In this quick but important video, I challenge one of the most common and misleading bits of advice you’ll hear in dog training—particularly around recall. The idea that “if you only reward the fastest responses, then only fast responses will occur” sounds tidy in theory… but in reality, it’s nonsense.
Why? Because there’s no consistent way to know at what speed or distance your dog is responding each time, and no way to ensure you’re only reinforcing the “fastest” version of their recall. If the logic were true, your dog’s recall would eventually become faster and faster until they were running at supersonic speed—clearly not possible. This video highlights why chasing speed alone misses the point, and how nuance, clarity, and communication matter far more than blunt reward schedules.
If you’re tired of inconsistent recalls, frustrated by selective listening, or confused by conflicting advice, my Skills4Life online training programme might be the clarity you’ve been looking for. It’s not about gimmicks or performance—it’s about understanding how your dog learns and how to build reliable behaviour in the real world.
🔗 Learn more about the Skills4Life programme: / jamiepenrith
There are many things that are heard when it comes to training animals or people,
and it is talked about increasing the answers that are desired to see more and decreasing those that are desired to see less.
And one of the things, especially when it comes to the ability to remember,
is something that seems to be something common and common that everyone seems to accept and agree with,
but that when applied in reality outside of theoretical environments is not sustained.
And it is that, in terms of the ability to remember, if only the best abilities to remember are reinforced,
only the sharpest and fastest answers will be obtained,
and those abilities to remember will increase systematically in speed and enthusiasm at a distance or under distraction,
based on the fact that only the best are rewarded, only the best are reinforced.
But the reality is that this does not happen.
And even if it did happen, how can a person know that their last speed or distance of memory was precise enough
to reinforce one that they consider faster or at a greater distance at the next exit,
if in reality we do not have the data that supports our process?
Therefore, if we do not have a concrete confirmation that what we are doing is really increasing
or trying to increase the strongest, fastest and best answers,
how the hell do we know that we are doing it?
And besides, the reality is that you can't do that.
Because if you think logically, if everything I reinforced was the fastest, the best, the most determined, the most enthusiastic,
where does that end?
In what term?
I would end up having the fastest and most receptive dog on the planet
because my reinforcement is absolutely correct and is better than the reinforcement of other people.
However, what you will actually discover is that those other people have a better setback than me
because they have a better individual in the dog,
a more capable individual or genetically predisposed to be able to provide them with those faster and more determined calls back.
But the individual almost sacrifices himself in areas of reinforcement, in areas of behavior psychology,
of what they tell us will work.
And it's just not true.
And as I say, think about it yourself.
If I reinforce the fastest and the fastest and the fastest,
when does that reinforcement reach its maximum point?
When can't I go further?
And I should have a supersonic dog.
But you'll never get it because it's not.