Italian Restaurant Etiquette - Avoid These Embarrassing Mistakes!

Globetrotter Tips
43 followers
33 Video Views·Sep 27, 2025
Eating is one of the best things about being in Italy,
but you may be in for some culture shocks
when it comes to dining out.
In this video, we'll share some of the differences
between U.S. and Italian restaurants
and how to navigate those differences
with our list of do's and don'ts.
Hi, we're Ed and Ed from Our Big Italian Adventure.
We spent half the year living and traveling in Italy,
and our channel is about helping you
have the most unforgettable, most amazing trip to Italy.
Before we dive in to our list of dining do's and don'ts,
let me just start by saying this is your trip,
and you should do whatever makes you happy,
as long as you show respect for the local culture.
But don't feel paranoid about being a tourist.
In all likelihood, no one's going to mistake you
for a local, but if you'd like to fit in more seamlessly,
feel comfortable with the local culture,
and enjoy your dining experience more, here are a few tips.
The first big no-no is ordering those dishes
that pass as an Italian in an American restaurant.
I'm talking about things like spaghetti and meatballs,
fettuccine Alfredo, and pizza with pineapple.
These are purely American inventions,
and you won't find them in Italy
unless perhaps you're at a tourist trap restaurant.
Now in Italy, you will find spaghetti,
and you will find meatballs, they just won't come together.
And you'll never find pizza or a pasta dish
with chicken in it, I'm not exactly sure why.
We've researched it,
and we can't find out the history of this.
So if you know why Italians don't eat pasta with chicken,
please put it in the comments below.
Do make it a point to try the local and regional specialties.
Every part of Italy has its own amazing cuisine,
and it would be a shame not to experience all those dishes.
For example, if you're up in Liguria,
try the pasta with pesto sauce.
And if you're in Florence,
try tagliatelle with wild boar ragu.
Or in Rome, try the spaghetti with cacio e pepe.
If in doubt, ask your server for a recommendation.
They're always proud to show off their regional specialties.
Let me talk a little bit about pizza.
Don't expect the pizza to come to your table sliced.
That happens only out on the street
where you're buying a piece of pizza
from a vendor called Pizza Italia.
In a sit-down restaurant, pizza's gonna come whole.
It's an individual-sized pizza
that is designed for one person.
So do take advantage of this custom
to order your own pizza with the exact ingredients
that you want without having to agree
or compromise with your dining companions.
Of course, feel free to share a slice
of your pizza with the others,
but it's not the custom here
to order one pizza for the whole table.
Don't ever cut your spaghetti
or other long pasta with a knife,
and don't use a spoon to twirl it.
The way to wrap it up is to use the side of your plate
and push the pasta against it.
It takes a little practice,
but if you don't put too much on your fork,
you'll get the hang of it right away.
The key is to grab just two or three strands
of spaghetti at a time.
And before you know it,
you'll be eating spaghetti like a pro.
Another rule of etiquette
that Americans might find a little bit puzzling
is that Italians keep their hands on the table
when they're not eating.
And whereas we're taught to keep our non-dominant hand
in our lap when we're not eating,
putting your hands in your lap is considered rude in Italy.
Keeping your hands visible
shows you're not trying to hide something at the table.
And this custom goes back to olden times
where you wanted to demonstrate to people
that you weren't a threat
and didn't have a weapon under the table.
We Americans tend to like cold drinks with lots of ice,
but don't expect that amount of ice in Italy
if you get any ice at all.
The drinks are cold from the refrigerator,
and in Italy, like in most places in Europe,
they just don't believe in adding ice to the drink.
There are a number of reasons for this,
one of them being historical.
In the pre-refrigeration days,
ice was more available in North America
where it was harvested out of the lakes and rivers,
and that wasn't as true in Europe.
And another reason is that Italians don't tend to like
having their drinks diluted with melting ice.
And finally, some people, especially older people,
believe that drinking something very cold
can make you sick,
just as they believe that being in a draft
can make you sick.
A word about the American custom
of getting free refills on beverages in restaurants.
In Italy, that's essentially not going to happen.
If you want another round, you need to pay for it.
But the good news is, is that beverages,
particularly water and coffee,
are much less expensive than they are in the US.
If you want to immerse yourself in the Italian dining vibe,
don't show up at a restaurant too early
because Italians tend to eat dinner later than Americans do.
For example, down in the south of Italy,
people don't go out to dinner until nine or 9.30
or even later.
Now up north, they go out a little bit earlier,
maybe 7.30, eight o'clock,
but essentially nobody eats at 6 p.m.
