The "Ugly" Truth About Longbows...

The Saga of Past Longbows
6 followers
3 Video Views·Sep 12, 2025
In this video I discuss (monologue) the definitions of longbows, and why it "matters" for some of you.
Basically... If you are a hardcore ELB or Warbow type, you might feel offended 😜
Hey guys, I'm just out here today shooting my longbow.
That's not a longbow, that's an American flatbow.
Well okay then, I'm just gonna shoot this longbow.
No, no, that's not, that's a American semi-longbow, yeah.
What do you mean?
Well then this longbow then.
Well, well no, it's, it's, it bends through the middle,
yeah, but it's too short, it's too short.
No, it won't do.
What?
Okay, well here is a proper longbow.
Yeah, yeah, nice try, nice try.
That's a, that's a Victorian longbow, yeah.
You kidding me?
Well, well this is a proper longbow.
Oh, oh yeah, now you've got a real longbow.
It's too short, it has to be six feet.
What?
Too short?
No, it's exactly six feet.
It's good.
Oh, it is six feet.
Sorry about that.
Anything, anything better?
No.
Wait a minute, something's coming.
Oh, yeah, the homogore, yeah.
Shit.
Well, don't get caught up in definitions, please.
So let's, let's, let's take a critical view of this.
Hang on.
Right, let's talk about this longbow business,
because it's getting kind of tiresome
explaining to people why a longbow is a longbow.
So the technical definition today of a longbow
is a bow without recurve that is at least 64 inches.
So this one here is actually not a longbow.
This is a hybrid bow.
Yes, because it's only 58 inches.
So technically not a longbow, not even if a woman shoots it,
because there are different standards if you're a man or a woman.
If it's a woman, then 60 plus inches would be a longbow.
If you're a male, it's 64.
Right, and then I know what you're going to say,
because then some of you will say,
well, it's an American flatbow.
Well, no, it's not an American flatbow,
because an American flatbow does not have a shelf.
An American flatbow is made of wood, only wood,
kind of like this one,
which I know some people will say,
this is an American flatbow.
Well, it's not.
This is the grandfather of bows.
This is the Hohnergobler.
I'll get back to that.
So the definition of a longbow is a bow
that is at least 64 inches from nock to nock.
This one is 66 inches.
The reason it's flat is not because it's mimicking
an American flatbow.
It's actually because this is the way you make bows today.
It's just the way you mass produce bows today.
So the demand on bows today is much higher
than it was 5,000 years ago.
So back 5,000 years ago,
you made your own bows,
or someone close to your relative in your tribe
would make one for you.
That's not the way it goes today.
Most people don't have tools or access
or knowledge to build bows,
or the patience for that matter.
Also, modern bows are much more effective.
So if let's just say you're an idiot
and you wanted to make a longbow
by some of your standards,
this shape, D shape,
both in cross section and in profile.
If you made a bow,
laminated bow,
fiberglass wood,
just like this one,
in those dimensions,
none of you would be able to pull it
because it would be pulling at least 200 pounds.
You can't do that.
You can shoot it for perhaps once or twice,
but not for an entire day.
So today we make bows like this.
And yes, we do make them with the shelf
because it makes it easier to recreate something,
to be consistent in your shooting,
to be consistent in your accuracy.
So this is the way we make bows today.
And most bows are made with a reflex deflector,
has a bit of a swing to it when it's unstrung.
But this is simply the way we make bows today.
And then we have the American semi-longbow.
Yeah, no reflex deflector,
just straight up bow when you unstring.
This is completely straight and it's fairly ineffective,
but it still has a bloody arrow shelf,
like Howard Hill did back in the 30s and 40s.
And by the late 40s,
Fred Bear had started making these fiberglass laminations.
Consistency, great.
You can actually mass produce bows.
So this is great.
And then we have this one here.
Somebody would call this a Victorian longbow
because it doesn't have physically big dimensions.
But this one is a 52 pound bow at 28 inches.
And a 32 is 61.
Most people cannot shoot these, simply too heavy.
So if you made this bow in those dimensions,
you would have a bow at at least 100 pounds
and very few people are even able to shoot that.
