How Bad is the Index Fund Bubble in 2025?

Global Finance News
11 followers
#finance
#financement
★ ★ CONTENTS ★ ★
0:00 The Passive Investing Trap
8:00 Catalysts for a Market Crash
10:40 Building Conviction and Buying Lululemon
24:15 How Phil Uses 13F filings
27:50 The US Debt Situation
34:10 How Phil View the Tariffs
39:20 Finding Buying Opportunities in Expensive Markets
44:30 Phil's Regrets
47:30 Phil's Legacy
Do you feel like this flood of passive investing over the last 10 years is a problem?
It could potentially be a disaster.
Phil Town is with us, investing guru and author of Rule Number One.
People could experience their retirement account completely come undone.
All they're doing is following an index that they're attached to.
When that comes down, it could be like dropping into the elevator shaft.
Rule Number One comes from Warren Buffett, who said there's two rules of investing.
First rule, don't lose money.
And the second rule is don't forget the first rule.
We certainly saw it in the real estate market right back in the early 2000s.
And I think we're seeing the same thing now.
I think we're going to pay the price for it.
Hey guys, and welcome back.
I have been away for a little while.
I've been over in the States hosting, doing a whole bunch of things,
but notably hosting an investing workshop with Phil Town himself.
It was an amazing event.
It went really, really well.
We had like 300 people in the house over three days.
But for those that weren't able to attend,
I got the chance to sit down with Phil and ask him some of your pressing questions.
So without further ado, this is the interview I got to do with the one,
the only Mr. Phil Town.
I hope you enjoy.
So Phil, we're recording this just after the Rule One live workshop,
which I think went pretty well.
Oh, I loved it.
Yeah, it was good fun.
So much fun to do this live.
We do it like once or twice a year.
Yeah.
Oh man, having everybody in the room compared to virtually, you know.
It's a lot better.
Good for connection.
And it was so great to see all the new money people come out.
It was fun.
It was a really good time.
But this interview, I guess, is for all the people that weren't able to come,
they've sent in some questions.
So the first question I have for you,
so we're currently sitting at a time where Shilla P is at 40.
And we've also seen over time, just this incredible amount of passive inflow of cash
into the market, into these big companies.
Do you feel like this flood of passive investing over the last 10 years is a problem?
And does it lead to anything potentially serious?
Yeah, I think it could potentially be a disaster
when you have a huge part of the market that's not discovering price at all.
Meaning that the people who are managing that money
are not looking at the value of the business against the price
and making a decision that it's on sale or not on sale.
It's too high price, so we should sell.
It's really a cheap product, so we should buy it.
There's nobody making that decision.
All they're doing is following an index that they're attached to,
meaning that as that index goes up, they're buying those same stocks,
which contributes to them going up, which contributes to them buying.
And you get into this loop.
And that loop, it's a positive loop as long as it's going up
if you don't consider price and value to ever be different.
But if they are different and they get really dislocated,
when they come down, it's almost like you're going to experience
the market going up like walking up the stairs.
But when that comes down, it could be like dropping into the elevator shaft.
It could be this aggressive cycle of selling,
which requires more selling to stay with the index as it's going down.
And so the real risk here is that people who have never seen the market
really do a major long-term change, right?
They've been investing since, let's say, 2009.
You know, we're talking 16 years or something like that,
where there's not been a major market change.
We had something during COVID, but it was over so fast that people were like,
oh yeah, it's just another blip.
People could experience their retirement account completely come undone.
I mean, in terms of 50% drop in it, that stays down there for quite some time
if indeed the price and value relationship has become really distorted
by more money flowing in the market.
And man, Brandon, I'll tell you, we certainly saw it in the real estate market,
right back in the early 2000s with a lot of very cheap money available for mortgages
and unlimited government support of those mortgages
resulting in a real major dislocation in the prices of things.
And I think we're seeing the same thing now.
And I think we're going to pay the price for it.
People who are investing, not to go on and on here,
but you and I know Lee Liu is a phenomenal investor.
And he did a nice analysis.
It used to be on his website.
It might still be there,
where he looked at the market returns over the long term.
And you could point, as many people do who are interested in passive investing
and want to support passive investing,
they'll point to the market in the long term and they say,
you get into the market and you stay for the long term,
you're going to really do well.
And you point to any other investment, including real estate.
And over the long term, there's nothing remotely close to what the market does
because the money is going into companies that can manage to grow it internally,
unlike gold or Bitcoin or housing.
You're not growing the money internally inside that investment.
It's just what it is.
And then it appreciates.
Well, in a company, they're growing that money at 15, 20% a year
inside there without you doing anything.
