Acupuncture and Mental Health

Healing Hands: Exploring Acupuncture
23 followers
14 Video Views·Sep 15, 2025
Heiko chats with Wellington Acupuncturist Kate Roberts about the use of Acupuncture for Mental Health. For more great programmes like this visit www.radiokidnappers.org.nz
You're tuned to Radio Kidnappers, the voice of Hawke's Bay.
It's the acupuncture on air program.
It's our pleasure as always to have in the studio, Heiko.
And we've got a very special guest today, Heiko.
We've got Kate Roberts, who's an acupuncturist from Wellington,
been on our show before.
Hi Kate, how are you going?
Good thanks, Ken. How are you?
I say our show. It's your show, Heiko.
No, it's our show, you know.
And what are we going to talk about today, Heiko?
Yeah, I like to talk about acupuncture and mental health.
And Kate's had quite a bit of an experience and interest in this topic.
So maybe first, Kate, we all know that you're an acupuncturist,
but tell us a bit about yourself
and how you got involved in the issue of mental health.
Yeah, sure.
Well, a couple of ways really.
Mental health's a bit of a family business to me.
So my mum's a social worker
and both my dad and my brother are psychiatrists.
And then over the years I've had a bit of personal experience
with depression and anxiety and panic and post-traumatic stress.
So it's kind of given me quite a bit of empathy in clinical practice.
And in my 20 years in clinic,
I've found that most presentations, or even the physical ones,
quite often are coupled with an element of emotional distress or strain.
So really I've found to be effective in clinical practice,
you need to address both the emotional and the physical state.
Okay.
So you're very highly qualified, aren't you, Kate?
I mean, are there many acupuncturists in New Zealand
who've got PhD qualifications in the research and that sort of stuff?
Well, not yet.
I do have two very good friends, Dr Deborah Betts and Dr Mike Armour,
who both hold PhDs in acupuncture,
but these are from Australian universities.
There's not really any universities in New Zealand
offering specific acupuncture postgraduate qualifications
apart from up to a master's level.
I was quite lucky.
I managed to enrol via the medical school in Otago,
so I'm in the Department of Primary Health Care.
So as I said, the school in New Zealand does offer a master's level qualification,
but if you're wanting to go up to a PhD level,
you either have to go overseas
or try and sneak into another health science department.
And what are you doing your PhD on down in Otago?
And what's the specific field or topic?
So I'm looking at developing effective collaboration
and communication pathways with primary care,
so specifically around mental health,
so what to do when we have a shared patient,
how can we work effectively together to make sure the patient is safe
and to make sure that the patient has the best outcomes.
What I've found with my research is at the moment
the communication pathways are not perfect, not ideal,
and in many instances they're not existent at all.
And so I'm really trying to create some systematic and structured ways
of getting that communication really top-notch.
Yeah, because that was going to be one of the next things that I say
because particularly maybe in the last five years
I'm getting more patients now that are coming into the clinic to see me
but specifically sort of coming in on that first-time basis
to say that they have mental issues.
They may have been labelled as depression or bipolar anxiety or whatever
and they've heard that acupuncture may be able to help
and often they're even afraid to say to their doctor or to their therapist,
look I'm going to get some, I want to try some acupuncture to help this.
Often I think maybe because of ridicule coming back
from some of the professionals out there.
Yeah, I mean it's interesting.
The labelling of mental health problems is a concern.
I mean you've probably been vaguely aware of the stats
that over the course of anyone's life half of New Zealanders
are going to have a diagnosable mental health problem
and in any one year one-third of New Zealanders could be diagnosed.
And Ken, how many times have you been diagnosed with it?
All the time.
But I don't quite have to admit that I'm a bit nuts.
What about you guys?
Yeah, I have no trouble admitting that I'm a bit crazy.
Now I know that a lot of these what we should call alternative therapies
like acupuncture and homeopathic remedies and whatnot,
they are considered to be alternative treatments
and I wonder, but they're also complementary,
they work alongside traditional medicine.
