The Pleasure of His Company (1961) is a delightful romantic comedy filled with wit, warmth, and unexpected tenderness. The film follows an elegant but unreliable father who returns to San Francisco for his daughter’s wedding—only to discover that reconnecting after years apart is more complicated than he imagined.
With a stellar cast including Fred Astaire, Debbie Reynolds, and Lilli Palmer, this charming classic explores family, forgiveness, and the sweetness of second chances. A must-watch for anyone who loves sophisticated humor and heartfelt storytelling.
Have you gotten any reply to the cable?
Cable? I've sent cables, not cable. To London, Paris, Rome, Athens, Madrid.
To Cairo, Marrakesh, Bermuda, Bombay, Nice, Monte Carlo, Salzburg, Vienna,
San Moritz, Lausanne. Total cost, $540.85. Total answers, none.
Maybe if you sent just one more. I'm sorry, darling. There aren't any places left.
But I've always dreamed of my father giving me away at my wedding.
I could kill him. If I could just get my hands on him, I think I'd kill him.
It's just that he moves around so much. If he'd gotten the cable, I know he would have come.
All right, my darling. I'll write your father one more time and tell him that we request
the pleasure of his company. I'm Rebecca Brannan.
I'm Tiffany Brannan. Welcome to Real Thoughts on Cinema.
Hollywood has been making feature films for 110 years now, but we mainly focus on the 20-year
period which we consider the golden era of Hollywood, 1934 to 1954. However, once in a
Last time, we talked about a pre-code film, namely a movie that was made outside of that time
because it was beforehand. This time, we're going to talk about a film made after that time frame,
The Pleasure of His Company from 1961. This film is about a young woman who's going to get married
and she wants more than anything for her father to be there to give her away.
But her parents have been divorced for many years and her father, Pogo Poole, is a pleasure-seeking
globetrotter who has only remembered to write her a few times in the many years he's been gone.
He unexpectedly shows up in their lavish San Francisco home one day and immediately takes over.
Of course, his daughter, Jessica, is instantly charmed by her debonair father,
but it isn't long before she begins questioning everything she'd known about her life.
Although she still loves her fiancé, Cattleman Roger, she begins wondering whether she's missing
out on something by not deciding to go with her father to travel the world. Meanwhile,
her mother is put in a difficult place with her new husband, Jim, because her first husband, Pogo,
is being very charming and romantic toward her. This film was made by Paramount. It was produced
by William Pearlberg, directed by George Seaton, and stars Fred Astaire, Lily Palmer, Debbie Reynolds,
Tab Hunter, and Gary Merrill. The reason why we generally focus on the period of 1934 to 1954
is because this time period is what we call the Breen era. During these 20 years, the Production
Code Administration was headed by Joseph I. Breen, and it was the job of this Production
Code Administration, or PCA, to enforce the Motion Picture Production Code, or Hays Code.
And it was this code to which the term pre-code refers, because that period was before Joseph
Breen enforced the code. Although, interestingly, the code was already in place from 1930 to 1934.
It was not enforced properly under the Studio Relations Committee, or SRC, because they didn't
have the power to really enforce it. Then after 1954 is when it really gets interesting, because
officially the code was not abolished until 1968, when it was replaced by the rating system.
But immediately after 1954, you can see a shift, and that's because Mr. Breen left,
and his assistant, Geoffrey Sherlock, took over as head of the PCA, and he was not up for the job.
This film, of course, was made in 1961, quite a few years after Mr. Breen had left. And it wasn't
an immediate, like, as soon as he walks out the door, we're all going to just completely throw
the code out the window. It was a gradual kind of breaking down of it, and you'll see it fluctuating
from even year to year. In 1955, there are maybe some films that are shocking, and then much later,
like in the early 60s, there are films like this, which it has so many wonderful qualities to it,
and at its core, it really is such a beautiful family story, and has a really good moral.
