Content Marketing is still as vital as it was years ago. We have seen companies making a fortune out of it and others who run out of business. The thing with content marketing needs you to be extremely careful with the channels you want to focus on. Always choose channels that you can control. For instance, we have seen people who solely focus on YouTube, then their accounts are discontinued, and they go down. Today, we are fortunate to have a content marketing guru joining me on the show, Joe Pulizzi. He is the founder of The Tilt, author of seven books, including Content Inc., and co-founder of the speech-therapy fundraiser, The Orange Effect Foundation. Today, he will be sharing nuggets of wisdom we need to know about content marketing. Listen in and learn.
Growing an Audience as a Solopreneur First, you need to identify your differentiating area by niching down your audience. Second, identify your home base. Decide which platform you want to use for your content marketing. Lastly, remember to be consistent.
Do people still read email? People still read email if it delivers the right content and captivates them enough. Your goal as a business should be to ensure your emails do not land in the spam box and that the content is worth your audience’s time.
Joe’s inner superpower Joe believes his superpowers are writing and following his goals. He believes in the power of reading his goals in the morning and at night. Reading his goals in the morning helps him remain focused all day long, and at night it helps him come up with crazy ideas on how to make them a reality.
Timestamps: [00:43] Getting to know Joe and the wonderful things he does [03:37] Tips for growing an audience as a solopreneur [07:20] How Joe exited his business. How much was the exit? [09:50] How to get sponsors [12:20] Joe’s new company [23:331] Are people still reading newsletters? [25:54] Text message versus email [31:44] Understanding the open rate and the future of email [39:49] How Joe transitioned into entrepreneurship [44:09] Joe’s inner superpower that has brought him this far
Quotes: “You can’t be great at everything. You can’t be remarkable on every channel, so pick your spots that you can do.” “My biggest concern with what’s going on with the creator economy right now is that I don’t think enough creators understand that those big, centralized tech companies don’t care about you individually. They will do anything to make more money.” “Your email needs to be so important that you become one of those 234 most important things that they go and open every day.” “It takes a long time to build a loyal audience. But once that audience starts to know, like, and trust you, they will ultimately buy anything you put in front of you.”
Do you have an idea for a business but lack funding? Or Do you already have a business and would like to see it grow but lack funding? Or Are you a real estate investor and need funding?
We love seeing entrepreneurs WIN! We offer 0% funding for up-to 20 months and no collateral loans, I have an experienced team that will help you get the funding you need when banks say no we say YES!!! Just hit this link https://www.7figurescredit.com?a_aid=superfunding and fill out the quick application that take 30-45 seconds, 13 questions no upfront fees no hard credit check we don’t even ask for your SSN# Once you submit the application you will be connected with a funding advisor who will answer all your questions and guide you through the funding process and get you the $$$$!!!! FYI we Broker commercial deals too.
Music Produced With 432hz For Mind & Body Relaxation
Welcome to Super Entrepreneurs Podcast.
Today we have with us Joe Polizzi.
Joe, how are you?
I'm doing fantastic. Thanks for having me.
Such an honor to have you on the show, my friend.
And for audience, you know, you're going to be really pumped
to learn more from Joe here.
Joe is a authority on content.
So it's going to be really, really amazing.
I'm looking forward to speaking in more detail with you, Joe.
So just to begin, I would like to kind of allow you to speak
and kind of introduce yourself and give us a picture
of all the wonderful things that you do.
Sure. Happy to.
We'll keep it short.
So basically, I started in publishing 20 years ago
and was lucky enough to fall in this area called content marketing.
It wasn't called content marketing at the time.
We sort of tried to rename the industry from custom publishing to content
marketing, which is basically instead of interrupting your customers
with information they don't want, like advertising, how do you create
valuable, relevant, compelling information, tell some wonderful stories,
find a platform, build an audience and then monetize that audience.
Started the company Content Marketing Institute
2007, really renamed it to that point in 2010.
Then 2011, we launched Content Marketing World, which is still today
the largest in-person event for content marketing.
In 2015, before my wife and I sold the business in 2016,
we had 4000 attendees from I think it was over 50 countries
at the time, all coming to Cleveland, Ohio.
Cleveland's my hometown.
And so we had a successful exit in 2016.
I took a sabbatical year at 18,
decided to write a novel in 2019 called The Will to Die
just to try something new, and then COVID-19 came around.
And for some wild reason, I decided to start another business.
So the new business is called The Tilt.
And instead of the old business, we targeted enterprise marketers.
So marketers that worked at IBM and Amazon
and tried to teach them complex content solutions.
Now with The Tilt, we're targeting content creators.
So solopreneurs, people that are trying to build their business
on YouTube, on TikTok, with a blog, with an email newsletter
and help them figure out the business model for success,
kind of like we did at Content Marketing Institute.
And then along the way, I've written seven books.
The most recent one is Content Inc., which kind of goes through the whole process
of how you start a business with nothing.
You build an audience first, and then once you build a loyal audience,
then you can monetize that audience up to eight plus different ways.
And that's the business model.
So here I am.
That's awesome.
Trying to help as many people creating content
to figure out that there is a business model.
