The Ancient Secret of the Fairies

Legendary Creatures
4 followers
Who really are the Fae?
What do we know about their world and their societies?
And how did old beliefs in fairies shape the daily lives of ordinary people?
#Mythology #BeastsoftheOldeWorld #mythicalcreatures #mythsandlegends #ancientfolklore
If you asked your average person what a fairy looks like,
they would probably imagine something like this.
But they'd be wrong.
Most people would probably say that fairies are playful and mischievous magical creatures.
But they'd be wrong too.
In fact, the iconic tiny Tinkerbell-style fairy is a fairly modern and romanticised image that
comes straight out of Victorian literature.
Despite being described in multiple other ways,
the tiny winged nymph has become the fairy default,
a cliche only deepened by modern depictions in fantasy media,
but very, very far from the fairies that the people of the past knew so well.
But if they're not like this, then what are they really like?
What do we know about their world and their societies?
And how did old beliefs in fairies shape the daily lives of ordinary people?
Join me to find out all this and more in another episode of Beasts of the Old World.
When it comes to the fae, most people have a very clear image in their mind as to what they look
like, how they behave and the sort of thing that they get up to.
More or less, everybody agrees.
The image is nothing short of iconic.
It's hard-baked into our collective consciousness,
so much so that even many modern spiritualists and believers picture a similar sort of creature.
And yet, in a dictionary of fairies, the great Catherine Briggs tells us that
The word fairy covers a large area.
The Anglo-Saxon and Scandinavian Elves,
the Dene Y'shee of the Highlands,
the Tuatha Dé Danann of Ireland,
the Tulworth Teg of Wales,
the Seelie and Unseelie Court,
the Weefolk and Good Neighbours,
and many others.
The Trooping Fairies and the Solitary Fairies are included in it,
the Fairies of human or more than human size,
the Three-Foot Fairies and the Tiny Fairies,
the Domestic Fairies and those that are wild and alien to man,
the Subterranean Fairies and the Water Fairies that own locks, streams or the sea.
The Supernatural Hags, Monsters and Bobbies might be considered to belong to a different category.
And there are, of course, fairy animals to be considered.
The point here is that the term fairy is something of an umbrella term.
It doesn't just point to one single specific creature,
but rather a family of creatures,
all different or unique,
and most of them having very little to do with the tiny winged fairy that we now know so well.
But Briggs's definition comes from 1976, just 50 years ago.
What if we were to look back deeper into the past?
What do the oldest texts about fairies have to say about them?
The Secret Commonwealth of Elves, Fauns and Fairies was written by Robert Kirk
nearly 350 years ago in the late 17th century,
though it wasn't published until two centuries later in 1893.
While not the oldest text to reference fairy belief,
the book is fairly unique in that it sets about explicitly trying to explain what it calls
the nature and actions of the subterranean and, for the most part,
invisible people of elves, fauns and fairies.
Very few other texts seek to do this,
which is why fairy lore is generally compiled from different accounts of
individual encounters or stories that have been handed down orally, perhaps for generations,
almost always subject to many unknown changes, omissions and embellishments
from the many unknown tellers across the ages.
Kirk's short book is therefore unique in the sense that it gives us a singular and specific account
of what fairy belief looked like in Scotland at the time of Kirk's writing.
What the book reveals is genuinely eye-opening.
Even from Kirk's own description of the work, two things become clear immediately.
The Fae were, more often than not, invisible to ordinary people,
and they were known to live underground.
Those who could see the Fae were said to have second sight,
and even those people were limited to seeing these strange beings
at certain times of the day, as we'll see later.
Far from the tiny winged creature of modern fantasy,
Kirk describes the Fae as being somewhere between men and angels,
similar to, but distinct from, how demons were once thought of.
He says that they are intelligent spirits with forms that can change,
and can even appear and disappear at will,
being made of a substance somewhat similar to condensed cloud.
Kirk tells us that they are not all of the same nature, and that
Some of them have bodies or forms so airy, thin and delicate,
that they survive only by absorbing fine,
spirituous liquids as light as pure air and oil.
