#HyperRealism#ArtCritique#PhotoRealism NOTE: The first drawing and the Mike Tyson drawing in the video were skewed horizontally a little bit in the editing software by accident. So, Although I stand by what I said about the Mike Tyson drawing, the drawing is not quite out of proportion to the degree that it is shown on the screen. And the proportions on the first drawing were spot on, so I'm sorry about that!
Hope you guys enjoy the critiques, and be sure to send me your drawings for critique on Instagram for a chance to be featured on my future roasts/critiques!
For in depth drawing tutorials check out my Patreon here:
Fabrice the artist here back with another video and today I'm gonna be critiquing your guys's art. I'll mention right off the bat
I'm not gonna be mentioning who the artists are just because I don't know who the art all the artists are
Because I saved all the pictures to my phone so that I could critique them on
Camera while looking at my phone next time. I'll remember who the artists were
but for now, you guys are just gonna have to watch this video and check to see if your drawing is
Critiqued or not. Let's dive right into it. First up. We got a beautiful portrait of a female
Now the first thing about this one that I noticed is the proportions are very very good. It's very realistic
However, I think maybe the paper could is a little bit
Too texturized for the effect that you might be looking for as you can see the texture on the page over the cheeks and all that
Quite readily another thing that stands out to me is the
Values could be a little bit more accurate the brighter spots could be a little bit brighter and the darker spots
Which could be a little bit darker just create a little bit more contrast
for example, this hair looks to me like it's supposed to be black hair, but
Because you're using I did what looks like to be graphite
The darkest really that you can get is a dark gray so it's not creating that really realistic
Contrasting effect in capturing those values actually, okay
So the proportions are great
The details are great, but pay a little bit more closer attention to the value
This one is a lot of the same things that I said earlier apply to this one
So the values could be a little bit more accurate. The proportions aren't too bad
Okay, but I think you need to spend a lot more time shading or blending in some of the shading on the cheek
Okay, so it looks a little blotchy on some of the areas of the face
Okay
Now this that would make it look by itself a lot better just clean that up
The hair doesn't look very realistic because it's a weird gray color a weird gray value
Okay, you want to get that nice and dark get those eyelashes get those eyebrows get the line the shadows in between the lips
Get that darker. I don't be afraid to play around some charcoal some different tools
Maybe I don't know what kind of graphite pencil you're using here
Maybe you're using a very hard pencil that doesn't appear to be very dark
But like I said in the past even if you're using an AP pencil an AP graphite pencil
The darkest that you're gonna get is a dark gray
Okay
So try playing around the values a little bit more fix up the face clean up those blotches a little bit and it'll be better
the next time
This one is pretty friggin sweet, okay now
I'm a huge Breaking Bad fan. So I was you know, probably gonna pick this one to critique now
I don't have a whole lot negative to say about this. This is an awesome drawing
I would say the background is a little bit blotchy
It looks to me like you used maybe some graphite powder or you use a graphite pencil to create the background and blend it
Tissue paper, so your background looks the way my backgrounds did a few years ago, which is
Leaves some room for improvement in my opinion to me
The weakest part of this drawing is the background and that would in itself make it look way
Now the best parts of this drawing the values are spot-on
I know exactly what reference picture you use for this. I almost drew this one myself actually and
You nailed it. The picture is
Super rough looking like the the graininess of this picture reference picture itself is exactly like this
drawing appears
And the values are spot-on. So the coat is appears to be a jet black now
I'm assuming you either use charcoal on this or you use a
really dark graphite pencil and
probably
Increase the contrast on a photo editing software. Okay, which is fine
But a black like this is unachievable with graphite. Just saying great job
Now this one appears to be quite suffocating. I friggin hope to God. This is not a self-portrait of you
Suffocating yourself in a bag or I hope this isn't one of your friends or Jesus wouldn't want to be the muse in this one
Let me just tell you that right off the bat
Having said that this is an amazing drawing the proportions are spot-on
The values are spot-on. There's some areas here, you know, like in the bottom, right?