That's great, because, you know, content is on every entrepreneur,
self-employed professional's mind, you know, and it's
and there's so much information out there and there's different suggestions,
recommendations with your backing and your experience
that you have in your career.
What would you as a top five suggestions
on growing an audience for a solopreneur, for example?
So I think the most important thing is you have to figure out
what we call a content tilt.
What is your differentiation area?
What is your hook?
How do you cut through all the clutter?
Where a lot of content creators get into problems
is they start creating content that's that's just like everybody else out there.
So if you're going to create a blog on, let's say, cloud computing.
Wow, you've got a lot of competition in that area.
So how are you going to figure out?
Is are you going to talk to a very niche audience
and really get that down to a narrow area?
Are you going to go on a new platform?
And that's your stick.
Are you do you have a sense of humor?
You know, what do you bring to the table?
That's amazing and interesting.
The other area that entrepreneurs get into trouble with this
is they want to be on all the platforms.
It's like, oh, my gosh, I've got to be on TikTok
and I got to be on Twitter and LinkedIn.
I got to do all the things.
Well, no, you don't.
That is a recipe for disaster.
Actually, what you want to do is choose.
So where's your home base?
We call this building the base.
Where are you going to set up camp and tell your stories on a regular basis?
So what we see is somebody picks a blog.
Somebody picks an email newsletter.
Somebody says their home is on TikTok.
Somebody is on YouTube.
Somebody's on Twitch.
Now, it doesn't mean you shouldn't use and leverage other social platforms,
but it means your home is one place.
So why is Joe Rogan successful?
Because he focused on having an amazing podcast.
Why did Gwyneth Paltrow create Goop?
And why was that so successful for her?
Because they basically just focused on creating an amazing blog.
Then you branch out and diversify later.
So that's the second thing.
And I think the third thing is the most important thing,
more than as much content as you put out.
It's consistency.
And a lot of people forget that.
It's like you have to figure out what is your time slot.
Are you creating?
Let's say it's a YouTube channel.
Are you producing a YouTube like every Thursday at 10 o'clock a.m.?
And that's your spot.
And instead of what a lot of creators do is like,
oh, we're going to upload on Monday and then maybe on Thursday,
and then I'm going to skip a couple of days and then do Wednesday.
It's like, no, no, no, no.
That's a losing proposition.
That doesn't work.
Look at what the great content entrepreneurs are doing.
They're very consistent with their schedule,
just like the old days when we used to get newspapers at the front door
that you used to get at the same time every day.
And when you didn't, you're very disappointed.
So that content is your promise to your customers.
So you want to make sure you uphold that promise and deliver consistently.
So those are kind of three areas.
Just kind of some research to know about.
It takes generally about nine months for a content creator to go from
actually make to nine months to actually make a first dollar.
So it's not like you get rich.
It's not get rich quick.
This is a marathon, not a sprint.
It takes about 18 months until we see content entrepreneurs
like hiring and outsourcing different parts of the business.
And about 26 months until they get to a point
where they're financially sustainable.
So which is not so bad for an entrepreneur.
So you basically just prepare for lean times,
cut your expenses down when you need to get it.
For us personally, when we started Content Marketing Institute,
took us 22 months to get to the point where we felt successful with the business.
And then, of course, in about six years later, we had a very successful exit.
So you can see from the 22 months on, if you do this right,
you can see hockey stick type growth and get to a point
where you can get that multimillion dollar valuation that you want.
So will this be like a personal question?
And you don't have to answer it.
But what range was that exit in?
Because I saw that smile on your face.
So a lot of people would love to hear.
No, I'm actually happy to share because in my book, Content Inc.,
I put all the numbers out there.
So just to give you an idea, I'll talk about the revenue and the way it works.
So we started on a blog.
So we basically delivered a blog post five days a week.
Content Marketing Institute.
So it took us about 22 months to get to what we call a minimum viable audience.
In 2010, I believe we had a little bit, let's say $400,000, $500,000 in revenue.
We got to that point.
So we're looking pretty good.
By 2015, we had just shy of $10 million in revenue at about a 23%, 24% net profit margin.
So we were taking home a couple million dollars.
And then in 2016, we sold the business for $17.9 million.
And then with bonuses and everything else that happened,
because there was an earn out and all that kind of stuff.
So it was a little less overall than about $30 million.
A little bit less than that, but we were close to hitting that number.
So yeah, it was very successful.
Yeah, it worked very well.
So we had multiple different revenue opportunities.
So this is really good for content entrepreneurs to think about.
So generally, a content entrepreneur will start with sponsorship advertising.
So did we.
Find some good sponsors.
Then we launched some online training.
We actually had a print magazine, believe it or not, that we sold advertising in.
And then we launched our big event, Content Marketing World.
That event ended up being a $6 million event all by itself.
And then when you look at selling an entity like an event,
generally a large event like that gets between eight and 10 times earnings.
So that's where you get the multiple.
So let's say if you're making $2 million off of that event,
you should be able to get, if it's a regular annual event,
you should be able to get $15, $16, $17 million for that kind of an event.
So that's why I love the event business.
And I'm very excited about if anybody listening to this,
if you're thinking about getting into in-person events,
now's a really good time because 2022 and 2023 are going to be amazing for events.
