Bottom 5 Tanks with Lindybeige
1 Video View·Sep 17, 2025
00:00 – Intro
00:51 – Countdown begins
13:55 – The final two tanks
Join Lindybeige at The Tank Museum as he counts down his picks for the Bottom 5 Tanks in history. From design flaws to battlefield failures, discover which tanks made the list and why they earned a spot among the worst of the worst.
Hello, I'm here at Tankfest, and a few years ago I was invited to make a video about my top 5 tanks.
Well, I've done that, and now I'm back to make a video about my bottom 5 tanks.
But let me be clear about this, I'm not saying that the 5 tanks in this list are the worst in the world,
but I am saying that they are my least favourite amongst the collection here at Bovington Tank Museum.
Yes, they said, please call us the Tank Museum, because we've rebranded ourselves as the Tank Museum.
But would Wimbledon rebrand itself as The Tennis Competition? No!
You've got a great name, Bovington, be proud of it. Bovington!
Please remember to like, subscribe, or click the little notification bell if you don't want to miss out on these videos.
And I'd just like to say thank you to all our patrons for making this possible. Please join them if you can.
My first choice at number 5 is this, the Carden Lloyd.
... Which some people might say, that's not a proper tank. No, this is a tankette, but this is my bottom 5,
so I get to choose, and I'm picking this, even though it has my name in it.
I'm choosing this because it is just so fabulously misconceived, and wasted so much of so many people's time.
Someone came up with the idea of a one-man tank, presented it to the Army.
They thought that was a little bit of a stupid idea, but how about they make it at least a two-man tank?
So you have a driver and a gunner, and the gun is just a Vickers machine gun.
Perfectly good medium machine gun, but they're nothing really spectacular. It doesn't really make it a tank, you could say.
And they tried to sell this idea, and did, to loads of other people around the world.
The British Army made 450 of this, they sold them to people like the Czechs, and the Canadians,
and the Japanese, and the Dutch, and the Italians, and the French, and the Bolivians, and the Finnish, and various others.
They didn't sell them in very large quantities. Most people took a look at this, thought,
hmm, we can do better because it's a bit rubbish, and so they made their own version.
But nobody actually used these things. The Belgians, they got really interested in these, and they tried all sorts of things.
They tried putting a 75mm gun on it. That didn't go well, because the recoil of the 75mm gun
threw this tiny thing right back on its haunches, and the gun pointed wildly into the air.
It was not a stable gun platform for a 75. So they tried again with a much smaller gun, but even that didn't really go terrifically well.
The Belgians, as far as I know, were the only people ever to use any of these ... firing them in anger.
This was during the invasion of Belgium right at the start of World War Two,
and a few of these that were waiting static in ambush fired some shots on one day.
And that is the only use that these ever came to. The Russians made over 3,000 copies of these things.
But everyone, when it came to it, just thought, nah, actually it's a silly idea.
And I'll tell you why it's a silly idea, because no one in his right mind really wants to sit in an open top,
thinly armoured, mildly bullet-resistant thing in the middle of a field, drawing attention to himself by firing a machine gun.
You're just so hideously vulnerable in this thing, and it wasn't comfortable at all.
This suspension, can you see these four wheels here that it runs on? They're all joined together on this solid bar.
This is a really, a real bone shaker of a ride. It was exhausting to go any distance over land on one of those things.
And not just exhausting, but also scorching, because there's an exposed engine right there,
right between the two crew members, right up against them. So yikes and ouch, and it's useless.
Well, you could say it has some legacy, in that later there came the Bren gun carrier and the Universal carrier.
And those, those were useful. But this, no, this was just useless.
I really don't like this tank. It's French.
And my next choice is this monster. Yes, this is the incredibly famous Tiger.
Everyone's heard of the Tiger. It's the iconic tank, isn't it?
If you think of the classic tank shape, with the turret on the top, the big gun sticking out the front, you think Tiger.
And it has such a fierce reputation, doesn't it? Or Tiger, you've heard of Tiger Terror, haven't you?
Because loads of vehicles were mistaken for Tigers by the Allies, because they were frightened of Tigers,
because it was the most terrifying thing they'd heard of, that the Germans had that was out there,
somewhere, lurking in the woods, about to shoot, with this enormous gun.
