Witches: Beyond Myths and Magic

Myths and magic
3 followers
Sep 23, 2025
WitchesAt times revered and at other times persecuted, witches and the phenomenon of witchcraft span global cultures and centuries of history, remaining popular even today. But what exactly is a witch and what do they practice? Were those famously persecuted for witchcraft throughout Europe and colonial America really witches? And, what’s up with those pointy hats?
: Beyond Myths and Magic
Welcome back to Dornsife Dialogues, and happy Halloween.
Today's the day when our little ones dress up in costumes
and eat so much candy they make themselves sick.
I can hardly wait.
My son is dressed up as a pirate.
That one was clearly all about the sword.
As my daughter was choosing her costume,
she asked me what my favorite one was when I was a kid.
And I had to admit that for at least half
of elementary school, I wore different versions
of the same one.
I was always a witch.
Turns out, I wasn't exactly choosing
the most unique costume.
I just learned that witches are by far the most popular
Halloween costume out there.
In fact, the National Retail Federation
estimates that 5.3 million witch costumes
will sell this Halloween season.
And that's just the adult size.
This raises the question of what it is
that captivates us all so much about witches.
So, as befitting a Dornsife Dialogue event,
we take this to the experts.
The concept of witches has been around
in various forms for a very long time.
And their history reveals a lot more
than an obsession with riding broomsticks
and boiling potions.
There are lessons on how humans deal with otherness
and our reaction to phenomena
that can't be easily explained.
We have a terrific panel for you today
that will trace the complicated history of witches
and offer fresh insights
from what they represent across cultures
to the changing ways they've been depicted
in art and in literature.
Our discussion today will be moderated
by Peter Mankal, USC Dornsife historian
and Andrew W. Mellon Professor of the Humanities.
Professor Mankal is an expert on early modern history
and the early modern Atlantic world.
He's also the founder
and Linda and Harlan Markton's director
of the USC Huntington Early Modern Studies Institute
and an author of countless articles and numerous books.
He's also currently serving on my team
as the Divisional Dean of Social Science.
So without further ado,
I'll turn the program over to Professor Mankal's
capable hands to introduce our panelists.
Thank you for joining us
and be sure to continue to tune in
to our Dornsife Dialogue series throughout the year.
Enjoy the program.
Hi, my name is Peter Mankal
and I'm really delighted to be moderating this session today
to bring into discussion with this very large audience,
two of my favorite, brilliant colleagues.
We're gonna be joined today by Deb Harkness,
renowned international best-selling author.
But before she was that best-selling author
of the Discovery of Witches trilogy
and then it's follow-up Times Convert,
Deb was a historian, kind of a regular historian,
a superb version of a regular historian
and our colleague in the history department.
And she is the author, for those who only know her fiction,
of two magnificent historical or nonfiction studies,
one on the brilliant polymath John Dee
and another called The Jewel House,
which is just the best book out there
to understand sort of the social construction of science
in early 17th century England.
It's amazing.
And she's a fantastic speaker, so I can't wait to hear her.
The second person on our panel is Lisa Battelle,
renowned medieval scholar in our department
and also in the Department of Religious Studies.
Lisa is the author of five, so far, nonfiction works.
The other book may come up during this discussion today.
And she is an expert.
Deb is an expert on the history of science
and Lisa is really, I think, an expert,
one of our leading experts on the history of women.
Among her titles is a book called Lady of the Rock.
Another is Land of Women.
She wrote the Early Medieval Women book
for the renowned Cambridge Medieval Text Series.
Then the book with my favorite title,
Landscape with Two Saints,
about two pioneering female saints in medieval Europe.
I am eagerly now gonna turn towards a discussion.
I'm gonna get us launched with a question to both of them.
We'll see who jumps in first.
As Dean Miller was indicating,
witches are ubiquitous, they're everywhere.
I mean, when we walked our dogs this morning,
there were witches hanging from trees all over the place.
So I guess my first question to Deb and to Lisa is,
what's up?
What explains this fascination bordering on obsession
with witches in our society today?
So I don't know who wants to jump in first,
but I'll follow your lead.
Well, Deb is good on witches today
and I'm good on witches long, long ago.
I can tell you they came from ancient society,
at least in Western culture,
and Greeks and ancient Romans had them,
but not what we call witches or what we mean by witches,
various female magic makers.
And there, at least one or two are in the Bible as well,
but they were not the pointy headed bad women
that we know from stereotypes.
I guess I would say that I think to follow up
on Lisa's point, the thing about witches
is that they were perceived by whatever they were culture,
whatever culture they were in,
anywhere around the world as sort of liminal figures.
They were threshold guarders.
They stood between healing and sickness,
between life and death,
between the hearth and the outdoors,
between birth and creation.
So that women traditionally occupied those roles,
but of course there are men who did as well,
and that's how you end up with men in the picture.
