Why Taiwan’s Economy Is Crushing Korea and Japan in 2025 (While China Says It’s Failing) | Digging into China
In 2025, Taiwan’s economy delivered a stunning performance: per capita GDP hit $40,000 with 8.63% growth — far outpacing Korea, Hong Kong, and Singapore. Yet on mainland Chinese internet, the narrative claims Taiwan is failing, even comparing it unfavorably to Henan.
This video explores the real story behind Taiwan’s economic miracle. Facing a critical fork in the 1980s, Taiwan chose two paths: one led businessmen rushing to mainland China for cheap labor, the other saw a small group bet everything on semiconductors.
Through the bold vision of 李国鼎, 孙运璿, and 张忠谋’s TSMC, Taiwan built a world-leading chip industry that now powers the global AI boom.
While many Taiwanese firms scramble to exit China, TSMC’s advanced foundries keep the island indispensable. The contrast raises sharp questions about timing, strategy, and why the mainland narrative differs so sharply from the numbers. A thought-provoking look at one of Asia’s most unlikely success stories.
Help me grow the channel by donating any amount through the link below—your support makes a difference! https://paypal.me/DonXiang
Hi, I'm Dong Shuang. Welcome to Digging into China, where we take a deep dive into what's
really happening in China and share some unique insights. In 2025, Taiwan's per capita GDP reached
40,000 U.S. dollars. The economy grew at a high rate of 8.6%, hitting a new high in 15 years.
It may not sound that shocking at first, but when you compare it with the neighbors,
it really stands out. Korea grew only 1%, Hong Kong 3.5%, and Singapore 4.8%. This is no longer
the Asian four little dragons, it's more like one dragon pulling three little worms along.
Even more surprising, Taiwan's fourth quarter growth hit 12.7%. The last time it saw double
digit growth was back in the martial law era. On the per capita GDP side, Taiwan surpassed Korea
for the first time in 22 years and it has now beaten Japan for two years in a row. But here
is the strange part. Even with such a strong performance, the story on mainland Chinese
internet is completely different. They say Taiwan's economy is nothing special, that it
can't even compare to Henan province. Taipei is basically like a Tangshan city, and Kaohsiung
is about the same levels as Zhangzhou in Fujian province, a solid third-tier city. Some people
even write long, serious articles predicting that in just two more years, China's first-tier cities
will start overtaking Taiwan one after another. I don't know if their faces are turning red,
but they certainly have the thick skin. What stings even more is that Taiwan achieved all this
under tough conditions. Every day there are military planes circling the island, missiles
show up from time to time, and some people keep waving that 2027 timeline countdown. Yet this is
a place that gets told every day it's about to collapse. It's short on coal, oil, natural gas,
and even fresh water is tight. If any other place had started with such a terrible hint,
it probably would have folded long ago. So why is Taiwan's economy still this strong? After looking
into it, I realized the so-called Taiwan economic miracle is actually a bunch of very low probability
events that all happened to line up together. If any one step had gone wrong along the way,
today's Taiwan would never have been possible. So today, let's talk about Taiwan's economic miracle.
Actually, Taiwan's starting point was quite similar to Korea's. Both were dirt poor right
after World War II. In 1949, the Nationalist government brought over 1 or 2 million people
from the mainland, along with a batch of gold. Taiwan itself is a small island. The Japanese
colonial period left some industrial foundation, but most of it was built to serve the war.
To put it bluntly, it was just supporting the war machine. In the beginning, Taiwan was a typical
agricultural society with an outside government in charge. Per capita GDP was only 1 or 200
US dollars, even lower than the Philippines at that time. So how did Taiwan turn things around?
At first, it followed a standard East Asian playbook. Cheap labor making textiles, plastic
products, and electronic parts assembly, shipping them out by boatload to the United States.
Back then, Taiwan had a nickname, the Kingdom of OEM. But everyone knows the problem with being
an OEM. You are always stuck at the very bottom of the supply chain. The brand owners get the meat,
while you are left licking the scraps off the plate. Still, thanks to this approach,
Taiwan's GDP kept double-digit growth all the way through the 1960s and 1970s.
By the late 1980s, this path started to run out of steam. Wages in Taiwan were rising,
land prices were shooting up, and the new Taiwan dollar had appreciated a lot. For a small factory
owner making shoes or clothes or doing assembly, the thin profit margin he used to earn was getting
squeezed. Labor was getting more expensive, and the exchange rate was eating into his profit.