This is an 88mm gun, and it was, for its day, fearsomely powerful. I'm not going to criticise the gun,
because it was a very, very powerful gun, and it could knock out anything the Allies had at the time.
Good gun, there's no doubt about that. As for its reputation, well, the most fearsome thing,
whatever it is, that the enemy has out there, that you can't see, is the thing that's going to give you the collywobbles.
Whatever it is. And Tiger Terror wasn't unique to the Allies facing these things.
There are loads of German reports of the British having loads of tanks.
All they actually had was universal carriers, but the Germans mistook them for tanks,
because you do when you're terrified and you're in a trench.
And, yeah, so people were frightened of this. But really, should they have been that frightened?
Perhaps we should be glad that the Germans were making these, and not, for instance,
twice as many Panzer IVs, which they could have done for the same cost.
This is enormous, it's so ridiculously wide.
This big, thick thing at the front that has to be armoured is twice the width of a Churchill.
And it's not as well armoured as a Churchill. People think, oh, it's brilliantly armoured, the Tiger.
It's not that well armoured, it's 4 inches at the front. Yeah, for its day, that was pretty good.
But a Churchill 7 is 6 inches at the front.
The side armour, not all that thick. And what they ended up doing actually,
because they couldn't rely on their armour to keep them safe,
is they would slope their armour by parking the whole vehicle at an angle onto the enemy.
Because this is slab-flat fronted, and so a shell would just slam straight into that.
But if you parked at an angle, it would be at least sloping sideways.
They still felt that they had to do that to protect themselves. They didn't feel immune in these things.
Yeah, it's big. Yes, it was sometimes terrifying, but it was a liability.
They're so big, they use up a huge amount of resources, and they're really sophisticated.
Oh, I'll tell you how sophisticated this thing is. This had electronic everything,
which meant there were loads of things to go wrong.
People sometimes say, do you know, this had a very sophisticated turret traverse.
They could, using just the motors, they could so precisely traverse it.
They didn't have to use hand wheels. Oh no, you could just use the electronic traverse and shoot that way.
Well yeah, brilliant. But what you've got in a Sherman is a much faster traverse,
which gets you roughly on target, and then you get the little wheels to get bang on target, and then you shoot.
It's quicker, it's simpler, and it worked.
Yeah, so this was sophisticated, but it was a sophistication that didn't help.
So the Tiger, it's ridiculously overrated.
And what do you think happened the first time the British encountered this monster, this terrifying thing?
It was in the deserts of North Africa, and what happened?
I'll tell you what happened, they were all immediately knocked out by 6-pounders.
Yes, 6-pounder anti-tank guns, the British standard anti-tank gun.
A very good anti-tank gun, ridiculously underrated by almost all war game rules, I'll have you know.
Anyway, while I'm back here I can say something about the exhaust, which was incredibly noisy,
and spewed out a huge amount of smoke.
When one of these started up, people from miles around knew,
oh, that sounded like a Tiger starting, so they were well warned.
And the suspension, people go on and on about, oh, this sophisticated interleaved suspension.
What do you think might happen? Do you think it's possible, as you charge across the countryside in Russia or wherever,
that maybe some pebbles, or gravel, or mud, or maybe some ice might get in between these,
and jam everything up over and over again?
This required a huge amount of maintenance, great workshops, and teams of people
all pouring their time, effort, and resources into keeping these running.
Now, I read a report of the fate of all the Tigers that fought in Italy in World War Two,
and they lost over half of them, not to enemy action, not to mines, but no, to breakdowns.
And when I say lost, I don't mean were put temporarily out of action, but were then later fixed.
Because every time you look at the strength of a German unit in World War Two,
you've got to imagine, oh, they had 100 tanks, yeah, but maybe only half of those were actually in working order and usable.
What I mean is that they completely lost, finally that was it, the war for that tank was absolutely over,
to breakdowns. Before they lost them, of course, they broke down over, and over, and over again.
They had to actually issue an edict forbidding people to tow Tigers using Tigers.
Now Italy, I don't know if you knew this, is actually quite bumpy,
and these things really don't like going up hills, and the gearboxes and transmissions really didn't like going up hills.
There was so much strain on them that they kept breaking, and then of course they need to be towed.