Once we sort of get through the unknown of COVID-19.
It's a great opportunity right now.
What's the best way that you recommend to get sponsors?
So if someone has a podcast, how is the best way for them to attract sponsorship?
So there's a couple of different ways to do it.
First of all, as much as we want to get revenue as soon as possible,
I like to tell, let's say in this case, a podcaster to wait as long as they can
to get to a larger number that you can sell to somebody.
So let's say that you just started and you're at 500 downloads an episode
and you're like, fantastic, but you really,
it's very hard to get substantial dollars for something like that.
So let's say you waited until you got 5,000 downloads an episode.
You're like, okay, that's fantastic.
It's very simple.
You need to make a list of your audience.
So who's your audience?
Let's say you're targeting mechanical engineers
that work at companies of a thousand employees or more,
and you're a business to business podcast.
Great. So you're like, I'll get to 5,000 downloads.
Well, who are the companies that are trying to reach those people?
Are they other software companies?
Are they manufacturing component companies?
So you should know, because you know the industry better than anyone else,
because you know the audience better than anyone else,
what those companies are.
So you make the list of those companies
and you should all along while you're building your business,
you should have partnership plans in motion to reach out to those companies
and figure out how you can help them.
Don't ask for money at first.
Get involved with them.
Know those people who are in charge of those marketing programs.
Say, hey, can we work on a research project together?
Do you have any information that I should be sharing with my audience?
Build that relationship first.
And if you do that, then the paid opportunities will happen.
So when we started Content Marketing Institute,
I had a list of about 40 different companies
that we wanted to work with that we knew in the future,
if we did what we needed to do, would pay us money for things.
But at first, we just wanted to build a relationship.
So I literally just went out, found their email address,
reached out, said, here's who I am.
If I can be of help to you in any way, I've got a regular blog.
This is what we're trying to do.
Not all those people reached back, but about half of them did.
I built very good relationships with those companies.
And then about half of those people ended up sponsoring us
over the next five years or so.
That's excellent.
Excellent advice.
Thank you, Joe, for sharing that.
I got it.
And for this new company that you have, right?
How do you service or serve entrepreneurs, for example?
If someone approached you today, how do you help them?
Well, it depends on where they're at in the process.
So if there's multiple stages, and for our model,
methodology is called the content model.
Are you starting?
If you're starting, we try to find out what's your sweet spot.
What are you good at?
Who's your audience?
Let's figure out the right audience niche for you.
What is that content tilt?
What's that area of differentiation that you can cut through the clutter?
Or you may be at a point where, hey, I've built an audience.
I've got my base.
I've got to figure out diversification.
So does that mean do I organically grow into diversification,
which means do I take my podcast and then, say, build a YouTube channel?
Or do I do a live event like we talked about before?
And there might be monetization.
It's like, Joe, hey, I really get the sponsorship thing,
but I don't understand how to create an online training course or something like that.
So basically, right now at the tilt, we just started in April.
We have an e-newsletter that goes out twice a week.
It's a very lengthy email.
But what we do is we have one learning at the top.
Here's the learning of the week.
So last issue, I talked about how content entrepreneurs can use creator coins or social
tokens, how they can launch their own crypto, the business case for that,
why you should look into it in the future, all those types of things.
So we'll teach one thing, and then we'll go through all the creator economy news.
So what's YouTube doing?
Should you take advantage of that?
What's this software doing?
We talk a lot about M&A as well.
Maybe you're a small creator, a mid-sized creator, and you want to buy another podcaster.
So those things are starting to happen right now.
Oh, really?
I didn't hear about that.
No, I would say what you're going to see in the next 12 to 18 months is you're going to
see a lot of acquisitions in the content creator space.
Some of them will be small creators buying or partnering with another small creator,
some of them are going to be large deals like marketing automation company HubSpot
recently purchased The Hustle online newsletter.
That was a $27 million deal or something like that, and The Hustle's 1.5 million circulation.
So that's the kind of deals we're going to start seeing because a large company,
it's very difficult for them to build an audience like this.
They have so many things going on.
It's very hard to focus on one niche, but they have funds.
They have a lot.
They have so much money.
As you know, it's ridiculous how much money these big companies have.
They'll say, oh, I like that podcast.
I like that e-newsletter.
What about that YouTuber?
And what they're doing is they're starting to pick these creators off, and instead of
what they used to do is just partner or sponsor, now they're going out and actually purchasing
them.
So at The Tilt, we're educating on all those things.
We've got a really wonderful Discord community.
We're launching online training in December, and we're trying to be that resource for content
creators to figure out not just how to build an audience or drive one or two revenue sources,
how they can be financially successful over a long period of time to get to whatever exit
that is.
Is that a lifestyle business for you, which is wonderful if you want to just keep going
forever and make whatever you make, or do you want to have an exit like my wife and
I did?
Beautiful.
It's amazing.
And for you, are your services a mix of done for you and education, or is it purity
education?
It's education and news.
So there's two parts of it.
One is, if you're a content creator, so we were trying to figure out, okay, what problems
do content creators or content entrepreneurs have right now?
The first thing is, how do I keep up with what the heck is going on with all the new
technology and all the new deals?