It was becoming harder and harder to make it in Taiwan. At that moment, two roads appeared in
front of Taiwan. One looked very tempting, the other almost nobody believed in. Taiwan's economic
fate had reached a critical fork in the road. Let's talk about the tempting road first.
Everyone knows what happened in mainland China in 1989. After that, companies from Europe,
America, and Japan were all getting ready to pull out their money. The whole world was watching.
But guess who jumped in against the tide? That's right, Taiwan. While everyone else was running
away, Taiwan dove straight in. Why? Because it was just too perfect. The same worker in the mainland
cost less than one-tenth of what they cost in Taiwan. Imagine you are a small boss in Taiwan
making shoes, clothes, or doing assembly work. Business on the island is getting tough. Then
someone tells you there is a place across the street where labor costs less than a tenth of
Taiwan's. The language is the same, the culture is similar, and it's just a two-hour flight away.
Would you go? So for the next 20 years, wave after wave of westward advance took place,
like a modern-day gold rush. But this time, the gold was cheap labor across the street.
First came traditional manufacturing, shoes and clothes, then circuit board, components,
and computer assembly. After 2000, even the big companies went in on a large scale.
How crazy was the scale of Taiwan's gold rush? Take Kunshan in Jiangsu province, just a county-level
city. At its peak, it had more than 5,300 Taiwanese companies. In 2007, almost all the famous
brand laptops you saw in stores around the world were made in factories opened by Taiwanese people,
using Taiwanese technology and Taiwanese management, but produced in the mainland.
So the Made in China label back then should really have had a parenthesis around it.
Taiwan takes the order. Taiwan supervises. Mainland produces global sales.
This model made Taiwanese businessmen rich. It also helped the mainland build the world's
largest electronics manufacturing supply chain. By 2010, 84% of Taiwan's outward investment had
gone to mainland China. Sounds pretty successful, right? Taiwanese businessmen made money. China
became the world's factory. Seemed like a win-win. But Taiwan itself paid a heavy price.
Before we talk about that price, let's go back and look at the other road,
the one almost nobody believed in back then. What happened to it? Let's set the clock back to the
1970s. While most Taiwanese companies were busy doing OEM work and earning hard money,
a small group of people inside Taiwan were thinking about something else. One of them was
Li Guoding, known as the father of Taiwan's technology industry. The other was Sun Yunxuan,
who came from an engineering background and later became Premier, basically Taiwan's Prime Minister.
In the 1970s, these two men made a decision that looked very risky at the time. They decided to
pour the whole country's effort into developing semiconductors. Looking at it today, this thinking
was actually quite similar to what Park Chun-hee did in Korea. The idea was simple. I know I have
nothing right now, but I am not going to waste time talking. I will go find the best teachers,
learn everything, come back, close the door, and build it big. Think about it. In the 1970s,
Taiwan didn't even have a proper electronics industry. Saying you wanted to make chips
sounded like a kid who just learned to ride a bike announcing I am going to race in Formula 1.
A lot of people thought this kid had lost his mind.
Even so, Taiwan merged three state-owned research institutes and in 1973 established the Industrial
Technology Research Institute. Then they sent a group of young engineers to the United States
and somehow managed to bring back a complete set of semiconductor manufacturing technology.
At this point, Taiwan was just one of many countries trying to develop semiconductors.
Korea was trying. Japan was trying. And everyone thought they could do it.
What really turned Taiwan from one of them into the only one was the next person who stepped onto
the stage. He made a decision that everyone at the time thought was crazy. That person was
Zhang Zhongmou. Zhang Zhongmou was born in 1931 in Ningbo, Zhejiang province.
He later went to the United States, studied undergraduate at Harvard, and got his master's
at MIT. After graduation, he joined the Texas Instruments and eventually became the head of
its global semiconductor business. A Chinese person reaching the top position in the core
business of a Fortune 500 company in 1980s America was extremely rare, even by today's
standards. How could Taiwan, which was determined to develop semiconductors, possibly let such
talent slip away? Li Guoding and Sun Yunxuan visited him three times and invited Zhang Zhongmou
to Taiwan. It's said they offered him three very attractive conditions that finally moved him.
At the age of 54, just about to retire, he decided, I'll go back to Taiwan and start a new
venture. In 1987, Zhang Zhongmou founded TSMC. On the very first day, he set one clear rule,
we will only make chips for other people, we will absolutely not do our own design.
