of
the four corners region the southwest region and on into mexico we have you know the puebloan people
the ancestral puebloan people that is not a native term that is a catch-all that is a is like
hey if there's people who are building adobe structures that are from about like 300 bc to
you know about 1300 ad that time period and they're building adobe structures and they're
growing corn we kind of lump that in and say ancestral puebloan people now among those people
there's different tribes there's different cultural traditions and even within a tribe
there's different clans and different clan traditions i acknowledge that 100 but i'm just
saying for understanding the architecture style those people are the ancestral puebloan people
it's kind of a clunky catch-all phrase and to the north mostly in utah and barely into the
surrounding states you have my region which is the fremont people now the fremont people are living
now it's interesting to note that before before about 180 the fremonts well the freemonts were
always living in pithouses but before about 300 bc the ancestral poblans also lived in pithouses
pithouses a pretty simple structure it's half above ground half below ground and um you you
have a ladder you get down on the top it keeps you warm in the winter and cool in the summer
both peoples have these but around 300 bc the ancestral puebloans randomly suddenly switched
and started making adobe structures and started growing corn which they were getting from mexico
okay so they made the switch they were more able to rest and they invested heavily they were all
and they still hunted but they were and they raised turkeys too domesticated turkeys brought
up from mexico but they invested they're all in they were an agrarian culture they a lot of times
there was reverence given to water spirits and rain spirits because again we need the monsoon
rains to water our crops well so from mexico you have corn and agriculture coming up to the
ancestral puebloans and then from the ancestral puebloans up to the fremont up north now mexico
was a thousand percent in on corn they invented corn uh the ancestral puebloans were a hundred
percent maybe 99 on the corn so this is hunting but 99 in on the whole corn thing and the fremonts
were like between 20 to 60 in on the whole corn thing they were in a colder environment didn't
have as much sunlight in most of the regions and so they started to graze corn but they were still
hunting and gathering and they still needed to be somewhat mobile and making a pithouse take is a
lot of work but it takes less work than making adobe structure so you have again mexico thousand
percent in on agriculture and corn ancestral pueblo and 100 in 99 in 100 in and you know fremont
significantly less but still growing corn i want to talk about granaries for both of these people
um it's generally pretty solidly accepted that the granaries of of the ancestral puebloan peoples
pretty cut and dry they're small if you see picture i'm going to show you let me show you
some video clips here this is my favorite uh this is in central utah in the bears ears area
i don't think i'll name it but it's it's easy to find out if you want um and it's not hard to get
to it's it's nice to look i'm going to do a drone video of it here soon showing how close it is to
the pueblo that ran it but the interesting thing about this site these granaries they are about a
mile away from the pueblo that operated them why are they far away why are they down in the little
hidden canyon well the assumption and this is what the evidence sure looks like is that this is
strategic like we're keeping our our mass storage over here away from our main area now we know a
lot of people aren't aware of this there was times of violence in the southwest and there was times
of great stress there's like a 50 70 year drought and when when things get dire people get crazy
people do crazy things they wouldn't normally do when it's about survival it's about survival your
family uh and you have you you kind of default to a more negative setting so we know there was
violence we've seen it we've seen the evidence in the archaeological record we know that there
was violence and we know to the bigger level outside of chaco there was even slave trade and
cannibalism there was some dark stuff that happened but your corn if you are all in on agriculture
your corn you must save that and so keeping it away if somebody might come into your village
and thump you or or give us tribute if you can hide your corn elsewhere then that seems to be
that might not be the reason why it may have nothing to do with that but looking at the
evidence it sure seems to suggest that this was a strategic place that these were usually
out of the way in a separate side canyon from the canyon you were living in why not store it right
with you we don't know so that's the ancestral Puebloan people and again ancestral Puebloan
uh granaries are typically they're they're they're well built and they're typically uh the doors
typically on the front sometimes it's on top but usually it's on the front and again these were
sealed up and then you go in get a bunch of corn bring it out in the winter use it these are pretty
cool okay well now the Fremont people the Fremont people were growing corn but their corn was far
more rare because they were not all in on agriculture they were only partly in they had
one foot in the water and Fremont uh Fremont granaries are strange I'm gonna take a look at
some images of some of these and then I'm gonna do we're gonna take a drone and we're gonna fly up
to one here so if you're looking at this Fremont granaries they're always in the most ridiculously
inaccessible places and some of these are near impossible to see they're not big these are tiny
compared to ancestral Puebloan sites these granaries are in very hard to reach places
where you might even need a rope to get into most of the in fact by today's standards most of these
you're only getting into if you're if you have rappelling gear uh and getting down into these
they're they're everyone I've ever seen that the opening is on top and there'll be a big stone
and there'll be some clay as well some adobe clay and it's uh all of these are so odd they're so
strange and they're all roughly the same size much smaller than the Puebloan ones we're gonna get to
the potential of a spiritual point of these in a minute now let's take a let's take a drone shot
here we're gonna take a little drone video this is uh one I went recently went to and we're gonna
