How handwriting benefits your brain | Neuropsychologist Dr. Audrey van der Meer

Intellectual thinking
238 followers
Can picking up a pen have cognitive benefits? In her first-ever talk at the reMarkable campus, neuroscientist Dr. Audrey van der Meer examines why handwriting is so important for learning and memory, particularly in children.
Drawing on decades of research, she shows how handwriting activates more areas of the brain than typing. This means better learning, better brain development, and better long-term cognitive health.
To learn more about reMarkable’s Scientific Advisory Board, visit: https://remarkable.com/scientific-advisory-board
#education #Intellectualthinking #lifeskilleducation,
Thank you everybody. It's really nice to be here. My name is Audrey Vandermeer.
I'm a brain researcher and professor of psychology at the Norwegian University of
Science and Technology in Trondheim, where I've been working for the past 30 years.
And I'm here to tell you why we remember things better when we write them down by hand.
I have been collaborating with my husband for the past 40 years, and in 2015 we started
to interest ourselves to study handwriting and what is happening in the brain, because we have
these characteristic EEG nets consisting of 256 electrodes that pick up surface activity from the
scalp, and we use inverse mathematic models to trace back where the activity in the brain
originated, because we're recording from the scalp, but we're really interested in where the
brain activity originated. And we've been studying handwriting and brain activity during handwriting
with typewriting on a keyboard and brain activity during the typewriting. We have published our
results. We have come with recommendations. Basically, it's very good brain stimulation
to use your hand to draw or write, because a lot of areas in the brain, the whole brain,
is basically involved when you write by hand or when you draw, and that is not the case for when
you're using a keyboard, because the keyboard only elicits very simple finger movements, whereas
when you write or draw by hand, it's actually very intricate movements that are performed.
You use your senses much more, and therefore more of the brain is involved. So we have been studying
with our electrode nets the pen's potential for learning in the classroom. We have published
several studies since 2017, showing that it really is advantageous for the brain. You use your brain
to a much larger extent when you're forming letters by hand or when you're drawing.
And these publications are open access, so anybody can go and find them online.
So what we did in our very first study was to test students, a group of university students,
bachelor and master students, while they were drawing words, pictionary words, so they were
presented with pictionary words, such as hedgehog or umbrella, but also more difficult words, such
as friendship or birthday, and then they had to either draw these words, or they had to give a
description of these words by typing on the keyboard, or they had to just type the word
repeatedly, with one finger on a keyboard. And then we were interested to see differences in
brain activity. The 2020 study that has become highly cited, we included a group of 12-year-old
children. For the first time, we also asked the participants to write the words by hand,
because in the first study, we actually didn't look at handwriting, because we assumed that
drawing and handwriting, the same underlying mechanisms were active, but we couldn't prove it
because we didn't test it. But in the second study, we actually included a handwriting condition,
and a drawing condition, and a typing condition. We found over and over again that when you are
drawing or writing by hand, so when you're using your hand to produce forms on paper or on a
touchscreen, you use your brain to a much larger extent. The whole of the brain is active. When
large parts of the brain are active, the brain is in need of communicating important information
between those active parts. It does that through neural oscillations or brain waves
that can occur in synchrony, in red on the graph, or in desynchrony, in blue,
and at different frequencies. What we find is that handwriting and drawing elicits very similar
brain patterns, namely synchronized activity in red in the lower frequency bands, and typewriting
is the old one out, because here we find desynchronized activity at the lower frequency
bands, and synchronized activity at the higher frequency band, where for handwriting and drawing,
we find desynchronized activity in the higher frequency bands. Here we see a head model for
all the participants, where we subtract brain activity during typewriting from brain activity
during handwriting, and then we're left with all these significant areas in red at the lower
frequency bands that the brain is more active during handwriting or drawing versus during
typewriting. This is clear and impressive in a way, showing that the brain really is much more
active during using the use of a pen. More recently, in 2024, we looked at functional
brain connectivity to see how the brain was wired up during handwriting and during
typewriting again, and then you get a connectivity matrix showing all the significant
couplings in the brain between handwriting and typewriting, and you see in the head model that
the model is kind of wearing a party hat during use of a pen, and it's completely flat
when they're typewriting. That shows that the brain is, in other words, much more active during
handwriting or drawing during use of a pen, and we see that time and time again, and that
forces the brain to be used in a much more efficient way. There's need for cross-communication
between those different brain areas, and you use your finger movements, your intricate finger
movements, to produce forms on a surface, whereas when you're typing, it's just these simple
finger movements that are actually exactly the same for every letter that you're trying to
produce, and that's why children who have learned to read and write on a tablet have difficulty
differentiating between letters that look similar but are each other's mirror image, for example,
simply because they haven't felt with their bodies that the production of a B is actually
completely different than the production of a D on paper. So the media has really picked up on this.