And I think that whole idea of thresholds
and liminality, I was recently in Brooklyn
and every doorway in Brooklyn,
every threshold was decorated with signs
and symbols of the season, including many flying witches.
And I just think that thresholds indicate a change of status
and we're all fascinated by change.
So having a figure who embodies change in your community
or who can help manage change,
I think that's still appealing to us, frankly, today.
Who wouldn't like somebody to help us get
through the next bump in the road?
You know, I think you're saying two things
and one of them I sort of agree with
for the past and the other, I don't.
I think which is something that was created over time
as a category, the same way we separated magic
from religion, superstition from magic.
And it's changed as you know, over the centuries.
And I think the figures you talk about
may have been different people in various communities
of the long ago ancient world.
For example, Ireland, which I study,
and in Ireland, it is not Halloween, it's Samhain,
which had nothing to do with witches originally.
It was a seasonal festival about the beginning
of winter, the dark times.
But you can see the same associations of concepts
that you talk about, Deb, over time with magic makers
and liminality and the inside and the outside,
the live and the dead.
It's interesting the way it morphs in response
to other kinds of historical trends.
Yeah, I guess I was thinking of, as you know,
I like to look at the name of something.
So for example, science, what constitutes science?
And still talk about it that way.
I would think oracles, I would think midwives
in the ancient world, I would think healers
in the ancient world, and various other saints,
visionaries, all these sorts of people.
People who knew technologies, scrying, crystal gazing,
whatever it might be.
Necromancy.
Necromancy, although interestingly,
necromancy is something that is liminal
even to those liminal practices.
Certainly people who speak with the dead, yes,
but actually to raise the dead
is a fairly specialized branch.
So I think of them all as precursors of the witch
because all of those strains are filtering down
until I think they're codified
in the sort of later Middle Ages.
I mean, I would put the pin,
although I think it starts a little bit earlier,
frankly, straight into the cover of the Malleus Maleficarum,
make it a little voodoo doll.
And that's when everything got codified.
And it's important for people to know
that's our vision of the witch,
and that vision is actually Germanic.
It's about Germanic traditions.
You should probably tell people,
we should probably tell people
what you mean by the Malleus Maleficarum.
Okay, you wanna tell?
I don't know the year, late 15th century, right?
Two Dominican monks, Crema and Renga?
I think it's 1519, but I could be off on that.
No, earlier.
No, it's earlier.
My bad.
Don't trust the non-expert, back to you.
And it's an amazing book, isn't it?
I mean, everything vile about women and magic
connected together, along with glamoring men
to think their penises live in a nest in a tree,
and weird psycho stuff like that.
They don't.
I'm not saying.
And it means the hammer of witches.
It was a book that was brought together
by two inquisitors to actually legally get witches.
A guidebook.
And be able to prosecute, it's a guidebook.
And so that's why it's been so influential.
And it's spurred lots of vernacular treatises
in various European languages.
But, and it's on, actually,
for those of you who are in our USC community,
it's on exhibition, I think, right now,
at the exhibition in the library.
But it's just, it's that that brought it all together
into our sort of broom-flying, ointment, potion-making,
baby-killing, dealing with the dead, and satanic.
And for that, you need, of course, Satan,
which means witches are, in our view,
are fundamentally Christian.
Well, that's the argument, isn't it?
I mean, Christianity made,
pre-modern Christianity made witches.
And that it came from,
it developed from the hunt of heretics,
and casting out others like Jews,
and all the techniques came together
to persecute women who supposedly practiced magic,
and men, as you pointed out.
And animals, and children.
And children, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Okay, so let me jump in briefly,
and just ask this question.
I mean, you guys have done a great job of now
identifying sort of an origin point
for our sort of way of thinking about witches.
But I'm wondering if I could push you a little bit
to talk about why this book,
and all of the intellectual treaties that it spawned,
then led to very real-life persecution,
persecution that was, in my understanding,
overwhelmingly focused on women,
and that it would eventually manifest itself
in one of the most famous examples in American history,
which is Salem in 1692.
But before Salem in 1692, there was, of course,
there's this much broader attack
on alleged witches in Europe.
So I wonder if you guys could talk about that shift.
I mean, it's one thing to say there's this idea out here,
and it's an entirely another thing
to then persecute women.
So I want your thoughts on that, please.
Well, don't forget, it was Protestant Europe.
That has a lot to do with it.
So do you want to explain why that would be the case, Lisa?
No, I want Deb to.
There are, of course, witch trials in other places,
but they tend to take the form of trials that are heresy.
Whereas in a lot of Protestant Europe, it was a felony.
So it was a crime because it had to do with evil deeds
that you did to other people.
Whereas in Catholic Europe or places like Russia,
it was about heresy, it was about believing in things.
Now, the Protestant isn't quite that clear.
There's lots of heresy,
things that smack of heresy along with the legal issue.