Today, that decision looks brilliant, almost genius. But back then, almost everyone thought
he had lost his mind. At that time, the mainstream way to make chips was called IDM,
design it yourself, manufacture yourself, sell it yourself, control the whole chain. Intel did it
that way, Samsung did it that way, Texas Instruments did it that way. Almost all the big players
followed the model. If you only do manufacturing and no design, how are you any different from
the tailor on the street who just hems pants for people? But Zhang Zhongmou's logic was actually
very simple. If I don't design chips myself, then every company in the world that designs chips
will not be my competitor, they will be my customers. And once this model gets going,
it creates a snowball effect. The more customers you have, the higher your factory utilization,
the more money you make, the more you can invest in research and development,
the more advanced your process becomes, the more customers cannot leave you.
When the snowball keeps rolling, all the material suppliers and the top engineers in the
entire manufacturing ecosystem end up circling around you. What you build is no longer just a
moat, it's an entire Pacific Ocean. So TSMC pushed forward step by step, 28nm, 14nm, 7nm, 5nm,
all the way to 3nm. Every time it broke through a new node, the gap with the second place grew
larger. By 2025, in the global chip foundry market, TSMC holds a little over 60% of the share.
But in the most advanced process, it leads by 2 to 3 generations and supports more than 90%
of the world's advanced capacity. Whether it's Apple's CPU, NVIDIA's GPU, or Qualcomm's 5G chips,
on this planet there is only one place that can make them, TSMC in Taiwan. Of course,
during all those years, Zhang Zhongbo also made one decision that looking back today
may be even more important than founding TSMC itself. While so many Taiwanese businessmen
were rushing to the mainland, he never moved the most advanced manufacturing processes there.
Another Taiwanese person did go. He founded SMIC, the largest chip foundry on the mainland.
This man used to be Zhang Zhongbo's colleague at Texas Instruments. He took a group of Taiwanese
engineers to Shanghai. Zhang Zhongbo chose to accept Taiwan's higher costs. Later events
proved that his choice decided Taiwan's national fate. Let's pause here for a moment and shift our
view back to those Taiwanese businessmen who went west. Those businessmen really did make a lot of
money in China over more than 20 years. But after Taiwanese scholars studied it carefully, the
conclusion was quite painful. The westward move caused Taiwan's wages to stagnate for more than
10 or 20 years. A huge amount of capital flowed to the mainland, and so did the job opportunities.
Taiwan did make money, but the money did not stay in Taiwan. It stayed on the mainland.
Then one day, the wind changed. In 2018, the US-China trade war began. The United States
started restricting exports of high-end chips and equipment to China, then added tariffs on
Chinese goods. Next came the pandemic, which broke global supply chain overnight. After that came the
tech war. China shifted from keeping a low profile to wolf warrior diplomacy. In this environment,
the world came up with a new term, de-risking. In plain language, it means you cannot put all
your eggs in the China basket. What if the basket tips over? What was Taiwan's situation at that
time? Remember the first road I mentioned at the beginning? 80% of Taiwan's outward investment was
in mainland China. This wasn't just putting all eggs in one basket, it was putting the eggs in
and then dancing on top of the basket. But those Taiwanese businessmen really are sharp. They rush
in first when there is money to be made, and they rush out first when there is a risk. The Center
for Strategic and International Studies surveyed 610 Taiwanese companies in the mainland. 57%
of them were either withdrawing or considering withdrawal. That number is more than twice the
rate for American companies and five times the rate for European and Japanese companies. The
data speaks clearly. In 2010, investment in the mainland made up 84% of Taiwan's total outward
investment. By 2024, that figure had fallen to 7.5%. The investment amount dropped from nearly
$10 billion a year at its peak to just $360 million. Not only investment, Taiwan's export
markets were also quietly shifting. By 2025, Taiwan's largest export destination was no longer
China, it was the United States. And while those businessmen were desperately pulling out, on the
other road, an unexpected storm pushed Taiwan straight onto the altar. In 2023, ChatGPT appeared
out of nowhere. Global tech giants all went crazy. Google, Microsoft, Amazon, Meta, plus a bunch of
big Chinese internet companies, almost every big name was rushing to build data centers.
Training large models and handling questions from billions of users around the world
requires enormous computing power. And behind that computing power are huge numbers of chips.