So there's this huge advantage investing in stocks
that has lasted for a long, long, long time, 140 years, 150 years.
Except what Lee Liu points to is that there are chunks of time in there
where this idea of passive investing, which looks so good in the long run,
has a run that's 20 years long where the return is zero.
And this is what people don't realize.
That has happened over and over and over again,
where the market peaks after a massive dislocation between price and value.
You've got prices up here and values haven't kept up.
It dislocates sort of emotionally far below that intrinsic value
and then slowly rises as people lose their fear of the market.
And that can easily take 20 years.
And I think right now is a very major potential turning point in this
because baby boomers, my generation,
have been responsible for a lot of what the market growth has come from,
which is baby boomers, 75 million of us in America,
pouring money into the market for our retirement,
the development of 401k plans, which has happened in my generation.
All of that has stimulated money that had never been in the stock market before.
And now it's just de rigueur.
You have to do it.
Money goes in the market and that money just keeps pushing the market up.
Well, what happens when those people retire, right?
I mean, how long are they going to be willing to stay in a market if it stops going up
and they're in retirement?
And the answer is not very long.
And when that happens, which is almost inevitable,
that money is going to start flowing out into bonds, into annuities.
And you're going to see the market re-sink itself back to more normal
numbers.
Because I feel like they're the people that want,
they're most inclined to jump out to protect themselves, right?
If they're close to retirement.
So it won't take much of a stimulus for them to be like,
whoop, my retirement's on the line.
Right, exactly.
I mean, these people have been through the big drop in 2007 and 2008, baby boomers.
And they're a bit holding their breath right now.
It's like, okay, how much longer can I ride this thing?
Like, I don't want to get out before,
if it's going to go up at 14% a year,
I'm staying with it.
But as you say, it's being driven up by a very small number of stocks.
And the whole rest of the market is growing at much, much lower rates.
And eventually those things will outprice their value
enough to where they'll stop growing at that rate.
And then you're going to see baby boomers get very nervous.
And I guess for this to all, or for any market to come crashing down,
usually it takes some sort of catalyst.
So what do you see anything,
what do you think are the potential triggers for this sort of market correction?
Right. I mean, we talk about that.
I like Nicholas Taleb's term, you know, the black swan.
Taleb's really, really added a lot to the whole lexicon of investing
when he brought that out, that the black swans come along with
far more regularity than they should.
According to modern portfolio theory, right?
They're very much a tail event that should happen very rarely.
And they don't happen very rarely.
They happen quite often.
And the thing that kind of defines a black swan event
is that you just can't imagine it happening.
You can't imagine COVID shutting down the entire world economy, right?
You can't imagine that all of a sudden,
the entire United States financial system would freeze up over mortgages.
And those two events are only like 12 years apart, right?
So these black swans shouldn't come along once, you know,
the hundred year flood that happens every 10 years, that's not good.
And so we're really looking to see what is a possible catalyst
almost as self-defeating, because if I can figure it out,
then it probably isn't that, right?
It's probably going to be something else,
but we can think of a lot of different things.
We've got, you know, conflict happening economically with trade.
We've got potential violent conflict happening several places in the world.
Any of those things go off seriously,
and you're going to get the beginnings of a recession.
We get the beginning of a recession, you're going to see the baby boomers jump.
Yeah, they're going to switch over.
Because if they start finding themselves having to raise interest rates,
you're going to see annuities jump in what they can give people as a return.
And that's going to look, you know, an 8% annuity, a 9% annuity over your lifetime.
It's going to look really good compared to a market going flat or down.
So you feel as though, because it's a black swan event, you can't really see it coming.
So therefore, it's almost a pointless exercise to try and predict something like that happening.
Yeah, I guess, I mean, you can predict this, it's going to happen.
Right. So knowing that it's coming, but maybe not knowing what it's going to be
or when it's going to happen, how do you and your team, Austin, Travis,
how do you guys go about your investing, knowing that the shill appears at 40,
the market seems expensive, the MAG7 account for 30-something, 40% of the S&P 500?
How do you guys continue to, you know, have the conviction and still invest into this market
when, you know, you can see these things developing that you're not happy with?
