What Is Truth? Exploring How We Know What We Know | Not Yet Now #7

Truth exists
11 followers
#Mysteries #UnsolvedMysteries #Truthexists #WhatIsTruth? #Exploring #HowWeKnow #WhatWeKnow #NotYetNow #7
Well, welcome back to the not yet now podcast one of my pet peeves, by the way, I'm always moving my glasses up
I've noticed as I've went back and watched our episodes. I just did it
So you see a little tape there and you get the idea. Yeah, and I do like a weird twitch, too
So I apologize in advance, but you know, we we try to keep this as raw as possible. But welcome back Brandon
Yeah, it's good to be back on
I got the boot one more time because of a lack of mics in the studio
We started with two mics and then we upgraded to three because we wanted to include Jill in the discussion and then the last podcast
We had Jordan and Vanessa on which was great. It was awesome
Yes, and there's way more to that story than we have to step aside for them. It was and that's so good and
We have ordered a fourth mic. So we'll have the ability in the near future to have four on the show
But yeah, welcome back if you're listening and I want to say like I love
You guys your interaction in the comments and there were some really thought-provoking
Comments in the comment section on YouTube where which is where most of that's going down at I don't think there's a way to do
that on the Apple or Spotify, but
Maybe Spotify
Anyways, though I was reading through my man. Some of these are so so he's coming for so thoughtful
There was a whole lot in there about having an embodied spirituality, which we're gonna talk about a lot in this podcast
So, but I want to thank you guys for that and engaging with what we're talking about here
it really is encouraging and I know a lot of people are encouraged by reading your comments and
I wanted to also something that we've been getting a lot of emails on lately is
So you guys are one updates on what's going on here? What is going on here in the valley?
After the hurricane and so I thought we'd maybe spend a little bit just tell you quick update things are getting better. Yeah
But we have a very long recovery
Brandon you're working on a lot of stuff
So maybe you can give a quick update because Brandon is full-time with the church
So he's kind of running point on a lot of this stuff
So maybe you can give our audience an update on kind of what's happening with yeah every efforts. Yeah, you
There's parts of it that just seem
Hopeless. Yeah, and like I don't know if I mentioned before just that the drive from my house to the church is
just
The way that the river is and the businesses that have just collapsed in it's not even that the buildings are gone the dirt that the
Buildings were on has gone and it just seems like when is this?
When is this ever gonna get back or some semblance of normal still plastic and trash 20-foot high in the trees?
We had a big heavy construction crew
From the eastern part of the state come in and they were working at a local Christian school and in like six hours
They pulled 25 cars out of the river in the ditches just right around the school
And so those kind of things it makes you seem like
How are we ever gonna overcome this but then on the other side?
the support and the people willing to help it just keeps flowing in like one of the things that people have ever been a part
of a disaster say is
The supports great for the first few weeks and then everyone kind of disappears and you're left to your own
And you know, we felt a little bit of that but for the most part
People have stepped in for the long-term plan
So I'm gonna leave from here to go meet with a group out of South Carolina that wants to help us rebuild
So we're rebuilding homes in this historic village called beacon village where the water was over the roofs of the house
So a local contractor we got a missions organization out of Louisiana that's sending the money for the labor Kingdom org one Kingdom
Tribute to that. Yeah, and yeah
And then world vision is supplying all of the material to do those and they're taking more donations, too
So that's for the 25 houses over there and that that efforts
Growing and then on the other side of the river the houses were completely destroyed. They're just they're not there anymore
We've bulldozed them and then we're gonna rebuild those from the ground up
And so it's it's been really cool to get to know these families and serve them
And again, just show them the love of Jesus in this dark time. Yeah, but there is a need still
So we would encourage you to give I mean some people are still living in tents
It's crazy that that's happening, but they are and well, they'd rather stay here locally in a tent
Then go find a hotel an hour away. Yeah, but there's just no long-term
The weather's temperatures drop and we do have another organization that's building cabins for people cat as cabins for Christ for Christ
Yeah, a Devon that those guys are great
So there's a lot of good things happen. If you want to want to be involved too, you can always
Give to the church, which is swan dot church
Swa n dot church and there's a drop down there for the disaster. It'll 100% will go straight to that
Yeah, so thank you guys for asking about that. But today we're gonna talk about something that I think
It might be the most
Relevant and important important cultural issue that we have right now in terms of like where where is the biggest threat?
