The Italian Job - The Epilogue

Classical Artwork Conservation
262 followers
19 Video Views·Sep 2, 2025
Oct 18, 2021
This epilogue comes to YouTube by way of the kind folks at my Patreon. After seeing this video they decided that it was too good to not share with the world. They voted and thanks to their generosity this epilogue is now available for the world to see.
These epilogues are generally reserved for Patreon. I answer questions from the audience, talk about the project and back story and occasionally I'm joined by the owner of the piece to discuss it further.
--
Support me on Patreon
/ baumgartnerrestoration
Official Baumgartner Merchandise
https://teespring.com/stores/bfars-store
Follow me on
Instagram - / baumgartnerrestoration
Facebook - / baumgartnerfineartrestoration
This video comes to you by way of the kind folks over at my Patreon page who,
after watching it, decided it was too good to not share with the world. So they took a vote
and decided that it would be public for everyone to see and enjoy. Now this epilogue video is an
example of the things that are available to my Patreon folks. Questions and answers,
conversations with the clients, sometimes some tidbits about the paintings, backstory, etc.
So say thanks to them and enjoy. Welcome folks and again welcome to all the new Patreons.
This is the epilogue for the Italian job. Phone always interrupts. Baumgartner Restoration.
Okay let's try that again. Welcome to the epilogue for the Italian job. I know you
are all super excited to see me and McGregor talk about those test results but first I'm going to
go ahead and answer your questions. You had a great deal of really insightful,
interesting questions and a couple of really pointed, sharp ones. Some of you really wanted
to stick it to me. So without further ado I'll get to these and then we'll get to the conversation
with McGregor. So Jesse asked, how often do I have clients requesting scientific analysis on
their paintings? I have clients requesting it a lot but I have very few clients who actually go
through with it. So scientific testing is not a panacea. It's not the answer for everything and
sometimes it can actually be misguided. So something like paint sample analysis is really
only good if you are specifically looking for something, specifically not looking for something,
or you have something to compare it against. Taking samples of paint isn't going to tell
you much about the painting. It's just going to tell you what the paint is made of. Now sometimes
that information can be useful but sometimes not. X-rays may see through the top layer of paint but
if there's nothing to see, there's nothing to see. Carbon radiodating may be beneficial but
if you're trying to figure out if a painting was painted in 1952 or 1954, carbon radiodating is
probably not going to be the answer. So scientific testing can tell us a lot about a painting but it's
not always the answer. And when I tell my clients this, oftentimes that, coupled with the cost of
some of these tests, usually sends that notion packing. Every once in a while, like in this case,
I do have a client that goes through with it and only after extensive research and explanation
and investigation would I ever recommend that. So Neilin said, given how frequently I comment on
conservators' work needing to be reversible, she was a little shocked to see me cut off a piece of
canvas. Even more so when I whipped out a saw and just took a chunk of stretcher. Is there some kind
of exception to be made when authenticating a painting is involved? Was the presumed
seriously ancient age of this painting a deciding factor in doing that? Well unfortunately there is
no way to take samples that are non-destructive. You have to take part of the object to have it
tested. And in this case, we suspect that the wood is not original to the painting and the wood can be
replaced. In addition, the wood requires a larger sample. I'm not exactly sure why. In terms of the
painting, I would have much rather taken a piece of the tacking edge were it present. But in the
past it was removed or lost so I didn't have any other choice. Now I specifically chose a corner
that already had lots of paint loss so that I was taking a section that was already going to need
quite a bit of retouching and work to make it whole. I wouldn't take a piece of canvas from
behind the face, let's say. Now unfortunately that's just the way it goes. You know, whenever
we take a sample, the owners, everybody has to be aware that it is a destructive process. We try to
mitigate that destruction and try to take just what we need. But unfortunately, you gotta crack some eggs to make an omelette.
Jody asked, I have been watching for almost a year now and I can't figure out when you use large
pieces of washi kozo or small. Well, sometimes I use small pieces when the painting has lots of
impasto and texture and I really want it to conform to that impasto. Sometimes I'll use large pieces
when the painting is really smooth. Sometimes I'll use small pieces because I have a whole
bunch of them cut. Sometimes I'll use large pieces because they are more convenient.
I don't want to say there's no rhyme or reason to it because of course there is. But using small
pieces or large pieces, sometimes it doesn't matter. Like in this painting, I was able to
use several large pieces because the painting was relatively smooth and flat, didn't have a lot of
impasto. So ultimately, sometimes the painting makes the decision, sometimes I do, and sometimes
the stars make the decision for me. So Lisa asked a really good question about past conservation.
