How the Victorians Faked Tiny Waists (without fainting!)

La Beautes
153 followers
The Victorians were just masters of illusion.
So masterful in fact that they continue to deceive us
into the 21st century and we continue to buy it.
So this is going to be a slightly off-the-cuff video
because I read yet another one of those oh-so-profuse comments
about how impossibly tiny the Victorian waste must have been
and how suffering they must have been.
And I know I've touched on this topic in various places throughout my videos
but I wanted one specific central place on this channel
where you can go to debunk the myth of the impossibly tiny Victorian waste.
Because to the modern educated mind
what we see when we see a tiny waste is someone who has pulled a corset
so impossibly tightly that they must not be able to breathe,
they must not be able to eat,
they must be on the verge of fainting
just because that is what we tend to have been taught about this period.
I would argue for the most part what you're seeing is largely an illusion.
So we have a couple of options that we can employ
in order to sort of give the illusion that we have this very tiny waste
and these are all practices that were used and employed
with profuse regularity throughout history.
Each person based on their comfort levels
and their desired outcome will choose a different selection of these methods
and this is what I want to sort of go over today
so that when you see photos or paintings of Victorians
or even earlier in the periods
you know what you're looking at and you're not in this mindset of
oh my god they all must have been size 000 humans
because that was not the fashionable body type in the 19th century
that is not what the Victorian is going for
and we're gonna we're gonna go over this.
So the first of course is reduction.
You can put on a corset and tight lace it down
or just lace it down and reduce the width of your waist measurement.
Different body types tend to have different ease and ability to do this than others
so arguably the people who tend to be most suited towards dramatic waist reduction
are people of larger body sizes and people with softer cores.
People with very athletic body types who are very solid and muscular or bony
don't tend to be able to get much reduction
or if you do reduce it takes a lot of effort
and it can be quite uncomfortable even painful.
So I have a number of things going on.
Not only do I not have a fleshy middle
but I also have some musculoskeletal deformities going on
which makes reduction for me difficult if not completely impossible.
So the wearing of a corset and I cannot stress this enough
and this has been stressed profusely all over the costuming corners of the internet
should be worn to your comfort.
It was worn to the wearer's comfort all throughout history for the most part
unless you're going for an extremely fashionable extremely idealized figure
and you're willing to endure some level of discomfort for the sake of fashion.
The ideal Victorian proportions or Edwardian proportions are
the bust to be 10 inches larger than the waist and 15 inches smaller than the hips.
So if you are able to achieve that solely through reduction
and be completely comfortable doing so that's great.
You're good, you're golden, you've done it.
Problem solved.
A lot of people cannot do it through reduction alone comfortably
and this is something that Hollywood very often misinterprets
when representing historical periods
is that they tend to cast very slim actresses to play these roles
which is not a problem.
I mean every one of every body type existed all throughout history
but instead of augmenting the hips and the bust
Hollywood just has it in their head that everything must be reduced.
Everything has to be as tiny as you can possibly make it
so you end up with these very thin actresses who don't lace down
who don't have natural reduction naturally
because that's not how their bodies work.
You put them into these corsets and you try and reduce them
you try and get the inches down two, three, four inches
that's not how they work, that will not be comfortable for them
and hence we get all of the complaints.
Wearing a corset does, you know, you feel like you can't breathe sometimes.
It's pinching me everywhere, restricting my ribcage.
And I put this corset on and then I was like, oh my god, I'm gonna have a panic attack.
What we should be doing instead is augmenting the bust and hips
so that their waists already naturally look very tiny
and that is where the other options come in.
The option that personally I prefer is augmentation.
It is the padding of the bust and the hips
to pad out those proportional measurements.
The reason that this Edwardian ideal, this Victorian ideal is this way
is because those proportions make that waist look very small to the eye.
I will use what I'm doing as an example
but maybe don't take this as the one true method
because my situation is particularly unusual.
Just to take a base waist measurement.
The waist, by the way, on some people it's the slimmest portion of the torso.
On most people it is the point at which you crease.
So you don't want to measure here which is your high hip
which a lot of people think is the waist
and you don't want to measure down here, that's the hip.
So we are looking at around 25 and a half inches.
We're gonna give this a go.
Okay, so as an absolute base layer
I've got a pair of combinations on.
This could equally be a chemise.
This is purely just keeping my skin safe from the corset
to prevent rubbing, chafing, discomfort
as well as protecting the corset
from having to come into contact with my skin
and thus needing to be washed every day.
Sometimes it can be built with these little illusion techniques already happening.