Especially if we're talking accuracy,
shooting competitions.
So basically today we don't make bows like this.
This one is not exactly mass produced.
Each one is different.
So this is 52, not 50 pounds, not 55 pounds,
but 52 because that's where it ended up
when it was finished.
And yeah, so we have all these definitions today.
Why is that?
Well, it is such because of competitions.
Competitions have driven us as human beings,
human being, not humans,
human beings into categorizing bows
in order to create fairness.
So if one shoots this bow in a competition
and another shoots this one in competition,
I can assure you that the one shooting
the fiberglass lamination with the arrow shelf
is more accurate.
Perhaps not by much, but by some.
So today we make these kind of categories
in order to create fairness.
But it goes even further than that
because we as humans have a need
to set ourselves apart from all the others.
We want to be a part of something,
but we also want to be special.
So by shooting a specific type of bow,
we set ourselves apart.
So I shoot a horse bow.
I shoot a horn horse bow.
What the **** ever.
And then somebody shoots American,
hill style American semi-long bows
and somebody shoots long bows.
Somebody shoots hybrid bows.
Somebody shoots Victorian bows.
Somebody shoots war bows.
War bow is actually just a subcategory of a long bow.
So all these bows, even this hunkier bow,
falls under the category of a long bow
because they are long and without reflex.
Then we have these sort of niche products.
So going by self bows is also becoming a thing again.
So because most people buy these
mass production laminated bows,
there are huge amount of people
who want to set themselves apart
by shooting self-made.
Self bows are one piece of wood.
This particular bow is the Hommagol bow,
the grandfather of all bows,
almost 9,000 years old design.
Not this particular bow,
but the design is a long bow.
Bent all through the handle.
It's long enough.
And back then, back in the Stone Age
and Bronze Age, Iron Age, Middle Ages,
people didn't care about the definition of the bows,
which is the tool.
Hunting tool or a weapon.
Nobody had this urge to categorize them,
to put them into something
that could promote us as human beings.
Back then, a bow was a bow.
And yeah, it still is.
So a long bow is an umbrella definition
of basically all these bows.
I guess you can filter out the,
well, let's do that.
Let's filter out the hybrid bows,
it's not a long bow.
But all these other bows here are actually long bows,
different variations of a long bow,
but all long bows.
So we have the English long bows
that are kind of elevated,
put on a pedestal.
This is the long bow.
Well, it's not because this one is older.
So basically, all you English people,
just copycats.
And before that,
in Europe, in the Bronze Age
and the Iron Age,
we have similar bows,
similar to this one.
Not with horn locks,
but similar in configuration,
older than your Welsh and English long bows.
So basically, you're about three,
4,000 years behind.
So stop putting a label on this and saying,
well, this is the only proper long bow.
It's not true.
These are all long bows.
I get that you want to set yourself apart
by shooting an English long bow.
Well, basically, it's only in Britain
or some places in Europe
that these are considered the only long bow
because you have some, what's it called?
Organizations that you can only shoot
this kind of long bow.
This is the only true long bow
in those organizations.
But we have the World Archery,
we have the IFAA,
who are world-spanning organizations
in which this one here,
the most modern of them,
is a bloody long bow.
So I don't care what a handful of people
in the great scope of things
are saying it's a real long bow.
We can agree this is an English long bow.
That's true.
That one is with horn locks
because we didn't use horn locks
in the rest of Europe.
We just used wooden soft locks.
But this is also a long bow.
And I'd appreciate it
if you start yapping about it
because it's getting quite tiresome
and you clearly have not done your homework.
So I might get some heat for this,
but that's okay
because I am being inclusive,
not exclusive.
So you can all join in,
all English long bows,
all English long bows shooters
and modern long bow shooters
and American flatbow hill style,
whatever you are,
all welcome to call it a long bow.
I think we can all agree on that.
And the rest of you who don't agree,
just piss off.
Basically piss off
and then leave us alone
to enjoy our long bows.
Right.
And so more provocative videos coming up,
I guess.
So see you later
and enjoy your long bows.