So what we do is we scour, I don't know, probably 100 different sources every day to figure
out, here's the 10 things that you need to know.
And we put them in the little blurbs, and we say, okay, why should you care?
So that we do that two times a week.
So you can, because I don't, I mean, I don't know about you, but it's a little bit difficult
to keep up with all the news that's going on today.
And so we've got a wonderful team of people that that's all they do.
And then we've got a whole community that they're in the different parts.
So what's different about ours and community than other ones is a lot of, we're not just,
we've got some that are on YouTube.
We got some that are using TikTok.
We got some that are podcasters, some that are email newsletters, some that are authors,
but they're not all on one platform.
And what we're trying to do is figure out, okay, what's the basic business model for
working this?
And then we'll take one topic in each newsletter and try to break it down and figure out, okay,
here's how you use this thing.
Do I, I don't know, honestly, where it's going to go because we're following the model that
we promote to our, uh, to our audience and say you the first nine to 12 months, you're
just in minimum viable audience mode.
You should just be building an audience.
You shouldn't be so worried.
Like that's, these are the lean times.
These are, these are the times when all you're doing your head's down building an audience.
And then you get to that nine, 12 month area.
You get to your minimum viable audience number, and then you start saying, okay, I've got
my base.
Like our base is an email newsletter.
What's our social media platforms.
We use, we use Twitter and LinkedIn majority for the most part, because you can't be great
at everything.
You can't be remarkable on every channel.
So pick your spots that you can do.
The reason we chose an email newsletter.
So this is important for everyone listening.
So a lot of listeners probably say, oh, I'm going to build on Facebook group.
I'm going to build on Instagram.
I'm going to build on Tik TOK, which is fine.
But you got to remember at the end of the day, that's not your audience.
You have to bring them there.
That's their audience.
You are renting, you're leasing space.
So what you're doing is if you think about it, let's say that you release an apartment
and you fix up that apartment and you put a million dollars into it.
Well, who does that help?
That helps the owner of the apartment.
Doesn't help you temporarily because you build a really nice place.
But at the end of the day, if you resell it, that's not yours.
That's Facebook's.
That's Instagram's.
So that's what we've been doing as content creators is building these platforms.
We chose to go with an email newsletter first party data because we can control that a little
bit more.
I now have the permission to communicate with the audience on a regular basis.
So our recommendation is always to say, OK, if you're building on another platform, that's
fine.
Maybe it makes sense for you to start on Instagram.
So start on Instagram and then you want to figure out your rent to own strategy.
So figure out how to move that audience over to an email newsletters or your exactly your
blog.
Maybe it's an online membership site that you can control something like that where
you get access to their first party data, their email address.
Because I mean, I don't know if you remember the days when Google Plus shut down, but at
the time I was in the corporate environment.
So we were working with a lot of, you know, billion dollar tech companies that had some
million, you know, they had a million plus members on different Google Plus groups.
One day they're going great.
They've got a million people on that channel.
It's working.
It's a vibrant community.
And the next day, Google says we're shutting Google Plus down.
And there were tears shed because they spent so much time and energy building up those
communities.
And then Google just says, no, we're done.
Well, you have Facebook, right?
Yes, exactly.
It's happening.
It'll happen everywhere.
Or something like Twitter can just kick you off their platform.
YouTube happens.
It's happening a lot with YouTube because YouTube is really tightening down what they
allow you to say and what they don't, which, by the way, is totally fine because they're
a private company.
They can do whatever they want, but we don't have to play by those rules.
So I just that's my biggest concern.
What's going on with the creator economy right now is the fact that I don't think enough
creators understand that those big centralized tech companies don't care about you individually,
and they will do anything to make more money.
And sometimes you'll get lost.
And there you go.
You've been building something up for a long time, and then it's gone.
So if you're listening to this and you built on other platforms, that's fine.
That's great.
Good job.
Figure out a way to get that to a point where you create some wonderful email experience
or some membership experience where you can get that email address.
Yeah.
And, you know, another thing is that a lot of people hear this and actually implement
this strategy, but they basically just don't want to reinvent the wheel, right?
So they see whatever the top people are doing.
They just mimic that, right?
Which is okay.
Just, you know, you don't want to reinvent the wheel.
You want to see who's doing something great and then try to, you know, do something unique
in that area.
But the problem is that they are also without people realizing, but they're building their
email list right in the back.
So building that database of your own is so crucial because like you said, you never know
what these platforms.
Well, that's a really good point because if you go in and you look at the Mr. Beast of
the world or the MatPat's of the world or these wonderful YouTubers that have built
this experience, they've come to that same moment where they're like, oh my goodness,
they wake up and they're like, oh my God, I've gotten 2 million followers on YouTube,
but I have nothing in the business that's an asset and they get scared and then they
start moving.
So if you look at those business models, after two or three years, they start working a plan
where they've got an amazing email newsletter.
Actually, I'll give you a really good example.
My friend Wally Koval started a site called Accidentally Wes Anderson.
So basically every day he puts a picture on Instagram that looks like it came out of a
Wes Anderson movie and he's got over a million followers on Instagram now and he came to
that same moment and now he's got his e-newsletter now has, I think, 50 or 60,000 subscribers
to it.
