Globally Inspired Flavors in a Historic New Jersey Town

WHYY
48 followers
176 Video Views·Sep 25, 2025
Under the Moon is the brainchild of partners and owners Santiago Orosco and Eric Richardson. Inspired by the flavors of Santiago’s Argentinian upbringing and Eric’s Italian-American family, this quaint cafe is serving truly cozy, inventive dishes.
---------------
Check us out on Instagram, we're @checkpleasephilly. Think you know the best restaurant in the Philly area? Head over to our guest application form for a chance to sit down at the Check, Please! table.
✏️ Guest Application Form - support.whyy.org/page/15427/data/1
📷 Check, Please! Philly on Instagram - www.instagram.com/checkpleasephilly/
🍽️ Full Episodes - video.whyy.org/show/check-please-philly/
Alan Amsus loves this cozy Argentine
spot that's dishing out global flavors
so unique you'll feel like a globe
trotder for truly unexpected tapas. He
heads to Under the Moon in Lambertville.
I'm Eric Richardson. I'm one of the
owners of Under the Moon. I'm Santiago
Rosen. I'm the other owner of Under the
Moon. Under Moon started in 2006 as a
very small coffee sandwich shop and we
sat about 27 people and we used to
change our menu every day. It was
handwritten. It was my mother, my sister
and I. If you look at our menus, it
varies from tacos to pizza sometimes to
whatever. You know, we like that we get
inspiration from different places and
then we put on their menu. I
I like to say that we're like a Spanish
Italian American mix. You know, we our
homemade scratch kitchen and I think we
infuse a lot of flavors from our
backgrounds. You know, I come from an
Italian family. Santiago is from
Argentina. So, we have, you know, a mix
of American culture, but also very
homegrown, you know, heartfelt
flavoring. We're very well known for our
empanadas with our homemade chimmy
cherry spice. Works on every day. Cold
days, warm days, empanada goes all
times.
My philosophy is that keep it simple.
Mainly for my grandmother. She used to
have a huge house with a huge sun room.
Every weekend there were like my cousins
and my uncles and we're a big family.
We're about 30 to 40 people. And she
will cook for all of us a lot of the
time. And so you will walk into her
kitchen and you will see like trays of
homemade one by one rolling places of
the kitchen whatever she can put and she
will cook for us. And she was amazing. I
remember that. Then my grandfather was a
mentor for a really important restaurant
in Argentina and he will steal recipes
and that's how you know inspiration came
from
the tapas in our menus to help create
that experience. Take a little bit of
everything and that creates engagement
and people talking more and talking
about the food, the flavors and having
experiences. You know, we're a gay
couple. We own this for almost 20 years
now. Everybody needs to be feel
comfortable with whoever they are. When
we started out, the idea was to have
like a little small cozy romantic little
place so people can camp with a snack or
whatever and then feel comfy and that in
Spanish means under the moon bakaluna
and everybody's welcome here.
Alan, Under the Moon is this cute and
eclectic restaurant and a cute and
eclectic town. Why did you pick it? I
picked it because every time I go there,
even before I'm seated, I feel like I'm
in for a fun time. There's something
very playful, almost whimsical. I think
I once described it to a friend as being
like Alice in Wonderland tea party kind
of feel. And I I just find that very
exciting. And the food lives up to that
that vibe.
What are some of your favorite go-to
dishes?
Well, the appetizers we had a friend and
I we ordered three. The standout was
definitely the um seafood empiñatas
which were new to the menu. They had
just introduced them and the empiñata
shells were really crisp. And then
inside was a mixture of shrimp,
scallops, and lobster in a saffrony,
paprika-ay, sort of bright orange cream
sauce that was just velvety and and
zingy sort of that the the just enough
red pepper in there to wake your mouth
up. And that was I think my favorite.
Yeah, we had that as well. So good. They
were wherever I go, I get pampanas if
they have it cuz I love empanadas. And
they were very, very good.
The only thing you have to remember is
that they're very well packed. So when
you bite into it,
it's gonna dribble on your shirt.
Get ready. Wear a bib.
That's it. Or eat it over your plate or
something.
I had the AI tuna
and it was cooked. It was done perfectly
cuz sometimes uh it's a little bit
tough. It can be. So this was perfect.