Coming against the kingdom of God
Caveat that we do belong to a kingdom. The Bible says they can't be shaken nor destroyed
So we don't want to I never want to present it as if oh my goodness
The kingdom of God is is under a threat and if we don't do what we're supposed to do, it's gonna end
That's not gonna happen. We do belong to a kingdom that can't be shaken nor destroyed, but I think God does give us
Kind of prophetic wisdom through Scripture and and through just cultural nuance that that we examine the philosophies of the world that
Set themselves up against the knowledge of God and and the Lord does want us to examine
philosophies that would be
Adversarial to the kingdom. Yeah, the there's two errors on either side of that though. The one error would say
This is such a big threat. I better get out there and fight or this whole thing is gonna fall apart
Yeah, and and then we we live out of fear and we're constantly fighting because we're afraid of what's gonna happen
But the other error is nothing can come against the kingdom. So I guess we'll just sit back
Which is the tension of the name of the podcast not yet now and you know
what we're trying to embody before we get into this because this is I'm gonna I'm gonna give
The term in a second here that I think it really is
Something we all need to be aware of we need to study
We need to understand the threats and we need to make sure that our our our our philosophies line up with the truth of the gospel
And the truth of God's Word and the truth of who God is and his inner life and his triune nature
but what we want to do is
We want to embody what?
Marks, I think Mark Sayers term because the name of the book is that we read was called non anxious presence
How do we speak the truth but not in a way like we what's so disruptive in culture right now is not
for us to get on Facebook and
Instagram and even this podcast
I mean there is a way that I know how to do it and maybe I've even
participated in in the past in my life where we can give you the red meat and
And it's just like and it gets tons of eyeballs because we're tapping into an anger
But everybody's kind of doing that right now, I mean just look at your social media feed and
What we want to embody is is something that truly is disruptive
And we would we would argue and believe and the Sears talks about this that to really be disruptive is to be a non
Anxious presence. Yeah, there's actually a have to find the video and maybe post on the channel
But there there's this video that circulated around on social media a while ago
And in the foreground is this guy shooting a tick-tock video and he's at a gym and he's stacking
Dumbbells, and I mean, it's pretty impressive. He's probably got six dumbbells stacked on each side and he climbs up it
Balancing on them and he does a handstand on top and he starts doing push-ups
And you're like, you know, wow, that's that's that's amazing
But in the background of the video is this 80 year old man who's shooting free throws and
During the entire video maybe a minute or two minutes long while this guy's getting set up and he's climbing up the guys just
shooting free throws never misses
Not a single shot and it's such a picture of do you want to be the big flash in the pan?
Yeah, just get the get out there really loud for the moment
Or do you want to have the type of
Thought life in the inner life of the guy in the background who you know is cultivated this free throw
Over the course of his 80 year life. Yeah where he's
Incredible at it, but he can just do it in this calm steady way and that that's what we're after as we try to think
about these issues, we're not just trying to make a
Splash on the internet what we want to help ourselves and help our church and and help the audience do is really cultivate that life
That's gonna persevere
Which should which should manifest itself in a non-anxious presence?
So what I mean the Bible calls it a peace that surpasses all understanding
Jordan and Vanessa particularly Vanessa talked about it on the last podcast
Which I thought I love her story and their story because they don't come into the discussion
With the Christian ease that we grew up with. I mean, we know the Christian pop culture world
We know I mean, we're like in the where you know
We're in the belly of the nuance of all that discussion and all the little things and little
denominational differences and all that, you know all that stuff and and they come into the kingdom without any of that I would call baggage and
So what they hear her describe?
The the peace of God that surpasses all understanding and what she has experienced was I mean
I know that it resonated with a lot of the audio
If you ever listen that podcast you need to go back to the last podcast and listen to it
Well the way they even came into our community from the first time we met them they didn't show up with an angle
They weren't trying to prove themselves or or argue for something
They simply came in and they were just honestly seeking what what is true? Yeah, where is life found?
How do we make life better and whatever the answer to that question is?