So if someone comes to see you Kate or even you Heiko
and they say look I'm on meds, I'm on Valium or whatever they call it these days,
do you suggest to them that they go off them?
No, definitely not.
No, definitely not. Legally, yeah.
Yeah, we don't think we can.
We're not allowed to.
We can't even suggest change your dose or whatever
and the way around that from what I say.
So I really think, and this is how I'm trying to encourage
to work together with others.
Go back to your doctor or go back to the psychiatrist
and talk with them and say look you have an acupuncture
and you want to maybe trial coming off or cutting back
and then I think that's sort of the first step
to try and get a bit of a communication going between the two therapies.
Is that what you do Kate?
Yeah, I mean one of acupuncture's real strengths is as an adjunctive
so most of the research says that if you get the treatments combined
the results will be more fast acting and quicker to act
and you usually have to be on a lower dose anyway
and certainly a lot of the work I do is supporting people
who are coming off or lowering their dose
or are suffering from side effects from meds
so it's a really nice synergistic kind of arrangement
between the east and west to maximise the patient's outcome.
A psychiatrist and a psychotherapist, what's the difference?
So a psychiatrist is medically trained
so all doctors go through a general medical training
so it takes about four or five years
and when they get to the point where they're a doctor
then they specialise and psychiatry is a specialisation in mental health
so they can prescribe medications, they can do acute hospital work
whereas psychotherapists are trained in a form of talking therapy
and behavioural therapy but they don't prescribe medications.
You agree with that Heiko?
Well, I think so.
Do you get more cred when someone comes to see you?
Kate, I mean here you've got all these letters after your name.
That's got to be a bonus word, hasn't it?
Some more cred?
I don't know.
I mean I think a lot of people might be nervous
about working in the area of mental health
because the outcomes are definitely not as clean cut
as with someone's got a sore back and they get better
whereas with mental health usually it's a pretty long journey
so I think I would attract those kind of patients
because I'm really aware that it is going to be
a long-term treatment option sometimes
and the results can be quite varied
and I'm really comfortable talking with patients about that.
I just want to know that I think Heiko and I talk every week
and according to Heiko it's not a thing that acupuncture can't help
but if I was mentally not unbalanced
but if I thought I was depressed and that sort of stuff
you guys would be the last people I think to come and see
because I would automatically think of a psychiatrist
or a psychotherapist because I would need counselling.
How do you get that message out there
that acupuncture can in fact take the place of
or help with that?
I mean you'd be the second place to call
it wouldn't be first port of call.
That's right, yeah.
But I think it's going to just take a bit of time
and particularly a show like this is of great value
to get the information out there
and Kate now doing the research at Otago
so there's obviously now there's the university professors
and the doctors down there, they're hearing about it
I know there's been a number of studies
and Kate's probably more familiar with these
like I mean at Chicago University or somewhere
where they've tested, had 20 acupuncture treatments
and then their depression scale has gone from 6 to 5
and all these things.
Kate would you have any idea in the West anyway
how much sort of research has been done
to try to see if acupuncture or...
Yeah look there actually has been screeds of research
and in fact just earlier this week
the 2018 updated Cochrane Review for acupuncture
for depression came out
and research never says definitively this works
like it always says it has potential to work
or the symptoms are reduced and more research is needed
that's just kind of how research rolls
but the Cochrane Review which is kind of the highest level
of evidence you can get
said that there is a place for acupuncture
especially alongside Western Med
but also of its own
the results that acupuncture gets
are always better than if you
you know when you combine it with standard care
than whether you just have standard care alone
and the results that acupuncture gets
are pretty similar to most talking therapies
so counselling, CBT in terms of you know
the scales of depression coming down
That PubMed research
is that available for anyone on the web?
Because I think what we should do is
chuck the link on
Yeah put the link on the YouTube
because I think that will be really useful
for many people to have a look at
Now obviously the ancient Chinese
when they were doing acupuncture
they didn't have a clue
what a chemical imbalance in the brain was
how did they know how to diagnose depression and treat it?