Others feed in a more substantial way,
drawing nourishment from the essence of grains and drinks,
or even consuming corn directly from the earth.
This latter type of fairy was therefore notorious for stealing food,
sometimes invisibly, but sometimes in the guise of a mouse or a crow.
This type of fairy seemed to be of a more corporeal nature,
and could sometimes be heard at work in the small hills that they were said to inhabit.
And yet, Kirk goes on, they have more common guises too.
He tells us that
Their clothing and speech is like that of the people and the country under which they live.
In the Scottish islands they're seen wearing plaid and multicoloured garments,
while in Ireland they wear swannocks.
This is a very interesting point in that it seems to indicate that the Fae
deliberately mirror human cultural dress,
possibly so as to blend in easily, but potentially for other reasons too as we'll see later.
It leaves us with a few thoughts,
first that the Fae are deliberately deceptive and masters of subterfuge,
and second that this means that if you were to see a fairy,
then you might not notice them as being different from a regular human being at all.
In fact, Kirk goes so far as to say that in some cases, usually at funerals,
fairies could appear as what he calls double-men,
supernatural counterparts of living people that are identical to them
in basically every way except for certain subtle signs and secret tokens,
distinguishable only by those with a good command of the second sight.
All this sets us on a very curious path.
Here we have creatures that are not strictly spirits and not strictly human,
something in between the two.
They're beings who, despite being invisible to most people most of the time,
are also able to change their appearance at will
so as to match the people or creatures that might live in the area.
Kirk is clear that they live underground and yet equally clearly paints the Fae
as beings that inhabit a plane of existence that is generally inaccessible to humans.
These are curious powers and behaviours.
What's the use of shapeshifting if you're invisible in the first place?
And why bother to dress and imitate local humans
when you could just slip among them invisibly and unnoticed anyway?
According to Kirk, the answer to these questions may lie deep in the past,
back in a time where humans were not so abundant as they are today.
In chapter 2 of his work he says,
Now that humans have so densely settled all lands,
we unknowingly work for these hidden people as well as for ourselves.
However, before the land was fully occupied by humans,
the Faeries had easy access to tillable land above ground, just as we do now.
The traces of their ancient furrows can still be seen on the slopes of high hills
from a time when the lowlands were covered in thick forests.
This seems to imply that once, when humans were not so many,
we once lived among the Fae as neighbours.
Kirk is never explicit, but it's also hard not to get the impression from the text that
the Fae seem to resent humans for our occupation of land that they consider theirs.
This might go some way to explaining their more modern reputation as thieves and
harmful mischief-makers, while in their minds they may only be taking what is rightfully theirs.
Perhaps this is why they choose not to appear most of the time.
Our own abundance has made their lives difficult,
and not just in the sense that we now control the land that they once farmed themselves,
but also in the form of a curious rule that Kirk asserts to be true.
When we have plenty, they have scarcity at their arms, and on the contrary.
Why this should be the case, he doesn't say, but he does point out that when the Fae have stolen
from a store of grain, the store will appear to humans to be of a much greater volume than
what it really is. The grain's still there, the stack still looks full, but when it's
threshed or used, it produces far less than it should. This shortfall is blamed on the Fae folk
having secretly taken the essence or value of the crop. Faerie theft is therefore invisible,
but measurable. Well, at least in some cases. The Fae are also known for stealing more than
just grain. The topic is too dark for YouTube, but if you do want to learn more about changelings,
then click the link in the description to join the Old World Patreon,
and watch the exclusive episode on one of the more sinister aspects of faerie lore.
Despite claiming that faerie theft is generally invisible, Kirk also reports a number of means
by which their stolen goods are delivered to the other world. He says,
What they take from humans is transported back to their homes through hidden pathways.
Some are said to accomplish this by drawing milk from a distant cow through a hair tether,
or by pulling a spigot attached to a post, causing milk to flow from an unseen source.
Cheese made from such stolen milk is said to float in water like a cark.