Yeah, I think this is the beauty of the investment strategy that Buffett's taught us, really,
that while we can't time the market, we can, we are certainly affected by the market
change between price and value. And as we are looking at individual, so forget about the market
for a second, if we're just looking at individual company values and what we're looking for is
something where the price is significantly below the value of that business, if we can find that,
we're going to buy regardless of what the market looks like it's doing. Because a market, a general
market collapse after we've purchased a company that we bought on sale, a general market collapse
is likely to take that company price down farther, which is fine. We would love to buy more
of it cheaper. That's right. So, and the opposite applies. When we have businesses in our portfolio
that have gotten to a price that's just dislocated way above the value, then we are going to sell
into that sort of irrational exuberance and get out of that company. If it's really massively
highly priced, we're going to go ahead and get out of it. And what happens then is we're pushed
into cash at a point in time when we end up with a shiller at 40, we're just pushed into it. And
that's where we are. We have a load of cash and we still own companies that we think are franchises
that are at reasonable prices right now, fairly priced, but growing at 15% a year, we're staying
with all of those. But the other thing that's happened is moving out of businesses that are over
priced has put us into cash and it's a natural condition for this type of investing. You just
are, I mean, Buffett said it so cleanly. I think once he said, so I'm going to tell you the secret
of investing, close the door, you know, sell into greed, buy fear. And that's really what that boils
down to is we're just looking at price and value when they get vastly dislocated because of
irrational exuberance, we're going to sell. When they get vastly dislocated because of fear, we're
going to buy. So it's a natural progression where we end up in cash at the right times. You can see
that with Buffett. I mean, right now he's what, 350 billion in cash roughly, because it's very
difficult to buy anything at these kinds of prices. What do you do with the money? You put it into
bonds and you wait. And how do you go about, this is a question that popped up a bit from my
subscribers. How do you go about the process of which you build conviction to sit with your team
and go, you know what, sure the market's overvalued, but I know with, you know, a high degree of
confidence that I'm not going to lose money when going into this particular company. What's that
process like for you to build conviction? Well, the first thing is the timeframe that we are
looking at in terms of I'm not going to lose money going into this company, which is extraordinarily
different than Wall Street. The Wall Street fund managers are predominantly funded by other Wall
Street fund managers. So a pension fund that's handling 180 billion from the California teachers,
let's say, is going to pick several fund managers from Wall Street to put that money with.
Well, the fund manager that's running that $180 billion pension fund doesn't need those fund
managers if he's going to sit in bonds or cash. He's perfectly capable of doing that himself,
right? He doesn't need to pay a fee for that. So the only thing he wants them to do is be active.
So I give you the money. Buffett puts it like this. I give you the money. Then I can sit in
the stands and say, swing, you bum. You got to swing. You can't stand at the plate and wait.
All right. So the market that we are competing in is driven 85% by a much shorter-term philosophy.
It says, I have to do brilliant things with this pension money or I'm going to get fired. That guy's
going to take the money away from me and give it to another fund manager. And that's the reality of
Wall Street. So short-term thinking in Wall Street is predominant. I sat next to a fund manager
from, I won't name the company, very large mutual fund company who said, the longest we stay in any
particular company is about 90 days. We have to keep moving to stay with our peer group and the
index, whereas we might sit in cash for a couple of years waiting for an opportunity to get into
a company we want to own. So it's a very different philosophy from what we do. So the
length of time that we're looking at is much, much longer before we would think, well, we have a
permanent loss of capital. Point being, we can buy something that's on sale, paying 50 cents on the
dollar. Market crashes in it. We're perfectly content to have it go down another 50% because
we have conviction. So your point is, how do you get there with that conviction? All right. The
first thing is you narrow down the world that you have to be convicted about really tightly.
We like to talk about it. Warren talks about a circle of confidence. We would talk to people
who are just getting started. A circle is much too large. You want a narrow little canyon. We say
inch wide, right there. Go a mile deep on that inch. And when you go a mile deep on an inch that
you can understand, like for me, when I was thinking about doing all this stuff as a guide
out in the Grand Canyon, I was like, wow, what can I really understand? And it turned out I could
really understand cruise ships. I am in the cruise ship business. It's just a raft in the
Grand Canyon. It's not this thing with 4,000 people on it. It's got six people on it, but it's
the same business. It's the same service business, the same connection with the people that you have
to have. And I can look at companies and see what they're doing in my industry. The same thing with
Harley-Davidson as one of our early investments. I understood Harley because I had built Harley
from scratch, right? Rebuilding engine, rebuilding the frame, doing the whole thing.
And I understood why people were getting involved in Harley-Davidson back in the 1980s, right?
So you find an area of the market that you're already really comfortable with.
My daughter, Danielle, liked to shop at Whole Foods, and that was her first step into buying
companies she understood. So conviction comes from understanding the business. That's the number
one thing. The second thing, which is super important, is that you can understand a business
really, really well and still be very uncertain about its future because it is having trouble
competing in the market with companies that are coming in and attacking it and trying to take
part of its market share. And so you want a company that has some quality to it that prevents
this competition from shrinking its market. It's got to have something that is unique to that
company, which is very hard to copy. So what would be an example of that?
