#幹細胞療法騙局--美國六十分鐘時事雜誌

#健康人生
242粉絲
7 次觀看·2025年9月6日
Comments are disabled for this video.
我們將看到我們曾經遇到的最荒謬的事物
漢人曾經到處旅行 探討醫療方法
據說是用中國蛇製成的
蛇油是沒用和危險的
因此 FDA 創立了停止其製造
以及其他食物和藥物騙局
但今天 蝙蝠藥物從來沒有變得更大
在21世紀
蝙蝠油被複製為複雜治療 使用腎臟
腎臟可能有一天會有治療
但互聯網上的醫學巨頭
正在發表恐怖的聲明
說他們可以逆轉治療方法
從腎臟癌 到多核酸癌
到任何類型的癌症
勤奮的人 正在賠償他們的生命
如同我們上個月第一次報道
這個罪行上沒有更好的窗戶
比起一個叫做醫生的男人
一個叫做 Lawrence Stowe 的男人
他並不意識到
某些他的患者
曾經有60分鐘的工作時間
其中一位患者是Steven Waters
一個在洛杉磯德州的學院管理人
在我們認識他六個月前
他得到的可能是最糟糕的診斷
他患有ALS
Amyotropic Lateral Sclerosis
也叫做Lou Gehrig's Disease
大約30,000個美國人
患有ALS在任何時間
如同Waters 他們都會死
大約在五年內
當他們的緊張系統
逐漸脫離他們的肌肉
一切只需要一點時間
我只是將事情設定到
需要最少的手動努力
處理個人衛生是很困難的
牙齒刷牙刷牙
非常困難 耗時很長
所以你只要做出
你能做到的適應
就行了
隨後Waters將能夠
只能動他的眼睛
同樣的命運
是Michael Martin
也患有ALS
Martin幾乎失去
任何說話的能力
很快的
他將無法走路
我好奇你家裡的
正常醫生
對你的疾病
和你的預測是什麼
我住了大約兩年
你住了大約兩年
我住了大約兩年
這是Stowe告訴我們的MS患者
他可以反過來治療她的疾病
用他的草藥和維他命來增強免疫系統
特製的疫苗和腎臟核酸
醫學專家說這是胡言亂語
但這和Stowe聲稱要反過來治療
腎臟疾病、ALS、MS等等
我們是唯一能夠幫助到
這些患者的治療
如果我們是大規模的藥品公司
我們會提供各種研究
獲得諾貝爾獎和醫學獎等等
Stowe並不是醫學醫生
他擁有兩份博士
但我們發現他只擁有一份化學研究
他擁有電子油業
也擁有油產業的合約
但1980年Stowe
轉變成了虛擬科學
有一段時間
他推廣了一種叫氨水的東西
他說它會減少老人的過敏
2003年
他創立了Stowe基金
為無證實的腎臟治療
Michael Martin
一位ALS的患者
幫助我們的故事
曾經聽說過Stowe的一位朋友
在我們遇到Martin之前
他已經給了Stowe
當Stowe醫生說
他可以用腎臟治療腎臟病
你覺得怎麼樣
你希望他相信
Stowe怎麼能讓
迷信的人相信
我們想知道
Steve Waters
很高興認識你
所以我們設置了隱藏攝錄機
在Houston的Michael Martin的家
邀請ALS患者Steve Waters
擺姿勢
是一位有興趣的患者
Stowe走進來
他失去了一隻腿
他說他患上癌症
所有人在房間裡
都知道我們的隱藏攝錄機
除了Stowe
Stowe曾經聲稱
ALS的腎臟病
所以我們給了Waters一些問題
來詢問Stowe的治療
所以腎臟病
是一種永續的修復嗎
是的
你可以重新運動
是的
如果我選擇永續修復
我會避免食物管
把我拉出車座嗎
是的
絕對的
我們把人拉出車座
我會越來越近
到某個地步
你可以說
你被治癒了
你被治癒了這個疾病
我相信這是100%可能的
因為我們用了其他方式治療
我們用癌症治療
這只是一種不同的
腎臟毀滅方式
你媽媽有癌症嗎
我媽媽患有肺癌
我們完全反過來治療她的肺癌
她死亡癌症免疫
有健康的肺臟
如果我選擇永續修復
大概是125,000
因為是第一階段的50,000
腎臟治療
大概是25,000
然後我們會跟進
治療
之後
確保得到的結果
大概是50,000
Stowe告訴他們
他們必須要去
Monterey,墨西哥
進行治療
他說他們的研究合夥人
會把血液形成的腎臟
從額頭和骨骼中釀製
並將這些腎臟注射到他們的肋骨
他說這些血液
會變成心臟或神經
將它們連接到肌肉
ALS有腎臟修復嗎
沒有
莫里森教授
是墨西哥大學
腎臟生物學研究中心的教授
他的實驗室是世界上
最頂尖的腎臟研究中心
所以當Stowe說
他會把血液形成的腎臟