We're open to and that posture I imagine is how they've carried themselves their whole life
And it's why so many of their former friends and colleagues or they're still friends are
Asking the question
What have you guys found? Yeah, like they're still in they didn't turn on those people. They didn't turn them off
They experienced the type of people they were and now that Jordan and Vanessa have come to Christ
There's so many people asking I want in on that. Yeah, it's kind of interesting how that's
Their story along with others in our church has been that's been kind of the
Ethos that Christ has developed in our body
which really kind of brings us to the what what what I what I want us to discuss today and this is going to be
a two-part series because it's a lot to unpack and I want to really lay a solid foundation, but
But the word the word is epistemology, which is a big fancy word
Which essentially means it's the how do we know what we know and the philosophy? It's a really
Important idea that is discussed and debated by philosophers throughout the ages
It's been debated by theologians throughout the ages. It is it really is an anchor for how we interact in the world
How do I know?
What I know and how can I know this to be true and I started looking at this years ago
But I mean think about what that would mean like with everything's happening today. Yeah. Yeah
It's so much more heightened because of the amount of information that's out there
I mean you sit down you go to work you come home you sit down you try to make sense of okay
What happened in the world today? Well, where do you go? You turn on maybe Fox News?
Maybe you look at CNN MSNBC
Then you get on Twitter then you got an Instagram and there you're just inundated with all of these ideas and quote-unquote facts
And the question is how do you sift through that? How do you make sense? What is actually true?
Is there something that's actually true or all these ideas just constructed? Well, we're making them up as we go
Yeah, we were just having this conversation about our personal business here and how much data that we have accumulated
When you do a video file, it's allies
We're having to talk about server updates and all that and but you you think about the massive amount of data
That's that's coming into an information which that's what data is it's information that's being flooded into
the marketplace of ideas even
This morning as I was on
Instagram I saw a video pop-up of
P Diddy puff daddy and
And it was very scary what he was talking about
But you know the first thing that popped in my mind when I watched this I wanted to share it by hey guys
This is what my gut reaction was
I need to share this with people but but but what stopped me from sharing it
Well, one of the things that stopped me from sharing it was I thought wait, this could be deep fake
And have you ever done that before so I know that like you maybe someone has shared something on
Social media only to find out it was fake news. It was a deep fake video
It wasn't the actual person
It maybe it was from a satirical site like the Babylon B or the onion and somebody didn't know that that was a satirical site
And so they they they share this story, but they and or maybe it's straight-up fake news
You know and and I mean at my family
I mean I can tell you how many time I cannot tell you how many times that the people like my uncle Si has died
I mean he has died many many times on the internet and and those things get shared their stories get shared and
But it's like but they're not true necessarily. And so how do we know?
What we know in this one even it's not an accident. That's the thing
Steve Bannon back in the 2016 election, so
Leading up to the first time that Trump got elected Bannon was helping with I don't know what his exact role was
He was political strategist for the campaign. He was the chief. He was I don't think I think they invented a role for him
It was called like I think he was a CEO of the campaign. Okay, but yeah
So so he was just speaking into okay. How are we gonna run this?
How are we gonna come against the media which seems to be against us as Republicans?
and he said
He said the Democrats don't matter
The real opposition is the media and the way to deal with them is to flood the zone with and I'll clean it up
junk or crap and
Basically his strategy was just to put so much noise out there
Yeah that it would just drown out the other noise of the media. So if people are saying something you don't like instead of
Combating the actual substance of the argument you just put a bunch more information out there
And then you lose sight of the other argument
That's which is to create chaos and it's the opposite of being a non-anxious presence. That's right
And I yeah, I would argue that that's very destructive and no matter from the right or left
This isn't a partisan issue. No, it was short term. You could argue as effective. Yeah, but long term
What's the results of a society that's just inundated with noise
well
And what what they're calling us now with because this was like I want I want I want to say pre AI at least
AI is today
artificial intelligence machine machine learning
Now this is a real issue that now we have AI bots competing to flood
The the marketplace with information because that's the marketplace through which other AI bots are are creating. Yeah
Creating information from and so you see this kind of on stairways now and this is gonna get this
I think there's gonna be an exponential explosion of this that like a I mean if you want to call it a singularity or
What but there's gonna be a it. How are we going to know in the future? What is true?
