This video investigates the unusual delay in announcing social security contribution bases across Chinese provinces in 2025. Typically set mid-year, these bases have surged beyond GDP growth, far exceeding minimum wages—like Shanghai’s 7,384 yuan base against a 2,740 yuan wage. Only five provinces have announced new bases, with most delaying, possibly due to declining real wages, public resentment over mandatory contributions, and fears of unrest or economic fallout. The system’s flaws are evident: only 34.1% of businesses fully comply, burdened by high labor costs. Past real estate booms tied to contributions inflated bases, but misused pension funds and fiscal pressures now limit reforms. Japan’s 1990s experience offers lessons, yet entrenched interests hinder change. Continued pressure risks public backlash or economic decline as businesses cut jobs to cope. #SocialSecurity#EconomicCrisis#GovernmentGreed
Help me grow the channel by donating any amount through the link below—your support makes a difference! https://paypal.me/DonXiang
Hi, I'm Dongsheng. Welcome to Digging into China, where we explore China in depth to
review unique perspectives. This year, an unusual situation has emerged.
The social security contribution base in many Chinese provinces has been delayed. Typically
by mid-year, regions across the country announce the new social security base wage, which usually
increases by a few percentage points annually. Over time, it's become clear that the rise
in China's social security base far outpaces GDP growth. For instance, in Shanghai, the
minimum wage is just 2,740 yuan, yet the social security base stands at 7,384 yuan. The stark
disparity between these figures highlights the government's excessive demands, which
are hard to ignore. This year, however, things are different.
So far, only five provinces, Hebei, Inner Mongolia, Heilongjiang, Fujian, and Hunan,
have released their new social security bases. Inner Mongolia's base remained unchanged
from last year. Hebei saw a slight decrease, while the other three provinces raised theirs
significantly. Why, then, have the remaining provinces and
cities delayed their announcements? In this episode, we'll explore the reasons behind
these delays in depth. Why do local governments increase the social
security base so aggressively each year, and what justification do they provide?
Officially, the process is meant to be rational and evidence-based. By Chinese regulations,
the social security base is tied to the previous year's average social wage in each region.
If the average wage rises, so does the base. But how is this average wage calculated? It's
a weighted average of wages from urban, non-private, and private sectors.
For example, imagine a city with 5 million non-private sector workers earning an average
of 120,000 yuan annually, and 10 million private sector workers earning 60,000 yuan annually.
The formula would be 120,000 x 5,000,000 plus 60,000 x 10,000,000 divided by 15,000,000
equals to 80,000 yuan per year. From this, an upper limit 300% of the base and a lower
limit 60% of the base are set, resulting in a monthly social security contribution range
of 4,000 yuan to 20,000 yuan. In practice, local governments have their
statistics bureaus release the prior year's average wage data, followed by the Human Resource
Department announcing the new base. Consider the five provinces that have published
their bases this year. In Heilongjiang, for example, the 2024 average monthly social wage
was reported as 7,570 yuan, leading to a new minimum contribution base of 4,542 yuan, an
8% increase from last year, far exceeding GDP growth. Given Heilongjiang's economic
conditions, this average wage figure seems highly inflated. It's clear the local government
is reluctant to relinquish the substantial revenue from social security tax.
Likewise, Hunan and Fujian have raised their contribution bases this year, with increases
that surpass GDP growth, reflecting a pattern of unchecked ambition by these governments.
Hebei, however, stands out as the only province to lower its base, reporting a 2024 average
wage drop of 151 yuan compared to the previous year, with the social security base adjusted
downward accordingly. Hebei's government deserves some credit here. They could have
manipulated the number to show a wage increase, but instead made a small concession to public
welfare, foregoing additional revenue. The varying social security policies across
regions reveal which local governments show even a hint of compassion. Zhejiang, for instance,
calculates its minimum wage using data from two years prior rather than the previous year,
resulting in a lower wage figure that reduces the social security burden on businesses and
individuals. Similarly, Beijing and Fujian distinguish
between enterprises and government institutions, setting a lower base for businesses and a
higher one for public institutions, which typically have higher incomes. Averaging them
together would inflate the base for those outside the public sector. So this approach
eases some of the pressure on private sector workers.
Looking at recent trends, Shanghai's base rose by just 1% last year, a relatively restrained
move. Generally, in China's more developed regions, local governments tend to be slightly
less burdensome, though only marginally so, compared to other parts of the country. This
might seem a little more reasonable, but it remains far from the standards of a truly
equitable system. So why have local governments delayed their
social security base announcements by two months this year? What are they hesitating
about? The reasons are not hard to discern. First, real wages have likely declined, and
while governments could fabricate figures to justify raising the base, the public would
see through it. Second, a recent Supreme Court ruling on
social security has fueled widespread discontent, with many now resentful of mandatory contributions.
