Exoplanets and Cosmology - Nobel Prize in Physics 2019

Scientists won the Nobel Prize
12 followers
2 Video Views·Oct 2, 2025
It's that time of the year again. It's the Nobel Prizes.
Always charge my phone up. You never know, do you?
Again, overlooked.
Yeah, just need to check the number.
I called it. Yes, I'm feeling a bit smug about this because
about five minutes before the announcement, I suddenly had this feeling who was going to win.
And sure enough, they did. Or at least they won half the prize anyway.
And the other half of the prize went to a guy called Jim Peebles.
A good call to see Jim Peebles get half the Nobel Prize.
He's regarded, I think, as the father of modern cosmology.
Did you put a bet on or anything?
I should have done, shouldn't I? Really? Yeah.
But no, I didn't. And it was literally five minutes before the announcement.
It wasn't that clever a prediction because I certainly wasn't the only person predicting it.
And they've been sort of one of the runners and riders for a number of years now.
But I sort of thought it was their time.
It's a slightly strange award.
And actually, so the citation reads,
was awarded for contributions to our understanding of the evolution
of the universe and Earth's place in the cosmos, which could be pretty much for anything,
really, because that covers pretty much everything there is.
But Jim Peebles is a cosmologist and is really one of the towering,
founding figures of modern cosmology in that he did a lot of the work.
He was part of the group that was predicting the existence of the cosmic microwave background.
He did a lot of work about the growth of structure in the universe,
the impact of dark matter on how structure would grow.
So really, I mean, he is, if you teach a course on cosmology,
in large part, you're talking about his work.
The model which is fitting the data so well has his influence on every single part of it.
He is a theorist, but he's one of those theorists who actually maintains a very
close link to the observation. So some of his work has actually,
he's written papers which are presenting observational data,
but more in a fairly theoretical framework. So you would think of him as a theoretical astrophysicist.
He's just demonstrated that in modern cosmology,
these are the key ingredients we look like we need.
And he was there at the start of each one of them playing a role.
So he can be, I think, properly regarded as the father of the subject and the expert.
It says it there on your board, father of modern cosmology.
Yeah, that's what I decided to call it. I did a tutorial today.
We have a tutorial system here at Nottingham where all the first years get to have a
there's usually six in the group. I screwed up, I had to do 12.
And so I thought, well, you've got to tell them about the Nobel Prize,
at least the bit I know about it.
If you were talking about Jim Peebles, you wouldn't say, oh, he did so-and-so,
because there's just so much he's contributed.
So the other half of the prize was shared between Michel Mayor and Didier Caylo,
and they worked on studying exoplanets. They still work on studying exoplanets,
the planets outside the solar system. And it was awarded for,
let me get the exact wording here, for the discovery of an exoplanet orbiting a solar-type star.
So it was really their discovery in 1995 was what kicked off the entire field of exoplanet studies.
Because exoplanets these days are like candy, aren't they?
There are many, many thousands of them. At that point, there was only one.
Actually, that's not quite true, because there were other planets.
And it's interesting the way they worded the citation.
It says an exoplanet orbiting a solar-type star.
The first exoplanet was actually found orbiting a pulsar, a neutron star, a rotating neutron star,
which is a very weird system. And no one really expected to find planets around pulsars.
And so it was clearly something very strange. And so although it was interesting,
it was like everyone was, well, it's nothing like the solar system,
so it's not really a planet in the sense that we would understand it.
There were also tentative discoveries of planets orbiting giant stars that preceded
the Maio and Kelo discovery. But this was really the first announcement of one which we would sort
of equate with something like the solar system. So it was a solar-type star, very like the sun,
with a planet in orbit around it.
Do you happen to know what star it was? It was obviously a nearby star.
It was. It's 51 Pegasus is the star, and the planet's called 51 Pegasus b.
It's about 50 light years away. It's a very ordinary star. As I say, it's a G-type star,
so very like the sun. A little bit more massive, I think 1.1 times the mass of the sun,
so a tiny bit more massive, but really almost a twin of the sun. Very bog-standard kind of star.
What method did they use to discover it?
So they used this radial velocity method. I mean, there are now a whole slew of methods
that are used for discovering and studying exoplanets. But one of the foundational
techniques and the one that made this first discovery was this radial velocity technique,
where if you've got a star and you think of a planet in orbit around it, the sort of simple
picture is the star is stationary in the middle and the planet's orbiting around. But of course,
they're actually tugging each other and sort of orbiting around their mutual centre of gravity.
What that means is that the planet is tugging the star backwards and forwards as well as the
star tugging the planet backwards and forwards. So the star is actually oscillating.
And so sometimes it's moving towards you and sometimes it's moving away from you.