go up here and I could barely see it from the ground level but flying the drone up there it
looked like there was sort of this dome shaped thing and I thought that was it because I was
looking through my binoculars but looking through the drone lens it was kind of hard to see but then
I saw nope actually I gotta go down lower and when you look at this this is not very big you can see
off to the side you can see there is the door that was on top and you can also see
spackled up on the side is clumps of dry adobe clay so this is probably left here to go ahead
and you know recover it every time you'll bring some water up with you reconstitute the clay and
seal it up so the rodents don't get in there so you know panning out from this site it's
pretty incredible and you can see this is not an easily accessible site well the interesting
thing is when you talk about these granaries again the assumption is these are strategic
that it's like we want to make these inaccessible to people there are some modern tribes who have
said no no you're coming to the wrong conclusion archaeologists these were prayer offerings that's
why they were so high up in the cliffs they're being close to the deity spirits and we we're
making an offering up there now part of the argument for that is the fact that these granaries
are so small compared to ancestral Puebloan granaries these are quite small you know they're
usually only like about this you know like this wide and you know like this tall they're not very
big it's not gonna store much corn so it's like well we're just gonna put some of our best corn
up there for the gods for the spirits as an offering now maybe that's the case we don't know
because the problem is we don't know 100 who the ancestors of the Fremonts are we know their
descendants we don't know who their descendants are nor do the descendants themselves we've done
DNA tests on different tribes all over and what we see is because the Fremonts had such a broad
range that when there were the droughts and the kind of that culture collapsed a lot of them kind
of assimilated into nearby tribes so nearby tribes that are not at all closely related to the Fremonts
themselves now carry on that DNA totally unrelated tribes so who has the answer on that well nobody
has a Fremont way of life there are no uh modern tribes that live in a pithouse you know you have
tribes like the Dene the Navajo that will use uh structures like Hogan's and Kiva's uh you know
remember the Kiva's are half above or sorry the the pithouses were half above ground half below
when the ancestral Puebloans went from pithouses to Pueblos then the pithouse
became a Kiva and so the idea of an underground you coming from above the ladder structure
still remained and that usage evolved with time so the interesting thing is we are not sure we
know the granaries were vital to storing corn we a hundred percent know this with um with with
the ancestral Pueblos but with the Fremont I will give you a couple arguments on the argument the
side of these are prayer offerings well the argument is these are usually very high up
very inaccessible and uh they're very small they're not throwing much corn so maybe just
kind of like an offering just a little bit of our corn the argument against that is the fact
that for example this site in Nine Mile Canyon every village around has access to the view of
this site you can see it from miles away if somebody's climbing in to get to your corn
you would be able to see it also we know that the Fremonts did not grow much corn and so you would
expect that your granary would be smaller even if it was a functional granary not a prayer offering
so for my understanding the my my conclusion is the verdict's out I want to understand all
the perspectives that different people are bringing to the table they certainly look
very uh strategic to me they very much look like we don't want people to get to these
including the ancestral Puebloan people theirs you know they seems like hey we're trying to kind of
put it a canyon or two over from where we are living uh which is why would you do that it's
we're trying to keep it out of the way we want it to you know so that if somebody comes in and
is trying to rob us or something or thump us then you know we're we're keeping our corn safe so we'll
survive the winter uh it's interesting so granaries are everywhere everywhere in the southwest and a
lot of them are small and it's amazing to see them they're little they're they're pretty neat but
they're kind of magical because you think this helped people survive this is this was the most
precious thing to people you think about what do we care about now but we care about our technology
our stupid phones and our air conditioning our fancy cars and stuff and it's like for these people
surviving the winter was entirely based on the ability to have grown corn dried it out and been
able to store it and it's interesting too when I go to a lot of these sites a lot of the ears of corn
are quite small and some of them are big there were different strains of corn coming up but
the interesting thing is Mexico domesticated corn and got these big giant ears
once those made it up north the Puebloan people started to also change the direction and
selectively breed the corn to more drought resistant versions and a lot of these ancestral
Puebloans would do dry farming which is where you are planting the corn and they're just kind of
letting nature do its work you're like I planted you go ahead you're not watering it you're just
letting rain do its work and so a lot of those ears are small a lot of those ears of corn end
up only being about as big as my thumb but it was still usable so we see a lot when I go to
these ruins I see a wide range of sizes of corn it's pretty cool to see so I hope you enjoyed
kind of this little whirlwind video talking about granaries granaries granaries I hope you enjoyed
learning a little bit more about the history of corn if you haven't already if you can subscribe
to my channel I very much appreciate it helps me to keep this up and going let me know your
thoughts and your perspectives in the comments because I like seeing all the different perspectives
that everybody has I like I'm learning from so many of you and I hope you're learning from me
as well I just want this to be a place where people can come together and learn different
things but always remember that life is a gift so never stop learning and never stop exploring
we'll see you next time