Like the way Chipotle Mexican Grill creates completely natural, organic, really gourmet food
at this price point is really hard to copy because you've got the problem of food storage. You've got
the problem of maintaining the health quality of the restaurant itself. You've got the issue of
sourcing those quality products around the world, around the country. And that's very difficult,
it turns out. And as a result, after all these years of Chipotle being famously successful,
no other company has come out with a national competitor. Very hard to do.
Right. So something very intrinsic to that business.
Exactly. It's built into it like railroad tracks are built into a train company, right?
You don't have railroad tracks, you can't compete. Or airlines have the same kind of
ability as they've got gates, right? Delta has gates in Atlanta. You can't get gates in Atlanta.
You can't get gates in Atlanta. It's really hard to compete with Delta out of Atlanta.
Right. Okay. Yeah. Makes sense. So a lot of questions came in from people that view your
stuff asking about high conviction and also Lululemon, which is a company that I believe you
guys have been investing in recently. How did you and Austin and Travis, everyone involved,
how did you guys work together to build your conviction in Lululemon?
Right. We go through a process that I love this process. It kind of started with
a software engineer who was using scrum management on a software team, which is a
very precise process to move the thing forward week by week or two weeks by two weeks. And we
started using that in the team. And so in order to use that, we needed to have specific pieces
of research completed before we would move forward to the next one. So we call the first piece of
that as just sort of a one sheet where you look at the company and you say, yeah, this thing is in
the ballpark of our circle of competence and we're interested in it. It might even be priced really
well. And then we moved to what we call a pitch deck, which is a multi-page project that usually
takes us about eight hours. And that pitch deck covers about 10 really important questions that,
by the way, we got in part from Bill Ackman, who put together his idea that you should be
looking at very specific things. I think six things for Bill that you really want to be
taking a look at. You can look that up at him. And so we look at these things and these are
really basic to a company being right in the ballpark of what we want to look at. And Lululemon
checked all those boxes. So then it becomes a question to us, okay, we want to do this.
So just what is the moat of Lululemon and how intrinsic is it? Is it hard to copy what they
do or is it easy to copy what they do? So the obvious moat with Lululemon is this massive
brand moat that everyone, it's one of the most famous brands in the world. And so immediately
a company trying to compete with them, a Viori or Alloyoga or somebody like that, even a Nike,
is going to have a problem because they don't have a brand that is focused on this specific
kinds of thing. And so what we needed to decide for ourselves for conviction was,
is that brand going to stand up against constant attacks? Will it stand up long-term? Because
there's lots of fashion brands that last five years, 10 years, and they're gone, right? And I
think that's the critical thing about Lulu. So if you wanted to invest in Lulu, you'd have to
determine that there's something else supporting that brand. It's not just a brand that, oh,
we produce really quality stuff. This is a Lululemon shirt right here, right? Yeah.
This time it's you that's wearing it, not me, right? We went to Lululemon together,
I don't know, a few months ago. And it just so happened, promise we didn't plan it,
I was wearing Lululemon pants.
You were wearing shorts that were from Lulu, right?
This time it's your turn.
Now I got a shirt on. I mean, I didn't intend to be talking about Lulu, but here we are.
And it's just that it's not easy to build this kind of a fabric and get this kind of a feel to it.
And all of my friends who've discovered Lulu for men, really in just in the last year or so,
have been amazed at how comfortable this stuff is to wear out when you're boating,
you're out on a golf course, you're doing recreational stuff. It is really amazing.
And it's not easy to copy. Nike hasn't copied it. So we started to look at that for conviction.
And when you dig deep enough on it, then the next question really becomes, okay,
is the management team going to be able to handle this and do a good job with it?
And the same teams there that's been turning 20 to 30% growth rates on this company,
they've hit a snag. The market responded to that and we could buy it at a cheap price.
And we trust that the combination of brand, the secrets and the clothing,
and this management team will pull this company out almost with total certainty that 10 years
from now, it'll be bigger than it is today. Right. Another question I have, it seems like a
lot of value investors, people that I talk to, use 13F filings a lot in their investing to either
find new ideas to go explore or, I don't know, not that you should really do it,
but almost to confirm that they're on the right track with something that they're looking into.
I'm very interested. And it's something I just personally enjoy looking into.
Not that I'm copying at Warren Buffett or anything, but it's just interesting to see
what these guys are doing. I'm very interested if you guys use 13F filings as well in your approach.
And if so, how do you use them? How should investors use them? I'm curious to hear your
No one should ever use 13F filings.
Use them all the time?
All the time. And it's such a great secret. It's a very well-known secret, but a lot of
people don't realize that if you have over a hundred million dollars that you're managing,
you have to file with the SEC. And that filing is called a 13F filing and it's done every quarter.