I mean, this is what Pilate asked Jesus, right? How did I have the truth?
What is truth, you know?
and and I think that that
the devil's always going to attack the the foundation of truth and knowledge because that is the way that God reveals himself as
So I was I was I wanted to tell you guys about and I think I've we've talked about this before
I think I've talked to you about this with I listened to a I'm a big Schaefer guy. I love Francis Schaefer
when it comes to epistemology
Schaefer and then another
Theologian from Westminster Seminary a guy named Cornelius Vantill
Have been very instrumental in shaping I've read their works and and particularly Schaefer because it's written he's writes in a much more
palatable way for to understand his teachings but
Kind of the similar idea but these guys have been very profound in my own life
And when I came across their work, I was I was just like particularly Schaefer at first
I was like wow, this is like I cuz I felt these I felt this tension
If you know we were talking to everyone was talking about postmodern culture, which is the truth is relative you have your truth
I have my truth now you would say it's my lived experience or let me
It's time for me to tell my truth as if truth is not something that's outside of ourself
But truth is actually in us. We determine it for ourselves
that never made sense to me, but I didn't really have a
framework to articulate what that was and I came across a
Sermon by Francis Schaefer. I
Don't know where I tried to find it. So I'm gonna paraphrase what he said
I think the sermon was given some at some point in the 1930 80s
What he said is he said there was a moment about 300 years ago or I say a cultural moment
That happened around 300 years ago in the German universities where they became progressively
Liberal and not politically liberal but theologically liberal but it all started in the departments of science and
they became overwhelmingly naturalistic and the way that I would define naturalistic would mean that the
The world the universe is a closed system
So just think about the universe draw a circle around the entire physical universe
Nothing gets in
Nothing gets out. It is a closed system. All that exists is the natural world. That's a
naturalistic understanding or framework of the universe and in that everything can be explained by science
Everything can be explained by some experiment about the way one physical thing and another physical thing interacts with one another
Yeah, it's all it's all a chain of physical reactions. So think about when you pour vinegar into a
Glass that has bacon soda in it like it just what happens
There's a there's a chemical reaction and there's a fizz and I don't know the physiology behind it all but but there's a chemical reaction
There that's the universe and and up until this point in history
This really wasn't the way science had operated. It was science. I mean Copernicus Galileo
These guys were coming out of the Catholic Church
now to be fair they were persecuted for discovering that you know, heliocentric ism and
And they were persecuted for that. They were called heretics
I think maybe I don't know if Schaefer makes this point
But probably that was one of the reasons why the departments of science in the German universities at the time
Kind of revolted against an open system. So a closed system. Everything that exists is natural physical
That's all that exists is matter and in an open system
You have a physical universe, but it's open God can get in God can get out God can move around like there
It's it's open. It's open to the spiritual realm
But at this point in human history in the German universities that became overwhelmingly
overwhelmingly naturalistic and as a result that eventually the
departments of theology also followed suit and at the time this was kind of the
intellectual hub of the world and so one of the things that happened as a result of this was that the philosophers began to
Absorb what was going on in the departments of science and they said wait, hold on guys
We have a we have a couple issues here if we are going to remain in the vein of reason
If we are going to remain in the vein of reason, then there's a problem with what you're saying. The first problem is
That we don't matter which is a big problem
If all that exists is the material world and there's nothing outside the material world
Then all we are is matter all all Zack Dasher and all the Brandon Hudson really are is we're just a collection of
Molecules and atoms just like this cup of coffee. I'll hold my hand
There's nothing in us to give us any real intrinsic value over a piece of trash
And so there's no basis for the value of humanity
Yeah
And just like the chemical reactions you talked about the way things in the world interact with one another
All of our thoughts all of our actions all of our feelings. They're nothing more than
reactions, it's
Basically something was hit the play button was hit a long time ago and everything's just playing out
Yeah, it's gonna happen the way it's gonna happen
No matter what everything is determined by a prior state of physical events not
Which is the second problem, by the way, the second problem, which was maybe more
Troublesome for them if they were to remain in the vein of reason and that's a big caveat