Uh very flavorful. I want to say a word
about the third appetizer we ordered
because um in contrast to the other two,
it was quite simple. It was a blistered
shishito peppers
which were very simple. Just olive oil,
a little salt and grilled or seared
somehow with a crumble of feta cheese
and a little bit of a lemon.
And it was very simple but really packed
a surprising flavor.
And how about the duck mac and cheese?
Oh, that's the signature dish, I think,
because, you know, it's mac and cheese,
and I love mac and cheese. I like even
bad mac and cheese, but this was really
good. But, um, and I love duck. Duck is
probably my favorite food. The cheese
they use is gouda, which, you know, is
is not so traditional. Usually, it's
cheddar, but the gouda and the duck give
it a super richness, and you just about
to think, "Oh, this is too rich. This is
too much." But it's studded with these
little dried cherries that really do
balance the flavor. They they make this
sort of not quite pickled, but this kind
of tangy pop in your mouth, and it
really balances out the richness. It's
it's a it's a stunning dish.
Gouda is like the bacon of cheeses. It's
very like smoky.
That's the best thing I've ever heard
anyone say.
It goes so well with like the with the
richness of the duck, but yeah, you're
right that the cherries kind of cut that
richness.
We ended up going with the tapis for
that reason. We wanted to try a little
bit of everything. Couple things that
stood out. The Spanish style potatoes
was one of the items. They also had a
really great skirt steak with a chimmy
chur sauce, which was phenomenal. It was
really good. And um the service was
phenomenal, too. Our our waiter Mitch
was really good at guiding us the right
way and saying, "Okay." And there was
one point where he I wanted something
and he's like, "I wouldn't get that. We
couldn't source really fresh ingredients
for that. It was phenomenal." So, I
really loved it. My friend had the
burger, the Lambertville. Okay. First of
all, the presentation is incredible.
Yes.
Uh the volume. I mean, it was huge. Just
the presentation was just beautiful. She
really enjoyed it. Yes.
I ordered a salmon uh which came with
charred Brussels sprouts and potato
flats, which were sort of long, thinly
sliced potatoes, almost like potato
chips. But the I ordered the salmon
because I love salmon. But it came with
a maple bourbon sauce. I think one of
the strengths in their kitchen is is
their sauier. Whoever's concocting their
sauces really knows what they're doing.
The maple bourbon sauce on the charred
Brussels sprouts was perfection. I would
go back just for those.
Oh goodness.
My friend ordered a steak and I thought,
well, the steak, mom, what do you do to
a steak? But it was beautifully cooked
and well seasoned. But it came with a
little sort of tin of um scalloped
potatoes
which again, you know, a little on the
rich side, but so good. So good. And
just that sort of crispy gratan
Yeah.
thing on top. It was just that was
really good.
And then of course there's a bar like so
it's like they've got a really eclectic
menu and then like really fun drinks.
And I know we hit the mojitos hard at
this table.
Yeah, we did. My friends and I each had
a mojito. I had coconut, she had mango,
and they were delicious. But the problem
with that kind of drink for me is I
could just toss those back real easy.
But it was it was it was very good and
not too sweet.
We had the blood moon um and it was
tequila with the blood orange puree.
Oo, that sounds nice.
So delicious. Very very good.
My husband had the apricot wheat beer
and it was very delicious. I had a taste
of it as well. And we had the mojitos as
well.
Two different types. I had the coconut.
My friend had the uh pomegranate.
Yeah, it was delicious.
And how about desserts?
I had the translations cake, which my
friend thought was a little too sweet.
I don't think I've ever used the words
too sweet in my entire life. It was
creamy and milky and rich and delicious.
Well, Alan, this was your pick. Sum it
up for us.
Wacky, eclectic, comfort food with a
twist.
And Jilda, what did you think?
Flavorful dishes. Um, everything very
different. Um,
uh, the sauces were great. And
yeah, and the town is just a wonderful
town to be in. It's just fun.
And Don, what's the big takeaway?
I think my biggest takeaway is the
variety they have. They had the tapest,
they had the dinners, they had brunch.
So, you know, whatever you're kind of in
the mood for, that's the place to go cuz
they'll have something that you know
that will satisfy you.
Check out Under the Moon for yourself.
Located at 23 North Union Street in
Lambertville, 6093971710.
Reservations are accepted and the
average tab per person without drinks is
$45.