This particular film had its origins as a stage play of the same name in 1958,
which was actually a big hit, and won a couple of Tonys. And there's not too much information
available about that play now, so it's hard to know just how similar or dissimilar it was,
but I think that a lot of the sophistication and witty dialogue you see makes a lot of sense when
you see that it was first to work on the stage. Yes, and other than one day when they're going
around San Francisco, it's mainly based in the house. Right, so I can see how it could
being centralized like that, I could see it on the stage. One of the characters who was most
regarded in the stage play was the character actor Charlie Ruggles, who played Jessica's
grandfather, and he actually won the Tony Award, and he was the only actor who carried over into
the movie, playing the same role of Mr. Savage, her beloved grandfather, in the movie. And there's
a lot of continuity between the play and the movie, and the fact that the same writer of the
play also became the screenplay writer. Oh, that's nice. And I think a connection you could see between
this movie and the pre-code film we discussed last time, Man and Butterfly, from 1932, is that they
both feature Charlie Ruggles in a supporting role, which is quite remarkable, considering they're
almost 30 years apart, and Ruggles wasn't that young in that earlier film. And it also shows
what a versatile actor he was, because he was quite a goofy side character in many pre-code films,
and even throughout the 1930s. But in his later films, such as in the late 50s, and particularly
in the 60s, he became one of the most lovable grandfathers, and this is one of many movies where
he plays just a heartwarming, endearing grandfather role. Yes, he still has that, always having
these witty remarks, you can still see that sort of comedic side that he had before, but it's in
such a dignified way here. And because of the strained relationship with the estranged father,
it's so important that she has this grandfather there, who sort of filled that role for her,
as well as wonderful stepfather, Jim. When you look at all these old movies, you can see
some great examples of different types of family relationships. Great parents,
interesting child roles, of course, but when it comes to great grandfathers, this one is one of
the top ones. Either this, or perhaps another role which Charlie Ruggles played, the grandfather in
the parent trap. Both, like you said, in a case of a divorce, where this grandfather steps in and
fills that role for a daughter, and that granddaughter can look up to her grandfather
in a way that she would with her father, if he were around. And he provides a lot of great
introspection, because he oftentimes isn't that involved in any of the conversations. He's sort
of the onlooker, and he'll just be making witty observations, and sort of providing a neutral
party, because Jessica's very caught up in the emotions of being torn between her father and her
mother, and then Jim, who seems like a pretty calm man at first, becomes constantly in a state of
nervous agitation, because he doesn't know what Pogo's going to do to try to come in and take over
his study, steal his wife, he just doesn't know. Right, and as much as she might... Make friends
with his servant, Toy. As much as she might deny it, you can tell that Jessica's mother, she still
feels a little something there. You still feel that they, obviously, they were very much in love, he
just doesn't seem able to settle down. Yes. I understand that he's been married three times,
and hasn't made a go of it any of the times, but it sort of unlocks a new part of his heart,
sort of when he meets his daughter after all this time. Right, because she's the only child he has.
Right, and he's just been thinking of her as this little girl all along, and seeing her grown up,
and realizing that even though he almost didn't forget about her, but hasn't really kept in touch
with her, she has followed him in all his adventures. He finds she has a scrapbook in her room
with newspaper clippings all about him, so realizing that she has loved him so much through
all this time that he's been gone, it really makes him realize what he missed by not being there when
she was growing up. And of course, speaking about performances, this is quite a stacked cast in this
film. Yes, yes it is. There are so many actors who were very famous, and had been famous a long time,
particularly Fred Astaire, Lily Palmer, and even Gary Merrill. And it's one of many classic films
where it's amazing how obscure it is, because it does have such, such a well cast, such a well-cast
film. You know, there's so many stars in it. And I can't start to figure out why that was. Sometimes
they'll end up being a lot of lower quality copies of films if it fell into the public domain. That
doesn't seem to be the case here, because usually that results in there being many copies. This film,
it's, it's really like it hasn't been preserved or re-released. There are copies available, but
it hasn't been released on DVD, and it's available on YouTube now, but it doesn't seem like Warner
Archive or some other usual preservation source has decided to restore it. And I guess maybe it
was never shown on television later. I'm thinking for Fred Astaire fans, this one is sort of unusual,
because it's a non-dancing role for him. Other than he does a bit of ballroom, but really it's
just a very serious acting performance. And I think that's really wonderful to see from Fred Astaire.
