Australian housing crash 2025 explained_ Top Economist warns

Wealth Wizards
9 followers
#finance
#financement
In this hard-hitting breakdown, you’ll discover:
✅ Why first-home buyer grants and LMI waivers pump prices instead of helping buyers
✅ How mortgage debt growth (and its acceleration) drives house prices in multiple countries
✅ Why the US subprime story is only mid-pack globally — and why Australia, Canada, NZ, UK went further
✅ The landlord windfall effect: policies that look helpful individually but are disastrous collectively
✅ Ownership reality check: outright owners down, mortgages and renters up since the late 1980s
✅ How “credit-based demand” props up GDP while trapping households in decades of debt
✅ Why politicians keep doing it — and what a price-down policy agenda would require
Helping people buy their own homes should be a goal of any government.
Based entirely on profit rather than balanced with the needs of people.
14 times their annual disposable income,
making it the world's second most expensive city to buy property.
This is a con job.
The impact of these policies over time has been to do the exact
opposite of what the policies claim to do.
This will make it easier for Australians to get a foot onto the property ladder.
This is actually going to do the opposite.
Your wages haven't risen by a factor of five or six,
but the price of the houses you're trying to buy have risen that much.
The rules of the game have not been properly set
and they've been based entirely on profit rather than balanced with the needs of people.
The Australian government's just released a new housing policy
and like all the other housing policies it's released is they're encouraging
young people to take out larger mortgages and therefore drive up house prices.
But that's not exactly how it was sold by the Australian Prime Minister,
or should I call the Australian Prime Real Estate Salesman, Anthony Abilisi.
Let's have a listen to how he pitched this on Twitter.
Mortgage insurance.
You need it but it adds tens of thousands of dollars to your home loan.
From October we're making it easier to buy your first home with just a 5% deposit.
You don't have to pay a single dollar in mortgage insurance.
That's because we'll cover it.
Because we want you to buy your first home sooner.
This is a con job which encourages young people to borrow more money
than they'd otherwise do to hand it over to the vendor
and that helps drive up the house prices
and that benefits the wealth levels of older Australians like Balbenizi himself
who are landlords.
So this is something which benefits the landlords
while you pretend to help out the tenants convert from being tenants to house owners.
It is an insane policy but it's indicative of what's been done worldwide.
Governments across the planet have treated housing as an asset class
rather than as a vital consumer service
and they've caused asset price inflation to far exceed commodity price inflation
in all but a handful of countries.
The Bank of International Settlements maintains a database on house prices
and of the 14 countries that they've got data going back to the early 1970s
houses are far more expensive in real terms in all but three of them.
Let's have a look at that.
The rise has been incredible.
These are prices which have been deflated by consumer prices
so it's showing how much house prices have risen relative to consumer prices
and the most extreme which happens to be the United Kingdom at the moment
but it was New Zealand have risen by five or six times in real terms
and that of course relates to your wages as well.
Your wages haven't risen by a factor of five or six
but the price of the houses you're trying to buy with those wages have risen that much
and even though we've all focused upon America because of its subprime bubble
and the impact that had on the global economy with the global financial crisis
it's only in the middle of the pack.
It's number eight of the 14 countries in terms of the increase in prices
relative to the 1970s.
So this has been something which has been done across the planet.
So the mechanism behind this rise in house prices
is something that's too complicated for mainstream economists to understand
because they think in equilibrium terms.
They ignore the banking sector.
These rising house prices have been caused by rising levels of mortgage debt
and that again is a global phenomenon.
Now first place in this case belongs to Switzerland
which is a strange country because there's so many other elements of money being hidden.
They nonetheless take our first place.
Australia is number two in terms of how much household debt
is taken on by households to buy properties.
Number three Canada.
Again America even though it was the centre of the subprime bubble
and the global financial crisis
its level of mortgage debt peaked at less than 100% of GDP
whereas all these countries exceeded 100% of GDP.
Now this causes rising house prices
by a mechanism that simply escapes the ability of mainstream economists to understand
because first of all they insist on a mythical model of banking
in which banks don't actually lend money.
They imagine banks are intermediaries
who transfer spending power from one person to another
and therefore the change in debt should have no significant macroeconomic impact.
Now in the real world banks create money when they lend.
That money is used to buy goods and services and also assets.
So the rising level of household debt drives up the level of house prices
and share prices and so on.