She noticed that the lining canvas was really a heavy weave, open weave, more like burlap than
linen, and asked if I was able to tell anything about the age of conservation. Sometimes if I
have something that is glued with PVA, I know that it couldn't be before a certain date because
that material wasn't available. But traditional techniques like this where they use a canvas with
a rabbit skin glue, that was executed as early as the 13 or 1400s and sometimes it's even executed
today. So sometimes I can tell based on the materials or based on the deterioration of the
materials, but oftentimes I just have a loose window. Something like this might have been done
between 1950 and 1980 or this was definitely post-1980 but I don't know when the
ceiling was. Or based on the age and the deterioration, I would expect this conservation work to be more
than 200 years old. So you can kind of suss out some details but ultimately it gets a little blurry
trying to figure out an exact date just based on the materials or their age.
Jessica and a few of you asked, what do you do if the painting is so big that you can't reach the
middle for the scraping? Well if I can't do it vertically then I will lay the painting down on
the floor after putting some protective coverings down and I will erect a scaffolding or a bridge
over the painting that allows me to kind of crawl onto it and reach the middle of the piece. It's all
very complex and mission impossible. Ropes and harnesses and all sorts of crazy stuff. I do my
own stunts by the way. If ever I have a chance to show you I certainly will. Okay Kathy said,
please take this as at most an exasperated question. Okay Julian, why on earth didn't you
face the painting before removing it from the stretcher if you were just going to do it immediately
after? Oh boy. Well I suppose I could have faced it right off the bat but and there is a good
reason for this. Because the painting was glued down to the strainer there were sections where
I was able to put my palette knife between the lining canvas and the wooden strainer and separate
that glue but there were also places where I had to put my palette knife in between the original
canvas and the lining canvas and then slice through the lining canvas and the facing would
have made that a little bit more difficult to to kind of judge where my palette knife was. So that's
why I chose not to face the painting right off the bat. Now I probably could have and maybe even
should have but you know sometimes you do things because you've got the experience and the know-how
and you just trust that this is going to be the right way to do it. So unfortunately Kathy there
isn't really a solid 100% gold answer other than because. Don't be mad. Sorry. So another Kathy
asked why didn't I use water to help loosen the lining canvas from the rabbit skin glue as opposed
to scraping it off particularly because I was going to use the gel water to remove the glue.
You know anytime we expose a painting to water crazy things can happen even if we are really
controlled about it so I like to limit that amount of exposure whenever possible. So I felt
that doing two rounds of water exposure to this painting particularly given how old it was and how
delicate it was just was a risk I wasn't willing to take and I've removed canvas via scraping so
many times that it is almost automatic for me. So while it took a lot more time and it was kind of
a pain I felt it was safer in the end. So Wendy said that we've seen a couple of clients reactions
and they do seem to be positive but she wanted to know have I ever had a client really respond
negatively for some reason. Yeah I have. I've had clients whose expectations weren't in accord with
what I communicated. I had a client who was disappointed at seeing his painting so clean
and vibrant and asked me to put a tinted varnish back on. I had a client who was disappointed
after removing all of the overpaint from a bad restoration job that the painting looked different
and I tried to explain to them that what they were familiar with what they had grown to know
wasn't actually the painting it was somebody else's correction of their mistake and that client was
just not happy and wanted me to put it back the way it was and so I had to find a way to
meet their expectations. Generally people are really happy they want their paintings conserved
I try my best to communicate to them in a comprehensive way what they should expect
what they shouldn't expect and make sure that those expectations are in accord with what I
can deliver. So I would say you know maybe once every three or so years I get somebody who's not
happy with a conservation but to some degree that's my fault for not being better at communicating
and ultimately their fault for having expectations that just are wildly inappropriate. So it happens
but very rarely. Now Wendy and actually a few of you asked about the patch that I put in of
new canvas if I paid attention to the weave of the canvas. Yes so the canvas has something called a
warp and a weft and that's how the canvas is put together you know warp goes this way weft goes
that way or vice versa and I align that with the canvas on the painting so I want to make sure that
not only is the weight of the canvas patch the same or as close as possible the thickness is
the same the weave is as tight as the original but also that it is aligned accordingly. I want to get
as close as possible as I can. Now Grace noticed that when I was removing the rabbit skin glue
some pieces of canvas came up as well and those were pieces of old lining canvas that I just
wasn't able to scrape off sometimes around the edges of the painting where the stretcher or
strainer support is the rabbit skin glue doesn't deteriorate as much and so the bond is really
really hard so sometimes I leave that and just take it off when I'm using the gel the laponite
to remove the rabbit skin glue. Kimberly Crunch asked do I have the means to do x-rays?
