Which is a bigger showstopper for a human Mars mission: food or radiation exposure? Does Vera Rubin leave any chance for aliens to still sneak upon us? Can something like space whales actually exist? And in Q&A+, when can we find out what dark matter and dark energy actually are?
00:00 Start 00:31 [Kasie Ream] Which is the bigger showstopper for Mars: food or radiation? 02:29 [Richard Vanasse] Does Vera Rubin make it impossible for an alien fleet to sneak up on Earth? 02:54 [ventsyv] One question to ask aliens 03:24 [Terminally Offline] How can I get into a career in a planetarium? 05:56 [Steve Kennedy] What is the difference between a Kilonova and a Type 1a Supernova? 06:12 [teknophyle] Should we quickly become a two planet species? 08:14 [Michael D] How do I feel about the possibility of "space whales" type aliens? 09:51 [Bobby 2112] How does artificial gravity work on various scifi spaceships? 12:34 [shootZ234] Interesting facts about black holes 12:55 [paul wilson] How bright will the Betelgeuse explosion be?
⚖️ LICENSE Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
You are free to use my work for any purpose you like, just mention me as the source and link back to this video.
Which is the bigger showstopper for a
human Mars mission, food or radiation
exposure? Does Ver Rubin leave any
chance for aliens to sneak up on us? And
can something like space whales actually
exist? And in Q&A Plus, when can we find
out what dark matter and dark energy
actually are? All this and more in this
question show. It's time for the
question show. Your questions, my
answers, as always, wherever you are
across my channel. If a question pops in
your brain, just write it down. I'll
gather them up and I will answer them
here. All right, let's get into the
questions. Casey Ree, what is the
biggest showstopper for why we haven't
been to Mars yet? Food or radiation?
Both. Neither. I mean, the biggest
showstopper for why we haven't gone to
Mars is because it's ludicrously
expensive. We would be looking at tens
of billions, potentially a hundred
billion dollars to send a return mission
to Mars. And you know, people are
proposing cheaper ways to do that. like
great by by all means demonstrate the
cheaper ways to do that. But right now
for the kind of architecture that we
could imagine uh it's going to cost you
a ludicrous amount of money and it
requires technology that we just don't
have. So an unwillingness to spend that
much money on that kind of an endeavor
is the problem right now. Uh let's say
we had people willing to spend that kind
of money. Then there's a whole bunch of
issues that all come together at the
same time. Food, not really. you send
enough food with the astronauts so that
they don't starve during the mission.
Radiation, radiation is a problem.
They're going to receive a much higher
radiation load. If they get caught in a
solar storm, it's going to be a problem.
Even when they're down on the surface of
Mars, they're going to be exposed to
radiation. So, you're going to spend 3
yearsish receiving a much higher like
200 times as much radiation as you
experience down on the surface of Earth.
That's a problem. Low gravity, uh, you
know, we know that weightlessness is a
problem. Well, the astronauts are going
to have to spend two 9-month periods in
weightlessness as well as uh either 3
months or 18 months on the surface of
Mars in 1/3 gravity. Um, so
there's a bunch of issues that we just
don't have locked in yet. And you know,
anyone tells you that this is going to
be easy is wrong. It's going to be hard
and expensive and it's going to require
a lot of very careful planning to be
able to pull this off. And so I am just
by default skeptical when anyone thinks
that we're going to go and start setting
up a city on Mars anytime soon because
there's just too much to do still and
nobody's willing to spend the money to
do it. Richard Venice, does Vir Rubin
make it impossible for an alien fleet to
sneak up on Earth if they try to come
from something that's visible from the
southern hemisphere? So Ver Rubin is
located in Chile and so it can see the
south pole of the sky and then it can
see through the equator and I don't know
exactly how far north it can see but if
the alien fleet came at us from the
north pole then Ver Rubin wouldn't be
able to see it. Ventiv, if you could ask
an advanced alien species one question,
what would it be? I think I'd just like
to know how they survived. Um, you know,
when we think about all of the potential
threats that we face right now,
artificial intelligence, nuclear war,
threats to the environment, threats from
the environment, asteroids, potential
bonkers science experiments, and we look
out into the universe and we don't see a
lot of aliens out there. If we actually
find the ones that survive, we like, how
did you do it? So that we can prevent
any of the bad things happening to us.
That's what I would like to know.
Terminally offline. Fraser, I love
astronomy. I want to work at a
planetarium teaching others. How do I
get into that career? what education or
skills help the most. Getting work at a
planetarium or like any science center
is a fairly achievable job. You know, we
have the science world in Vancouver as
well as the planetarium in Vancouver.
I've known people who've worked at both.
Um, as well as I, you know, I have
friends who work at different museums
and science centers around the world.