So he's in the process of doing that, building out his entire media portfolio because all
this, all we're talking about here is media 101.
But a lot of people don't realize that.
So now he's got his Instagram following.
That's great.
He's got his email newsletter.
He's starting, he's got the blog.
He's in diversification mode.
He's starting a blog.
He's starting other products and services.
So that's kind of where you go.
So there is steps.
First, build that base, heads down, whatever that platform is.
Then you get to a point where you want to build that audience and that starts with that
email property.
And yeah, to your point, look at what the great ones are doing.
They're all doing it.
It's just, we don't realize it because we may only follow them on TikTok or Facebook
group or whatever the case is.
Yeah.
And newsletter, do you feel people still read?
I haven't done any research on this, but are people signing up for newsletters with
having access on your fingertips and just Google things?
It's so funny.
So we've done a lot of research on this because I've got probably more than anything else.
I get pushed back on this because they're like, Joe, this is, you know, social media,
web three.
Are you kidding me?
Are we going to go back into the dinosaur?
Yeah, exactly, that's what I was thinking.
Yeah, which email is a very old technology, but this is so I always ask this personally
and I'll ask this to you.
It's like, so you get just like me, you get tons of spam email, right?
Yeah.
But it aren't there.
Don't you have two, one or two emails that you open all the time that are really important
for you?
Always, always.
Yeah.
And I even, I even, I even sign up for things, but I say I don't want it, but I,
I cherry pick the good ones.
So that's the thing.
I'm so, so, and I'm the same way I've got, I've got three or four emails every day that
I open that are important to me.
And what we found out is that, and then, so there's, first of all, is this our goal is
it is a creator is not to be part of the spam.
Your email needs to be so important that you become one of those two, three, four most
important things that they go and open every day.
And the other thing I'll get is all Gen Z millennials.
They don't, they don't open email, whatever.
And I'm like, okay, well, first of all, millennials do.
If you look at the, the, uh, research, they open email just as much as Gen Z or boomers
or whatever, or, uh, uh, Gen X or boomers or whatever the case is.
So that, that's the first thing.
The second thing is what are, what's the glue that holds social media together?
The glue is email.
What does every social media platform ask for?
When you start up your email address, email binds everything together.
It's the primary key of the database of social media right now.
So I think a lot of people forget that.
So that's where we have to figure out.
And is that, or does that mean you have to have an amazing, remarkable email newsletter?
Maybe, but it might be an online group.
It might be something that's linked with your discord channel, your discord server.
There's a lot of different things that you do, but you have to create
some kind of one-to-one experience where you can access that.
So, so you, you don't have that middle layer of the social media platform in the middle.
And between email and text message, what, what are your thoughts?
Because text message platforms are coming out, right?
Yeah.
It's interesting.
So we're, that's a, MS, SMS is really interesting on how that's going.
What we've seen success with SMS is during a short period of time.
So if you go to Disney world, you sign up for their updates while you're there.
And people will absolutely sign up.
They absolutely open.
They don't look at it as interruption.
And, and they say, that's a great technology.
Now, outside of that, now we're starting to get into some experimentation where
you're a content creator and will, it's a very personal technology, right?
Getting a text, getting an SMS.
That's very personal.
So you have to make sure that this is really a welcome message.
I've seen people do it really well where you're starting to see, yes, there's a possibility.
They want to get that information.
So I know one of my friends is signed up to an SMS of a local journalist because he wants
all the local news that's going on in his community.
And he wants to get that every day and he gets it through SMS.
That's great.
Makes sense.
Welcome personal.
A lot of people don't want to get that because that's the way they don't want that kind of
a business relationship there through SMS.
So we're looking into it.
I don't know what the future is.
I think it might be useful.
I like it for short periods of time where you turn it on and turn it off.
I don't know about ongoing, how open people are going to be to, to doing something like
that.
Maybe WhatsApp is better for that instead of your, you know, personal text.
Maybe, you know, Facebook Messenger, whatever the case is, we don't know yet, but it's still
an experimentation mode.
That was a good point that text messages based on a person's mood at the time as well, when
he gets a message, right?
It could be, you know, they're cool with someone getting messages, they're reading it, you
know, and at one time they get a message and it's just the wrong text.
Oh, I don't need this interruption because a text message is really, it basically comes
in between whatever a person is doing, right?
It's very intimate, like you said, very personal.
I found that I signed up for text message once, but when it was just, when it came a
couple of times, I did opt out of it.
And emails can continue to come.
I just, I don't, until I get really, really a lot of them, then I start, you know, unsubscribing.
But other than that, I can understand what you mean by that point of text message being
personal and interruptive in some ways.
Yeah, who knows what's going to happen in the future?
Like now WhatsApp is bought by Facebook, right?
And their privacy situation.
I wanted to ask you about the privacy.
A lot of people, you know, with the new email technology, they have a lot of spam or ways
to kind of move emails away from their inbox, even if they sign up.
I know there's ways to ask them to reply back to make sure it doesn't go in those folders.
Any suggestion for that?
Yes, absolutely.
It's a great point.