It was also believed that the Fae lived in a society comparable to ours, with ranks, groups,
and a hierarchy, and Kirk reports that those with the second sight have often reported seeing
the Fae hold their own marriages and funerals. It must also be pointed out, though, that Kirk
does anticipate the possibility that they perform these rites to mock our own customs,
a suspicion that paints their dressing in human clothing in a very different light indeed.
He also describes their homes to us, large and beautiful,
and lit with bright lights from fuelless fires. All this makes the Fair Folk fairly unique.
Most mythical creatures are presented in tales as isolated encounters that are used
primarily to explain single strange events. So why were the Fae treated differently?
Why did they have society and civilization when Boggarts, for example, did not?
To answer that, we need to talk about who Robert Kirk was, and why he wrote this book.
Robert Kirk was a late 17th century Scottish minister. He was also a Protestant who,
while not being a folklorist in the modern academic sense, was keen to record the many
widely held Highland beliefs, with a view to classifying the Fae within Christian cosmology.
Now, Kirk isn't doing this for his own amusement, and it's clear that he takes the witness accounts
very seriously indeed, but neither is he advocating for some sort of pagan revival.
This is a very devout Protestant minister trying to reconcile and systematize old Highland beliefs
about the Fae within a Christian intellectual framework. This is important for a number of
reasons, not least because within early modern Christian thought, supernatural beings were
expected to belong to a coherent hierarchy of creation. Angels, demons, human souls,
animals, and all the visible world all had a defined space within that hierarchy,
but the Fae didn't fit cleanly into any recognized category. Some believed that they were the souls
of the dead, others thought they were wandering spirits, most classified them as devils or demons,
and many dismissed them entirely as delusion or fantasy. But nobody could agree.
Kirk's solution was unusual. Unlike many of his contemporaries, he refused to collapse the Fae
into demons or wandering souls, insisting that they were instead something somewhere between
men and angels. In other words, the Fae were not misidentified devils, they were a class
unto themselves, and a distinct order of beings. By defining the Fae as a parallel order of creation,
separate from ghosts, demons, spirits, or souls, Kirk stabilized a theological tension that had
troubled early modern thinkers for a long time. Now, the Fae could exist in a way that did not
contradict Christian cosmology. But theology was only part of the pressure.
There were practical concerns as well. Kirk needed a coherent explanation for what appeared to be
recurring patterns of Fae behavior. Repeated crop failure or theft, injuries to livestock,
sudden illness, disappearances, and unexplained deaths. These didn't appear random, and in
agricultural communities especially, they had a material consequence. A series of bad harvests
could mean the end for an entire community. Explaining these away as random events simply
just wasn't good enough to those communities. A single mischievous sprite might explain one
isolated incident, but it can't really explain the recurring loss of food or crops, or when
harvests were not as yielding as they appeared to be. A migrating, organized people competing
with us invisibly for resources seemed a much better explanation. And we know that folk believe
this to be the case because Kirk gives us anecdotal evidence of how belief in the Fae
shaped the daily routines of those who lived in the highlands at that time.
But why did ordinary people and entire communities organize their lives around beings they could
rarely see? The first point to note is that the common Christian depiction of Faeries as nothing
more than demons and servants of Satan certainly had an impact on how people felt about them.
For a long time it was the case that folk both retained their belief in the Fae while also
accepting Christianity as their religion. Even before Christian thinkers painted the Fae in a
demonic light, Faeries were already seen as a tricksy bunch anyway, being known for operating
in ways that do not seem governed by anything that we ourselves would recognize as morals or ethics.
To take one notorious example, the Fae were known for their ability to permanently disable humans
they noticed were aware of them. Kirk says,
With a painless puff of wind they can instantly strip a person of both natural and supernatural
sight, leaving them permanently blind or even striking them dumb.
It shouldn't be a surprise to learn therefore that there was a great deal of suspicion,
anxiety and sometimes straight up fear of the Fae folk. The additional label of demon
only served to deepen these concerns.
Just as the Fae were more likely to be seen at dusk, the liminal time between day and night,
Kirk tells us that the Fae were believed to move at fixed points in the year.
At the start of each season they relocate to new dwellings, wandering endlessly until the
end of time, unable to stay in one place. They seem to find some relief in their constant traveling,
their chameleon-like bodies drift near the ground, carrying their belongings as they move.