If they were able are going to remain in the vein of reason of rational thought
Then we have to admit that we don't matter and then the second thing we have to say is that we don't actually have free
Will we can't determine anything? There's no
acquiring of knowledge
Everything every thought that you have it's not a thought
It's a result of a prior state of physical events. For example going back to the bacon soda
Analogy with that with the
With the vinegar if you pour the red wine vinegar into the bacon soda
There's no decision that's being made inside that cup where the bacon soda says, you know what now that we're together
Let me create some kind of let me do this thing here and they're like they're talking about it
They're like, you know what? Let's decide that's that's not how it just happens
It is a result of a prior state of physical events. And so in the same way
If
If the world is simply naturalistic and all that exists as matter one
We don't matter and two we we don't determine anything which you can see the problem because you just determine these things
Yeah, and so there's an issue there. So so if in order to remain in the vein of reason
The philosopher said we have to do one of two things. We have to become complete nihilist
Which we which is talked about a little bit before. Yeah, just nothing matters. Nothing matters
I think there's a song on that right Metallica. Nothing matter else matters. Yeah, I gotta go back and read that
We're at the point of that song
I don't know but it was from the 90s and the 90s are full of nihilism a nihilism. Nothing matters at all
there's no point to human existence and and and we don't have free will and I mean Schaefer would argue that
Basically kill yourself
and nobody
Very few people live that out to its logical conclusion. Yes, there's something put into us
We would argue by the Creator that doesn't allow ourselves to fully resolve it
So some people do I mean, I think Van Gogh and others went to the end of their what's called existentialism
What Schaefer called existentialism which we would now probably call post-modernity, but it's this idea
Well, I'll get there because I think it's where we where we landed
but that but the option is the remain in the vein of reason the option is become a nihilist or
Admit that God is there
But you don't have any other option if you are to remain in the vein of reason we got to become nihilists and kill ourselves
or we have to admit that God is there and I know this is a
you might say this is an oversimplification and
Perhaps it is but I think the point remains that really if you boil it down there aren't really I can't come up with another
option if we are to remain in the vein of reason and what Schaefer argues is
That they did the unthinkable as he would say they did something that had never
The philosophers that had never been considered in all of human history. They did they did the unthinkable and
They chose to abandon reason they just said well, let's just abandon reason then let's just escape from reason
Which is the title of his book?
Let's escape from reason and and we can we can kind of have our cake and eat it too. We can abandon rationality
We can abandon reason and then they split the field of knowledge
Into two categories into the subjective and the objective realm. How would you define that?
By the way, the difference between subjective and objective. Well
Going back to Schaefer. He talks about the two stories in the house
Yeah, and so on the ground level he puts the objective facts. So these are the things that are
Observable and testable so the things that science can speak to so just like the experiment if we do this
We know what's gonna happen. How do we know?
All of the things where we can test them and so this is math
These are knowable two plus two equals four every single time
So we put that on the on the on this lower story of our house that we're building our lives on
And and basically in that the way we view it
It's these are the things that quote-unquote matter and then up on the second story of the house is subjective
I can hold one thing you can hold another they can be completely opposite
I can hold that. There's one God you can hold that
There's a thousand the guy over there can hold that there's no God at all and it's okay
It doesn't matter if they conflict and they don't make any sense together because they're just like emotions
They cut they kind of come and go and nobody can really know it and it doesn't really matter
Because we have these real things down here that we're actually living our lives based on. Yeah, that's good
William William Lane Craig
defined it as
Objective truth would be it's true
Independent of my perception of it. So I it doesn't matter how I perceive it or what I want it to be
it's true regardless of my perception or experience of it and a subject of truth is
subject to
my own interpretation my own opinion, it's more of a
Heard one apologist talk about starburst and he had like a jar of like a hundred and fifty
Different colored starburst and he asked the audience. What's the best flavor?
Well, I think the pink is you think the red we all we vote on it. Well, that's a subjective truth
It's subject to your own personal preference or taste right now, but if I ask you how many are in the jar?