Every 90 days, the best fund managers in the world, along with the other 8,000 that aren't
the best fund managers, are all calling you up on the phone and telling you exactly what they bought,
how much they paid, and what they sold, and how much they paid, how many shares of it.
They're calling you up on the phone. Imagine if you had access to that. It would be like,
nah, don't bother listening to that. We love looking at Michael Burry stuff or Warren Buffett's
stuff. What are they doing on a quarterly basis? And the way we use it is as a lead. It's a lead
gen for us. It isn't axiomatic that we buy what they buy, although I think you could make a case
that you probably should. It's probably not a good pattern to get into just blindly copying
and not—it leads you to not doing your due diligence, right?
Right. For us, the problem with doing that for us would be, even as an individual investor,
would be that should that stock drop, right? I mean, we're talking about how a stock,
we could buy really cheap and it could still go down 50% if the market goes down or whatever.
Whatever's driving it down could continue to drive it down. Well, if we buy out of pure faith
that, ah, you know, Michael knows what he's doing here, and you buy this thing and then it goes down,
what Michael's not telling you is what he's doing right now after it went down or before
it went down because you're 90 days behind. And so that's the first risk. And the second is that
it's a real emotional trauma. If you guys have never experienced this, you have real money
in the market that you don't want to lose. It really would be horrible to lose it. And it's
going down and you have no conviction about what it's invested in. Well, that's very scary.
If you haven't gone through that, that is very scary.
So long story short, use the 13Fs.
Yeah, the 13Fs are enormous. In fact, I mean, we put them on our website, you know,
as well as a number of other websites. They're free to get and it's great to get them. And the
only, you know, you've got a government website, so of course it's a nightmare to try to figure
out what you're looking at there. So I'd say you should go get it off the web. You know,
there's a lot of people that compile those. Yeah. And what we do is look through the 8,000
fund managers and we narrow it down to the handful that we really think are fabulous and are,
yeah, we've got probably 60 fund managers that we think are good enough to, you should take a look
at what they're doing. Where can people find that website out of curiosity? You go over to
rule1investing.com and click on toolbox. Okay. So it's in the toolbox. Yeah. Awesome. All right.
Well, I want to move on to a different topic that is very much asked about as well. People are very
curious to hear your thoughts on this US debt situation because there's been a lot of media
talk about it. I feel like, especially since interest rates have risen over the past few
years, I know they're coming down now, but still generally higher. All of a sudden,
$37 trillion of debt seems to be much more of a problem than it was in 2020, interest rates were
nothing. People are very curious to hear your thoughts, living here in the States, seeing the
political situation. What are your thoughts on the US debt situation? Is it a genuine problem?
How do you fix it? Yeah. Well, first it's a genuine problem. I mean, it's a really serious
problem and it's one where the curve is sort of rising straight up like a hockey stick. And as it
goes up since just five years, now the interest on the debt, which has risen in those five years by
200%, you know, went from 2% to 5%. Now that interest on that debt, having accumulated that
much debt is running, I think it's the single largest thing in the budget. It's over a trillion
dollars. It's more than the defense budget that America is using. Serious problem. And it's
accelerating. The current administration added another 3 trillion to it over some time. And so
if there's no way to get additional revenue and we keep spending more than we make,
essentially and eventually the currency collapses. You get to it and the collapse comes about
simply because people won't lend you money at that interest rate. They're worried they're not
going to get their money back. And so the interest rate climbs no matter what the Federal Reserve
does to try to hold it down. They demand a higher interest rate or they won't give you the money.
And that higher interest rate bankrupts the government. It goes to 10%, boom, and now
you're at, what, 2 trillion. And it doesn't take long. I think in the next decade,
the debt could easily, on this trend that we're on, could easily hit 50 trillion. And when it
hits 50 trillion and interest rates rise to find the money in the market, then the Fed has one of
two choices. You can't pay for things. You've cut social services, which would create a revolution,
right? Or you print money. And that's the alternative. The way they print money is that
the Federal Reserve Bank makes an entry and just creates the money with a, yeah, one click. And
then it buys U.S. Treasury bonds with that new money. And the money's now into the market and
it pays for government expenses. The problem is there's no wealth created. It's just printing
paper. And inevitably, when you do that as your last resort, your inflation rate goes through the
moon and you become a third-world nation. And the rest of the world, who has all of these dollars
in reserve to handle trade, will find another solution. And those dollars will come into the
market instantly and exacerbate the problem. And so you end up with a currency collapse.
And that is a disaster for America. So, second part of the question is, can we fix it?
I mean, there's kind of two sides. Yeah, go ahead.