As you can see, we've got a fitted waistband
with a deliberately very fluffy front here
and a bit of gathering at the waist
so that, you know, when you're just walking around
in your combinations apparently
you're already giving a little bit of that hourglass vibe.
So this is a bit of a debated topic
as to whether the corset is padded
or whether the padding is added on top of the clothing.
The general consensus is that anything goes.
It depends on what you're comfortable with.
Personally, I've added the padding into my corset
so as you can see, I mean, you know this
if you watched the making portion of this corset
I've got a bit of bust padding, a bit of hip padding
already built into the inside of this corset
so when I put it on, it is already good to go
already starting to do some of the work for me.
Some pairs of combinations and some chemises
can be built with a little bit of ruffling at the top
some bows, some extra fluff that is slightly deliberate
so that when something goes over top of that
this is held out by the front
and that adds a little bit of volume just up here
which can help with the whole illusion situation.
This is stiffened with synthetic baleen
which is a synthetic fake whalebone
not real whalebone but it behaves like real whalebone
so meaning that it is very flexible
real whalebone was very flexible
and you can bend, you can move
I've still got plenty of room down here
I can fit my whole hand down here
and it's just delightful
I can move, I can bend, I can breathe
this is all just fine and dandy
So theoretically over top of this layer goes
what would be called a corset cover
which is just a bodice layer of something roughly
mostly the point of it is just to hide the ridge of the corset here
I'm actually using a chemise
which is going to have a similar effect up top
and it won't be seen on the bottom
because it will just be covered with a petticoat anyway
but just so that you know
One of the additional benefits of the corset cover
beyond just smoothing everything out up here
is that it could very often be built with
lots of ruffles and lots of frills at the top
so if you are nearing the ideal proportions up top
then you could just add a little bit of rufflage at the top
and be fine and not have to do any padding
Personally I need as much help as I can get
so I've got my padding in the corset
and then I've got my
well I've got some roughly bow layers with my under layer
and I've also got the gathering up here
and the frill up here
which will help to once again
just give me a little bit of fluff up here
The next layer is the bustle pad
Once again this can be as large or as small as you need it to be
I've got just relatively slim little pad here
that will just come across
not so much across the hips
because I already am wide enough at the bottom
but then across the back as well
and this gets tied at the waist
kind of but slightly below
because you don't want any of this bulk
interfering with the actual waistline
because then that just adds bulk
which is what we're trying to avoid
And over top of this goes the petticoat
Once again this petticoat is built
primarily to just smooth out all of these layers
As you can see
this petticoat is built off of a Victorian pattern
so it's got this yoke across the top
which will keep everything nice and smooth
just around the high hip area
and then we've got a little bit of gathering at the back
which will help to give us some fluff
right where we want the fluff
So as you can see
we are beginning to look a bit like our friend back here
although our waist measurement is quite a bit larger than hers
So the next tactic of illusion
is quite literally illusion
the illusion of the outer garments
that you're wearing over top of your corset
the dresses, the jackets, the coats, the whatever
are all built to sort of trick the eye
into seeing a very specific shape
So for example in the middle of the 19th century
when the fashion was for the waist to be very very small
it is arguably the period of the smallest waist in fashion
This is also why coincidentally in this period
we tend to have arguably some of the largest skirts in history
We have those very big large round crinoline skirts
which make the base of the dress look very large
and it widens the hips of course
therefore by comparison making the waist look very tiny
augmenting the shoulders with sleeve puffs or shoulder padding
or sort of elongating the shoulder line
as was done in the middle of the 19th century
by dropping that shoulder seam
and making the shoulders look very low and sloped
Incidentally in the Regency period
where the waist is not really a feature of the silhouette
we have very small sleeves
and this is I think why we tend to think
that so many of these garments are made for very very tiny people
because when we look at them
all we see is the proportions
all we see is the sloped shoulders
all we see is the big skirts
the densely pleated waist seam
and therefore the tiny waist
and we just assume it must have been made for a very tiny person
Kenna Leavis who's a dress historian
has put together a really interesting database of extant garments
with their waist measurements
and you can see how many of these garments
don't have teen or low 20s waists
This dress for example
you would look at this and you would think
oh you know she's pretty tiny, right?