Well, I made I feel like there's 172 and you so I feel like there's a hundred and forty one
What doesn't really matter at that point what we perceive or what we want to be true, man
I really want there to be a hundred and eighty what doesn't matter. There's a hundred and fifty we count them
there's a and so that kind of that idea of the difference between the two and what I think so what happened is is they
They put they separated this field of knowledge as you mentioned and in that lower story was science
Scientific facts mathematical equations. These are things that we can know to be true. And then the upper story was faith values
Things that we we we want to be true for us and and and that had never been a reality
yeah, the things that used to be at the center the discussions of
God and virtue and what what makes us human all of those things used to sit here and then everything else like math
And science served that as the highest good
This was moved out of the center and put in its place was ultimately ourselves
Yeah, we became the center of reality
And so it leads to this other idea in philosophy. And again, these are the I know these are big words
But they they they carry so much with them is the correspondence theory of truth versus the coherence theory of truth
Yeah, and this is if you get these ideas
Then you'll be able to go back into the discussions about what's true on the internet and sitting around with your family and friends
And you'll be so much more equipped to have those conversations
So the correspondence theory of truth is what it sounds like it truth corresponds to something
It's true because it's true because it ties to something that's true. And so what it does is it?
Takes truth from being something that we have to construct and hold on to and it situates itself
Outside of us. Yes, I've heard it said this way that the correspondence theory of truth is is when my thought
Matches up with what's reality? Yeah, and the relationship between that so if I have a thought that it's raining outside
And I walk outside and it's not raining if you say hey Zach, it's raining outside. I mean, that's him
I have a thought now, you know, I pick out the window. I'm like, okay thought it's raining look out the window
It's not raining. That's not reality. Well, then that's not true
Yes, I didn't line up now if I look out the window and it is raining now
My thought has matched reality in the correlation the correspondence between thought
My thought life and what's real when that corresponds and is accurate then there's this thing called truth
Yeah, Dallas Willard said truth reveals reality
And then I love that he says reality can be described as what humans run into when we're wrong
Hmm and so we're running down our lives
We're living out our truth
But the problem is reality is sitting there and we come smack into it when we're wrong
So the classic example would be I believe I can fly
So I climb up on the building and my truth is that when I jump I'm gonna take off and just soar like an eagle
Reality is the ground
Sitting beneath you that you're going to smack in the law of gravity very hard. Have you seen the key and pill skit?
there's one where I
forget what I think it was
peel was playing a
Football player and they're interviewing him in the locker room at the end of the game
He's like kids you could do anything anything is possible
And it's like this motivational speech if you want to fly you can fly. No, seriously go jump off a building. You can do it
Promise you made kids anything is pot and they're like it just keeps going over and he goes like over the top
And then the next scene is he's at a press conference
I was want to apologize to the 12 kids that jumped off a building, but it's kind of like this argument
I'm absurd and he pushed it out through humor, but it's like no there are things that we are bound to there is a reality
That we're bound to and what's interesting about Schaefer's two-story
house is that
Well the idea one is that
We you live in the bottom story and and you say that the top story isn't real or it's subjective
But then you what you do is you reach up
Onto the top story to bring down into the lower story to prove that the top story subjective for example
When we go back to the idea of free will and we go back to the idea of our thought life
we determine
That all things are determined by physics
We determine that what think about that?
I know how do I determine that all things are determined by a prior state of chemical or physical events
So I reach up here into this
Spiritual world about thought life and I had a thought
That there are no thoughts. I have to I have to use the things of God to prove that God isn't real
I mean that that's kind of the absurdity of yeah
I heard Jordan Peterson do this great thing on this. He said we want to base our lives on science
We're scientific people that no longer need religion
But he said science is predicated on religion and he listed out these four basic claims of science
One you have to believe that there is truth. So to do science you have to believe that there's something that is true
Yeah that it can't be true today and not true tomorrow
So it has to be consistent metaphysical assumption that you have to make yeah, you have to believe that truth is understandable
So not that only that it exists
But it's something that we can communicate and communicate and get our minds around three
You have to believe that understanding truth is good that that actually understanding that things better than not understanding it again
That's metaphysical and then fourth you have to believe that there is a thing that is good
Meaning that there's something good and then something not good and then how do you define those?