Uh, one of the writers at Universe Today
writes planetarium shows. So, many of
the shows that you've probably watched,
she wrote them. Um, and so like how do
you do it? Um, so what's great is that
you can get in at the ground floor at a
lot of these places. You can go and get
a season's pass and come on a regular
basis that you can get to know the
people that work with them and a lot of
them do various volunteer events. A lot
of volunteer outreach uh where people
come and set up telescopes or uh you
know open observing nights like in
Vancouver we have the HR McMillan
Planetarium. I don't know what its
current name is, but you know, it's the
space center and they have a telescope
right beside the planetarium and they do
open nights where people come and just
use the telescope and it's it's a fairly
big telescope. It looks great and you
know you look at Mars, look at Saturn
and so on and you you know a lot of the
cases these things are staffed by
volunteers. So you know you don't need
to set up a tremendous long-term career
to be able to have an interesting role
to play at a science center. uh you know
generally an undergrad science degree
will be what you would would be really
helpful um which can then be used for
other things right um but I think don't
wait contact your science center your
space center today and let them know
that you want to volunteer that you want
to participate in various activities and
what are some of the events that are
coming up that you can be a part of and
they will they will be glad to have your
help because they're always understaffed
that there are a lot of projects and a
lot of education depends on these places
and they don't have the people to help
them do that. And this is you make
friends and you connect and you
demonstrate your enthusiasm, you get
invited to larger and larger projects
and eventually becomes obvious that
you're the person and you'll get a job
offer. I guarantee it. Um so, you know,
and and then get involved in larger
projects around your country where you
are participating in other big events of
outreach and community and things like
that. And eventually, inevitably, uh,
you'll be tasked with responsibility and
probably a salary. Steve Kennedy, what
is the difference between a kilanova and
a type 1a supernova? A kilanova is two
neutron stars colliding with each other.
A type 1A supernova is a white dwarf
that has accumulated 1.4 times the mass
of the sun and explodes. Technopile, do
you think maybe we should quickly become
a two-planet species? Aside from climate
change or asteroids, I'm mildly paranoid
about nuclear doomsday. No use worrying
about it, I guess. I don't think we
should be we should quickly become a
two-planet species. I think we should do
everything we can to minimize the
chances of climate change causing a
problem and nuclear apocalypse and all
that kind of stuff. Um, and that we
should work on becoming a solar system
spanning civilization at whatever is the
rate that it takes. You know, I think a
lot of people set Mars as the goal and
then they want to do whatever it takes
to accomplish Mars as the colony, but
the problem is is that we're too early
on the tech curve for us to rush colony
on Mars. It would make a lot more sense
for us to just follow the tech curve,
use, you know, develop different kinds
of technologies for living and working
in space and harvesting resources and
creating more of a institute resource
utilization situation in space. And then
finally there will come a time when yeah
sure uh colonizing Mars is is the
obvious next thing. And the reality is
is that Mars is so terrible that even if
we just had the worst possible climate
change on Earth if we had a nuclear war
if an asteroid hit us um almost any
disaster that we could imagine it would
the Earth would still be a thousand
times more habitable than Mars and it's
right here. It's under your feet and you
don't have to go anywhere to deal with
that. So unfortunately, there's kind of
like nothing we could do to make Earth
worse than Mars. I mean, like,
obviously, hold my beer, you know,
someone's going to try, but yeah. So,
unfortunately, I I I just don't think it
makes sense to rush that outcome. It's
time to shout out all the new $5 patrons
and above. David Norby, G Shawn Gorle,
Boret Clankar, Robert and Carol Mchuan,
Matt with one T, Harry at Zact, George
Bissiden, Nomad Gunslinger, Rich
Hellzerman, and Terry Johnson. Join the
club at patreon.com/universe
today. Michael D, how do you feel about
the possibility of space whales type
aliens? So people have proposed that you
could have uh life that exists in space
itself and there's surprising science
under this. So when you think about
life, you know, we imagine that you need
some kind of gravity environment that is
providing the atmosphere, that's
providing the water, that's cycling the
environment, you know, the the minerals
and so on. But there was actually
researchers that I interviewed about a
year ago where they were looking at
could you have life exist just in the
vacuum of space? And what they
calculated was that if you were far
enough away from the star, so you
weren't getting a lot of radiation,
that life could form a membrane in space
and it would then be able to bring water
inside that membrane, be able to have it
become liquid because of the radiation
coming from the sun. and that there's
other resources that they would have
available to them and they could grow to
fairly large sizes and to be able to be
completely independent from a gravity
well. And it was it blew my mind when I
was talking with them about this because
um you know this is the thing that we
expect like we should be looking for
life at planets but what if we look for
life just floating in space between
planets but it would probably not be you
know the space amoeba from Star Trek. It
would probably more be bacteria colonies