People all across the world are very engaged in this topic, handwriting versus typewriting, and
what it means for the brain. We've been in The Economist, we've had an issue in National Geographic
last year, and in Scientific American, so why handwriting still matters in a digital age, and
we've also been on puberty that went viral with half a million likes within a week or so.
It's really been crazy. So what does this mean for the real world? We are not denying that we are
living in a digital world, and we're not proposing to go back to writing in stone, but we now know
that handwriting is extremely good stimulation for especially maybe the developing brain, but
also maybe for the aging brain. We have suggested to the Norwegian government that they should
introduce a minimum of handwriting tuition at primary schools, because it's so important for
their brains. I'm not saying that it's easy for a six-year-old boy, active boy, to sit down and to
learn to make those letters on paper, but it's very good for their brain, and I would say it's essential
for their brain stimulation to force the brain to be used for what it is good at, and to challenge
the brain for what it is good at. And if you want to become good at something, if you want to use
your brain to its full potential, you have to challenge it on a regular basis, and you have to
sit still and make those letters, and produce a good handwriting style, not only for the brain
stimulation, but I also think that handwriting is part of our cultural heritage, and by not teaching
the next generation how to write by hand, we're actually losing an important dimension of being
human. Thank you. You mentioned in your talk that you did the study with the participants typing
with one finger. Would it be different if they used all their fingers? That's a very good question,
but we couldn't, because if you're using all ten fingers, then both hemispheres are active, and then
it would be a confounding variable, basically. So since we are writing with one hand, and using three
fingers max, we also asked our participants to type with just one finger of their preferred hand,
as to not find this crossover effect when you're steering ten fingers. Also, it's difficult to
recruit people who have equal ability of ten finger typing, so then we would also make it
more difficult for ourselves. So we just asked them to use the finger of their preferred hand
for typing, but of course there may be more crosstalk when you're using ten fingers.
Have you done any study on potentially how handwriting could help old people with
Alzheimer's? Today they're forced to use smartphones, and they don't really enjoy it, I think.
Yeah, that's also a very nice question. We have been thinking about including or looking at
cognitive aging, and see whether regular use of handwriting could fend off cognitive
decline, so to speak. And we are planning a study where elderly people who are used to keeping a
diary on a daily basis, or on a regular basis, and compare them with a group of elderly who have gone
completely digital, and are not using their writing skills regularly anymore,
and to see whether we find any differences in brain activity, better brain activity in those
who are used to writing. You mentioned that handwriting can also help us remember things
better. Is that because there is a relation between kind of how active the brain is,
and how much we remember things later? Yes, I should have said, the activity we find in all
these brain areas on the slide I showed earlier, in a synchronized way at those low frequencies,
that kind of brain activity is related to learning and remembering centers in the brain.
Thanks for the talk. I was curious about, you mentioned that these kids who didn't
write by hand, they had a hard time differentiating between the mirrored shapes of
letters like B and D. Was that in regards of the handwritten shapes of those letters,
or also reading like typed text? It's both reading and writing, yes. That is fascinating.
For instance, in Waldorf schools that rely a lot on self-handwritten pensum,
they form the letters with their bodies, and they play these games to incorporate
the letters in daily life, because that is the important thing. You need to feel with your body
and all of your senses how these forms are shaped. Thank you.