Those all go outside of science
yeah, but they're the very assumptions that science builds everything it does on top of and you can't
Ultimately, I would say in this you can't escape what any of this that's the thing about it
Yes, you can't fully ever really escape it without and Schaefer talked about this
He said, you know part of the problem with an apologetic like his
He said you have to be very careful with it and I'm paraphrasing this. I don't know where he said it
although I've read almost everything he's written, but he talked about like when you're when you're entering into this type of
discussion with people who are
existentialist you have to be very careful because if
if you deconstruct
Post-modernity or
Existentialism which is this escape from reason if you deconstruct that for people
then if you don't reconstruct with the truth of who God is and they're back in that that dilemma of remaining in the vein of
Reason, which is to basically kill yourself or admit that God is there. So there's a real there's a real repercussion
as we as we uncover this to show people, you know as we're having these discussions with people like we got to be careful because
this can lead to
to a crisis like
What many people an artist and some of the most intellectual people among us through our history have come to the conclusion and it ended?
Their life. Oh, yes, but but even if you say there's something true
But it's it's the coherence it's it's what I want to construct it's my truth
Though the problem with that is we have to artificially manipulate our environment
to always line up with these statements that we're making and
so I have to control the friends that I hang out with because if they say something that
Disagrees with this thing that I've constructed the whole thing may come tumbling down. I have to I have to
And so we talked about
Thanksgiving and are we gonna go to our friends our families for Thanksgiving? That was the big debate. Well if I'm always
Just making up truth for myself and trying to create a system
Then yeah, it may make sense for me to exclude my family because if they're gonna challenge this thing
That's so core to me
Then I better stay away from them because it will literally shatter my life if they challenge it
But if if it's a correspondence theory of truth, meaning there's a truth outside of me not one that I create
it's actually something bigger that we can all fall into and so me being around others becomes a
Conversation to push all of us out towards what is actually true. Not each of us trying to defend what we want to
Kind of build for ourselves. Yeah. Yeah, I think we tend to create
Unneeded and dangerous and destructive loyalties to systems and doctrines
That are part of a group think right? Yeah, I mean if I here's an example
If I were to tell you the sky is purple
We're sitting in a room right now that you can't see outside at all
How do I make sure that I always convince you that the sky is purple?
Well, the one thing I can't do is let you go outside
Maybe on a cloudy day and then I say well, it's purple above the clouds
But if you ever go outside on a clear blue day, you're going to quickly realize
That's not true. And so you look at the way that so many people live their lives in our culture
That's what they're doing on a broad societal level
They come up with these ideas and these ideologies that they hold to and that are popular for the moment
And then they have to build all these structures and institutions and systems around just to prop it up
man, that's really good and I think what where where we've
Arrived and some of this is really cracking and I'm glad I thought about this
I think we talked about some previous podcast a cistern
That we are humanistic cisterns that we have constructed doing are they're not holding the secular utopian
Vision and promise is not delivering. That's a good thing. I'm thankful that it's it's unfit that it's cracking as it is, but
We are in a different place than probably what Schaefer and like how he saw it
in his
Which I would say was prophetic. I mean he was seeing something before it had fully infiltrated
the pop culture of
Western thought
In his in his two-story dichotomy
There was that there was a lower story where there were noble things
there such as mathematical facts and
Scientific equations like the like like these scientific truth like there was that there was biology
There was physics. There was
Algebra that was all in that lower story and a lot of the stuff in the upper story was still
Generally agreed upon and so it didn't quite create the division wasn't yes
But now we live in a culture that
even the things that were knowable in the past are
Unknowable such as
biology now gender isn't determined by biology or at all and and and and so you're your
biological reality may not be your reality if you see it in a different way or
even mathematics has been under assault as as a a byproduct of the the the page the Western patriarchy and and
These are this is all it's not knowable anymore
And you say man, what what is behind all and and I think what well, we know it's behind it
But I think well, why does this matter?
When you live in a bifurcated truth
What's going to happen is you are going to fill at war with yourself
We would argue it is that this is probably that one of the anchor
Evils
That ripped the human spirit apart
It's one of the someone in the comments of the last podcast with Jordan Manessa had talked about this that that we've we've moved into a
new form of Gnosticism a
disembodied
Spirituality I loved I loved how he phrased that but but that's what we're experiencing now
Mm-hmm Gnosticism meaning that the the the the the physical is bad and that the spiritual is good
And so now my physical body I'm now at war with my physical body because it doesn't match what my
Spirituality says that I am. Yeah, and so the question then becomes
Do I receive truth as something outside of me or do I have to create truth?
To bring meaning into the world
So is there a meaning and a truth that exists that I receive and then live into what we would call revelation?