I was going to say, is it inevitable? Maybe a better way to look at it. Is it inevitable
that the way out is everybody in America pays for it through really high inflation? Or not
even really high inflation, but elevated inflation over a long period of time?
You can get out of it that way if you stop deficit spending. You say, okay,
no more deficit spending. And now we'll inflate our way out of it so that we're paying back 37
trillion a dime on the dollar in terms of buying power. And if we do that over a slow enough period
of time, all of our trading partners will have time to react with their own currencies and
we might get away with that. So that is one possibility. That's a better possibility than
the alternative, which was tried in Great Britain back when it was going through a currency collapse
back in the early seventies, where they raised taxes to 95%. And what happened is the Rolling
Stones left Britain, the Beatles left Britain, you know, Rod Stewart left Britain.
You might come live with me in Australia.
I will be leaving because they'll try to tax at a high rate and all the money will go away. And
if it can't find some other solution, some other way out the door. And one statistic about that
that's fascinating is the 1960, we had an interest or a tax rate of 91% in America.
And we received back in terms of government revenue, 7.9% of GDP. Today, we've got a 37%
tax rate and we got 8% of GDP and revenue. So rising taxes doesn't rise revenue. It doesn't do
it. It's totally been tried. It doesn't do it. Okay. So we can throw that one away. So we can
inflate our way out of this. Maybe if we stop spending too much money, maybe we can do that.
Alternately is what president Trump is trying to do, which is to tariff our way through this,
which will cause a couple of things. First off, they think we're going to bring in about the same
amount of deficit, same amount of revenue as our deficit spending about 3 trillion over the next
decade from the tariffs, which also pushes companies to construct manufacturing in the
United States, to hire US labor at a high rate, right? Which pushes up the tax revenue.
So a combination of tariffs driving businesses into the US pushing up labor wages to push up
with inflation so that there's some parity there is a possible solution. I don't know if it'll work
for sure. That's about it. That's about it. On the topic of tariffs then, do you feel as though
what we're sitting through now is kind of short-term pain for longer-term gain?
Yeah, absolutely. I think there's a big dislocation in global trade going on, right? With
two sides to this. First is our necessity to disconnect China manufacturing from critical
manufacturing in the US. So it's not going to work for us to have our drugs manufactured in China
if China is going to become a potential violent... Where do you get your drugs?
Yeah. And where do you get your drugs? And so companies are trying to disconnect and move
around the world in different places. So while they're trying to do that and they're moving to
Bangladesh, all of a sudden they have tariffs on Bangladesh. One company was building a car. I was
looking at sort of an off-road car. They were going to do this in Mexico. Boom, up go tariffs
in Mexico. They just cut off manufacturing completely and don't even make that car.
So there's a lot of dislocation going on. But I do think it's relatively short-term. If we can
stabilize and if this rise in tariffs force our trading partners to be
fairer with us in terms of what they're keeping out of their country,
you don't see a lot of Fords in Japan. So we want some parity here. And this is one way to get it.
So short-term might be two, three, four, five years, all right? But in the long run, tariffs
are kind of a one-time hit, right? If your tariff is now it's 10%, well, okay, that's built ultimately
into manufacturing, it's built into the retail price, it's built in all along the chain,
and then it's done. It's in there and there it is, done. So I think, yeah, four or five years
from now, this will all settle out. One of the things I found interesting listening to Elon Musk
talk about this recently has been this idea that short tariffs might encourage manufacturing to
come back to America. But he raised the point that if you want to do that, for companies to
make change in their business and where they manufacture, tariffs have to be predictable
and stable. And I feel as though so far we've not seen that. No, we're in the negotiating phase.
That's tough. I mean, if you step back and take the view from 30,000 feet over a relatively short
period of time, let's say two or three or four years, my guess is we'll see this absolutely
stabilize. But right now, they're negotiating. And this is how governments negotiate. They go to
the brink, they threaten, because they know they don't have to do anything unless it becomes really
painful to not do it. And so Trump is trying to make it very painful for these countries to not
do what he wants them to do. I'm not going to make a value judgment about what he wants, right?
This is pure negotiation going on right now, and that doesn't last forever. It's a phase.
Right. Okay. So we get through that phase and eventually it evens out.
And it has to do what Elon said. It has to be predictable. Here's where we're at. Done.
And your thought is that once it reaches that kind of equilibrium stable point,
that's where you start to get the broader trend of companies pulling their manufacturing
back into the United States.
If they know this is the final deal, this is as good as it's going to get,
I need to build a factory in America. Yeah, I see that happening. But I think
we're talking a couple, three years.
Another question that I got from the subscribers related to tariffs. This is a direct question
from one of them. Which American companies do you think will end up benefiting most from Trump's
tariffs? And how do you see specifically American tech? Do they stand to be significantly affected
by tariffs and trade wars?