It's interesting because both of the two main stars, you could say, Fred Astaire and Debbie
Reynolds, were musical performers, and there are non-musical roles here. At this point, Fred Astaire
had officially retired from dancing. This was his second non-musical film in a row, because he thought
he was getting too old to dance. But despite that, he does do quite a bit of dancing and singing in,
not like big musical numbers, but ballroom dancing with his daughter and with his ex-wife. And he
even sings a little. The classic song, Lover, which is an old Paramount tune from a pre-code film
from 1932. So you get to see that talent which Fred Astaire had, even though he's like, oh,
I'm too old to dance. But he's still dancing up a storm and singing. And even when he walks around,
he looks like he's dancing when he walks. And he has that great theme music accompanying him.
Yes, the music is a major part of the film, in spite of it's not being a musical.
The beautiful scoring by Alfred Newman, who's one of the great classic film composers.
The main theme, it just really is nostalgic, I think is the best word for it. It really grabs
you right away when the film starts. You know this is going to be something special, hearing
that theme. And then there's the jazzier theme that always plays when you see him going around.
Like you said, it makes it almost like a dance number every time he's walking around,
because of his signature gait and then that wonderful music accompanying him.
This wasn't the first movie which Fred Astaire and Debbie Reynolds had made. Interestingly,
he was the leading man in the film that really was her breakout film, Three Little Words,
11 years earlier, when she's just like almost a cameo performance playing Helen Kane. And she
doesn't have any speaking lines, she just sings a song, actually overdubbed by Helen Kane. But now
all these years later, she would play his daughter, showing that she really wasn't as young
as she's supposed to be. Right. And Tab Hunter, who plays her fiance, was a very popular young
leading man at the time. Right, but he was not originally intended for this role, is that right?
No, Rod Taylor was the first actor considered for the part. He's a similar type. I could see
why he was considered. And then, very interestingly, as the woman playing Fred Astaire's
first wife is Lily Palmer, who was a German actress, who later made British films and
eventually American films. And she's supposed to be an American in this. They refer to that a couple
of times. I thought she was French for years. Yes, me too. I guess she almost could just have
a refined New England accent. But once you know, you can tell she does have a subtle
German accent. I think she's largely well known for having been in a lot of crime films in the
mid to late 40s, or films noir, as many people like to call them. And I always just knew her in
this role. I have now seen her in a couple of the films, but for many years, this was the only film
I'd seen her in. And she's really perfect in this part, because she plays so well, that very
dignified and refined sort of club woman. But then she's got this really fiery side that he brings
and their dynamic together is really quite electric. An important character in this film,
you could say, which isn't a person, is the city of San Francisco, because it takes place very
notably in that city, which was one of travel and adventure, being a port city. And they did a lot
of location footage in San Francisco, which you can see from the exteriors as well as the interiors.
They actually filmed at the mansion, which was called the Spreckles Mansion, that really served
to give an air of realism and a sense of place to the whole film. And then you see them going
around town and they were able to capture location footage for that. And I think it really helps you
realize that they're there in San Francisco, which is such a notable city. And even the music fits
that theme of that city on a hill. And above all, the central character of Pogo Pool, or Biddeford
Pool, which is his full name, which is actually sort of a joke, because there's a body of water
in Maine, which is called Biddeford Pool. P-O-O-L. So his first name is Biddeford. And no one calls
him Biddeford except his ex-father-in-law, Mr. Savage, who says, I called him Biddeford. And he
does. This is a very unusual film, I think, and very unique, not just for, you know, being a
non-musical role for Fred Astaire, but just in and of itself. And it's a very, very impacting story.
And it really deals quite deeply with the difficult topic of divorce and remarriage, especially
when there are children involved. How it's affected Jessica's life, how not having her
father there, and that it's taken him so long to come back. He realizes he's sort of missed out on
really being able to spend any time with her, because she ultimately does decide to get married,
as she planned. And there's a bit of lingering regret kind of for all parties. You can see
he and his first wife, there's a little bit of regret that they couldn't make it work,
even though she's very happy with her new husband. And although Jessica is going to be very happy
with her husband as well, there's still that thought, if only he had come back five years
sooner, or maybe I made the wrong decision and should have taken the time to go with him. But
it's really when he realizes that she wanted to do it for him, not for herself, is when he realizes
it wouldn't be right for him to take her away, because the time for that has passed. But it's
an interesting question for debate. And I think, as a viewer, you can kind of think about,
what would I do in her position? That's always an interesting thing, if a film can leave you
with a question, not in a frustrating way, but just you kind of think about, what would I do
in that character's shoes? And somehow, this film especially really puts you in her place. You really
feel her struggle, and it really makes you think about it and ponder that point. It's always
interesting to consider any film, which is a Sherlock film, and consider whether it has any
aspects that would have been different under the Breen era. There are some Sherlock films which
really don't have anything which wouldn't have been allowed under the Breen era. We've talked
about it before. Yes, yes, we have. But by 1961, you're not going to find many of them. By this
point, the tide had turned, and it had been enough years that Hollywood had changed significantly.
