Who doesn’t love free money? This Cash Course episode tackles subsidies: payments and discounts the government uses to encourage one economic activity over another. Teach your high school students how subsidies work, how they distort markets, and who’s really footing the bill. Because when the government subsidizes something, everybody pays!
So,
how's business?
Terrible. Lemons have doubled in price,
so I've had to raise my prices, too.
Maybe you should sell something else.
I can't do that. We are the ultimate
lemonade corporation.
Would you like me to subsidize that?
You're going to subsidize a lemonade
stand?
Yes, it is my specialty.
What's a subsidy?
Wait, is this another
A subsidy is an incentive usually
implemented by the government to
encourage people to engage in certain
behaviors or to protect businesses. This
incentive comes in the form of payments
or discounts. A payment subsidy gives
money directly to producers like giving
corn farmers $1 for each bushel of corn
so the farmers can produce enough
supply. Thanks. A discount subsidy
reduces the cost for consumers, like
offering a $200 credit on treadmill
purchases to promote exercise.
All right,
a $200 credit? I'll take two.
I'll take three.
In a market economy, prices rise and
fall based on the natural flow of supply
and demand, eventually reaching an
equilibrium. Interventions like
subsidies, though, distort that
equilibrium and impact the price signals
between consumers and producers. Let's
take a closer look at how subsidies
work. First, consumer side subsidies.
This is when the government attempts to
entice buyers to choose a certain
product. For example, the government
offers a 20% discount on groceries when
you get a flu shot in the store's
pharmacy. Now, more people want the flu
shot because it comes with added value.
Look at this line.
It's out the door.
This kind of subsidy increases the
demand for both the flu shot and
groceries more than there would have
been without the subsidy. Without an
increase in supply, those goods will
become more scarce and the price will go
up for everyone.
A carton of eggs is how much?
But at least it's 20% off.
Second, we have producer side subsidies.
This is when the government attempts to
help the seller make more of a good or
keep their costs stable enough to stay
in business either through a tax break
or a direct payment. For example, the
government wants to encourage consumers
to use clean energy vehicles. So, it
offers a car company $1,000 per electric
vehicle. Nice.
With that financial incentive, the
company produces more electric vehicles.
This results in more supply that's
readily available for customers to
purchase, which has the potential to
bring down prices for everyone who buys
an electric car.
Oo, heated seats, monogram steering
wheel.
Wait, I thought the subsidies were
supposed to help make things cheaper.
They can for a time. That's because the
government initially carries the cost by
providing producers with payments or
discounts for customers. However,
there's a trade-off. The government has
to recoup the money from providing the
subsidy, and this usually happens
through higher taxes or more government
borrowing. Those taxes come out of your
pockets, and more government borrowing
often leads to inflation. In the case of
both the flu shot and the clean energy
vehicles, the government may shift tax
revenue or raise taxes to cover the cost
of the subsidy or to make up for lost
tax income. So, why bother with
subsidies at all? Oo, hot pink.
Subsidies can have benefits such as
protecting consumers and producers with
lower and more stable prices. They can
also help certain industries succeed,
encouraging new businesses and
innovation. Subsidies are also used to
help lower income individuals afford
basic necessities through direct
payments. But subsidies always create
market distortions. When prices don't
reflect the true value of goods, people
and businesses get the wrong signals,
like spending on goods that are only
popular because they're discounted, not
because they're actually valuable.
Check it out. 200 lb of oats. They were
on sale.
Why do you need 200 lb of oats?
They're great for horses.
Girl, you don't have any horses.
I might have some in the future.
Subsidies often waste resources and
create inefficiency by producing goods
that aren't wanted or needed. If
electric vehicles are subsidized, the
company will be incentivized to produce
more. But that's not a response to
actual demand. Surplus cars will go
unsold when the resources to make the
electric vehicles could have been used
to make more of the products people
actually want, like a gas powered car.
Woohoo!
Now this is a car. Those subsidized
businesses are also given an advantage
over those that are not, creating more
competition for the same resources. This
drives up demand, which increases the
price of the materials a business needs.
Those that can't afford to keep up go
under. Subsidies are a powerful tool for
driving certain economic behaviors, but
as with any intervention, they come with
trade-offs. Discounts and payments sound
enticing, but altering the regular flow
of supply and demand can lead to
unintended consequences. So, next time
you hear about government subsidies, ask
yourself, who's getting the boost and
who's paying for it?
You took the subsidy after all, huh?
Yeah, but now there are 10 lemonade
stands on this street alone. I'm getting
squeezed.
Perhaps I can interest you in a cup
subsidy to go along with that lemonade
subsidy.
No.
Watch more at prageruids.com.
And parents, don't forget to subscribe.