Oh man, honestly, that's just out of my circle of competence. Yeah. We're not a strong tech
investor. We don't really try to figure out where everything's going to be. We much prefer
something much simpler than that, which is a company that's just got an obvious business
that we really like, and it's gone on sale for some small reason. Right?
Right.
Yeah. So I can't really, that's really out of my league.
But I think that's how it's so rare. And I think this is why you're a good investor, right?
Is it's like what Charlie Munger says, know what you don't know.
Know what you don't know.
I feel like so many people, like if we're on CNBC and you're a CNBC talking head right now,
you'd be like, yes, so American tech, you try and make something out, right?
Right. You never want to be that guy who doesn't know.
Exactly. So there's the difference between a rule one investor and a CNBC talking head.
The ability to say, you know, we don't really know all that much. We don't follow it. So I
that's still like a valuable answer, you know? All right. For beginners, you stated in rule one
that we should look for an obvious example of a wonderful company being
available at a margin of safety price. In the current market,
how long might it take a beginner to find this? Do you think it would take say three,
six, 12 months? It just feels like many companies that are wonderful
are currently near or over their intrinsic value.
It's felt like that in general for six or seven years now.
Gosh, if we were to go back to, I think 2017 is like seven years ago, eight years ago,
Warren said, you know, every 10 years there's an economic storm and it's time to catch the gold,
right? That was a long time ago and it hasn't really happened yet. And as a result, it's harder
for us to find things. But every year we've found at least one thing that's on sale and we have a
fairly narrow circle that we're working within. So I think that investors may have a difficulty
if they're starting inside that sort of narrow canyon or small circle, there may be nothing in
that that's on sale right now, but you do the work and the work of understanding that business
inevitably leads you into widening that circle or widening that canyon. And gradually things
start to fall in there. The other way to go is to simply look for things that are on sale.
And going back to the 13 F's, follow Michael Burry. He's really good at finding stuff that's
on sale. Much of it is a little bit difficult to understand why he's doing what he's doing,
but it turns out well much of the time. Look at the 13 F's as an idea factory. You see what
Bill Ackman is buying. They may be buying at a little more expensive price than we really want
to pay, but it's a really good source to figure, okay, this guy at least thinks this is worth
buying into. And you'll see that they're not sitting mute for two years. They're finding
things out there. And if they can do it, then we can do it too.
Okay. So use it as an ideas list, I guess.
Absolutely.
Does Phil see any promise in tokenization and other blockchain tech as a meaningful
solution slash alternative to the current fiats available? If not as a currency,
then the technology itself to make markets more efficient and unlock liquidity.
Final note, if so, would he ever invest in that space? Here we go.
Okay. So the keyword here is invest. And my view is that that's not investing. That's simply a
hedge, right? Because an investment to me is something that is producing cashflow. Ultimately,
what I'm doing when I'm investing is I am spending money now to buy a lot more money into the future.
And I can predict that future money with a high degree of confidence. That's investing. So if
something isn't producing cashflow ever in the future, like gold, silver, Bitcoin, it's not a
cashflow generator, then I have no way of understanding what its value is today other
than what someone else might pay for it. So I would be buying the equivalent of a Picasso.
And without really being an expert in Picassos, I could still be pretty confident that 20 years
from now that Picasso will probably be worth more money than it is today. Or maybe a Steinway
piano or a violin or anything else. I don't know anything about that I can't predict the future on
in terms of its cashflow. I could only say highly likely it's going to be worth more. To me, that's
speculating. Now, a lot of people argue with me on that. It makes sense, though, what you said.
That's kind of how I see it. If the question was, will you speculate on Bitcoin?
Yeah, I could see us. Maybe not Bitcoin per se, but some aspect of it that we understand
blockchain around what value it adds, how it might be used in the future. But just purely Bitcoin,
I would say I would be deeply interested in it if we were at that point in America where
we were destroying our currency or could see we are destroying our currency,
because I'm going to want something that's going to hold its value, even if that value is fluctuating
50%. It's probably going to be better than a currency that's going to zero. And I can get
out of the country with it. We'll be heading somewhere else. And when we do, it's highly
likely that the government that's in place right then is not going to permit you to walk out of
the country with a lot of assets. That seems to be the case when things get nasty. So I think
there's a place for it. If I was in Afghanistan, when the collapse happened, I would wish I would
have Bitcoin. I'm not trying to walk out of the country with gold bars. So yeah, I think there's
a place. Interesting. Another question. What are your biggest regrets from your investing journey?
Do you have any regrets? Yeah. The biggest regret I've got is a $30,000 Jaguar that I bought.