So, and of course, with the GDPR laws in Europe, and then what's happening in the United States,
you've got to make sure you've got double opt-in.
So double opt-in for those people that don't know, basically, if I go to a site and I sign
up, that doesn't, if I just sign up and click submit with my email, that doesn't count.
That then sends you an email and you have to click and confirm.
So that's your double opt-in.
And if you're not doing double opt-in and you have an email newsletter, you've got problems
in the future because you will not be in the requirements of a lot of email providers then.
And so down the road, that's where we're going.
That's where every country is going.
Make sure you have double opt-in.
So what happens is this is what you do.
So you do the double opt-in.
Somebody clicks through.
And then that welcome email needs to have information to say, hey, please whitelist me.
Make sure that you go into your email settings, Gmail, whatever, and say that this email is
going to be coming from whatever, joe at the tilt.com.
Make sure that you go ahead and whitelist me on a regular basis.
Or it could be reply.
But I like the whole idea of looking at whitelisting.
If you do that and you sort of tell your, whatever your outlook or email that you use,
that this address is okay, you will get through.
So you have to do that and educate in your welcome email.
And again, if people want to receive it, they generally do it.
If I really, really want to get this, if they don't want to get it,
then you're not, it doesn't matter anyways.
They're not going to open your email, whatever, forget about it.
And so we work really hard at the tilt to make sure that we give them a welcome letter.
Welcome.
Here's what, here's what this thing is all about.
Thanks for signing up.
Make sure you whitelist us here.
It's coming through this email address so that we can make sure we deliver.
And we've had, I mean, the opt-in stuff with Apple is interesting, right?
Because Apple keeps changing their privacy
where they're not necessarily counting open rate anymore.
So as an email newsletter provider, maybe you're looking less at open rate,
which, you know, we, you know, we'd love to hit 40% would be an amazing open rate.
Even 20% is generally industry standard.
But now you're going to click through rate as sort of,
that's the measure because you can measure a click,
but you can't necessarily measure an open anymore
because Apple's doesn't really let you do that as much anymore.
So, and since everyone's opening them with their iPhones,
you know, Apple and Apple can do what they want to do.
So again, you know, we've got all these gatekeepers in our way
and it's great technology, but it also, it's tough for a content creator.
Yeah.
So the other point that you mentioned about the open rate,
I'm at 29.3, something like that.
And so I was thinking, ----, it's such a horrible rate.
No, that's great.
It's good. Is it good?
Oh yeah. Yeah.
So, so just to give you an idea.
So I've, I mean, I've been doing this for 20 years.
So if you just, if you look at just a regular company,
if you look at Microsoft and Microsoft sends an email out to their audience,
if they get three to 5% open rate, they are thrilled.
Really?
So that, so that's, that, that's just for like a regular open
windows update email, whatever the case is.
So let's go to like a, um, a business company that sends out an email newsletter
to their customers.
And it's a regular email newsletter, generally 17, 15 to 17% open rate.
That's your industry standard.
Okay.
So anyone listening to this information?
So, so now the issue is, is that I don't know how to measure this anymore.
Cause our open rates are all over the board.
Like we had an open rate the other day of 39% and the next one was 17%.
Is it that big of a deal?
No, we're not, we're not getting the right numbers from Apple.
So I can't, I can't look at those with any confidence anymore.
So what I'm, what I would like everyone to do is focus on one or two things that you
really think that people will click on your email newsletter, because that you can,
you can measure on a regular basis and click through rate will be the measurement of email
going forward from now on instead of open rate.
That's just where we're at.
I missed that point.
What did you, what did you mention about the email that when you send it,
are you talking about like the title to make sure it's the hook?
No, no, no.
Of course the subject line is the most important thing for somebody opening.
So, okay.
So let's say I send you an email and you open it up inside the email.
I want you to click on some article, some link, some offer so that I can measure that
you are actually in that email newsletter because because of what Apple's doing and the other,
the other email companies, they won't let you measure open rate like you used to.
So, uh, but I can measure click cause that's under my content, clicking them to my site.
I can always measure that.
So that's what, so I want to put something that I know that you will open, or I'm going to say,
this is the one article of the week that you must read something like that.
You go ahead and click through.
That's why, by the way, in every email newsletter, you don't want to just repurpose information.
You actually want to have something original, remarkable in every email newsletter that they
can't find anywhere, anywhere else on the web.
So that's, so they'll actually open your email and then hopefully click, click through on something.
So Joe, like if people are listening to this right live now, and you know, when we go
publish it and on the Shopify and iTunes everywhere, right, they will hear this
information, but if they're listening, you know, I feel like what you just shared is
such an important part that they should give some importance to it because just by adding
that link in the email can give them so much more data that can help them, right?
For their business.
That's right.
And it's just, it's so interesting.
It's funny because I don't think we expected to talk about email so much, but yeah, I I'm
amazed because when I, when I'll do case studies, so we always look at the business models of
different media companies.
But if you look at like a Financial Times, a New York Times, Washington Post, Buzzfeed,
Huffington Post, really take some time and look at those business models.
And you don't realize that everything is built upon their segmented email newsletters.
So people will say, Oh, New York Times made a great turnaround selling digital subscriptions.