You know in the corners a little bit where I think you kind of rushed some of the blending a little bit
This could be a little bit more
Fine-tuned the details here look phenomenal
Like I said, the values are great
The darks are nice and dark and the bright spots that are supposed to be bright are nice and bright
The parts that you don't think matter as much like the little corners
That the eye doesn't focus on make sure that you blend those in a little bit better. Okay, but other than that
Great job as you guys know, I drew Mike Tyson as well
The main thing to me that stands out about this one man is the proportions
Honestly couldn't be any worse. The proportions are
awful
Okay now you spent a ---- ton of time on the details
it looks like like you've got some of these details pretty friggin good like the
Blurry spots in the corner. You've got a couple
On the cheek you got some water droplets there. I see some good points here. That's really good. But all that means
Nothing if the proportions are as off as what they are here
Okay, so I would say work on your proportions whether it's just using a grid or honestly
I've never personally used the grid
However, you know that's going to come with practice
The most important things are going to be getting the values accurate and the proportions accurate and details come last
okay, so you're focusing way too much on the details and
Leaving much room for improvement on some of these other things like the glove is super blotchy
you need to blend that in way better and
get those proportions down, but I will say the
Values are good. Like the hair looks nice and dark the shadow under the neck here looks phenomenal
The details on the lips the chin. I really really like the
The droplets on the cheek here. So you really did an amazing job with that and the background to me looks
Pretty weak it looks to me like at first glance to me. It looks like you're using a very cheap willow
Charcoal I can almost guarantee that this was not generals
Charcoal sticks or charcoal pencil because it looks it looks like a very cheap charcoal
So first thing get rid of that willow charcoal is garbage
Just get a better
Charcoal pencil and just throw out that
Next I this kind of looks like a young Joaquin Phoenix. I'm not too sure
however, first thing that jumps out to me is
It looks extremely flat. Okay, so it looks like almost like a minimalistic
Drawing. I'm not sure if this is supposed to be an attempt at photo realism or not. I'm seeing some use of some cross hatching
It looks like you you know
It looks to me like you really rushed some of the shading on the forehead here. The hairline is way too straight
It's completely unrealistic
It's not a perfect straight line like that, you know, take a better look at the forehead
There's no shading here on the forehead
Now this might be something that you were going for in terms of like a minimalist drawing effect perhaps
I really like the sweater nice and black really dark, right?
I don't know if you use like an ink or charcoal pencil or something like that
But really good job getting a solid black sweater there
The proportions aren't bad
however, it looks like a little bit like the jawline is a little bit out of
Proportion the forehead here sticking out a little bit too much. Now. This will just come with practice
okay, like just trying to get the portions a little bit more accurate and just take your time with the
Shading on the side of the head here. I would try to play it pay a little bit more close attention to some of the
Details and shading on the forehead instead of leaving it completely blank. Okay, nice job
Next we have
Mandalorian this one's really cool
This reminds me of some of the Dragon Ball Z drawings that I used to do when I was a kid
This is really cool. I like the the highlighted like the background how it's
contouring the
Figure of Mando, which is great
I like the I think this this gentleman here has sent me this drawing a few months ago
If I remember correctly the first picture that he sent me
I think if I'm remembering correctly the editing on this is looking a lot better
It's looking more black and white instead of like a gross looking beige like like a cheap camera type look
So I think I told him to turn the saturation down or turn the highlights up or change the color of the drawing
So that it actually looks more like the actual drawing instead of a shittier version of it
The proportions are great. The values aren't too bad
I think you could go a little bit darker and some of the darkest spots like between the legs is how the helmet here some
of the cracks between the gloves and so forth
And I would just try maybe blending in some of those lines a little bit. Okay, so it does look quite realistic
Which is great, but it does look a little bit
unrefined, okay, so you might want to use like a brush to kind of blend that in a little bit or maybe
use a
small blending stump or sometimes something that works actually really good is you can achieve a nice blended in effect with just
Building up some of these shades a little bit more gradually so that you don't have to do much blending at all
And you don't get this unrefined
Kind of rough appearance, which I don't think you were going for. Okay
Good job
this one I
Really wanted to include this one because this one is a phenomenal drawing. Okay, this is a French artist and he's
Now like this is an incredible drawing super realistic like the details under the eye here are
amazing, I don't know how big this drawing is like I
Think it might be like an 11 by 14 or kind of a smaller drawing and to have this kind of detail in a drawing
Like that size if I remember correctly, it's not very big. It's very impressive like, you know, some of this some of these
Details under the eyes like the little
Textures under the wrinkles under the skin under the eyelid
amazing, the values are spot-on
Everything here is really good. My first thing I would tell you man is draw bigger, right?