Just the four companies, Google, Amazon, Microsoft, and Meta, their total spending on AI in 2025
came close to $400 billion. That's roughly half of Taiwan's entire annual GDP or a full year of
Israel's GDP. Now imagine that $400 billion dollars flowing up the supply chain, where does
it ultimately go? NVIDIA designs the GPUs but doesn't make them. Who do they give the work to?
Apple needs the most advanced process for its self-designed chips. Who do they give it up to?
AMD, Qualcomm, Broadcom, the answer is always the same name, TSMC. That's why we saw Taiwan's
exports in the fourth quarter of 2025 surged by 49%. For one economy to grow its exports by nearly
50% in a single quarter is almost unthinkable in world economy history. There is one more detail
worth noting. TSMC once had a major customer called Huawei. After the US sanctions, TSMC could
no longer make chips for Huawei. Many people thought TSMC would lose a lot, but the capacity
freed up by Huawei was filled almost instantly. Apple, NVIDIA, and Qualcomm were lining up to
grab it. The new orders far exceeded what Huawei used to bring. If you think about it deeper,
it's quite scary. If US-China relations had not worsened back then, if Wolf Warrior diplomacy
had not led to the most advanced lithography machines being banned from sale to China,
and if Zhang Zhongmou had not insisted on keeping the most advanced processes in Taiwan,
then probably more than half of these AI chips orders would have gone to China instead.
Taiwan's latest burst of growth really brought together perfect timing, perfect location,
and perfect people all at once. Looking back, those two roads from 40 years ago now feel
full of drama. The businessmen who took the first road and went to the mainland to make easy money
are now racking their brains trying to figure out how to get out. The people who took the
second road and stubbornly focused on the hardest part, semiconductors, are the ones now holding up
half of Taiwan's economy. If Taiwan had not decided back then to pour national effort into
semiconductors, and if Zhang Zhongmou had done what many other Taiwanese businessmen did,
treat Taiwan as just a stepping stone and gradually move core capacity to lower-cost
places, then today's Taiwan would most likely have lost its low-end industries,
failed to build high-end ones, never surpassed Japan and Korea, and never reached a position
where the whole world cannot do without it. It would just be an ordinary mediocre second-tier
economy. Finally, let's talk about those interesting comments on Chinese internet at the beginning.
They say the whole of Taiwan can't even compare to Henan province. Some people on Zhihu write
serious predictions. Never mind whether these predictions get slapped in the face, the logic
itself is strange. You take Henan, with its population of over 100 million, and compare
the total economic size with Taiwan's 23 million people, then conclude that Taiwan is no good.
Doesn't the person saying that feel embarrassed? Comparing Beijing or Shanghai, the first-tier
cities, with the whole of Taiwan is also not the right way. If we compare per capita, Taipei has a
per capita GDP of 70,000 U.S. dollars. The city where TSMC is based, Hsinchu, even reaches over
90,000 dollars per person. If we treated Hsinchu as an independent economy, its per capita GDP
would rank right behind Luxembourg and Ireland, third in the world. Of course, China has 1.4
billion people and uneven development. That's normal. There is nothing to laugh at.
But when others don't laugh at you, yet you turn around and laugh at them, that doesn't make sense.
What's more, why did wages in Taiwan stagnate for 10 or 20 years? It was precisely because for the
20 years, Taiwan's capital, factories, technology, and management experience were poured
desperately into the mainland. Those Taiwanese businessmen helped build the world's largest
electronics manufacturing supply chain for the mainland. Behind the words made in China,
how much was actually Taiwanese capital, Taiwanese technology, and Taiwanese orders?
Yet instead of a single word of thanks, they mock Taiwan every day at the third-tier city level.
They shout about the fighting and the killing, talk about keep the island but not the people.
Just think about it honestly. Does this sit well with your conscience?
Sometimes I really have to admire this kind of narrative. When they can't win on per capita,
they switch to total GDP. When they can't win on industrial position, they talk about market scale.
When welfare falls short, they bring up development stage and national conditions.
They sound like they are discussing economics. But no matter how you turn it,
it always comes down to one thing. They cannot let Taiwan look too good.
In plain terms, it's about putting others down to cover up their own shortcomings.
Today, they mock India. Tomorrow, they belittle Taiwan. The day after, they ridicule America.
As long as they make others look a little worse, their own problems seem to disappear along with it.
Thank you so much for watching. If you find this video helpful, please like it,
drop a comment below, and hit the subscribe button right here. It really helps YouTube
suggest my videos to others. I'll be back with more content soon. Until then, be well.