Probably the most common thing you see is the inclusion of mild profanity. It had become
almost standard in every film by the early 60s. And this film is on the milder side for that,
at this point. It includes two usages of one of the milder Sherlock swear words. That's really the
main thing about this movie that I would say makes it obviously a Sherlock film and not a
Breen-era film. And I'm sure that that dialogue was in the play. And just like many Breen-era
films came from plays which had profanity, and they removed it from the movie. But they no longer
had to do that during the Sherlock era. There also is some dialogue which is a little suggestive,
a couple of lines, mainly things that either Pogo or his ex-wife Kate say. But I mean,
it's so sophisticated compared to everything that we see today that it seems almost prudish to call
it suggestive. Because it's, again, so minimal. Slight innuendo. Or they're just a bit more
straightforward about certain things. And use of certain words, which aren't swear words,
but just they didn't usually say under the code. Or under Mr. Breen, rather. Code was
technically still in place. But I agree with you that looking at it as a modern viewer, and not
us, because we don't count as modern viewers, because we haven't watched many modern films.
But coming in as someone who hasn't really watched classic films, you're not going to
be offended by this. It's still going to seem nothing like anything you're going to see now.
And the main thing which I would consider when looking at a Sherlock film is,
does this have the basic spirit of the code? Of being something which is decent, and above all,
upholding strong moral values. And I think the way this film handles divorce is very much
in alignment with what the Breen era code would support.
Divorce is kind of an interesting question when you think about the code.
Because it's not exactly mentioned in the code. It doesn't say never show divorce and remarriage.
Although you do see many films where a couple gets divorced and they get back together.
It's not usually portrayed, but it is once in a while, because it was not in the letter of
the code. And I think, like you said, the way it's handled here...
Because the thing that the code said wasn't don't show divorce. It was that
the state of marriage must be upheld. The sanctity of marriage. You must not
make marriage look bad. So what this film does is it makes divorce look bad.
We see how divorce hurts people. First of all, the child. Jessica has had years of missing out
on having a father whom she would have loved to have as her father because they got divorced.
But you also see both of the parties involved. It's not like they hated every minute of being
together and they're so glad they're not together. They still love each other to a degree. Maybe
Kate gets along better with Jim, but she loves Pogo even now in a way that she never
will love Jim. And you see that she was Pogo's only true love. He's still been searching for
something. And one reason why he immediately connects with Jessica so deeply is that he sees
in her not only himself, but what he loved about Kate. So it shows a reality about life. There
is a lot of divorce today, but there was a lot back then too. After World War II,
divorce became more common. So it shows a real situation, but it doesn't say this is a good
thing to do or you should do that because it's better than fighting. It shows if you make that
decision, people are going to end up suffering because of it, including yourself. You might miss
out on something. Maybe you should stick around. Maybe you should try a little harder. So I think
nothing thematically would have been different about the film had it been a Breen era film.
Yeah, just probably like five or six lines of dialogue and it would have been a completely
a Breen era film. The other thing which you can see that shows changing times is fashion because
the Breen era insisted on decency and modesty, which led to very fashionable and beautiful
clothing. By the late 50s and the early 60s, more revealing costumes were becoming commonplace
since they were allowed, but that's not the case in this movie at all. There are some gorgeous
costumes and none of them are too revealing. I think as is often the case when movies are not
being watched over, they will exaggerate fashion. I would say I think this is probably a more
realistic look at actual 1960s fashion. They probably like to make it look more sleazy.
Especially with two high society classy ladies like Kate and Jessica. They're very refined women.