But fundamentally, European witch trials and witch hunts
in Protestant areas, which is where most of them happen,
had to do with maleficio, with evil deeds
that you could say, your neighbor killed my cow.
My cow has value.
This is a felony.
Therefore, I'm going after you as a witch
because I will get the value of my cow back.
And then it went from there.
Yeah, the question is why, always,
why did this kind of thing not happen earlier?
And you can look to broad economic, social factors
about bringing people together in urban centers
and stuff like that.
But it happened in small villages too.
And in previous times,
there were people who got accused of this stuff.
There were people doing magic, man and woman,
maybe different kinds of magic.
But how can you explain the sudden shift?
I've always been-
Because in 1517, Martin Luther pinned a little bulletin up
on the cathedral door and belief fractured.
So suddenly you were in a realm where a multiplicity
of different beliefs, all of which were labeled
as the other, came into being.
So if you were an Anglican, everybody else was a heretic.
And if you were a Catholic,
all the Protestants were a heretic.
And if you were Anabaptist,
everybody else was a heretic, right?
So, and law is based on precedent.
Magic, and unless you directed it at the king,
was largely a religious crime tried in church courts.
Not after the fracture of belief systems
in 1517 and the years following.
Then witches are prosecuted in criminal court.
That's true.
And they're actually prosecuted.
I mean, magic went on quite openly in monasteries
and universities in the late Middle Ages.
A lot of the things that those women were accused
of doing later on, but it involved literacy and learning
and all sorts of other signifiers of people
who were among the leaders.
It wasn't these marginal women.
Right, so there we get to the big M word.
The M word being misogyny.
But it was there before, there was misogyny before.
I mean, it's a complicated shift.
If you think about all the intermediaries,
all the liminal figures in Catholicism
between the world here and the world beyond.
Interlocutors.
Interlocutors, liminal interlocutors.
There are a lot of them.
With Protestantism, interlocutors go away.
Except, you know, so, right.
So who's going to, the desire to have an interlocutor
doesn't just go away, but all,
there was a void in Protestant Europe.
So the midwife down the road who births babies
and gets bodies ready for burial,
seems like an interesting person to talk to
if you're looking for an interlocutor.
Does that sound plausible to you?
You're suggesting a need.
There's a need among people, really,
for the kind of magic that witches get accused of.
And the question would be, I guess, why women seem,
not women seem powerless,
why women don't seem sometimes uppity,
but why they get credited with these abilities, right?
I mean, maybe they had them, some women.
I think it's because I think it's,
I think maybe some did, like saints.
I also think that women were very powerful
in the community.
It doesn't matter what the men were saying,
or the misogyny.
Women guarded the threshold between life and death
on a daily basis, because they were the food makers.
They were the cauldron keepers.
They were, yeah, they were.
But they were also, you know,
if you think about gender theory in the medieval period,
right, based on Aristotle, women were weaker,
weaker of body, and thus weaker of mind,
and in Christian sense, weaker in that
they were more prone to sin, especially lust,
which made them more open, what, to Satan, you know?
So you've got so many threads feeding into this ideology
that suddenly acquires such huge power
that tens of thousands of women and some,
and men, but much more women, were executed for that.
And it's not like magic.
That's where I wanna push you guys a little bit more,
is I think, you know, I think in some sense,
the modern stereotype, you know,
the sort of that figure hanging from trees
on neighborhoods Deb saw in Brooklyn,
I was in Brooklyn last week,
saw the same sorts of things, right?
That modern stereotype is like, you know,
or Dean Miller deciding, you know,
she wants to go out as a witch
or whatever the most popular costume,
there's sort of a ha-ha, you know, sort of element to it.
But, you know, in 16th, 17th century Europe,
this was no fun and games, right?
I mean, you're talking, I mean, Deb is talking
about the central role that these women played in society,
and all of a sudden there is this war, you know,
that takes many, many casualties.
And so something seems to have triggered this.
And I think I would agree with Liz,
that misogyny obviously is not new.
So what is going on that sort of puts this attack
of women sort of on steroids and let people just act
in ways that seem to our eyes just so shocking?
Well, now you're asking us to explain the mechanics
of a society that decides suddenly
to persecute one group, right?
And I hesitate to draw this comparison,
but it's like explaining, yeah, I know,
why the Shoah took place or why other genocides took place,
why people earlier in Western European history
went after Jews or lepers or, you know, any other out group
when there's social political conflict, what do you do?
You find someone to blame.
Paupers.
Paupers, yeah.
The elderly.
Indigenous Americans, you know.
Perhaps you guys could explain what's going on
in the 16th century, late 15th, 16th and the 17th
that's making this happen, because unlike Lisa,
some of the things about genocide that you just mentioned,
you just previously guys have been talking
about the central role of these women
in these communities, right?
So they're not defined as the other,
they're defined in some sense as us, but different.
But something happened to ratchet up this salt.