Within two years of starting as an investor, I made enough that I could buy a Jaguar.
And it was a $30,000 car at that time. I could have bought a $5,000 Corolla. And $25,000 could
have been in the market at 15% a year, compounded for 40 years. That Jaguar, I've calculated,
it cost me $8.8 million. I'm sorry, $8.6 million is what it cost me. $8.6 million. $8.6 million car.
So that's a regret. Another one is just the mistakes I've made. It's very hard not to regret
the mistakes. There's a certain amount of regret on mistakes I made by errors of omission. I didn't
buy things that I was on the edge of buying. And I thought, yeah, and then I didn't pull the trigger
for some lack of full conviction. And then they just took off. So there's always regret there.
But those are the kind of regrets I'd rather have than the few that I have of things I put money
into that I shouldn't have. Those are very painful. And the lessons that come from that,
you hope you never, ever repeat. So one way of thinking about this is experience is what you
needed right before you got it. And so here comes this experience. I wish I'd had that experience.
I wouldn't do what I was about to do, but I didn't have the experience, so I did it. And man,
then you just look back on it and go, that was so dumb. And they're mostly, honestly,
Brandon, they're mostly hubris regrets, thinking I knew more than I knew.
And the more I do this, and this is the beauty of being an investor, I think, is
it's a long-term cumulative process. You're a better investor at 80 than you were at 20.
And so I feel like I've learned something about hubris. I've learned something about
cognitive biases. I'm biased toward whatever I already have decided that's good.
I've learned those things, and those are hard things to learn. You don't know that you don't
know unless you're really looking at it hard. And I think that's one of the things that Charlie and
Warren are extremely good at, have been extremely good at their whole careers, staying away from
what they don't know, which means you know what you don't know. But beginning investors don't
know what they don't know. And hubris is massive in beginning investors. Oh, I've done 10 hours of
work. I know all I need to know. And it turns out maybe you don't. The last question I have
personally is, we've spoken a little bit how you're feeling like you're approaching retirement.
Once you transition away from rule one investing and look back at your career, what do you hope
your legacy is for the next generation? Well, I hope, number one, that I'm healthy enough in my
mind that I never transition away from the actual process of investing. I feel like I'm in a career
where you die with your boots on. I see that over and over again. But it is a really cool
career. I mean, as Charlie once said about Warren, he's never really working full-time.
He's never worked really full-time. And it's a little bit tongue-in-cheek because we don't
consider reading four or five hours a day working. It's just what we do. It's fun to do. So I hope in
the regard of investing that I always do it and I've always got the brain there to do it. But in
terms of the education side of things that we do, yeah, I'm definitely transitioning from that
and working with guys like you. And people that have worked with me for years and have been trained
by me for years are starting to take more and more of the reins of teaching other people.
So I think my legacy I hope for is probably the same one Warren hopes for or Charlie,
and that is that we've contributed to the education of people as investors. And that
contribution have made it possible for people to grow toward financial independence that they
wouldn't have had otherwise and toward generational wealth where you've learned
and your kids hopefully will learn and teach their kids. And that ultimately could be an
enormous legacy. I mean, I hope we can get there, but that legacy is really exciting. I mean, think
about a leverage, talk about a bar that could move the world is if the ordinary person no longer had
to really be concerned about a career, no longer had to think about a career in terms of I have to
make money, just a career in terms of what do I love? And I can change it if I'd stop loving it
to something else, because I'm not financially dependent on that job. That would be a legacy
that I know Melissa and I would, we'd be so proud of that. Well, I think you're definitely achieving
it because even just from my personal view, the way I got into investing was through rule one.
And when I finished the book, I gave it to my dad, and my dad read the book. And now he's all
about rule one investing. And then I took it off my dad and I gave it to my friend, Matt,
who read it. And he was like, wow, this is cool. And then it just spreads.
And that makes me so proud, really. I really feel proud of that. I, I've, I got a burst of
pride there when you said that. And I was just thinking about when that book rule one came out
and it was pushed by random house. So it was in the bookstores on fifth Avenue was front window
bookstore. And I got my daughters and took them to New York so they could see that right from
their dad. And as we, we walked away from the, from the Barnes and Noble bookstore window and
walked to cross a street, a guy turned right there in his car and stopped as we were in the stop
sidewalk. And he goes, fill town like that. And then he drove away. I was like, whoa. And Elena
looked at me and said, dad, you have fan. Yeah. That's awesome. Oh, I think it's been a, an
incredible career. And, um, I'm very happy to have sat down today and had a chat with you about it.
So yeah, I appreciate it, Phil. Thanks very much for joining me and, uh, and we'll see you soon.