Yes I don't do them myself I work with a x-ray technician to come and do them on site because
the equipment is extremely expensive and I would have very little use for it other than x-raying
myself all the time and they are experts so they know exactly how to shoot all sorts of objects
including paintings. So Yuan asked McGregor keeps using we when mentioning the painting
once it was decided to be restored in video one does that imply partial ownership between
McGregor and the heir or the collector? No I think McGregor is just talking about the royal we you
know me and him making decisions about how this painting is going to be cared for. I often use
the royal we the Lebowski we to talk about the decisions that I make when really I'm making most
of them but I like to include the client as part of that process. So Christy asked when it comes to
the cleaning of the old thick layer of varnish is it faux pas to glean over the entire painting with
the solvent so that when you go over it section by section it doesn't take as much effort? Yeah
that's something we wouldn't want to do because the whole idea is that the solvent that is breaking
down the varnish layer could potentially damage the paint layer and that's why we go with little
swabs and in little areas and in controlled sections so that we limit or mitigate the
exposure that the solvent has to the painting. So simply going across the whole painting and then
going section by section number one the solvent would evaporate and the varnish would harden back
up but also it just isn't as controlled and control is really the name of the game. So Linnae
asked I'm curious when in dealing with a project like this you decide to involve academics in the
authentication or research part of it? Well it's a really good question because many people want to
embark upon authentication or research of their pieces and sometimes it's just not possible there's
no information and we would be barking up a tree that would yield no fruit to mix metaphors.
In this case and in other cases where it is potentially possible I operate like the detective
I gather the dots or the facts I put together a dossier and then I will give it to a researcher
an appraiser and historian and then I will let them connect those dots or figure out what they
mean. It is not my job to make any definitive statements about whether a piece is authentic
or not I can certainly provide information that helps things like saying the canvas is
significantly deteriorated and is in accord with a painting being very old or something like
the adhesive used could not have been from such and such date because it wasn't invented
so on and so forth. My observations can be very valuable to a researcher appraiser or historian
but ultimately they're the experts and they're the ones who are going to have to make that final call.
Oftentimes they won't they will put together what is called maybe a probability report where
they outline the pros and cons or the yeses and nos and then say based on that evidence
we believe there to be a strong possibility that the painting is by so-and-so or is from such and
such era. But authentication is a really tricky game because nobody wants to put their name on
something and then have it come back to bite them or be incorrect or risk their reputation or end up
the middle of some sort of legal battle because their statements were used the wrong way. So
authentication is really really tricky and I generally tell my clients to avoid it unless
they really absolutely need to know or there is really compelling evidence that will make an iron
clad case. So wy1 said I noticed that when you were cleaning the coat of arms you used a much
smaller swab than when cleaning the rest of the painting. Well the reason for that was that that's
where I was starting and I wanted to make sure that a the solvent that I was using even though
I had tested it at various locations on the painting before was still safe and using a small
swab was a great way to do that. It's really controlled. Also the coat of arms had just about
all of the colors in it had black white red some sort of green I think there was some yellow the
you know so it was kind of a little sampling of the entire painting and so starting there and
using a small swab allowed me to really control not only my solvent exposure but control which
color I was working on and just to kind of make sure that everything was safe. It's always better
to go slow always better to be safe than sorry. Now this last comment really wasn't a question
but it was really insightful and so I thought I would share it with you as it was posted by Needle
Inn. Now I get to offer up a bit of information that might maybe shed some light on that last
weird part of the inscription assuming the painting is genuine. Under this lady's dress
would have been an undergarment called a pair of stays although at this early juncture it would
have been actually called a pair of bodies from which the modern bodice derives. Stays created
a different shape than a corset but their function was the same to support the bust and create a
rigid supportive infrastructure onto which the many many pieces of the lady's ensemble could sit
without impeding her ability to you know move. During this time period dress wastes tended to be
raised not quite an empire waist but pretty close. The pair of bodies would still have extended down
to the waist however because part of their function was to support the spine. So take a
look at that portrait drop the waistline in your mind's eye about eight inches and then look at
what you see below it. This lady was pregnant. Her baby bump appears where the pair of bodies ends.
If McGregor is correct in interpreting the Maximilian to refer to the concept of
greatness or maximizing it may be referencing the idea that the family will be great or increasing
via a baby. Depending on the length of the engagement between these two people or the
delay between the marriage and the portrait it's totally possible that was okay. Now that's really
interesting. Unfortunately Margarita died just two years after the date of this portrait so it's
certainly possible and we know that she had a couple of children. Unfortunately we don't know
when exactly they were born but based on Nina Lynn's expertise on the clothing and the costuming
I think that maybe she's on to something. Maybe this painting reveals the future children and if
that's the case man that is just so cool. Okay now I've done enough talking. I've answered a
whole bunch of questions. I know you want to see me talk to McGregor so let's get to it.