In European society up till recently, if not still,
women are always the other.
What are you talking about?
Okay, well, we should leave some of these things
off the screen, Lisa, so we'll get back to that later.
That's a separate conversation.
Okay.
Can you guys situate for this large audience
why that time period, like what explains this?
I mean, in North America, the area that I'm most familiar
with, and I know Deb knows a huge amount about Salem also,
the number of witchcraft accusations is tiny compared
to what happens in Europe, right?
They start in the middle of the 17th century,
they peak at Salem in 1692,
and then they mostly trail away, right?
It did never reach the level of what happened in Europe,
even though this is among a transplanted
European population.
So I guess what I'd like you guys to do is to explain
what's going on that explains this mass assault
on these women.
Well, Deb, you've already pointed to a couple of factors.
Yeah, I mean, I don't like monocausal explanations
for things as a historian, they don't work for me,
whether it's the Renaissance or whatever.
So, or slavery or religious persecution,
you know, there's a lot of freight and weight behind
one of these so-called sudden developments, right?
So here are the things that I, in no particular order,
right, so you've got the splintering of belief and faith
into multiple religions, you have the printing press,
you have in England, certainly the highest level
of literacy that they had, and until, you know,
and then it dips until in the 18th and 19th century,
and then it rebounds in the 20th.
So increasing levels of vernacular literacy.
You have a handbook for prosecution
and law is based on precedent.
So you've got print, the Malleus Maleficarum,
you've got vernacular publication,
you've got the splintering of faith and belief,
you've also got exploration and increased trade,
which means that others are coming in at you
in all sorts of ways.
But I would put it to you that what Lisa mentioned,
Aristotle, the theological ideas as women and sin,
yes, these would have filtered into interactions
with the learned held by all levels of society,
at church, with your priests, with the local official.
So there would have been some knowledge of it.
But in this 15th, 16th, 17th century, you know,
there's, you know, the early modern equivalent
of Aristotle for dummies being published in,
you know, in vernacular languages.
So more and more people have these books with these ideas,
and then there's this manual,
and that's what leads to the persecutions.
It's that there's just a lot of,
not to use a horrible metaphor,
there's a lot of fuel on that fire.
And women, you know, maybe you see one African in London,
and he makes you really easy
and kind of fascinated about the other.
And then the African gets back on the ship
or stays in London, and you go back to your village,
and you're thinking, hmm, the other, hmm,
and fascinating, but terrifying.
And you start looking for them, you know, where you live.
And hey, presto, women have a lot of power.
There is a misogynistic bent to culture.
They are the other, I agree with you 100% Lisa,
and you start getting accusations.
And then it becomes like a grudge match.
Yeah, I think that's important for the explanation
of accusations on a local level,
and how a community can get bound up
into counter accusations and so on and so forth.
And every little grievance or complaint
about who's in charge filters into the conflict, right?
But, you know, you also said something
that I think is important.
You know, there was a booming economy,
the population's growing, people are moving around more.
So not only are books with their words
and pictures really crucial circulating,
but so are people with stories of, you know,
weird things that happen elsewhere.
So all of a sudden you're able to identify
those kinds of weird, awful, maybe dangerous types
in your own surroundings, right?
And in the old days, if you were Catholic,
you could go to church when you had a misfortune
and be told that it's part of God's plan, right?
And if you're-
I pray to this saint.
Yes, yes, pray to the saint for help with it, right?
And then what do you do if you don't have those outlets?
You have to find someone else.
It's not just the devil, it's the devil's agents.
And Peter will correct me, but, you know,
when you are in, say, Salem or, you know,
Ipswich, the places that are so associated
with the panic in 1692,
when you're in one of those places,
please let us not forget that this was the frontier.
And therefore someone who might've been
an ordinary housewife good at making medicines
in their village in Essex, England
comes to Essex County, Massachusetts
and is one of a very few with that skillset.
There are very few, like, university-trained doctors,
not that that was worth very much,
there are very few surgeons.
And so, and it was the frontier
where providing for keeping a family alive,
dealing with disease, dealing with livestock was challenging
and women played a very significant role
in keeping a family alive.
So it's not surprising that if something went wrong,
women were also blamed.
Let me follow up with a specific question for you guys.
So the most comprehensive study
of the North American colonies revealed
by a historian named Carol Carlson revealed
that it wasn't just sort of women in general
who tended to be accused.
They tended to be older, that is post-menopausal women.
They often were single and they were often poor.
That is, they were in many ways
that we as historians think
they were sort of already pushed to the margins.
So I think to follow up Deb's point,
these are women with a great deal of knowledge about things,
but I'm just curious if those patterns,
elderly, single, maybe economically marginal,
applied across Europe
or was that perhaps a North American phenomenon?
Do you happen to know?
I know it was young and old, as Deb already said,
male and female in Europe.