And a lot of towing vehicles just weren't up to pulling something so flipping enormous up a hill.
So they would, you know, we've got another Tiger, let's use that. So they would use another Tiger,
and then that Tiger's transmission and gearbox would be overloaded, and that Tiger would be broken down.
So they had to forbid that. These things were breaking down all the flipping time.
And after a while, having repaired it, and it broke again, and repaired it, it broke again, repaired it,
they just said, that's it, right, enough, we're just leaving this great lump of useless metal here.
Here we are then, the big one. This is the Jagdtiger, and it is just huge.
I mean you can see that it's quite big, but you have to stand here to appreciate just how
mind-bogglingly immense this thing is. It has a palpable gravitational field.
This has thick armour at the front, and it's enormous, look how wide it is.
And it's got this enormous hull that's thickly armoured, so it must be tremendously heavy.
And it is, this thing weighs 72 tonnes, and that's before you've put the crew and the ammunition in it.
But what a gun, oh what a gun. People go wild about this 128mm gun.
I have to jump to touch it up there, this thing's so tall.
And, well, you might think, well it's got thick armour, and it's got a really big gun,
so it must be really brilliant. No, no, this wasn't brilliant at all, this was a really bad idea.
What is the point of an enormous gun that can knock out anything that's around,
if it's never in the right place to be used?
How do you get this gun into position? This is a tremendous gas guzzler.
Germany has no oil fields, and the late war is running out of fuel.
And this is too wide for most roads, it's far too heavy for almost every bridge.
And how do you get it even to the bridge? Because there are no bypasses.
This is 1940s Europe, there are no crisscrossing motorways everywhere.
No, you've got to go through the little winding country roads, which lead through a village.
You get to a village, oh, T-Junction, brilliant. So you come to the T-Junction,
before you can turn left you've put the end of your barrel through a cottage.
So you have to back up, the engineers have to smash that cottage down.
You then try to turn, oh no, it's hit a telegraph pole, that'll have to come down too.
You get to the bridge, oh dear, you can't get across the bridge.
This was a nightmare for logistics. So this was a terrible idea.
But it's not actually on my list of least favourite tanks.
Because instead, this is. This is the Tortoise.
And the Tortoise is the British equivalent of the Jagdtiger.
It's tremendously thickly armoured, there's 9 inches of armour here.
This is proof against almost anything. And it has a stupendous gun.
I've waxed lyrical many times about how great the British 17-pounder was.
Well this, this is a 32-pounder gun. It's a big wallopper of a gun.
This could take out anything the Germans had.
So it's got thick armour, it's got quite a big crew.
There were seven guys in here because it took so many men to handle the ammunition for the gun.
It's got machine guns, it's got two Bezos on a turret there,
and another one the other side which can pivot around the place.
It's actually, it's better equipped in terms of machine gun than the Jagdtiger.
But this never actually saw action during the war.
They started putting this together in 1943,
but they took so long developing it that the war ended before they could put this into action.
So it never did a thing, so it did even less than the Jagdtiger.
And of course it wasted a huge amount of resources,
all the design teams and all the manufacturing resources.
Do you know this has got a one-piece casemate?
Just think how difficult casting something like this is in one piece.
This weighs 80 tonnes, it's even heavier than a Jagdtiger.
They always have a tremendous time moving it around in this museum, it always damages the floor.
So why have I picked the Tortoise and not the Jagdtiger?
Well, it's because the Tortoise is British.
Now the Jagdtiger wasted a huge amount of resources for the Germans,
and did nothing for the German war effort.
Well, say I, good, that's good, I'm glad the Germans lost.
I'm frankly very relieved that the Allies won.
But the Tortoise costs ... just think how many more Churchills they could have built
that were actually useful.
This was meant to be the vehicle for attacking the Siegfried Line,
but when it actually came to it we had the Churchill Crocodile,
and that was extremely effective.
Did the job absolutely fine, no problems.
This was a waste.
We needed to win this war and this wasn't helping at all.
Bad Tortoise, bad!
The Tank Museum is a registered charity,
and every purchase you make from our online shop directly supports our work.
We ship worldwide, and if you subscribe to our email list,
we'll give you 10% off your next order.