And by studying the spectra of the star and looking at those little dips where there are
spectral lines in the star, you can see whether they're being shifted, doppler shifted towards
the red end of the spectrum or the blue end of the spectrum. So you measure that backwards
and forwards wobble of the star. And that gives you a measure of the mass of the thing that's
orbiting around it, as well as how rapidly it's orbiting around it by how quickly the
thing oscillates backwards and forwards. That's a good method. I imagine that method
had been thought of for quite a while and all the astronomers in the world have access to
telescopes and telescope time. What did these scientists do that made them able to be first?
What method or trick or idea did they have that made them the winners?
So there's a couple of aspects here. Firstly, people weren't really looking that hard at the
time, because there was no expectation that you'd actually be able to detect much.
Because we had this, and so if you think about what's easy, what's easy to detect in this case,
you want something where there's a strong gravitational pull between your planet and
the star to tug it a long way. So it's got to be a big planet.
So there's two things. You want it to be a big planet, so it's massive, so it will tug
the thing backwards and forwards. And actually you want them close together, so the pull of
And so what you'd really want is a planet like Jupiter close to the star.
Now at the time, we only knew about one solar system, and Jupiter in our solar system is a
long way out, as is the way with scientists. If you've only got one example of something,
you convince yourself that that's the way the universe works.
So we had all these ideas at the time, back in the 1990s and before,
that actually Jupiter-like planets only existed in the outer reaches of solar systems and things
close to their stars were all little things like Mercury and Earth, which you wouldn't be able to
detect. And so because of that, there wasn't really a huge expectation that we'd be able
to detect this kind of effect. And what these guys actually found was something that's about
half the mass of Jupiter, very close to a star. And so actually, and subsequently, of course,
we found many of these hot Jupiter-like planets, so Jupiter-like planets which are close to the
star. And so it turns out that actually the universe doesn't work the way we thought it
did back then. And there are mechanisms where even if a big planet forms a long way out in
a solar system, there are mechanisms by which it can kind of migrate inwards towards its star.
So they found something that no one was really that much expecting to find,
which is why there wasn't a huge rush to try and find these things. The other thing is they had
some very clever instrumentation. They actually built a custom-built spectrograph that allowed
them to measure very small Doppler shifts. They were down at sort of tens of metres per second
that they were measuring these wobbles in these stars, which did require very good instrumentation,
very stable instrumentation, where you can actually calibrate things with that kind of
accuracy to really measure those very small shifts. So you couldn't have just had like an
off-the-shelf night of VLT and have found that sort of thing, right? You probably could now with VLT,
but in the 1990s, no. You really wanted a custom-built instrument. It wasn't on that
large a telescope. I think it was a two-metre telescope. So even by then, those standards,
the standards of the 1990s, it wasn't a particularly huge telescope. But it was just a very clever
spectrograph, and they were looking for something that no one else was really looking for.
As an astronomer, and you were an astronomer in the 90s.
I was, yes.
Do you kick yourself and think, oh, I could have done that. That would have been like a week's
work, and I could have been the one to find it. So the interesting thing is, before their paper
in the 1990s, in the 1980s, let me show you another. So let me show you their paper. So
a Jupiter-mass companion to a solar-type star.
Nobel Prize right there.
And it's, you know, it's actually not a particularly long paper. It's not got many
pretty pictures in it. A few graphs.
Not even a picture of the star?
Not even a picture, no. Nothing spectacular about it at all. I mean, you know, nice-looking data.
So here's the wobble backwards and forwards of the star. So sometimes it's going away from us,
sometimes it's coming towards us. And you can see, so here's the scale, 50 metres per second.
So they're small shifts that you're actually measuring here. So that's the wobble that they
were measuring. So here's the interesting thing. That was the 1990s. In 1989, this paper came out.
The Unseen Companion of Telephone Number, A Probable Brown Dwarf. And it turns out they
had actually also discovered a Jupiter-like planet.
He's on there as well, there though.
He's actually, my author is on there as well. So he's one of the authors. But the primary
mover of this, a guy called Dave Latham, was actually in an office just over the corridor
for me at the time, because I was a PhD student and he was a proper serious scientist at that
point at the CFA in Boston. He wasn't very excited about this result. I mean, he was a
bit excited, but he was actually, you know, because, and again, it comes back to the fact
that no one was expecting to find planets. And the reason why, he didn't know that he'd found
a planet. So brown dwarfs are sort of one-up from planets. They're sort of failed stars.
And no one was, you know, people were expecting to find brown dwarfs because we find binary stars
quite a lot of the time. And they have different mass ratios. And it wouldn't be terribly surprising
if once in a while the littler one turned out to be not quite making it as a star.
So people were not that surprised to be finding stars with brown dwarfs in orbit around them,
because they're basically just very closely related to binary stars that we know exist.
Like a failed binary.