Well I guess for in ancient Chinese
they didn't really differentiate between
a medical, like a mental symptom
and a physical symptom
it was all just seen as symptomology
so if someone was you know
kind of running around
you know at the top of a mountain
with no clothes on
that was just the same as if they came in
and they had a sharp stabbing pain in their tummy
like it's you know for them it was like
oh this is a symptom
something's gone wrong
something's out of balance
and we're going to treat it accordingly
so they didn't kind of have the labels
that we have
that I think are slightly limiting
these days
they just saw a person
that was in a state of dis-ease
and they worked to kind of
get them back into a state of ease
Because I know some of the
the classic
in terms of traditional Chinese medicine
the symptoms
you know they saw it
it's like
you know I think it's described
as fogginess in the brain
or the mind feels like
it's full of like you know
wet towels or something
and this is a common symptom
that I found
that some people here
with you know
sort of mental conditions will say
and then
in terms of modern medicine
these labels are sort of
is it like bipolar
or depression
so you know the fogginess
I would probably correspond that
to a western symptom
called blunting
which is where
you know there's that
kind of disassociation
or disconnection with
you know stimulus
and that is a depressive symptom
definitely that kind of
inability to engage
and yeah there's kind of
a lot of traditional organ
and meridian correspondences
that could be at play there
so
in Chinese medicine
we might say
you know it's heart fire
could make you stressed
and then we'd use
the heart meridian
to kind of address
the nervousness
and the palpitations
and things like that
So if I come and see you Kate
or you Heiko
and
I get treated for
depression for instance
and if I go to the doctor
I'm going to get a pill
I'm probably going to feel better
or a bit more calm
within an X number of days
how am I going to feel
with acupuncture?
How soon will I be feeling better?
Good question Ken
I'll let Kate answer that
Yeah I mean look
it's pretty hard
to say exactly
what your response
to treatment would be
and that's the same
for medication as well
what I do notice
is that when people
have one session
of acupuncture on the table
the relaxation response
is usually quite instant
we're kind of
we're getting
tapping into that
the stress response
so the way that your body
produces adrenaline
and the way it combats
adrenaline
and trying to get it to relax
more effectively
and also more quickly
when it becomes stressed
and those results
can be instant
Yeah and I've definitely
had that experience
where I've treated people
and they haven't actually
told me that
they were feeling
flat or depressed
or whatever label
it might be
and then I've
treated them
for something else
and then as we know
the acupuncture
releases endorphins
and does all these things
to relax people
and then they say
oh geez
I feel something shifted
I actually feel
like better
I feel clearer in the head
you know
or they come back
the next week
and they say
oh you know
I felt like
so much better
in my head
for three days afterwards
and yeah
this is again
I think it can be
the powerful effect
of the acupuncture
but be it
you know
to shift someone
permanently
like long term
yeah
it's going to take
a little bit of time
You mentioned labels
Kate
and obviously
I'm not an expert
at all
but there's depression
there's depressive psychosis
there's schizophrenia
there's bipolar
there's clinical depression
there's postnatal depression
there's traumatic
stress disorder
I mean
how do you classify them
and that's a good one
because you're not doctors
you're not psychiatrists
you're not psychologists
so how do you put
the right labels
label on
whatever I've got
We don't really
tend to use
a lot of those
labels
I mean
we're obviously
aware of them
because we work
with Western medicine
and most of our clients
will come to us
with a diagnosis
I think
what's interesting
is that the number
of diagnoses available
has increased by
you know
over 400
in the last 20 years
and I think
part of that is
because they're trying
to classify
symptoms that maybe
don't need a diagnosis
and it also ties in
with you know
being able to get
insurance funding
quite often is linked
to having a specified
diagnosis
so I think sometimes
the whole labelling thing
isn't necessary
people are just
usually either
anxious or depressed
or a combination
of both
I would say
that's the majority
of mental health
presentations
and in Chinese medicine
we just put that
into our terminology
we speak a slightly
different language
but it's just semantics
you know
we see people that
have got the same
presentations
we might just
call it something
different
Are there any
of those disorders
that you might
walk away from
as an acupuncturist
and say hey
this guy's a bit
of a nutcase
I know I would
never walk away
from a patient
that was in distress
but there are
certainly conditions
that I would work
very closely with
their GP
or other
you know
other therapists
if I had concerns
Yeah and I've
had to say that
in the past
and I said look
I'm happy to treat
you and I think
I can help
but we really
need to work
together
with your GP
or whatever
on this
and sometimes
I will email
the GP
or at least
let them know
that I'm treating
them
just from a
safety point
of view
You also hear
of people who
are on
antidepressants
literally
for years
and years
and I guess
it becomes a habit
that they think
that they're
depressed
all the time
Is that what
happens with
the acupuncturists
though?