This dress, the waist measurement on this dress
The key is to make your shirt waist a little bit fluffy around the waist
so that when it gets cinched in with the waistband of the skirt
then it looks like you've got a very tight very small waist
because look how far in it's going
compared to all the fluff going on over top
So finally we are adding the skirt
This once again has a very tight waistband here
which will sit nice and flat against the waistband
I'm going to fluff out this front a little bit
because that will once again help
just to make things look a little bit smaller than they actually are
And here's a neat little trick
is these waistbands can be as tight as you want them to be
and you will not feel it
because you already have this corset
you can already move and breathe
but the waistband is just going to sit flat against the corset
and you're not going to feel a thing
So equally, an equal bit of magic that was often employed
is these very large sashes
and this is something that I noticed when I did my Mary Poppins project
is that you can put on one of these very wide very tight sashes
and pull it very tight
and it looks like because it is sitting so tight
and so flat against your waist
but it's really cinching you in
even though really, you know, it's sitting flat against the corset
I can't feel a thing
So here's our final result
I don't know, this is like the worst possible background
you could film this in front of
So here's the final result
Here's what we have
I can move, I can breathe, I can bend
I can still fit an entire hand down in my corset if I wanted to
We are clocking in at a roomy 26
so we've added a half an inch
even though by illusion we look a little bit smaller
By contrast, here is where we are in the same outfit
minus all of the sculptural understructures
So as you can see, we are much more just sort of standard human shape
so we are not quite as dramatic as the Victorians
So we do end up with a slightly different shape here
and not a, you know, quite quintessentially Victorian shape
So last but most definitely not least
the final measure that you can take to ensure that your waist appears
the absolute most snatched it can possibly be
is image manipulation
This was profuse in the late 19th century
all throughout the 19th century really
but the ability to manipulate an image has been in existence
almost as long as photography has existed
Essentially, never trust the picture of a Victorian
especially where the waist looks absolutely impossibly tiny
and especially when that waist is next to a backdrop
that is not terribly busy
and can very easily just be scraped down ever so slightly
because that is very much what they were doing
Everything from waist measurements to body shape
to facial features and skin texture
anything could be realistically just altered a slight, slight amount
So as is generally good practice today
don't believe the photos that you see on social media
because most of them have probably been facetuned
or otherwise edited to some capacity
So too have photographs all throughout history
So why do we have this idea that all of the Victorians were just very, very tiny?
One reason of course is the amount of very, very tiny garments
that do genuinely survive to us today
So how do we explain that?
Who are these people?
Where are they coming from?
And to this I say to you
survivorship bias
These dresses still exist in their almost pristine museum quality
display-worthy condition
precisely because not a lot of people could fit into them
They couldn't receive as much wear
They didn't have the opportunity to completely degrade
A lot of these garments that are very small are worn by very young women
before they have finished growing
before they've grown out of these garments
And so they don't have the most amount of time to be worn
and therefore are often in the best condition
if not surviving completely
The Victorians were just masters of illusion
so masterful in fact that they continue to deceive us into the 21st century
and we continue to buy it
But it's really interesting to study because a lot of these techniques and practices
can be employed still today to achieve aesthetic ideals
that are seemingly impossible to achieve
without necessarily causing yourself harm
And this is one of the things that I think the Victorians actually
might have been onto historically
in that one of the things that I think we are really misunderstanding about today
is that there is one specific way that you have to do things
in order to achieve one specific ideal
History teaches us that there are other options
History teaches us that there are a vast number of body types
When you look at tailoring books of this period
it's not just here's how to draft for this one body type
There are entirely different sets of instructions
drafting instructions for all different sorts of body types
and not just body size but different skeletal configurations
So basically no, the Victorians were not ubiquitously impossibly small
They were in fact employing a wide range of different methods
to trick the eye into perceiving a very specific body ideal
and that these methods were employed across a range of various body types
and in accordance to the wearer's not only physical composition
but personal comfort
I think that is just so magical
and I think it's even more incredible
that this practice has literally just been so well implemented
that it has been completely forgotten
and has managed to continue to trick us into the 21st century
I think that is magical
and there's something in there that we can learn
Speaking of expert illusions
this video is brought to you by NordVPN
the fastest virtual private network service
working to help keep your online presence safe
But NordVPN is not only a VPN service
protecting your devices from being spied upon
by tracking sites and online malware
NordVPN also offers a whole host of other privacy-oriented services
like password management
ensuring that your passwords are unique and hard to hack across all of your logins
and dark web monitoring
so you can be kept aware of any of your personal information being leaked
to malicious establishments
Thus you get to ensure that your IP address
and thus your location
remain nicely hidden
Where in the world is Bernadette Banner?
Wouldn't HBO like to know?
Too bad they won't see through the careful guise of NordVPN
and I can carry on tricking them into thinking I'm in the United States
whilst I consume all of their content
Get the exclusive NordVPN deal at nordvpn.com slash Bernadette
It is risk-free with Nord's 30-day money-back guarantee
I'm literally never getting out of here
I can do it this way, right?
We're good, we're good
Absolutely nothing amiss has happened here