It's a, one half of it's kind of failed to ignite. So one half is a star. The other half
didn't quite make it. Because they weren't expecting to find planets, he convinced himself
he hadn't found a planet. And the reason why there's an ambiguity, because you might think,
well, you know, we know what masses brown dwarfs are, we know what masses planets are,
turns out there's an ambiguity in this method. And the ambiguity in this method is, I kind of
drew this, you know, when I was waving my hands around, I did it like that. But we don't know
whether the system's like that, or whether it's sort of, I can't do it that way, that way, like
that. And of course, if the planet's orbiting that way, you don't see that the star is still moving,
but it's being tugged in the plane of the sky. So you don't see these Doppler shifts.
So this is ambiguity, and of course, you can have anything in between. So actually, if you see a
certain movement, it could be a relatively low mass thing that's in the plane of the sky. So
we're seeing all the movement of the star. Or it could be it's almost in the plane, a much more
massive thing. And actually, this thing's jerking around all over the place, but we don't see most
of the motion, because most of it's in the plane of the sky, rather than towards us or away from
us. You've got to get lucky, it's kind of, you need it to be punching you in the face rather than
wobbling around. To get the biggest signal, you really want to be lucky and just catch the thing
edge on so you see the biggest signal. Because of this ambiguity, you can't tell really directly
from the observation, whether you're seeing a brown dwarf kind of in the plane of the sky,
close to the plane of the sky or a planet close to edge on. And because they had this expectation
that they shouldn't be finding these planets, they convinced themselves that they were seeing
a brown dwarf star binary fairly close on. And it was a bit unlikely, because actually,
it has to be surprisingly close to face on for it to work. But they sort of convinced themselves,
they do actually say somewhere in the paper, or it could be a large planet. So they do actually
at least make, you know, say we might have found a planet. The extra thing that Mayor and Calo did,
is they also looked at the properties of the star. So they actually could measure how fast the star
is rotating, because you can see one half of it, if the star's rotating, one half of it's coming
towards you, the other half's going away from you. And so you can actually see, what you end up
seeing is a kind of a broadening of the lines. So instead of seeing the line wobbling, you see
part of the line being shifted one way, part of it the other way, the net effect of that is you see
a slightly broader line. So they could measure the rotation of the star, kind of the, at least,
but again, it's the same thing, right? Is it a star that's rotating in the plane of the sky,
or is it rotating edge on? But they knew some of the properties of the star, you could just
make observations of it, find out what kind of star it is. And we know how fast stars typically
actually rotate that are of that type. So they have this measurement of this kind of one component
of how fast the things are rotating. And it could be either a very fast rotating star that's
sort of pole on, or it could be a relatively slowly rotating star that's edge on. But we know
intrinsically how fast stars like this actually rotate. From that, you can figure out that
actually this system is relatively close to edge on. So there's one more leap here, which is that
as long as the star's axis of rotation is the same as the planet's axis of rotation, which, for
example, it is pretty much in the solar system, the sun's rotating about kind of the same axis that
the solar system is, then that actually tells you that the system has to be relatively close to edge
on. And once you've got that, then you know you found a planet. So that was the sort of the extra
bit, I guess, that is what really got them the Nobel Prize. Plus, actually, just the confidence
to say we found something that no one expected to find. So in the future, if one day we go and visit
other systems and other planets, and we can somehow do this, this particular Nobel Prize
one would be a good one to visit, wouldn't it? It'd be like a historic one, it'd be like visiting
for humanity. This was a historic site for us. It probably, I mean, it's not the easiest one to
get to because it is 50 light years away, and we now know about planets, you know, that are
only a few light years away. So it's probably not the first one that would ever get visited. But yeah,
when it becomes routine, it will become one of the stops on the tourist trail, I suspect.
Of course, there could be other planets in the system, right? We've just seen this one fairly massive
Jupiter-like planet very close to the star, which really wouldn't be very hospitable because it's
going to be a gas giant, and it's going to be very hot and very unpleasant. But who knows, there could
be other planets further out in the solar system.
Father of modern cosmology, does that mean there's an older cosmology? Like where does it, where did,
where did old cosmology transition to modern cosmology?