surrounded by some kind of film that
keeps them safe from space. Bobby 2112,
how come on the USS Enterprise they're
not floating around inside? They have
gravity on the ship. How do they do
that? Yeah, this is one of the things
that tells you that that a science
fiction show isn't taking the science
very realistically because trying to
explain how you get artificial gravity
or having your astronauts float around,
having your your crew float around in in
weightlessness is a pain to film. Um,
and there have been shows that have done
this. uh we think about the expanse like
they take gravity or a lack of gravity
very seriously. Now they have come up
with a fusion engine that allows their
spacecraft to travel with like 1g of
acceleration and then when the
spacecraft is flying then everybody
experiences gravity and then the
spacecraft turns around and then it
decelerates at 1g and everybody
experiences gravity on the deceleration
burn as well which is awesome. Um, and
then there's the times when they they
aren't burning and they're in combat and
they're everybody has to uh sort of get
into a seat and like tie themselves down
and then be able to handle really
extreme accelerations. It's so cool. So,
if you want to see a show that does this
properly, the expanse is the absolute
best. But they did this in Babylon 5
where they had the human uh spacecraft
have giant rotating sections in them and
so part of the time people are in
weights and other parts people are in
these. Uh when they did the Martian they
had this giant rotating chunk of the
spacecraft that people could be
operating in. So it takes a little bit
of creativity and um
uh science to build that into your
science fiction. And yeah, so like
anything else you watch any kind of uh
science fiction show where they're on a
spaceship and they're like, you know,
how are they walking around on the
surface of the ship? Who cares? Is their
answer. It's easier this way and people
aren't going to care. And mostly people
don't care. So I think that is fine,
right? I don't worry too much about the
liberties that science fiction takes.
And that's a big one, right? And they
describe it, you know, in Star Trek,
they describe, you know, turn on the
anti-gravity
inertial compensators and the gravitic
hull plating or whatever they do, right?
Just just gobbleygook uh sciency
sounding words so that they can have
people walk around in a set on Earth and
it looks like they're in gravity, right?
That's all. Shoots 234. My summer
astronomy class just started and my
professor says she loves black holes.
Got any super interesting facts we could
talk about in class. If you had a black
hole with the mass of the entire
observable universe, it would have an
event horizon of the entire observable
universe. See how she handles that one.
Paul Wilson, if Beetlejuice goes Nova,
will we see it in the daytime sky? Yes.
uh Beetlejuice if it goes off it's about
640 lighty years away and it will be as
bright as the full moon but compressed
down into a single point. Like if you
had the full moon and Betal Juice, you
could remove the full moon. Bet Juice
would be casting that same amount of
light. And of course, we can see the
moon during the day and we would be able
to see Betal Juice during the day. It
would just be like this brighter star
object in the sky all day long and we
would be able to see it. Now, it
wouldn't last for long. It would last
for a couple of months until it faded
away. But yeah, it would be a, you know,
when Betal Juice goes off or any other
close supernova. It will be a hell of a
thing. Did you know that you can watch
the same video with no ads and get a
bonus question over on Patreon
completely for free? We call that Q&A
Plus. And this week's bonus question,
when will we find out what dark matter
and dark energy actually are? And if you
want to watch that episode, add free.
I'll put a link in the show notes.
All right, those are all the questions
that we had this week. Thank you
everyone who asked your questions in the
YouTube comments, everybody who asked
your questions during the live show that
we wrapped up two months ago. Uh, now
I'm going to talk about the schedule.
Uh, but first I'd like to thank our
patrons. Thanks to Abe Kingson, Andrew
Gross, Bailey Griffin, Brian Bod,
Carwin, Chuck Hawkins, Commander
Bailock, S Nelson, David Gilad, David
Mats, Evan Pro, Hudson Ward, James
Clark, Jeremy Matter, Jim Burke, Jordan
Young, Josh Schultz, Marcel Smith,
Michael Pcell, Monzo, Nick Borquez, Nick
Solari, Paul Robach, Rink Kaidu, Richard
Williams, Sean Sergeant, Steven Fer,
Mley, Vlad Shiplin, and Wolf Gang Clots
who support us at the master of the
universe level and all our patrons. All
your support means the universe to us.
So, we are now just a couple of days
away for us returning to our regular
schedule of live streams. So, now the
way this works is that we delay the
release of the question show a week
after we record the live question show
and that gives our editor time to pull
together the questions. And so this is
going to get weird, but the next live
question show is going to be on Monday,
September the 8th. So 1 week after the
Labor Day weekend, and we're going to
return to our regular schedule. So we'll
start at 5:00, go till 7:00, and then
the next week we will rotate to Europe,
and then the week after that we will
rotate to Asian time. And so we will
return to our regular normal schedule.
And so I'm going to put the next event
here on the channel. It's there right
now. And so if you want to click on the
notification to get a reminder of when
we're going to do that, this is your way
to do it. And then like I know it's
rotating. I know it's complicated, but
anyway. And then the actual question
show will come out
on the following Tuesday and Thursday.
So that's how the schedule works.
Uh, I can't wait to see you all again.