I'm trying to think of the narratives I've read
or the stories about whether it was particularly,
older women or women who were already
in some way in danger and thus dangerous.
I don't know, Deb, do you?
Yeah, I think I, of course,
owe so much to Carol Carlson and it is a semi,
I mean, it is a very, very legitimately esteemed
and it set off all of the scholarship,
but I think the scholarship
has kind of taken us away from that, Peter.
I mean, again, I was just in New York
and so I saw the Salem exhibition
that the New York Historical Society
used to be at the Peabody Essex.
And there I saw John Proctor's brass sundial
made in 1644 in London.
Now, this is not an economically marginal woman.
This is a very wealthy man with,
if I'm sorry, if you have a brass sundial
sitting in Salem, that looks right there
like a little bit of woo-woo magic
if it's the only one there.
So, I mean, he clearly doesn't fit that stereotype.
And I think as we delve more and more
into the accused, the executed, the escapes,
a different picture emerges.
And I think they're often women in very high standing
with very established, well-to-do extended families.
Maybe that makes them a target.
Maybe other people don't like how successful they are.
So, I think that's where I think it differs.
It differs over time and it differs over locality.
I mean, let's not forget that one of the accused
witches was married to somebody who had a knighthood
and that's in Salem.
Yeah, well, one of the accused in Salem
was the wife of the governor of the colony, right?
So, yeah, no, I absolutely take the point.
Let me shift us a little bit here.
You know, I'm struck by the fact
that I'm sitting in this virtual room
with two renowned scholars, two renowned historians,
both of whom, by coincidence,
graduates of women's colleges.
That's just a plug there.
Coincidence?
I don't know.
I don't think so.
I'll let you guys run with that or not.
That's entirely up to you.
But what I was trying to steer us was towards
the fact that both of you, as your careers have evolved,
have decided that the way to think about it
and write about the past is to move,
is to not only become expert in what you do as a historian,
but to then to express some of that knowledge
through fiction.
And I was just curious if you guys wanted to bring in,
I mean, Deb, you are so widely known
for the discovery of witches trilogy,
and obviously witches are foundational to that,
but equally foundational to that
is your deep knowledge of early modern history,
especially early modern England.
So I'm just wondering if you guys can talk a little bit
about why move towards fiction
to express some of the ideas that fascinate you.
So I'm just gonna leave that open for you guys to jump in.
I wanna hear what Lisa says.
I was gonna say you go, I'm the newbie.
No, no way.
No, you go, you go, that's why it's interesting.
Why did you decide that fiction was the way?
The same thing.
But I've been working on religion for a long time,
history of religions.
And if there's one thing that so-called secularized scholars
have trouble dealing with, it's the project of belief,
belief in a divinity, belief in magic, belief in witches.
I mean, what do we do?
We tend to act like strict social scientists
and find some function in the belief.
Oh, they believed this because they were impoverished.
They believed this because they were ignorant.
And we cannot account for the operations
of the supernatural in history,
which is not to say that there were,
but we can't even think about the possibility as scholars.
And so if you're dealing with the experience
as someone like a witch, as Deb does,
or a person who sees visions as I do in my novel,
how do you treat that person as anything but a loon
or a victim unless you can write
about the supernatural as a reality?
And you can't do that as an academic, you just can't.
We haven't found a voice for that yet.
Or maybe we've just ruled it out.
So that's why I did it.
So can you tell us all a little bit about said book?
I mean, how, so how did, no, but seriously,
so how did you pick, you know,
first tell us the working title
and then tell us the, you know, why, why this story?
What did you, what work did this story do for you?
Yeah, you know, thank you for asking that.
It came out of academic work, you know,
because I've always been fascinated
with things like accusations of witches
and with what, this was my question.
And I wrote about it in a book about the middle ages
and a book about a woman who actually does have visions,
lives today, has visions of the Virgin Mary
out in the Mojave Desert once a month.
And, you know, the first question
that goes in someone's mind
when you go watch someone have visions
is does she really see something?
And if so, what does she see?
And then how does she know what she's seeing
if she's the only one who sees it?
And how could she explain what she sees to others?
And how could they make sense of it
and decide whether she is seeing it,
whether it's good or bad or personal
or has meaning for others.
And you see all these snippets of information
in historical accounts.
You might read a chronicle and it says,
oh, there was a woman in this village
and she said she saw angels and, you know,
she confessed and now she doesn't see them
or she went away or something like that.
And you know, there was a whole big story there
about what she saw and how she came to understand it.
And that was a story I wanted to tell
after watching this modern visionary,
but I wanted to tell it about the place I know best,
which is early medieval Ireland
where everybody had visions, you know,
and you had druids making magic and it was cool.
And the only conflict was between kinds of magic,
Christian and not.
So that's the story.
It's called, right now it's called Beck Dreams of War.
Great title.
Thank you.
So Deb, can you tell us your move into fiction, please?