At these seasonal changes, those with second sights, or rarely women, experience terrifying
encounters with them, even along roadsides. For this reason, people who can perceive them
avoid traveling alone during these times. Kirk is not explicit but it seems likely
that these times of the year were also the liminal moments or traditional quarter days
of the Gaelic calendar. Samhain in early November, Imlk in early February, Beltane in early May and
Lunashir in August. At the turning of each quarter, these beings were said to travel across
the land in great numbers, and seers reported frightening encounters on the roads at precisely
these times, and so people adjusted. Unless you were in great need to travel, you would not do so
on these days, and certainly not alone. In fact, these migrations affected people so much that
it has even become customary among the Scottish Irish to attend church every first Sunday of the
quarter, believing that this will protect them, their crops and their cattle from the harmful
magic and thievery of these wandering spirits. Many of the more superstitious people will not
return to church again until the next quarter begins, as if the only purpose of worship were
to shield themselves from unseen dangers. Kirk also notes that many refused to taste
food at funerals or large gatherings because those with the second sight claimed that the
also attended such events, and they were afraid that
they might unknowingly dine with fairies or be poisoned by them.
The Fae's reputation was such that folk took all manner of preparations against them.
When women were in labour, for example, objects of protection were placed in their beds.
Cold iron specifically was believed to repel these beings that
otherwise could not be resisted. We will look at why this was the case in a future video.
Perhaps most tellingly, Kirk is very keen to stress that the second sight itself was not
celebrated. Those who possessed it were often disturbed by it. Kirk describes seers who were
frightened and in some cases deeply disturbed by sudden apparitions. It wasn't treated as a gift
to be cultivated. The Fae, after all, were a mysterious and scary class of creature.
Even when they appeared to laugh or be merry, Kirk likens their smiles to
the grinning of a skull, as if they are merely acting out of joy than truly feeling it.
So whatever we make of the belief itself, the response to it was consistent.
People adjusted their behaviour. They marked their calendars and avoided travel at certain
times of the year. They guarded their homes and their beds with iron that they knew the Fae
couldn't abide. They sometimes refused to eat at funerals, and they often interpreted illnesses
and death, along with crop failures, afflicted livestock and other general misfortunes,
within a structured system of Faerie Belief. And that perhaps is the most important point of all.
Whatever we think of Faerie Belief today, the people of Kirk's Scotland didn't treat the Fae
as the playful, harmless sprites we think of now. As far as they were concerned, the Fae
were neighbours. Invisible, unpredictable and often downright evil, but neighbours nonetheless.
They were believed to inhabit the same hills, the same roads, the same fields. They competed
for the same grain. They crossed the same thresholds at the same turning points of the year.
They attended the same funerals. And they moved through the same landscape.
And that landscape wasn't a fantasy realm. It wasn't somewhere you found within the pages of a
book. It was home. What does that say about our place in the world all those years ago?
How strange and grand and mysterious. How terrifying it must once have been.
The tiny, winged figure of the Victorian imagination is small, sentimental and very safe.
But Kirk's Fae are organised and invisible. They have their own customs and movements.
They have their own will and a moral code that we cannot possibly hope to understand.
They resent us, they compete with us for food and they steal it whenever they so please.
They can injure us whenever they want to and they're always watching.
That alone should make us pause the next time we see a tiny Tinkerbell-style figure
fluttering and smiling in the margins at the edge of a children's story.
Hi folks, thank you for watching this episode. Please give us a thumbs up if you enjoyed it
and if you want to learn more about the Fae, hit subscribe and set notifications to catch
the next part of this miniseries when it comes. In the meantime, why not watch another creature
feature from our archive or check out our new channel, Myths of the Old World, where we dive
deep into classical mythology from the Old Norse, the Ancient Greeks and from Arthurian legend as
well as much much more. The link's in the description as is the link to the Old World
Patreon page where you can watch everything from every Old World channel completely ad-free
plus get access to exclusive content that you can't watch anywhere else.
Thanks again and I'll catch you in the next one.