放進額頭
來製造心臟
你怎麼看
我們每天都在這實驗室
研究血液形成腎臟
包括額頭核血
血液形成腎臟
不製造心臟細胞
然後血液形成腎臟
會做什麼
它們會開始
製造新的腎臟細胞
並修復腎臟
Stowe的不可思議的提議
經常有效
因為他的受害者
聽說了一些
腎臟的保證
但並不太瞭解
有一段時間
有些科學家認為
血液形成腎臟
可以替代任何類型的細胞
就像Stowe所說的
但科學家現在知道這是錯誤的
腎臟治療
是血液中的唯一的醫學標準
和血液中的一些難見的疾病
其他都沒有
有很早期的研究
關於腎臟細胞
可能會幫助ALS病患
但Stowe的訴求並沒有
莫里森醫生認為
腎臟的破壞
已經有幾十年了
他認為Stowe的訴求
沒有基礎
經常有人
報告三到四個星期
他們開始注意到效果
注意到效果
三到四個星期
你可能會注意到
三到四個星期的側面效果
你將它描述為奇妙
這就是它
如果某個人
把一些腎臟細胞
插入ALS病患的脊椎
然後他們站在
他們的車座上
有一個持續的修復
這將是奇妙的
但這就是Stowe保證
在麥克馬頓的辦公室
他描述了一個訴求
充滿誠意
他還說
德國大學
正在計劃建立
研究中心
有一個特別的名字
他不支持我們的方法
但我們發現
Morales正在用
沒有科學基礎的方式
Morales是一名美國人
住在德國
擁有一個
墨西哥醫學證書
我們得到他
簽署的證書
到某一個
Monterey醫院
並發現
醫學學位
來自一個
後來被關閉
因為銷售畢業證書
Morales離開了
住院訓練
Morales和Stowe
帶了我們的患者
一趟到醫院
Morales已經在做
腎臟治療
他描述了
他使用的技巧
墨西哥官員告訴我們
腎臟治療
ALS並不獲許可
醫院說
Morales並不知道
他在使用腎臟
並不獲許可
我們找到
Morales的一位
前患者
Muna Erickson
在墨西哥
她患有多種腎臟症
治療無法
Morales告訴你
你應該期待什麼
他告訴我
我應該期待她
從電梯上走出來
她從電梯上走出來
從電梯上走出來
Muna Erickson和她的丈夫
Keith並不是
有很多錢的人
因此他們迫不及待
賣了他們的家
為了向Morales
提供15,000美元
Muna Erickson說
他們到達了
一間廢棄的
墨西哥醫院
為了計劃
腎臟注射
但Morales
給了她一顆腎臟IV
而不是
他最後
把腎臟IV
從她的手指頭
Muna Erickson
如果你可以
用你的手指
告訴我
腎臟IV的位置
在你拇指的尾端
是的
你覺得怎麼樣
我考慮到
把我妻子帶回家
但是她
非常努力地
注射腎臟
我認為她
會有一個
完全的精神崩潰
如果我
把她坐在飛機上
Muna Erickson
你感覺有所改善嗎
沒有
我覺得有改善
在Monterey
墨西哥
Morales和Stowe
來到了一間酒店
他們遇見了
Patience
Michael Martin
和Steve Waters
他們期待
看到另一筆退款
35,000美元的現金
但這不是
他們打開的門
Mr. Stowe
Mr. Morales
我是Scott Pelley
我有60分鐘
接下來會發生什麼
一會兒後
Steven Waters
和Michael Martin
兩位ALS患者
用60分鐘工作
來到Monterey墨西哥
見到Larry Stowe
和Frank Morales
Stowe和Morales說
他們可以治療
ALS的症狀
用無證實的腎臟治療
他們遇見了一間酒店
我們安裝了隱藏相機
Stowe和Morales
期待看到
35,000美元的退款
但反而
我們走進去
做了一個
紀錄性的採訪
這是Larry Stowe
坐在右邊
沙發上
Michael Martin
和Steve Waters
和Morales
正在解釋
如何治療腎臟
嗨Steve
Michael
Mr. Stowe
Mr. Morales
我是Scott Pelley
我有60分鐘
我想問你幾個問題
紀錄性的
你提出的採訪
我理解
你遇到過
坐在椅子上
有些患者
沒有有改善
至此地步
你反過來
是的
你知道嗎
Mr. Stowe
有點麻煩的是
你是個假人
你
你誤會了這個採訪
你誤會了
你和德國大學的
你誤會了
你和FDA的工作
你現在又誤會了
他們的期望
Nobody at the FDA knows anything about any of this.