When you finish this video, go to tankmuseumshop.org
and you'll find something you never knew you needed.
Right, this is my next choice.
Can you tell what it is yet?
No, you probably can't, but I'll put you out of your misery.
This is the A7V.
You still don't know what it is, do you?
Most probably you don't, because A7V is such an un-evocative name, isn't it?
Tiger, Cromwell, Comet, those are proper tank names.
This one doesn't have a proper name, A7V.
Is that the best they could do?
Okay, this one, just so that you know, is the big German one.
You know, World War One, the British came up with the tank,
the Mark IV was what was being made in thousands by the time they came up with this.
And this was the German equivalent, sort of.
These things were slow.
But that's a little bit unfair, because tanks in general in this period were slow.
But these were particularly cumbersome and difficult to drive.
They had a reputation for overturning,
which is not, frankly, what someone just about to get into one wants to hear.
And the driver who sat up there, he had a massive 33 foot blind spot.
You can see where he's looking there,
and you can see where the front of the equivalent of the bonnet is.
So there's a massive great dead space he can't see in front.
And of course this is World War One,
there are shell holes and all sorts of obstacles to be negotiated, which he can't see.
There were an awful lot of eggs in this delicate basket.
Packed inside this infernal machine were 17 to 25 men.
And the shell surrounding them wasn't hardened plate or anything,
no, it was just quite ordinary steel.
It was reasonably bullet resistant,
but I wouldn't want to be, frankly, any of the eggs in this basket.
Now during World War One the British made over 2,500 heavy tanks,
and the Germans captured and put into use on their side 50 of those.
Which is significant because in total the Germans only ever made 20 of these.
Yes, the Germans had far more British captured tanks than their own tanks.
So this is really not a significant tank.
It appeared very late in the war and played almost no part in deciding matters.
So it's quite an insignificant tank,
which is a little bit annoying ... given that in every completist book,
or every collection of plastic kits, they have to have one of these.
You don't have to have one of these, this is an insignificant tank.
Now I'm down here by the running gear.
And for full disclosure, this is actually not a complete original tank,
this is actually a wooden mock-up.
But it gives you a very good idea of the general proportions.
Look at the ground clearance, it's tiny.
Now the British had developed the tank, and they'd come up with this lozenge shape,
with the big high horns that reached far up and forwards.
And they were great, a proven design for crossing trenches.
This, on a really good day, under ideal circumstances,
could maybe, with the following wind, cross a 6 foot trench.
But if there was mud around, or a parapet, and some posts, and what have you, no it couldn't.
This had a lot of trouble with trenches and mud.
Now then, it's World War One.
What is the entire point of a heavy tank in World War One?
It's for dealing with trenches and mud.
So if you can't do that basic thing, you're a rubbish tank.
So the Germans had their chance, and they blew it.
They could have just copied the British, and come up with a very similar design to the British.
But oh no, they had to develop their own tank,
and they came up with this great heap of nonsense instead.
This did play one part in history though, because on the 24th of April in 1918,
three of these waddled forwards and encountered three British tanks.
And there was the first ever tank-on-tank engagement, which the Germans lost.
Two of the British tanks were females, they just had machine guns,
so they just pulled back and left it to the one male that was armed with six pounder guns.
And it blew up one of these and saw the other two off.
So there you go, when it actually came to it, it couldn't deliver the goods.
All right, all right, yes, this is my number one.
This is my least favourite tank.
And it's not just because it's French, but do please bear in mind this really is French.
This is the Char B, this is its main gun.
And would you believe that in the original conception of this they didn't even have a turret?
They put that on, the most useful bit, as an afterthought.
They thought, oh no, now let's have a really low gun in a vehicle for taking out fortifications
by going really close to them, and then having a gun that's so low
that it can fire through the firing slits of bunkers and so forth.
Just think how close you'd have to get to a bunker for that to be a consideration.
That's not a very good idea, and that's not the way tanks were used.
Yeah, they added that on as an afterthought.
And it's got a reasonable, for its day, anti-tank gun on it.
But this tank was phenomenally expensive.
It cost three times what the D2 cost, which had the same gun on it.
So they could have had three times as many tanks in three times as many places,
with three times as many pairs of eyes looking for targets, with the same guns on.
