Alfred Sisley’s "Péniches" and Pierre-Auguste Renoir’s "Cariatides," which had been on loan to the Dieppe Museum and the Renoir Museum in Cagnes-sur-Mer since the end of World War II, were the subject of forced sales in 1941. On May 16, 2024, these artworks were officially returned to the gallery owner’s heirs during a ceremony at the French Ministry of Culture.
Sotheby’s, the first auction house to establish a department specializing in restitutions, is deeply honored to have been chosen by the heirs of Grégoire Schusterman to present these two masterpieces for sale.
Painted in 1909, "Deux jeunes femmes nues, guirlandes de feuillages et de fruits" (estimated at €1,000,000-1,500,000) is part of a series of four works consisting of two diptychs, where Renoir drew inspiration from the classical ideals of Antiquity and the Renaissance. One of these diptychs is now housed in the collections of the Barnes Foundation in Philadelphia.
Painted in 1870, "Vue d'un port, les péniches" (estimated at €800,000-1,200,000) exemplifies the atmospheric studies conducted by Alfred Sisley during the early days of Impressionism. In this work, Sisley carefully captures the reflections and transparency of the river, alongside the soft light of the misty sky. Although it was part of Charles Pearson’s collection, the exact date of its acquisition by Grégoire Schusterman remains unknown.
In 1950, these two works were among the 15,000 works of art brought back to France
and considered works of art that were to be restituted to their rightful owners.
Every painting has a story, just like people, objects. This is especially true for paintings
by artists such as Renoir, these wonderful caritades by Renoir, a typical example of his
Impressionist interpretation of the nude. This is typical also of paintings by Alfred Cisley,
Les Péniches, the Barges from 1870. After they were painted, they circulated on the market
in the early 20th century and in the 1920s were bought by an art dealer called Grégoire Schusterman.
The secondary story of these paintings is just as equally fascinating as their position as
important Impressionist works because they're inscribed in history at large.
With the onset of World War II, with the occupation of Paris by the German troops,
Grégoire Schusterman therefore had to sell these works under duress. These were forced sales because
he had no choice, he had to leave Paris as quickly as possible. Deportation orders were in progress,
the Gestapo was actively looking for him. In 1941 he therefore sold these works,
they ended up in Germany. It's when the Allies started recuperating looted goods that they
reappeared. The Renoir reappeared in a castle in Bavaria, the Cisley reappeared in Rhineland
at a parent of the German art dealers. What is special about the caricatures by Renoir painted
in 1909 is that you are now in the sort of the second half of the artist's oeuvre. You have this
loose brushstroke, this very sort of vivid use of colours, very free, therefore reinterpret what is
a very classical motif into a modern pictorial language that was part of Impressionism. This is
exactly what's going on with Cisley as well. It was painted much earlier in 1870, so this is
almost pre-Impressionist because the first exhibition is held in 1874. What is wonderful
about these works of art is that you have this historical aura and there's this very
passage through the vagaries of war in World War II and restitution and it's very moving.
They are works of art that we're proud to present at auction for the first time.