And we can see that here by breaking down
both the house price index and the level of household debt.
So if you look at the two together
and I'm doing this for America here
there's been generally speaking rising house prices
and rising mortgage debt at the same time
but there are cases where there's been rising house prices
and falling household debt.
So if just look at that level you can't really see what's going on.
The demand for housing fundamentally is new mortgage debt.
That's the change in the level of mortgage debt.
If you divide that by the price level
you get a rough indication of how many average houses can be bought per year
with that amount of monetary demand.
That gives you a relationship between the change in the level of mortgage debt
and the level of house prices.
When you put this through a statistical analysis
there's no point doing a correlation of these two
because they're both rising.
When you look at the change in house prices
versus the change in mortgage debt
you get a reasonable correlation
but the main one comes when you look in the change in house prices
and the change in the change in the level of mortgage debt.
That's what I identify as the cause of housing prices rising
and the correlation coefficient is crazy high
for something which if you've done first and second differencing
to data which is only collected on a quarterly basis.
Now that's the American situation.
Nobody denies America had a housing bubble.
It's burst and it's now rising once more
but the burst is definitely there.
Australians will claim they haven't had a housing bubble
because their house prices are still rising.
But you do the same analysis with the Australian data
and you find the same pattern.
Almost always rising house prices and rising mortgage debt.
A reasonable relationship between change in house prices
change in the level of mortgage debt
but the causal one which is the change in the change in mortgage debt
and the change in house prices
that's got an even higher correlation than the American data.
And now let's take a look at how Australia
has managed to keep these prices rising.
So the very first one was under the Labor government
back in 1983 over 40 years ago
and this is Labor supposedly the progressive party in Australia
and you had another policy by them.
They were going to abolish what's called negative gearing
but they reintroduced it in 1987
and negative gearing is a peculiar Australian policy
where a landlord is allowed to write off the expenses
of maintaining a property including interest payments on it
against not just the income from the property itself
but their entire income.
House prices might fall
not if the Australian government's got anything to do with it.
Look at all these policies.
In January 1988 shortly after the stock market crash of 87
they brought in the second version.
They call it the first homeowner scheme.
I call it the first home vendor scheme.
In July of 2000 which is the time of the stock market crash
in America a 14% fall in the market then
which people were afraid was going to lead to a collapse.
In fact the bubble continued on until 2007.
They brought it back again.
This is now the so-called Liberal government.
Liberal in Australian means conservative just to confuse things.
You have three so-called progressive changes here
then two liberal then a progressive then two conservative.
This is a bipartisan policy to push house prices up.
October 2008 is particularly significant for me
because I was warning about the global financial crisis
and because it was being driven by rising levels of mortgage debt.
I inevitably got asked about house prices.
And by the way if you want to use my proprietary software Ravel
for economic analysis too
you get it as a free bonus inside my seven week
Rebel Economist challenge
like over 600 people have already done.
To learn more apply at stevekeene.com.
So all these schemes are designed to pump up prices
and you can see their impact when you look at the timing of these policies
against what happened to the rate of change of house prices in Australia.
All these policies have done is encourage people to borrow money
and buy a house with that borrowed money.
Look what they did to the level of household credit.
Household credit was falling before the first time
that Hawke brought in this policy.
Bang!
Household credit increases.
The second change.
Bang!
Up goes the level of the increase in household debt.
You then have some low years
and then the rise into the end of the end of the telecommunications bubble of the 1990s.
And then when there's a fear of a serious downturn
the conservative government so-called the Howard government
brings in and does it twice in a very short period of time
and then makes the change permanent
boosting the money they give to the first time buyers to buy a home
encouraging them to take on mortgages.
The increase in household debt that year was more than 14% of GDP.
Now that increase of borrowing by the private sector
has the same stimulating impact upon the economy
as a government deficit of 14% of GDP.
So it looks like the economy is doing really well
and the politicians take the credit
but it's all because they're encouraging the household sector
into higher and higher levels of debt.
Now the one that most matters to me is this one here
which is done by Kevin Rudd
because I was warning of the global financial crisis
for one and a half years before it happened.
I'm recognised as one of the dozen or so economists
who actually predicted the global financial crisis.
But in Australia because so much of this was driven by rising house prices
that's what I got asked on the 7.30 report
and this is in October of 2008.
Associate Professor Stephen Keane has come increasingly to prominence
over the past couple of years specialising in the economics
of Australia's spiralling household debt burden.