It's very similar to Lisa's, no surprise,
which is that, you know, as a historian,
I was trained to mind the gaps, right?
So historical records, even more so in Lisa's time,
perhaps than in my time,
they're not great at recording
those, the everyday details of life,
how you would, you know, what the herb women collected,
what the midwife did, what other things they did.
And so, you know, in my scholarship,
I just decided everything was,
I was taking everything as real, right?
So whether it was John Dee talking to angels
or a woman accused of witchcraft, it's a real thing.
It's a real thing to them
and it's a real thing to the people around them.
So for example, you know,
when John Dee went to Central Europe, to Bohemia
and met with representatives of the papacy,
no one tried to figure out if what he saw was real or not.
They all believed it was real.
They just wanted to know if they needed to prosecute him
or if he was dangerous to the Pope.
So, you know, it's, so if you take it that it's real,
you know, that led to my big question,
which was, okay, why are we so fascinated
with these supernatural preternatural beings like witches
and today and what if they were real?
And that's what led to, that was literally,
what if there really are witches and vampires and demons,
right, all the figures of sort of medieval,
early modern and modern lore, right?
To blame people, others to blame things on.
And it just, you know, it went from there.
And what I was fundamentally interested in was otherness,
was how all of these sort of icons of otherness
were so tightly woven into our lives,
were so meaningfully woven into our lives.
And what that says about us as a species,
I think human beings are attracted by otherness
and repelled by otherness.
Doesn't matter what otherness we're talking about.
Somebody who's neurologically diverse,
somebody who's disabled, somebody who's queer,
somebody who's trans,
somebody who's Catholic if you're Protestant,
someone who's Jewish if you're Christian
or Muslim if you're Christian,
we have all of the same impulses
and we are acting on them in modern.
This is not something that's like done and dusted
in 1692 in America.
Yeah, and you know what else?
I think we have room in our brains
no matter what we tell ourselves about religion
and science and enlightenment.
We have lots of room for fascination and desire
for a variety of the supernatural,
for religion and for other kinds of supernatural.
So, you see so many new groups interested
in practicing magic or in divination
or in astrology or various kinds of religion.
I mean, apparently a lot of younger people
are now interested in very conservative Catholicism,
particularly because of the panoply and the rituals.
So, I mean, we want it, we want it,
but we're also afraid of the people
who can master it and wield it, right?
Because they're not like us.
I mean, if we could do it, we wouldn't need them,
but we do need them because we want to know
why bad and good things are happening
and what bad or good things are gonna happen next.
And how to control them or protect ourselves, right?
Exactly, it's like weather forecasting.
Yeah.
We all rely on weather forecasts for good and ill.
Do I take my umbrella?
Do I not take my umbrella, right?
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
And this is just a basic thing.
In the early middle ages,
at least in the part of the world I study,
it wasn't take my umbrella or not.
It was say a protective prayer comes spell
before you go out into those hills
and depend on the skies not to get you wet
or to lose your animals or whatever, you know?
And they always had an element of spell casting.
Absolutely, and wearing amulets and doing ritual things
and whether it was to protect a grain,
but a grain harvest or a livestock or a sick child.
And again, these are all the things that feature
in the Malleus Maleficarum.
Yeah.
And they get associated with women
because women are associated with transforming
so many of these things.
Yeah, I've been thinking about this.
I mean, we attribute the focus on women
to certain developments
in the later middle ages, early modern period.
But there's a trend, for example, in Celtic culture,
something about women's words,
women's ability to make magic with words.
And there are these inscriptions
from like the second or first century of the common era
about brictubon, women's words,
which turn up later in medieval literature.
You know, there's a prayer to St. Patrick.
Patrick, protect me from the spells of women and smiths,
metalsmiths and druids.
Three powerful classes.
All three of which create and destroy.
Yep, yep.
So I wanna jump in.
Again, this is, I think, a common thread.
Yeah, yeah.
And always women.
I mean, I thought initially it wasn't,
but it really was always women can do these things.
But they don't emerge as witches
until much, much later.
So let me jump in with a quick question
and then I'm gonna open,
and then I have some questions from this audience.
My quick question though,
and Frank, I was reminded by the,
you know, it's gonna rain, take my umbrella,
is can you please talk a bit,
not at length, you don't have to,
but about broomsticks?
Because, you know, if there is one thing
that every witch seems to take with them,
you know, when they go out the door,
it seems to be a broomstick.
So, I mean, can you put that into historical,
cultural context for the audience, please?
Well, they rode on animals too.
The small livestock.
Yeah, goat.
Which women took care of
while the men were taking care of cows.
At the moment, if you walk down our street
here in Los Angeles,
the figures dressed as witches hanging trees
are not riding on pigs or sheep or horses,
they're riding on broomsticks.
So you can say at some point that became the thing,
but I'm just curious if you can talk about broomsticks.