Like you got insane potential like your drawings are really really really good
but if you want to take your art to the next level and
Something that took my art to the next level is draw on a bigger paper
This paper size is
100% holding back. Okay, so I don't have much to tell you here. You're on the right path. Your drawings are amazing
Keep going
Go bigger with your drawings and you will excel to new heights. I promise you
Okay, this one this looks quite realistic now to me again. The background is very weak
It looks again to me like very blotchy cheap willow charcoal. All right, you guys got to stop using willow charcoal throw it out
It's garbage. This looks great. It looks to me like you used a ton of
Generals charcoal white if I'm correct now in my opinion, I think you probably relied on it a little bit too much
I see a little bit too much
Blue here so that to me is evidence of relying a little bit too much on charcoal white generals charcoal white pencil
and
you should be using a
Tombow model zero eraser to erase some of these white details in instead
Okay
so what you can do is cover a little spot on the page with some charcoal powder and then use that as your foundation to
Erase some of those white hairs in with this beautiful tool right here. So great job
The values are great. You know, the blacks are very black, which is great
If you did use a white Posca acrylic paint pen for the whiskers, you know, that's an acceptable use of that tool
However, again, I would suggest if you can erase those in but I understand sometimes you can't erase in charcoal that
Precisely and not have it get that white
Okay
So at the very least I would erase those whiskers in with the tombow first and then go in with the Posca paint pen after
Okay, so great job fix that background though now it looks to me like you're stuck in your head here or
stuck in someone else's head, but
One thing that I don't I'm not a huge fan of at all is when people edit the background to be perfectly white like this
To me looks too photoshopped and you can tell
When I zoom in here, I can tell that the space between the hair is
still smudged
Like the color of the background would be and then where the hair would be
Where the outline of the hair is it's completely white
So it's kind of obvious that like they whitened the background using a photoshop app or something
Which like I said, I'm not a huge fan of it just kind of looks a little bit unnatural and digital art almost
so
The proportions here are great. The values here are great
This concept looks interesting, I don't really know what you're trying to convey here, but interesting concept
I would say the hair on the
Boy is a little bit unnatural looking. I see that you actually drew around the white
Highlights of the hair to create those white highlights again
This is not the right way to do that like or it's at least it's gonna be way harder to achieve this
What you want to do is create the hair entirely dark and then where there's light spots
Erase them in once again with this tool the tonvo mono eraser. Okay, so great job. The values were great the
Proportions are great
It's a very interesting
Concept this isn't really something that i'm particularly into but I think it's pretty interesting
But I'm also not really a fan of editing the background like that, okay, although that's just my personal preference
There's nothing wrong with doing that
A lot of people like that look a lot of high-level artists edit their pictures exactly like this
I just don't really like it. Okay, good job
And what the hell am I looking at here, I don't know what's going on with this girl's facial expression
Where did you find this picture?
Anyway, it almost looks uh, it looks really really faded away. It almost looks like you drew this
on like
Wood or something like it looks extremely extremely rough now the proportions don't look too bad to me
The values look very weak, you know, the the the darkest values here are a light gray almost so it's very
Unrealistic just because of that I will say this is extremely grainy
This would look a lot better if you could smooth that out a little bit better and create a little bit more darker
Areas, so like the inside of the mouth is like a median tone. It should be nearly black
Okay, the background probably should be black
I'm, not sure what pencils you used here, but try exploring with some darker shades. Okay
Having said that I do really like the clean cut nature of
Uh this I think you probably put a tape and then removed it when you were done. That's a nice touch
Good job, and I really like the fact that it looks like you use an eraser to erase those individual white hairs
Over the face so good job doing that
okay, but you might want to look into getting a different texture paper because to me I think it's
Taking away from the quality of your work, and i'm not too sure who this is
However, you did an amazing job with some of these tattoo
details
um
Again the hair to me
It looks like you you drew it with a pencil individually leaving the white highlights of the hair
Empty which to me is a mistake again
Use that tombow mono eraser to erase those in instead that would make it look
It almost looked like his hair is made out of wool. Like he looks like a teddy ruxpin doll or something, right? Like
You got to clean that up, right?
So to me the hair is by far the weakest part of this drawing, but I think everything else on this drawing is amazing
So great job, but one tip to me
It looks like the background is done with graphite maybe and it looks like you literally drew it with a pencil
individually
Painstakingly drawing the whole background with a pencil. That's what it looks like to me
It looks good
But I think it would have been a lot better to just use like
Some charcoal powder with a brush you could have done this background
In like 30 minutes or less and it would have looked a lot smoother than this
now i'm not sure what if that's what the effect you were going for but
I do like it, but i'm just trying to give you an easier way to try to do that background save yourself some time
And make it maybe look a little bit better as well. And also
uh little things that take away from this as well is the
The top part of this drawing is not completely straight
So you could have probably used some tape to edge it off so that it was perfectly square kind of like the previous drawing and
you know, you could have the most super realistic drawing, but then if the background is like
Crooked and it's not a perfect rectangle. It just makes it look unprofessional. It takes away from it
Okay, so fix the hair use the tombow use a brush on the background instead
You'll save yourself a ton of time and look way better and make sure that the outline of the background and the overall
Dimensions are straight. The outline is straight
Okay
Great job amazing job on the details and the values and the proportions
Anyway that concludes the video for today
I'm, sorry. I didn't get to all the videos. I got over a hundred submissions
So i've got a ton of pictures for future videos and
I'll be doing these pretty often because I think they're quite informative and they're super fun for me to do
Okay, so thank you guys for watching. I hope you guys learned a thing or two
Stay tuned for the next critique video in case that i'm going to be critiquing your video next
I've got a ton of pictures less to go through so I probably will okay
Uh
Subscribe to my tutorials on patreon. Okay, buy my prints on etsy
Subscribe to my channel hit the notification bell if you haven't already and I will see you guys in that next video. Peace