You know how they did that?
Because they have more than 70 segmented email newsletters that go to different audiences.
And then what they get, they get them to sign up for those segmented email newsletters,
and then they upsell them to a digital subscription.
That's their entire business model.
Like people don't realize that.
So what happened?
And by the way, every content creator is going that way.
You're seeing Instagrammers do the same thing.
YouTubers, people on TikTok, they're all saying, Oh my God, what do I do?
And they're going to the segmented email strategy.
So, and it's, and yes, it's just, it's boggles my mind that we're talking about 20 plus year
old technology, but, but that's, you know, but again, you could, you, we could get on
another rant and talk to you about, I think a huge opportunity is, is in print magazines
right now because, because it's so hard to break through the clutter on social media
and online today.
And there's no competition at the post today.
Everyone gets mail today, but most of it's spam, direct mail.
They don't want it.
It's very easy to get attention.
So what you're seeing is Walmart, Lego, uh, Amazon, they're spending way more money in
2021 than 2020 on their catalogs and magazines.
Oh my God.
Just wait till holiday time comes.
Wait till you get your big print catalog from Amazon going back.
And so why is that?
It's just smart marketing.
Why is that?
You have a captive audience and you have no competition.
It's like television was in the seventies where you could, you could buy a 32nd spot
across.
Yeah.
You could buy a 32nd spot and you could get attention from all these people where you
can do the same in print today.
Now, granted it's expensive to do something in print.
So that's why if you can partner with a number of other creators, partner with a sponsor,
like when we did our magazine back in 2011, we got six or seven sponsors to help pay for
the production.
And then we could get that magazine in front of, we would send it to chief marketing officers.
But so that's the type of thing to think of.
And maybe that's a next step for a creator, but man, you're going to see companies launching
magazines like crazy of the next two years.
And people are going to say, what?
This is, this is nuts.
There's just no competition there.
They can get attention there.
Yeah.
I was just thinking that like, if anybody's listening as an entrepreneur, they're saying,
what kind of business do I do?
What do I do?
I want to pivot.
I want to try something.
There you go.
You know, start a magazine, you know, contact, uh, you know,
that you want to partner with and create something that can be tangible and be in front of them at
all times.
Like whenever we get a magazine at home or whatever, it's always sitting around on the
table for like, I don't know how long it just sits around and then finally we throw it away.
But you know, people, you'll open it, right?
You'll just see it.
If the cover is good, you'll just open it and you'll check it.
So I can see how you can penetrate a market doing that.
Why?
It's funny because I mean, I, I don't know about you.
I had grew up with two boys and they loved Lego bricks and they got every month.
They got Lego magazine and they would wait till it came in the post.
So these are, these are kids that grew up digitally native, you know, playing video
games, the whole thing.
And they would wait for that print publication.
I remember they used to take it and they used to lay on the living room floor and just go
through it and flip through the cover to cover and you know what would happen after that.
They would ask us, Hey, we got to buy this new Lego thing.
We got to go buy this new one.
And by the way, Lego still produces that Lego started brick kicks magazine in 1987 and they
still produce it today as Lego magazine.
They've got multiple different magazines that they produce.
So that's where a lot of people don't realize Amazon, same way, the most innovative companies
in the world, Red Bull, Red Bull creates red bulletin, like 2 million subscribers to that
magazine.
Like a lot of people don't realize that the most innovative companies in the world have
print magazines, but you don't see it because you don't see it on the newsstand.
You get it only because you subscribe to it and so you'll get it to your house.
So just crazy.
That's crazy.
Amazing.
So I wanted, I wanted to ask you the story.
If you have a story between, you know, working or doing like the, the, basically the transition
into entrepreneurship, is there some kind of a story there?
Well, so I've always wanted to start a business, but I, but I got my job in corporate environment.
So in, in business to business publishing and basically hit the, it's probably 2005,
2006.
I had all these ideas because the industry of content marketing was starting to boom.
Google just, you know, Google was catching on fire.
We started to see Facebook launched to the public and then Twitter launched in 06, 07.
And I got this feeling.
I was like, Oh my God, so many of these companies out there are going to have to create their
own amazing content and tell amazing stories, or they're not going to get attention from
anyone.
They can't just advertise and interrupt their way to attention.
So I started talking about this idea, which ultimately became content marketing Institute.
I've talked to my wife about it all the time, and this is the end of 2006.
And she just finally said, Joe, either start the business or stop talking about it.
Like make your decision.
Cause I've been talking about it for a year now.
So this is the end of 2006.
I said, okay, here's the promise I'll make with you.
I will, I will leave the company that I'm at right now and start a business by the end
of March, um, 2007.
So that was my last day of work in corporate environment.
April 1st was my first day, you know, putting out my shingles, starting the business and
in preparation for that, we really changed a lot of things about our expenses.
Uh, we didn't take, uh, you know, we took basically stay at home vacations.
We ate a lot of, my wife calls it the bologna and ramen noodle years.
We really cut our expenses down as much as possible because, you know, it's, we weren't
making any money for the first two and a half years.
So we really had to buckle down and do that.
But, and, and by the way, probably felt like a failure for that two and a half years, because
basically you get up and it's weird as an entrepreneur and entrepreneurs will understand
this.