Third, there is a limit to how much pressure people can endure. Excessive demands could
drive citizens to protest, increasing costs for maintaining stability. Even without the
protests, raising the base too high could backfire. Businesses unable to afford contributions
might close, leading to unemployment and reduced government revenue. Alternatively, companies
might avoid hiring full-time workers, especially young ones, opting instead for retirees or
part-timers, further shrinking social security collections. Raising the base doesn't guarantee
revenue. It must align with what people can realistically afford.
On August 29, FiveOne Social Security, a third-party agency under Zhonghe Group, released the 2025
China Enterprise Social Security White Paper. It found that 61% of Chinese companies have
labor costs exceeding 30% of their total costs, and only 34.1% fully comply with social
security regulations. This underscores the immense burden social security places on businesses.
Most companies in China seek ways to avoid contributions, and after all these years,
only one-third comply faithfully. This points to a fundamentally flawed system, one that
society rejects because it exceeds what businesses and workers can bear.
This explains the intense backlash to the Supreme Court's push for mandatory contributions.
It implies that two-thirds of Chinese companies could face lawsuits over social security compliance.
How many will collapse under this pressure? To survive, some may exploit policy loopholes
such as hiring retirees, reducing full-time staff, or cutting wages. But how does this
benefit China's economy?
The exorbitant social security bases far exceeding minimum wages trace back to the real estate
boom. Local governments driven by greed linked contributions to property purchases, reaping
huge profits. To buy a home in a city, you had to pay social security for several years.
When property prices soared, people complied, as contributions could be offset by rising
home values. Governments exploited this, raising bases year after year. Now with property prices
falling, the bases remain sky high. Essentially, governments collected a massive tax in advance.
But those funds have been spent. Even if they wanted to lower the bases to ease the burden,
fiscal constraints make it difficult.
This year, China's audit office exposed widespread mismanagement of social security
funds. Nearly every province has misused or misappropriated these funds, dipping into
them to cover salaries or debts. Nationwide, 40 billion yuan in pension funds have been
diverted.
Meanwhile, opportunists exploit the system. In Shanxi, a public sector worker improperly
employed since age 1, retired at 22 and illegally collected 690,000 yuan in pensions. In Heilongjiang,
intermediaries and public officials defrauded 115 million yuan through illicit enrollment.
Recent 2024 audit reports from provinces reveal rampant illegal pension distributions, exposing
the many unseen parasites draining these funds.
Such abuses are nearly impossible to curb. A government overseeing itself is unlikely
to be effective. If a poll asked Chinese citizens whether they support paying into social security,
the approval rate would likely be very low.
China's current social security challenges echo Japan's experience in the 1990s. After
Japan's economic bubble burst, corporate profits fell, and the public willingness to
pay into social security plummeted. Businesses cut full-time jobs and increased part-time
roles and with an aging population, Japan's social security system faced a massive deficit.
The government eventually used fiscal funds to cover the shortfall, contributing to Japan's
high public debt today.
Japan didn't reach this solution easily. Initially, like China now, they tried mandatory
contributions and delayed retirement, only to realize these measures were ineffective.
They eventually turned to fiscal funds to support the system. Japan's missteps could
have been a lesson for China. But the system has constrained China's economy.
China supports a large number of retired public officials whose pensions rise annually. To
protect their interests, the system sacrifices those outside it.
In summary, the delays in announcing social security bases this year stem from the public's
dwindling capacity to bear the burden.
If governments continue raising bases recklessly, two outcomes are likely.
1. Public unrest could erupt.
2. Businesses might cut jobs, reduce wages, or hire only retirees or temps, leading to
higher unemployment and reduced government revenue.
Local governments face a dilemma. They recognize that bases can keep rising, but fiscal pressures
and deficits in social security funds make lowering them difficult.
Japan's experience offers a clear solution. Governments must redirect funds from large
infrastructure or tech projects to public welfare and challenge entrenched interests
to make concessions. Only by prioritizing citizens can an economic recovery be achieved.
Ultimately, a flawed system faces two fates—proactive reform or being forced into reform by public
pressure. Without reform, no system can endure indefinitely.
Thank you so much for watching. If you find this video helpful, please like it, drop a
comment below, and hit the subscribe button right here. It really helps YouTube suggest
my video to others. I'll be back with more content soon. Until then, be well.