Interpreting Chinese Landscape Painting - Curator Kevin R.E. Greenwood

Chinese Literature & Culture
83 followers
9 Video Views·Sep 21, 2025
The subject of landscape painting seems clear: images of scenic, natural vistas laid out before the viewer. Throughout the long history of such works in China, however, landscape paintings were rarely about a specific location, and typically not about the land at all. In this video (11:57), which features works from the Allen's collection and others, Kevin R.E. Greenwood, Joan L. Danforth Curator of Asian Art, highlights some of the varying ways Chinese landscape paintings can be understood.
Made possible with generous support of a Freeman Asian Arts and Culture Initiative grant from the Freeman Foundation.
Landscapes. The subject seems pretty straightforward. Images of the natural world,
usually vast vistas stretching off into the distance. In China, landscape was one of the
most important painting subjects with a history stretching back as far as the 4th century
and with a tremendous diversity of painters and styles. However, landscape painting in China was
rarely just about the land. Some of the earliest surviving landscapes are found in the Mogao
caves at Dunhuang, an ancient Buddhist site in western China. In these early paintings,
like this mural dating to the 6th century, landscapes were simply there to provide a setting,
a backdrop for the story or lesson the painting was made to tell. Note how the landscape here is
also used to break up the different parts of the story. By the 10th century, landscapes were
appreciated by themselves as, in part, representations of the natural world. This work, Travelers Among
Mountains and Streams by Fan Kuan, is one of the most famous examples and is over six and a half
feet tall. Such paintings, large and immersive and originally often mounted on screens,
were designed to create a kind of virtual reality for viewers. Artists went out into the wilderness,
made sketches, and returned to their studios to create paintings that were not images of specific
locations, but were instead intended to convey an almost mystical experience of the landscape
to viewers. In these paintings, the immensity and majesty of nature was contrasted with
the insignificance of human beings, usually tiny figures seen going about daily activities.
At the time, this natural hierarchy of towering mountains, hills, trees, rivers, and finally humans
was understood to symbolize the political hierarchy, with the massive mountain a stand-in
for the emperor. If large immersive paintings were one way of suggesting the experience of
being in the landscape, another related to a painting format developed in China, the hand
scroll. Unlike large screens or hanging scrolls that could be viewed by a group, hand scrolls were
a more personal experience. Viewers could move through the space, rolling and unrolling the scroll
section by section, pausing or moving seamlessly forward or backward at their own pace, as if
actually traveling through the landscape. This unique format added an element of time to the
viewer's experience of the painting. As we move through this complex and colorful landscape hand
scroll, notice how the scene changes from filling the space with immense mountain forms to fading
away into the distance. It is almost like a piece of music, sometimes loud, sometimes quiet, varying
in volume and complexity. Even though this painting is from the 17th to 18th centuries, it has
connections to the past. Like the earliest landscapes, it uses rich, bold colors of blue and green,
a color scheme that, in paintings done in later periods, was used to suggest magical, faraway
places, escapist visions of imagined rural utopias where viewers could retreat for a moment
from the cares of their daily lives. However, unlike the earlier images where the tiny human
figures were often busy at work, leading pack horses or carrying firewood, in these later
paintings the figures were often elite gentlemen accompanied by a servant. This was exactly the type
of person with the means to own such a painting, members of the educated elite known as scholar
officials or literati who were part of the imperial government and who had wealth and power.
In fact, images of scholars in the landscape became a regular, almost expected part of Chinese
landscape painting. But what are they doing exactly? Most often, as seen in this 15th century example,
the figure is not working or farming or traveling, but pausing and looking and experiencing the natural
world. And we, as viewers, are sharing in their experience, seeing the world of the painting
through them. But there is another way of understanding Chinese landscape painting.
In the late 13th to mid 14th centuries, China was part of the vast Mongol empire that stretched
from Eastern Europe to Korea, the largest land empire in history. During this time, many members
of the Chinese scholarly elite could not or chose not to serve the Mongol emperor. Some of them
turned to landscape painting, usually combined with poetry and calligraphy, to express themselves.
These landscape paintings became more about the expressive potential of painting than about
representing places or nature. In this work, the painter Ni Zhan's very austere landscape
is really a kind of self-portrait, here conveying the painter's loneliness and sadness.
An isolated group of trees stretch up from a rocky outcropping. Their sketch-like quality
was a deliberate choice by the artist, painted in a way that suggests they were done quickly,
in a moment of spontaneous expression. The trees seem to reach across a body of water toward
distant mountains. For Ni Zhan, those mountains represented happiness at the time far away from
the artist after the recent death of his wife. The inscription, written by the artist in an
style of calligraphy, reads,
On the riverbank, the evening tide begins to fall. The frost-covered leaves of the wind-blown
grove are sparse. I lean on my staff. The brushwood gate is closed and silent. I think
of my friend. The glow is nearly gone from the hills. At the end, he writes that he made this
painting for his friend, Shengbo. That dedication, and the many red seals of later collectors who
own the painting, point to the importance of these paintings in networks of scholars,
as well as to their continuing importance as works of art and as objects of great value.
As they continue to evolve in the next few centuries, something very interesting happened
with one type of landscape painting that took them even further away from representing the land.
Let's compare Ni Zhan's work with another by Wang Yuanqi from nearly 350 years later.
They are dramatically similar, but why? As early as the 15th century, literati painters began to
create a secret expressive language in their paintings by imitating the styles, compositions,
and even special brushstrokes that were connected with earlier painters. By painting in the manner
of a past artist, they were associating themselves with that artist's character, an idea that has
its roots in copying the calligraphy of early masters, and by doing so, embodying their virtues.
Wang's work is in the manner of Ni Zhan, and he credits him in his inscription, writing,
Master Ni's brush is incomparably marvelous. From his compositions to his brushstrokes,
there is no area in which he is not deep and concentrated. Although there were many types
of painting in China, even many types of landscape painting, this particular style
of landscape favored by the educated elite became the most respected and was considered
the official or orthodox style of traditional landscape painting. In this spectacular work,
Wang Jian creates a landscape carefully laid out before us with a foreground, middle, and background,
and a central axis that draws the viewer up through the painting. Wang's inscription states
that the work is in the style of the 13th, 14th century painter Zhao Mengfu, although it has
elements from other masters as well. Painters in China have continued to study and master this
literati mode of painting down to the present, and today it provides a stylistic choice for artists
who may also be expert in other styles. This painting by the modern painter Liu Haishu is a
fine example. Simple buildings nestled in among trees, a boat on water, a bridge, the mountains
at the top are done with carefully layered dots, a technique connected with the 11th century painter
Meifu. The painting is firmly a part of the literati tradition. Yet Liu Haishu is best known
as a pioneer in modern Chinese art, one of the first Chinese painters to master oil painting,
as seen in this work The Cockfight from 1940. Instead, Liu chose to paint in this most traditional
style during a period in the 1960s and 70s known as the Cultural Revolution, when artists were
expected to paint in modern styles with overt political messages, like this painting of a
also from the early 1970s. Always an iconoclast, Liu chose this style at a time when anything
traditional was seen as counter-revolutionary. His defiant dedication to tradition and respect for
the long cultural heritage of landscape paintings seen in this work and others,
led to his brutal suppression. He survived the suppressive period, perhaps in part,
by escaping in his mind, like generations before him, to the blue and green landscapes of places
and times far away. If landscape paintings in earlier periods represented imperial power,
escape, cultural solidarity, elite status, or the inspiration people found in the natural world,
in the hands of Liu Haishu it could also be a statement of resistance, a commitment to a long
Chinese cultural heritage, one that he valued and suffered personally to preserve.