There's no reason why they would wear something which is immodest. My outfit is inspired by the
fashion of Jessica. She wears many dresses with very full skirts and with chiffon or sheer accents
and a string of pearls. My outfit is inspired by the fashion which Kate wears throughout the film,
Lily Palmer. Most notably, the dress which she wears when she goes to a party celebrating her
daughter. It's a long evening gown with a scarf draped around the shoulders and like most of her
costumes, an hourglass silhouette. In one scene, she wears a very small hat which is almost more
of just a hairpiece, which was becoming quite popular in the 60s as hats were going out of
style. This movie stands out because it has a touching, meaningful story which would make it
a delight to watch no matter who was in it. But beyond that, it has a rare combination of some
really big stars. You have of course Fred Astaire, one of the greatest musical stars, showing his
dramatic ability, as well as just a little bit of dancing and singing to show how great he was,
as well as the dramatic yet surprisingly comical Lily Palmer, Gary Merrill, who in one of his
funnier performances, Charlie Ruggles as the lovable grandfather, the Chinese actor Samuel
Fong in a hilarious and lovable role as the houseboy, Toy, and then of course, Debbie Reynolds
in a mature and very sensitive role as Jessica, the daughter. It's a deeper performance than you'll
see in some of her earlier musical films like Singing in the Rain or The Affairs of Dobie Gillis.
She shows real depth as she's this young woman who's torn between three parents and two men she
loves. And she shows us that longing she has as a daughter as well as the conflict as a young woman
in love. And I think this film especially would not be what it is without the performance of Fred
Astaire. We were observing this and one of his earlier films, Holiday Inn. In both of them he
plays a character, I think, who could very easily be really unlikable. He's kind of a scoundrel.
Yeah, but there's something about him and it might just be that he was really such a good man in real
life. That sort of shines through and it's impossible to dislike him. You really see
all the nuance of this character and it plays beautifully off of Debbie Reynolds' equally nuanced
character. Yes, and thus he's able to capture that spirit of this man who's so charming that
he makes women just instantly fall in love with him. And men too. He's charming to everyone.
Even his rival, the new husband, at first thinks, oh he's a really likable man. Of course he quickly
goes to see that he thinks he should just be in charge of everything. He starts ordering 15 cases
of the most expensive champagne for his daughter's wedding. He chooses the best room in the house for
himself. He starts telling Chinese jokes to Toy and winning his favor at the dance. All the daughters
and mothers alike want to dance with him because he's just such a smooth operator. He certainly
doesn't dance like a father. Yes, but he never seems like he's trying to be an operator or trying
to be smooth and charming. His charm is so effortless that it just seems like it's himself.
And the man who played it on the stage wasn't a huge name like Fred Astaire. I don't imagine he
could have been anywhere near as charming as Fred Astaire was. And of course Tab Hunter does a great
job as the young man who at first seems like just sort of a maybe even slightly oafish cowboy. But
then later in the film you realize he too is very dramatic. More dramatic than Tab Hunter often was.
Yes, you really see another side to him. And he in turn gives very meaningful speech especially
when he denounces the life of idleness which his future father-in-law treasures so much. Saying
there's nothing romantic about a man who doesn't work. A man who doesn't stick around and care
about his family. Likening him to a bull who doesn't care about the calves he fathers. And
at that point, although it's a rough spot for his relationship with Jessica, it's that strong spirit
which ultimately you realize is why Jessica loves him. Yes. So all these great actors and these
meaningful moments make this such a beautiful film to watch again and again. As we were saying,
it's a shame that it isn't on DVD or available for purchase or rent on a streaming service like
Amazon Prime because as it's a later Technicolor film it should be very clear. It is available for
free on YouTube. There are several copies. They're not the clearest copies of a 61 film but some of
the ones which are on there now are much clearer than copies which were previously available. So
you can see the details quite nicely and get a good look at all the beauty of this film.
The beautiful costumes. The details of the acting. And it's a film which can be enjoyed
again and again. Today we talked about a film which features a wonderful grandfather character.
Next time, join us as we talk about an equally wonderful grandmother
in a film which has a unique assortment of specialty performers
set in an equally unique location. Thank you for watching. Goodbye.