Broomsticks, okay.
I'm gonna go back to the woman and the hearth
being the hub of life and death
in every home, everywhere, for all time.
And here's what you have to do with hearth spaces.
You have to brush the detritus out of it.
And then you sweep, where do you put it?
Well, the man is not coming with the recycling truck.
So you sweep it through the door.
You take this stuff and you sweep it out
through the door of your house into the street,
you brush it off your steps.
So they are tools of liminality
and it is the tool of the kitchen.
And it is the tool, they didn't know why,
but they knew that clean houses made for healthier people.
Not always, but they were certainly manic about cleaning.
We have this weird idea that they all lived in filth.
They were so obsessed with cleaning.
So again, the idea of sweeping something clean
so that something can grow is really important.
So I think it is the most essential
and humble kitchen tool other than fire itself.
And therefore it's a woman's tool
and it's just a symbol of all the work women did
to keep people alive and to help them in death.
You know, the artists of your period, Deb,
really picked up on that in their depictions
of witches and women riding those broomsticks
or wielding them around it.
It's so erotic in a vile way, right?
Like women riding Aristotle.
Yeah.
Don't go there.
No, but there's a similarity.
Yeah.
A woman on top, Natalie Zeman Davis, not good.
Exactly, yeah, that's it.
Okay, so let me just clarify for the audience.
Natalie Zeman Davis is good.
In fact, she's great.
She talks about this idea of a woman on top.
I just want to make sure we're a little clear
about sending the wrong message out to this audience.
Thank you, yes.
Another revered female historian who did much to explain
the operations of misogyny and superstition
and disbelief in early modern culture.
And certainly a powerful magic maker and pretty.
Exactly.
Absolutely, I want to bring in some of the questions
that have come, but there are a lot coming in.
I'm gonna start with a very straightforward question
from Kimberly, who asks,
where did the idea of black cats and witchcraft come from?
I'm going back to the cauldron and the hearth.
If you want a clean home,
I think you have cats because they eat mice and rats.
So, you know, that's important.
And the black or the gray cat,
I think it's just associated with darkness, right?
And cats are mysterious, right?
You can't really figure out why they do what they do
and they go all over the place.
But they had other familiars, right?
All sorts of things.
Yep.
Toads.
The occasional dog.
Birds.
The occasional dog.
Yeah.
Okay, thanks.
I mean, as a companion of two dogs
who are terrified by cats,
I'm certainly happy to agree that they can be scary.
Let me turn to a somewhat different kind of question.
This is from Maureen.
And here's the question.
Since literacy and the spread of new ideas,
as well as increased exposure to the other,
were the province of an economic and educational minority,
do we assume that the definition of persecution of women
was engineered by that class?
Could there have been an economic component
to witch hunting?
I'm not sure what the answer is.
I would sort of disagree.
I disagree that this was limited to a certain class.
If you were a shoemaker working in London
and a trip, a ship from the Mediterranean put in,
all kinds of others poured out of it.
You didn't need to be on that ship.
You didn't need to own that ship.
You didn't need to go to Africa or the Middle East
to experience otherness of that sort.
And again, print culture, broadsides, posters,
illustrations that come off the printing press,
there's a lot of ways in which this was available
to people of all classes.
Now, there could still be an economic motivation
for accusing your neighbor,
but it's not an engineered thing.
It is what's happening in culture.
And it's, I mean, I can see where this question comes from
because you emphasize, Deb, the Malleus Maleficarum,
a printed manual by educated inquisitors,
but you need some groundswell of suspicion
and distrust and anger to motivate those prosecutors.
And anxiety.
Yes.
And it seems to be one,
I don't know if you still agree with this approach to it,
Deb, but there's one argument
that as the process became even more judicial,
it became essentially more fair and rational
and witch trials halted eventually because of this.
Right, but not a belief in witches.
Not a belief in witches.
Because witchcraft and anxiety go hand in hand.
And I think we can look at our own time
and modern versions of evil, witches, or others,
and know that profound societal and cultural anxiety
leads to wild accusations against people
who used to be your very nice next-door neighbor
and it's now the other.
Yeah.
And then there are sort of the cultural swells
of interest in magic
and being able to control outside forces, right?
I mean, I'm not a modernist,
so I'm totally confused by these trends
in the 19th and 20th century,
but the rise of spiritualism that came hand in hand
with the rise of certain technologies,
and then the revival of witchcraft, formal witchcraft,
and then the creation of all these various neo-pagan groups.
I mean, I find that fascinating
that it occurred in co-evolution with various technologies
and anxieties about that.
Okay, so-
Yeah, and-
Oh, sorry, sorry, Deb, sorry.
No, I was just gonna say, you know,
and today the fascination with conspiracy theories, right?
It's anxiety about why are bad things happening to me
and who is to blame for them?
And they use words like cabal,
which is a magical term, you know,
to describe the people who they believe are responsible.