That they've
got to come
and see you
for years
and years
and years?
Oh I think
if they do
then we're
probably not
doing our
job very well
You know
usually
the whole
idea of
acupuncture
is to get
the person's
body into
a state
where it
can heal
itself as
quickly as
possible
So we're
trying to
reinstate the
body's own
self-healing
ability
And you
know
sometimes that
will take
longer with
people if
they've
maybe been
in a state
of disease
for quite
a long
time
But ideally
you get
them to the
point where
they don't
have to come
and see
you
And then
every so long
they might have
a wobble
and they need
to come back
and get a
top up
But the idea
is to get
people to be
able to heal
themselves
Yeah they
need to be
independent again
So you
don't have to
want to rely
on the
pharmaceutical
drug or
on St.
John's
Wort
some herb
or on
something
you've got to
have acupuncture
twice a week
for the
next 20
years
It's just
not the right
way to do
things
Is it about
the needle
or is it
about the
talking to
them about
their problems
at the
same time
So when
they come and
see you
are you just
going to put
the needle
and not say
anything
or are you
going to
wants to
talk a
lot in
terms of
trying to
counsel them
I think
that
professionals
sure I
still talk
to them
a little
bit
but for
me the
best part
is letting
them relax
and letting
that 20
minutes go
by so that
the endorphins
or whatever it
is changes in
their brain so
they feel better
but sometimes
it may be
important to
talk to them
What about
you Kate
It's usually
a bit patient
led so I
can tell when
a patient
comes in if
they need to
have a bit
of a chat
then I'm
there for them
and it's a
safe place
and they feel
cared for
they're always
going to get
their needles
they know
they're coming
to an
acupuncturist
the needles
are always
going to
form a part
of what
the treatment
is
other times
people don't
want to
talk at all
they just
need that
space to
lie down
and be
calm
and gather
their thoughts
I work
with the
acupuncturists
we develop
what's called
a therapeutic
alliance with
our patients
so it's
patient led
we care for
them in the
way that they
need it and
that provides
real strength
with their
outcomes
Do you ever
see the day
when you
pick up the
phone and
ring 0800
mental health
and do you
ever see the
day when
we might
see a
drop in
acupuncture
mental health
clinic where
people can
just get on
the blower
or drop in
and have a
bit of the
needle and
feel a whole
lot better
have you
thought of
running a
study and
maybe a
feasibility
exercise
about what
that might
cost
I would
love to
be able to
do something
like that
it always
comes down
to funding
and time
you know
the acupuncture
school where
I work with
set up a
community drop
in clinic
but it's
only one
day a
week
and ideally
these kind
of things
need to be
accessible
more than
that
I think
there's real
scope for it
to happen
I mean
acupuncture
is a
cost
effective
treatment
to run
it's easy
to do in a
group setting
but you
know
let's keep
trying
maybe in the
future
let's see
if we can
get more
community
based
stuff off
the ground
I think
once my
PhD is
finished
I'll have
a little
bit more
time
I've
got
to
back
to
but
I
can't
to
get
back
to
again
I
don't
know
how
long
I
can
get
back
to
school
again
I
don't
how
can
get
back
to
school
again
I
don't
know
long
I
can
get
back
to
school
again
I
don't
know
how
long