And the University of Texas is not going to be starting a regenerative medicine clinic with your name on it.
When we asked Stowe to back up his ALS claims, his story changed.
Give me a Stowe Foundation patient who has ALS, who has stood up out of a wheelchair and walked away.
We don't have any ALS patients. We have MS patients.
We are talking about the treatment that you have taken their money for.
Is that a treatment that would allow them to stand up out of a wheelchair and walk away?
No, we've done it with MS patients.
I don't believe that's what they understood.
I don't believe that's what you told them.
They weren't listening.
Can you give, oh, actually, we were listening very carefully.
Do you have the tape recordings?
I do.
Pull them up.
I have.
Pull them up. I want to hear them.
I can do that.
Okay.
And we did.
This was your meeting in Houston just a few weeks ago.
Well, if I opt for the permanent fix, will it keep me out of a wheelchair?
Oh, yeah. Absolutely.
We've had a number of ALS patients be able to get out of their wheelchairs.
That's not true, is it?
The Stone Foundation has not.
You told Steve that you were going to keep him out of a wheelchair.
That's not true either, is it?
No, that's very true.
You're going to sit here after seeing that,
and you're going to look this man in the face
and tell him that he's going to stay out of a wheelchair?
I mean, that's cruel.
What is his prognosis if he doesn't do this?
His prognosis is the same either way.
I know it's wrong.
Mr. Stone, you told these men in Houston
that a cure was, in your memorable phrase, 100% possible.
Possible? Is that a guarantee?
The folks at home are wondering what goes through your mind
when one of these men pushes a suitcase full of cash
across the table to you.
What are you thinking?
I'm thinking that they came to the right place
if they want any hope at all.
So is there a permanent fix for the stem cells?
Oh, yes.
Many patients have pinned their hope on Dr. Frank Morales
and his improvised stem cell procedures.
Recently, he injected stem cells
into the spine of a 7-year-old American boy
in an attempt to treat the boy's autism,
a procedure with no basis in medical science.
We found Morales's training is dubious.
This is the certificate he presented to a Monterey hospital
showing he completed his training at Texas Tech University,
but in the interview, he switched schools.
Have you ever been licensed to practice medicine
in the United States?
I have, and I worked under University of Texas,
where I was at in El Paso,
and came to Mexico after that.
The University of Texas, El Paso,
has no medical school
and no record of Morales as a student.
But you have a license or had a license
to practice in the state of Texas?
Absolutely.
It was an institutional license
at the University of Texas, El Paso, Utah.
So you can go there and you'll find it.
I mean, that's simple.
If you did your homework, that's lousiness.
That's the only word we have.
Sorry to say.
Not only does he have no credentials
from the University of Texas,
we found that his Texas Tech credentials are fraudulent.
A Texas Tech lawyer told us,
where it was obtained or manufactured,
I couldn't say,
but it was not issued by Texas Tech.
Several minutes into the interview,
we watched the Stowe-Morales relationship dissolve.
Morales walked out,
then came back to disavow Stowe.
Scott.
Yeah.
I think that just, you know,
in the sense of using him
to try to bring me down is,
I think is inappropriate.
I mean, it's...
So come talk to me about it.
Well...