So this is just unfortunately human nature
and history shows us that it cycles through
every now and again, you know?
And it can't be, I mean, people always look back
to previous constructs for their accusations, right?
So, you know, accusing women and others of incest
or cannibalism or, you know, that kind of stuff.
I mean, there's a long, long tradition
of those very accusations against people
who are feared and distrusted.
Killing babies.
I've heard that about Christians, actually.
Yeah, Jews, witches, killing babies.
Yeah.
This is a, you know, this is a pretty long tradition
and led to, you know, a lot of death.
So I would just encourage everybody to reflect on that.
Yeah, yeah.
Okay, another question.
This is from Leah.
Why would women be accused of witchcraft for healing people
when men doing alchemical researches
were still able to enter national science societies?
This person goes on to say,
what were the boundaries of magic in the early modern era?
There were none except in the eye of the beholder.
I always say magic like beauty is in the eye of the beholder
and there are no differences.
And it's, you know, women were not welcome
in formal medical guilds and practices.
They were not able to be apothecaries.
They were not able to be surgeons.
They were not able to become physicians.
Yeah, yeah.
They provided all the same services.
And in fact, you know as well as I
that in the later middle ages
when women were still public healers, legitimate ones,
some were brought to trial for, you know,
things that failed, cases that failed
and for actually trying to co-opt activities
they shouldn't be practicing.
Yes, let us never forget that in early modern
and medieval medicine, you contracted for a cure.
So if you were not cured,
you could take somebody to court for breach of contract
and they did because they were very litigious
and knew the law.
So it's like having a suing your contractor
because they don't actually finish building your house.
Well, from one litigious society to our litigious society,
here's a question that comes in, which is,
well, I'm just gonna read it to you.
It comes from Erica who writes in,
it strikes me, that would be Erica,
that many social media quote unquote influencers
are spellcasting through the process of manifestation
and positive thinking.
Erica would love to hear more about your thoughts
on how spellcasting appears in modern culture.
What a cool question.
Because, you know, I was just talking about magic
and technology or religion and technology.
I draw, as Deb says, we draw the lines, you know, ourselves.
And I, yeah, I don't know what to say,
except that I expect it's absolutely the case.
And I wonder if it works in practical terms
and I have to try it.
Well, I definitely think the cell phone
is the crystal ball or scrying device of modern times.
I think that casts a spell on us,
has enormous status as a thing that we hold in our hand
and it gives us visions of things that are often unreal.
Speaking of social media, you know,
but there we are scrolling anyway.
So, you know, I think it's not fair to just blame this
maybe on social media influencers.
I think musicians cast spells.
I think because they elicit an emotional response.
I think newscasters.
I think politicians.
I think movie stars, you know,
there's all kinds of people who hold power
in our collective cultural identity.
And I think that is the same.
What does visuality have to do with it, you know?
I mean, I have, I'm watching this woman out in the desert
who sees the Virgin Mary and people come to watch her
and they take photographs,
which they interpret for signs of the supernatural.
But the thing is they come with the latest cameras.
You know, people think sometimes that those who believe
in magic or the supernatural of various kinds,
that they're sort of anti-science, but absolutely not.
I mean, these folks in the desert
are using the latest technology to prove
that the Virgin Mary comes to the desert.
Okay, we are gonna be wrapping up fairly soon,
but there's one question.
I wonder if you could,
I hesitate to say this because it's a giant question,
but we have very little time.
But I'm gonna ask the question anyway.
Just if you could be brief.
It's from someone, I don't know the name.
What role did the transition, as this person puts it,
of nature-based religious traditions
to monotheistic religions headed by men
play in the persecution of women
and accusations of witchcraft?
I realize you could write a book about that,
but we have a minute.
Go.
Huge.
Yeah.
Huge.
I mean, once women were not allowed to be religious leaders,
what do you expect?
They were still religious leaders.
It's just not officially.
Yeah.
What she said.
Yeah.
Okay, well, I think we're in our last minute
of this amazing, and for me,
completely enlightening and illuminating event.
Do you have any last thoughts
that you'd like to share with the audience?
We have, I think, less than a minute to go.
Lisa first, and then Deb.
Yeah, I mean, you can't get rid of belief
in the supernatural.
It's in your pockets like lint.
Okay, Deb.
Women in power has always been a volatile combination,
and we've always had it.
And also, just as a postscript,
Lisa, we gotta team teach a course.
Yeah, it'd be so much fun.
Oh my gosh.
Oh my God, we've got to team teach a course.
And show movies about witches.
On that note, as we plug
what would no doubt be the most popular course ever at USC,
I wanna take an opportunity to thank my brilliant colleagues,
Lisa Battelle and Deb Harkness,
for sharing their views on witchcraft today.
And with that, I think we are done for the day.
Thank you so much for joining us.
Thank you, Peter.