I'm giving the transition time around the 1960s, which, by the way, is another important time for the,
that's the epoch of Higgs and Kibble and Brout and Englert and people. The discovery of the
cosmic microwave background radiation, I think that kind of transformed the field from being
one that was full of speculation and promise in solving Einstein's equations without really
knowing what the background material was in the universe, to first, the first time we established
that this radiation, this remnant of the hot Big Bang that emerged when the first atoms were formed,
say, 400,000 years after the Big Bang, and then just propagated outwards for the next 3.8 billion
years, that the detection of that in the 1960s, 1965, in fact, it was announced by Penzias and
Wilson, that, where they associated a temperature to this radiation, that I think is what you might,
I'm calling here that it's kind of the start of modern cosmology. And Peebles was there. In fact,
it's not very well known, but the paper by Penzias and Wilson, which is one page long,
there we are, busting our gut writing all these long papers, one page paper, about the third or
fourth line, having announced that they discovered this radiation, that they don't really know what
it is, they say that in the preceding paper in the journal, which is Jim Peebles' paper with Dickay
and Wilkinson, they say they've come up with an explanation for what this could be. And it is,
in fact, the microwave background radiation at a temperature of around, at the time, they say 3.5
Kelvin. Sort of, it's now seen as about 2.7 Kelvin, but that's okay. It was 3.5 plus or minus
0.1, so they were perfectly okay. But Peebles was there. And in fact, not only was he there,
he's the one that actually, in the previous paper, the one that literally appears before it, which
is a mind-blowing four pages long. That's a huge paper by comparison. He's the one, along with his
co-authors, who suggest that actually this remnant radiation is linked to the hot Big Bang, and that
it's got these thermal properties. It's that, I think, which is really key that you can pin down
as being one of Peebles' main contributions here, that he recognises A, the significance of the
radiation as being linked to the early universe. And the second thing that he does, which I hadn't
seen done before, he points out that because we now know the temperature of that radiation,
and because we believe in the idea of general relativity, and we can understand how that
radiation changes its temperature as the universe changes scale, because it gets redshifted, it
cools down as the universe expands, it means it's hotter earlier on. And so he's able to link
the temperature you've got today to an estimate of what the amount of matter must be in the universe
today, because he knows what it must be around the time of nuclear synthesis. He's got a bound
he can use. And by doing that, he actually, in this paper, without, I don't think necessarily
really realising that they're saying there must be some sort of dark matter, he actually points out
that the estimate for the amount of baryons, matter in the universe in terms of baryons,
is actually lower than the critical matter amount that you need, that we see today. We believe the
universe today is spatially flat. That means there's a critical amount of matter in there.
And he said in his calculations, there's not enough. And in fact, the end of his first paper,
the one that appears with Penzias and Wilson, comes up with ways of trying to
increase the amount. But he was there, he was pointing out this connection between
measurement of the radiation and the density of matter in the universe. And that's absolutely
integral to the rest of cosmology. The man in the street probably hasn't heard of the lambda CDM
model. But I think if you said the standard model of cosmology, that's what you would say
Peebles was responsible for. The standard model of cosmology has various contributions to the
overall energy budget. So before Peebles was around, we knew that there were baryons.
But we didn't necessarily know how many. And Peebles began to put a bound on that from this
paper. But then he made some even bigger contributions in some sense. The next thing
he sort of realized was that, again, using the fact that you've got this cosmic microwave
background that had been detected by Penzias and Wilson, he was aware of the fact that
there's fluctuations to be expected in this cosmic microwave background. And he's the one,
along with you, who actually was the first to fully do sort of numerical simulations
of different types of cosmology and predict what the acoustic oscillations were that we
see in the microwave background. Remember those peak structures that are big peaks and then they
go down in the CMB? He was the first to numerically show what different cosmologies would predict.
And so in amongst it, he showed what a flat universe would do. And that's the one that
pretty much is observed by, first of all, by WMAP and then by Planck. The initial anisotropies
were demonstrated by Coby. But the original work solving the numerical codes to show roughly what
they would look like is from Peebles. What made him good? Why is he good at this?
What is it about him that all the other cosmologists haven't got?
I don't think anybody has his overview. A, he's very, very strong mathematically.
He's developed the statistics that's used in much of the analysis of the CMB and of large-scale
structure. When you're looking at correlations of different regions of the sky, he developed
the techniques you need. More than that, and his ability to solve equations and do integrals and
he had this, he has, he's still there, he's 85, but he's still very active and really on the ball.
He has this overview. He can see the bigger picture. He can see how a given calculation,
a given observation tells you something about something else in the universe by extracting out
from that small initial observation its impact on the whole of the background evolution.
To do that is not easy because there's so many balls in the air and he's able to juggle them
all in the air. I think that in many ways is his big skill. Have you ever met him?
Oh yeah, I've met him many times at conferences. He's such a nice guy. He's one of these people
that is always prepared to give you his time. If you're walking for dinner or having lunch,
he asks really pertinent questions. I've always found him to be somebody that is easy to get on
with, that when he asks questions, he's very polite, but he's not afraid to tell you if he
thinks you're wrong, which he's done to me a couple of times. Professor, I know in cosmology,
there are different camps and schools of thought, people who like string theory and
A, B and C and all that. Is peoples on your side or on the opposite side?
Peoples sits sort of above it all. I don't think he's worried about the camps, to be honest. He
goes where the science tells him. I'm really excited about Neil because it's for lithium
batteries and so he's gone on a battery safari. Some of you know that Neil is a motorcyclist.
He has an electric motorcycle.