You have highs and lows.
There's nothing in the middle.
You either think this is the greatest thing in the world or you think you're a complete
failure.
And I thought I was, I didn't think we were going to make it.
And by the end of 2009, yeah, by the end of 2009, I, I didn't, we weren't making money
yet.
The model wasn't working.
Wasn't patient enough.
I was going to give up, go get a job.
And then, but from that time and six months later, everything turned.
And by the beginning of 2010, yeah, 2010, things are really working.
And then the next year we became a million dollar company.
And we made, I think we made Inc, uh, fastest growing business to business company in 2013
and 14.
So that, I mean, but that's how fast it can turn.
That's the problem is you have to realize that the most important thing to be an entrepreneur
is patience and keeping low expectations at first and know that you're in this for the
three to five to seven year game.
And if you're expecting short-term success, I don't know that model.
Like, I don't know how to do that.
It takes, it takes a long time to build a loyal audience.
But once that audience starts to know, like, and trust you, they will buy ultimately anything
that you put in front of them.
They really trust you.
And then you recommend a product or service.
Of course, hopefully you're doing it from your heart.
You're not, you're not trying to get rich quick.
You will be very, very successful.
So as we started to build our audience, which ultimately by 2015, we had 250,000 on our
email list.
Then anything we put out there that they, Oh, online training.
Sure.
You know, paid subscription.
Sure.
We'll look at that.
We got a new event on the West coast.
Sure.
Content marketing world, Sydney.
You want to come try that?
Sure.
So those things started to work really well for us, but it starts with just building that
audience and being really patient.
Yeah, no, it's great.
Thank you for sharing that story.
You know, at the end of the day, it comes down to mindset and entrepreneurs go through
it.
I went through it.
Everybody, you know, it's just a journey.
The key component is the belief system we have inside, right?
That belief system within us that we know we're going to achieve something and that
will drive us.
So we kind of have to become that goal before we can actualize it.
So it was great that you made it a success.
We always like to ask our guests, you know, what's your inner superpower that got you
to this point?
What do you feel that is?
Oh, geez.
Well, some people would probably say writing cause I'm, I'm an okay writer, but the,
the probably really good writer.
I don't know why you said, okay.
The seven books, I guess, are tested that I can at least, I can at least write.
We don't know if it's any good, but I can at least write.
I think the thing that, that I do in my daily habits that most people don't do, and it's
worked really well is, is a goal setting plan that so basically, and I've, I've read
Think and Grow Rich by Napoleon Hill, Seven Habits, Stephen Covey.
And I put together, yeah, sort of a formula.
And my formula is I created six areas that I think could help me to be a complete person.
So what are my financial wealth goals?
What are my career goals?
What are my family goals, spiritual goals, mental goals, philanthropic goals?
So I have those and I, and at all times I'll have two or three under each one that are
measurable.
So I want to say, okay.
And by, so, so in 2007, I wrote down the goal of by 2015, I want to sell the company for
at least $15 million.
I had that goal.
I read that goal every morning when I woke up and every, and then before I went to sleep
every night, I read that goal.
And so there's two things that happen.
If you read it in the morning, you, you get fixated on how, what am I doing to get to
that goal today?
So it helps you like not to get into email or go down the social media rabbit hole.
And then if you read that before you go to sleep at night, the brain does amazing things
in the subconscious.
And I really feel like when I, when I read those at night, I wake up with all new kinds
of crazy ideas or things that maybe I didn't think of.
And so the brain works through those things for you during the night.
And, and so that's probably the superpower is actually doing that, looking at the goal
in the morning and the evening.
And that has powered, you know, what I want to do and what I want to do with my family
and spiritually and mentally and, and, and giving back and all those types of things.
Beautiful.
So important to get back.
It's so amazing.
It was a pleasure meeting you and having you on the show and this, this record, this
recommendation you gave about, you know, writing your goal in the morning and evening.
I'm a, I'm a big believer in it, you know, or reading it.
For me, I write it every morning, but being aware of your goal every day, it's such a
powerful thing for a human being.
And it's great that you found the success and you're going further and further and serving
people because I can see that mentality in you, that you have that service and mentality
where you're looking for ways to make it better for others.
Success your way coming into your door is just going to be a default.
So keep that up.
You know what I mean?
My, my wishes, my hope, my prayers are with you and I want you to grow as big as you possibly
can.
Just remember to remember us.
Well, I am honored to chat with you today.
That was super fun.
I hope we, we gave some insight to some people, definitely about email, but
honestly, you're, you know, honestly, you're probably right.
The most important thing of all the things we talked about is probably the goal, the
goal setting, because where are you trying to, what's your North star?
Where are you, where are you trying to go?
If you wake up every day and you're not sure where you're going and what you want to be,
it's very, very difficult to, to, to make an impact as a content creator, as an entrepreneur.
Yes.
Great.
Thank you, Joe.
I have a great day.
The rest of the day, if anybody wants to get in touch with Joe, he's, he's a nice guy.
Amazing guy.
And again, I wish you the best.
And thank you for coming on the show.
Thank you.
Thanks for having me.
This was fun.