Yeah, or do I have to create it that there is nothing here
And then it's just up to us to try to muster something up and that really sits at the core of this idea of
Epistemology for Christians is that we do believe that there's greater God when Jesus comes and in John 146
He says I am the way the truth and the life what he's making a statement of is that
Before all of this I am yeah
all of this flows out of who I am in the only way that you're gonna find peace and
understanding and prosperity and flourishing and all the things that you want is to fall back into me simply to receive
From me and so the pursuit we talked about this before the pursuit in our conversations
Isn't let me fight you because I got to protect what I'm holding on to
It's there is a reality
He has a name Jesus and we're going to seek him together and what it wherever that brings us
I'm gonna lay down some things that were wrong that I'm holding on to and I'm gonna press further into
Things that I've already discovered about him. Yeah, which our term of the epistemological
Humility. Yes, and
TS Eliot said that we we develop systems
For ourselves so that we don't have to be good
So even in even good and even Christian man, even I would argue this has been a very
Problematic issue for the church is that we try to put everything into a system
So that we don't have to be good
Give me the doctrine give me the system not to diminish systematic theology or systems or doctrines or any theology
but but when that becomes the focal point and even reality itself if reality is not understood as
a man who has a name which is Jesus the incarnation of the triune God then
Then we're gonna fall flat every time which I'll say this to in this episode
But we're gonna unpack this more in the next episode get a lot more practical with a lot more media
Yeah, how we then have these conversations, but I do want to say what so you said, okay?
we I think we can make a very solid case for why a
humanistic epistemology is
Unattainable because it can't be lived out
It just it contradicts it contradicts itself. And so what is a good kind of framework?
To where we could say how do we how can we know anything to be true?
and we're gonna take a
What's called a presuppositional approach meaning that we're gonna presuppose we've talked about this already in the podcast
Some of these concepts will drip throughout
We are going to make a presupposition and the reason why we're gonna presuppose
something coming into the argument or coming into the discussion or coming into the exploration is
Because we don't have the ability to not have a presupposition
Everybody is going to have a presupposition if you were raised by imams in
Iran you are going to see the world in a particular kind of way
because of the way that you were raised and because of the things that you were exposed to if I was raised in the
Bible Belt by a Southern Baptist preacher
I'm gonna see the world in a particular kind of way because of the culture that I was raised in so
To act like we can come into it any discussion
Completely objective and like we're free from all biases is a we would argue a form of arrogance
Which we participated in but and probably continue to participate in on some level
But we want to strive to be at least admit. No, we have presuppositions
our presupposition and
Moving into the discussion is going to be this
father
son
Holy Spirit and
Incarnated and the one we call Jesus
We're presupposing that we're putting that on the table
And so the the way that we're gonna are our filter that we're gonna go through is we're gonna say everyone bring their
Everybody can bring their presupposition to the table
Let's just be honest about what the presupposition is and now you bring yours
I'll bring it. This is the one works. We're starting with everybody's got to start with something and then what we're gonna look at is which
Presupposition can be lived out
What can I actually live can I can actually live like this is true and does it contradict itself?
Yeah, and that's the foundation right there
Yeah
And it matters because you you can't just say why don't we all just get along and love who cares what you think who cares?
What you feel let's just love one another
It's because going back to the whittler quote reality is what you run into
When you don't pursue what is actually true. Yeah, and so these ideas have consequences
Devastating consequences on families on societies on individuals you talked about the way nihilism
Leads to just utter despair and in most cases suicide. That's a consequence of an idea
So if we really want to love our neighbors
Then we have to pursue what's actually true because if not, it is going to lead to the destruction
Yeah, and only only by aligning with what is true
can we actually live it out without contradiction and if we can't and at the at the core of our
Worldview our identity the way we're approaching reality if it's in a way that can't be lived out
And it's in a way that that's a walking or living contradiction
That will have serious implications on our spiritual health
and so the part that we would argue that
We are pushing for this that the one of the foundations of a healthy spirituality
And even a healthy body and an embodied spirituality is
To align with what is real and and that what is real ultimately is a God who created us
so we'll come back next time and
And we're gonna dive into this in a deeper way, but that's part one. So come back next Tuesday for part two