Initially he was almost a lone voice
with his pessimistic view of how dramatically
that burden could impact on us all.
He's not alone now
and he believes Australia faces its own savage correction
including an inevitable housing slump.
I spoke with Professor Keane earlier tonight.
Now the comments that I made in that speech
were then used by the presenter Kerry O'Brien
to savage the Prime Minister the very next day
about what I was saying was going to happen
as a result of increasing house prices
and increasing levels of mortgage debt.
So economist Stephen Keane pointed out in this program last night
that America's private debt levels are way beyond
what they were going into and during the 29 Great Depression
and so are Australia's.
That must worry you.
And the Prime Minister rattled said
well we continue to provide a strong budget surplus
which is actually partly causing this problem here
and knocking the public debt again as usual
politicians focus upon public debt rather than private debt
which is a real worry.
But then O'Brien comes back and says
do you agree with my assessment?
I've been warning about it for quite some time.
Well what happened?
Six days later the Rudd government doubled and trebled
the amount of money they gave to the farmers
buying an existing home or buying a new home
and to even top that out
the Victorian state government gave another $14,000
on top of the $21,000 you could get from the federal government
to encourage people to buy new houses on the periphery of Melbourne.
When the Australian economy's recovery began
the major growth in employment in Australia at the time
was real estate agents in Victoria.
Whenever there's a danger of a falling level of house prices
the Australian government pumps it up again
with a scheme of this nature.
And you can see the impact of Rudd's change
on this comparison of Australia versus America
because before the crisis broke
the rate of change of Australian private debt
was far higher than America.
The change in private debt in America was peaked at about 15% of GDP.
Australia was 23% so I had every reason to expect Australia
to have a bigger crisis than America had.
You had the declining levels of house prices in Australia
and a declining level of credit up the top here
but it stopped because of the first home vendors boost.
People went back into buying housing
that stimulated credit-based demand
and credit in Australia which is the black line here
never went below zero.
Whereas for America it went from plus 15% of GDP to minus 5%.
So a 20% change in the level of credit-based demand
in the American economy.
Australia had much the same scale but it didn't go negative
and that's the reason that Australia avoided the recession
during the global financial crisis.
But the price that Australians paid
and this is price paid by young Australians
rather than with rich old Australians
was higher house prices making it even harder
for them to get into the housing market.
The impact of these policies over time
has been to do the exact opposite
of what the policies claim to do
and that's reduced the level of home ownership,
increased the level of people who have a mortgage
against the home and increased the percentage
that are renting housing rather than owning it outright.
So this is a policy which looks good to the individual
which is disastrous collectively
and makes the world a harder place in which to survive.
If you go back to the stage
when only a few of these policies have been introduced,
this is data from 1988,
unfortunately there isn't data from earlier,
almost 44% of Australians owned their own home outright
and less than 30% had a mortgage
and less than 20% were renting.
If you fast forward to the last to date
the data was collected which is 2018,
the number of Australians who owned their own homes outright
had fallen from 43% to 31%.
Those who had a mortgage went from under 30%
to about 38%, the renters were about 17% of the population,
now they're about 27%, it'd be worse now.
All these policies have had the exact opposite effect
to the one that the politicians pushing them
have claimed they would have.
This is a case where the government has been using
its power to create money not to build infrastructure,
not to build schools, not to have welfare
but to drive up house prices
which makes one generation very well off
at the expense of other generations
as this is a disastrous policy and I am frankly disgusted
that the Albanese government is going and doing
exactly the same thing as all the predecessors have done.
This is a policy which is designed to inflate
the asset prices to the benefit of old people,
the expense of young people
and it gives an illusion of economic progress
when it's actually locking the countries that do this
into a form of penury
because once you're paying the level of prices
that come out of these policies,
you own the house,
you spend all your money servicing the debt,
you're giving your money to the banking sector,
you can't afford to go shopping,
you can't afford to invest
and you get stagnant economies coming out of it.
There's no way that politicians are going to stop doing this
until we have political parties that represent the majority
by being people who are renting rather than owning properties.
So it's in your own self-interest
and it's in the interest of the economy and society in general
to vote for political parties
that intend to bring house prices down
rather than popping them up.
And if this video gets lots of interest,
I'll explain how it would work in a subsequent video.
So like, subscribe and share
because it's time it stopped.
Good luck.