The big exception to this is restaurants
that cater to tourists.
You'll find them opening very early,
but when you see that, it might not be the best place to go
to get the real Italian dining experience.
Instead of eating early,
do take advantage of the aperitivo culture.
Head over to a bar or cafe and have a spritz or a Negroni,
and often in those places,
they will give you some free snacks
that will help tide you over until that later dinner.
Italian menus are divided into several courses.
You have first the antipasto, which is like an appetizer.
Then you have the primo,
which is the gnocchi or the pasta or the risotto.
Then you have a secondo,
which is usually the meat or fish dish.
And finally, at the end, you have the dolce or dessert.
Don't feel you need to order something
from each of these categories.
In fact, most Italians don't do that in general.
They'll have maybe just a primo or just a secondo,
or perhaps they'll share an antipasto,
and then they'll have either a primo or a secondo.
Like Anne said at the beginning, this is your trip.
So feel comfortable ordering whatever you want.
If you're hungry and you'd like to order a primo
and a secondo and a dolce, go for it.
Make sure you enjoy yourself.
That's the key.
Another section of the Italian menu
is the contorno or the side dish.
But don't expect the side dish to come included
with your meat or fish dish.
You're gonna have to order that separately,
and there probably won't be a whole lot of options
because the Italians tend to eat
what is seasonally available.
So for example, in the summer,
the menu might have eggplant or zucchini,
whereas in the winter, you'd see cauliflower and cabbage.
Just because you've ordered pasta,
don't expect Parmesan cheese, Parmigiano,
to automatically be brought to the table.
The Italians don't add that to dishes with seafood
like spaghetti with clams, spaghetti alle vongole,
because they feel that the cheese overwhelms
the delicate flavor of the fish.
And like we've said before, if you want it,
if you like seafood pasta with Parmesan, ask for it.
It gets some strange looks,
but if it's what you want, take it.
Unless you're staying at a big chain hotel
or one that caters to American or British tourists,
don't expect a full American or British breakfast,
or even eggs, because Italians tend to eat a sweet breakfast,
just a cup of coffee and a pastry, maybe a yogurt,
but you'll never get waffles, eggs, bacon, hash browns,
and all that sort of thing.
Now, if you find yourself really desperate
for an American or an English breakfast,
in larger cities, if you go out into the piazza,
there will often be cafes
that advertise having a full breakfast.
Just be prepared to pay a premium price for it.
Most of the time, when you go into a restaurant
for lunch or dinner,
you'll get a basket of bread brought to your table,
but don't expect them to bring butter
and don't expect them to bring a little plate
with olive oil and or vinegar for dipping your bread.
That is an American invention
and you won't find it in Italy,
except at touristy restaurants.
But do feel free to use your bread
to mop up the remainder of your sauce on your plate.
That's called fare la scarpetta,
and in most situations is considered perfectly acceptable.
The exceptions would be in a very high-end restaurant
or if you were out at a business dinner.
Don't expect your server to hover
or to keep coming back to the table repeatedly
to ask if everything's okay or if you need anything else.
And don't expect them to bring the check
until you ask for it.
Once you have your food,
the server will typically not bother you again.
And don't mistake this for bad service.
This is just the custom here.
And if you need anything else, just flag them down
and they will come over and get you whatever you need.
Tipping in Italy is quite different than it is in the US.
Don't feel like you need to leave a percentage
of the check as a tip.
Servers in Italy are salary employees
and they make a decent wage
and don't rely on tips for most of their income.
And for that reason, Italians don't tip very much,
if any, at all.
And they certainly would never tip 15 or 20% for a meal.
Now, if you've gotten really good service
and wanna show that you liked it to your server,
leave a few coins on the table.
Anything you leave will be very appreciated.
The one exception to that may be in restaurants
in very touristy areas where American tourists
have conditioned the servers to expect a larger tip.
If you get some pressure, don't be intimidated by it.
Leave a few coins.
That will show your appreciation appropriately
to the Italian server.
Also, be aware that you can't add the tip
to your credit card.
There's no place in their system for that to happen.
So if you're going to add a tip,
you need to do it in cash
and just leave it on the table for the server.
And a final don't.
Do not get drunk in public.
While Italians certainly enjoy their wine
and they certainly enjoy an aperitivo,
they always drink in moderation
and you will very rarely ever see an Italian
visibly drunk in public.
It's just something that is frowned upon there.
So have we missed anything here?
Have we missed any do's and don'ts
about eating out in restaurants?
Are there regional differences we haven't addressed?
Please add them in the comments below.
We'd love to hear what you think.