Legal experts tell us that both Stowe and Morales
have broken U.S. law,
committed fraud by making a false claim.
It doesn't matter that the procedure
is done in another country.
We wondered why the FDA
is not acting against
the many stem cell con artists
whose websites are up for anyone to see.
But the FDA commissioner,
Margaret Hamburg,
declined to talk with us on camera
about any aspect of stem cell quackery.
Many experts believe that the FDA is outmatched.
Patients need to beware.
Larry Goldstein,
a prominent stem cell biologist,
and researcher Doug Sipp
are with the International Society
for Stem Cell Research,
an organization of the world's
leading stem cell scientists.
Sipp is tracking bogus stem cell clinics
all around the world.
How have these operations grown,
say, in the last 5 years or so?
I would say the growth has been explosive.
I've been tracking it kind of closely
for the past 3 years,
and I've been able to come up with
more than 200 clinics
that are offering some version of stem cells
for some type of medical condition
for which there's no really good evidence
that the stem cells would be
either safe or effective.
Well, are all of these clinics frauds?
On one end of the spectrum,
you have people who are doing
essentially badly designed,
uncontrolled human medical experiments
for profit.
And then at the other end of the spectrum,
you just have thieves
who are preying on the sick
and their families.
Now, an ALS patient might say to you,
How could I possibly be worse?
This is the question you get sometimes.
How could I possibly be worse?
I'm going to die.
I'm going to die in 2 or 3 years.
Why not give it a try?
Well, what if,
as a result of this treatment,
you ended up in excruciating pain?
What if you managed to bankrupt your family
through the use of one of these
expensive, unauthorized treatments
so that they can't care for you properly
as you decline?
There are things that are worse
than your current situation, I think.
The experts in stem cell research
believe these procedures
are at best ineffective
and potentially dangerous.
A study by UCLA
found patients at a Chinese clinic
often developed spinal meningitis.
But there's rarely any mention of risk
on the websites that offer false hope
for dozens of afflictions
ranging from Down syndrome to cancer.
One of the different things now
is that the power of the Internet
now gives this tremendous global reach
to people who in the past
would be kind of the local quack.
So instead of the snake oil salesman
standing in the back of a pickup truck,
he can now reach
every ALS patient on earth.
And say, come to me
and I'll help you out in Mexico
or in Russia or in Thailand.
What we see here essentially
is stow on an industrial scale.
Stow on steroids.
You could say that.
And he might as well be
sticking his hands into the pockets
of those people
and taking the money out
without even talking to them.
That's how bad I think it is.
I wonder what you think
when the top people in the field
that you pretend to work in
call you a snake oil salesman.
It comes with the territory.
It does come with the territory.
We wondered what Stow would say
to the idea of giving Michael Martin
his $47,000 back.
Has he asked for it?
I'm asking.
You'd give it back to him.
Now that's a deal I'd like to make.
Really? OK.
And when he continues to go downhill
6 months from now
and hasn't made any progress
Are you going to tell me
the cost of his care?
I'm not buying what you're selling.
Fine.
Of course that refund never came.
When we first walked into the interview
we thought Stow might not stay.
But he sat there for 2 hours
as though if he only talked long enough
he'd convince us.
Thanks for sitting with us
and talking to us.
You're not running away on me, are you?
Well, I was planning on leaving, yes.
I think I'm done.
All right.
Thank you.
You've just cost this man his life.
I want you to know that.
You know, I don't think so.
Larry Stow never gave up
even after his lies were exposed.
When we left the room
he turned to ALS patient Michael Martin
and tried to close the sale.
We'll keep in touch
because I can tell you
that you know what's going to happen.
If you don't take some type of aggressive action
The scene at the hotel
was the end of the Stow-Morales collaboration.
They didn't contact the patients again.
Michael Martin and Steve Waters
continued to fight the progression of ALS.
What would you like to see happen to Larry Stow?
I don't care, Martin said.
He has to live with himself.
Since our story first aired last April
Lawrence Stow has closed his business in San Diego.
We've learned that the FDA
has been investigating Stow and Morales
but the agency won't comment further.
Meanwhile, the ALS patients
who helped us with our story
are losing ground to their incurable disease.
Steve Waters had to retire from the college
and Michael Martin is now in hospice care
and can no longer breathe on his own.
MING PAO CANADA.com