But no, no, no, they had to go for these things.
Now there's a weird illusion, actually.
When you see photographs of these, they look enormous.
And yet when you stand next to it, it's not actually that big.
The front of it's only that wide.
It had a crew of four, but only one in the turret.
And that's a really bad idea.
A one-man turret is not a good thing.
The poor commander, he could see almost nothing out of the cupola here.
So he had to get out of the back of the turret to look around at the world about him.
He then had to traverse, fire, find new targets, spot those,
work this gun, load this gun, fire this gun, and try to command the three men beneath him.
So there were two men trying to work this horrible gun, and one driver sitting on this side.
Now the two loaders working on this gun had no traverse, you'll notice.
There's no way of traversing left and right, this.
So how did they deign?
Well, you had to turn the entire vehicle.
But they had no mechanism back then for turning a vehicle very precisely.
So aiming this was very approximate.
And at long distance, well, good luck frankly.
So not a very useful gun down there.
Crew communication, awful.
And command capability, awful.
Now fair's fair, this was a decently armoured tank.
And for its day, yeah, it was a well armoured tank, at least from the front.
This sloping plate here at the front would keep the 37mm anti-tank rounds
of the standard German anti-tank gun of the day out.
They would go pinging off that.
But let's not go overboard by how well armoured it was.
It was only 40 to 60mm at the front.
That's not that great, it's not as good as a Sherman,
which is generally considered only a medium armoured tank.
Although the Sherman, to be fair, did come a bit later.
And round the side things were quite a bit thinner.
And there's a bit of a weak spot down there, which I'll show you.
But before I do, I may draw your attention to this interesting and unusual design of tank track.
You see it's symmetrical and sort of bulbous and rounded.
And you might think that would afford it a very poor grip.
And my guess is, yes, it did afford it a very poor grip.
It might be good at spreading the load.
But nobody ever copied this design later.
They went for things where you've got a good grip on the ground and tear away.
Now the sides are flat, and of course a lot thinner than the front.
So from the side, this is definitely vulnerable.
It's flat, it's high.
And look at this, there's a great big air vent here to the engine.
Such an anti-tank gunner, just put around there, boom!
Now, some bright spark, or perhaps I should say idiot,
in France came up with the interesting idea of developing a specialist tank fuel.
Yes, a fuel specific for tanks, which was presumably slightly better
than ordinary diesel or petrol that other people might use.
During the Blitzkrieg, this turned out to be a really bad idea.
You see, these are gas guzzlers, so they had quite a short range.
They were fairly slow, and they had to be followed by a column of fuel bowsers on lorries.
So the Germans were able to advance into France,
stopping at just the local ordinary domestic petrol station,
and just fuelling up as normal.
But these had to stop and be refuelled by those vulnerable lorries.
And of course it did happen once that the Germans caught them.
And well, I think you can understand how that went,
when they were caught vulnerable, being refuelled.
The Germans captured loads of these, but what did they do with them?
Did they use them as battle tanks because they were such fearsome things?
No, they recognised pretty soon that ... using one of these in battle was not a brilliantly good idea.
They used them as munitions carriers, some were converted into flamethrowers.
They were used for training drivers of tanks.
This particular one was used with an oppressive mission.
And that's one of the reasons I have particular hatred for this tank,
because this tank oppressed my countrymen.
Yes, this was stationed on the Channel Islands for keeping down the populations.
And well, I think you can understand that that's not a good thing.
And it's so filthy, I mean just look at it.
Look at the ... this is easily the grungiest tank in the whole museum,
which possibly reflects the contempt that other people have for it, frankly.
I mean, for goodness sake, France, have you never heard of a parade ground?
So those were my five bottom tanks.
Were they your least favourite as well? You could comment below.
I'm not going to read the comments though, because frankly I don't care.
But I do care about tanks, always have.
Whenever I do my tax return at the end of the year,
and you know, get to the optional bit at the end for what they spend your tax money on,
I always tick the box for tanks.
But possibly you're not a British taxpayer.
But there is a way you can support the museum here,
because you can subscribe to the Tank Museum's own YouTube channel,
or become a supporter of the Tank Museum on Patreon.
So there you go, I've said my thing now.
You can now say yours.