Well hello once again McGregor. Thank you for joining me for the third time. I know I've eaten
up tons of your time but this is really exciting and this is going to be really fun because we're
going to be talking about the test results that we did on the painting and so I want to jump right
into it. We did two different types of tests. We did paint sample analysis and radiocarbon dating
and we took five samples of paint and two material samples for the radiocarbon dating.
Now we'll start off with the paint sample analysis. Paint sample analysis is a process whereby the
chemists using various types of spectrometry, gas spectrometry, Raman spectrometry, high resolution
mass spectrometry and of course X-ray fluorescence and a bunch of other cool scientific processes
break down the individual elements in any pigment. So they will take black and they will break down
all of the basic elements and then they will give us a report as to what they find.
Paint sample analysis is interesting because it is not only about what we find but what we don't
find. That is, if we found lead white in a painting we may expect that to be there but if
we found titanium white and we didn't expect that to be there well that would be an outlier or a
flag and that would cause us to have to reinterpret the results. In addition, paint sample analysis
is just one point of gathering data and unless you have something to compare it against
it's hard to make a definitive quantification. So we don't have another painting by this artist
so we can't take samples of both paintings and compare them. So what the lab does is they break
the paint sample apart and then they figure out what's in it and then based on their database and
their tens of thousands of archived samples they will match them to samples that they have and
they'll give me a report and a breakdown of what each paint sample is made of. So if you remember
we took five samples. We took a sample of the red, the greenish-bluish, the black, yellow,
and the white and so the lab came back and this is what we found. The red was composed of pigment
red 106 which is vermilion. There was white in it which is white lead and then some other
components dolomite and quartz which are what would be found in white. The white area was
white lead, simply enough. The yellow area was pigment yellow 43 which is girtite and
lead stannate which is lead tin yellow and then some other elements that are not that important.
The black was composed of carbon black, pigment red 101, hematitite, and then a little bit of white
lead. Again, all things that we expected and were in accord with this painting. Now the green area
actually wasn't green. It was blue. It was composed of azurite, carbon black, white lead,
dolomite, and then some iron oxide and quartz which are minor trace elements. Now what is
interesting about that is azurite is a copper base and over time it can change as it oxidizes
and it changes into malachite which turns green. So initially the crest had blue in it, not green,
but over you know several hundred years it oxidized and it changed. Now what's even more
interesting about azurite is that we know the dates that it was used. The first in art, at least
in the Schacht Gallery in Munich where they did extensive testing of all of their paintings,
the first appearance was in the 1300s. Now it actually goes back to the Egyptian times and even
a little bit before that in Asia but in painting 1300 is about when we first see it and you can
see that it really falls off in the mid 1600s and that's because azurite was replaced with
ultramarine which was much more available. It was much cheaper and also not toxic because azurite
when it's ground up in a powder form can kill you. It is even low level toxic in its paint form so
newsflash to all of us we were handling some pretty toxic stuff. Anyhow you can see that the
use of azurite really trails off in the mid 1600s. Now looking at the entirety of the samples that we
found it's interesting to compare them to other known paintings where extensive testing has been
done and so one was Hieronymus Bosch 1450 to 1516 and you can see just about every color that is in
your painting is also in Bosch's painting. We have lead teen yellow, we have azurite, we have vermilion,
we have lead white, and we have ivory black instead of carbon black so that gives us one
clue that the palette isn't so dissimilar from Hieronymus Bosch's and that time period but of
course it's also very similar to Rembrandt's palette from you know nearly 50-60 years later.
We see the same lead tin yellow, the same azurite, we see a different black but we see the same
lead white and the same vermilion and that is also similar to Caravaggio. So we have these three
different artists painting in three roughly different time periods all having similar
palettes to yours so nothing terribly conclusive but what we didn't find were any outliers. We
didn't find any synthetic paints, we didn't find any paints that would have been not in existence
during the purported time period of your painting. So these samples were largely about what we didn't
find and yes they are only samples and they are only representative of five areas of the painting
but within those five areas we didn't find any red flags so we can call those test results
successful. They may not have given us any firm answers as to what it is but they have kind of
framed what it isn't and it isn't a modern painting. So on to the radiocarbon dating which is of course
a whole nother crazy process. So everything on earth exchange every living thing on earth
exchanges carbon and there are several different carbon molecules there's carbon 12, 13, and 14.
12 and 13 are incredibly stable they don't decay but carbon 14 does and thanks to some Nobel
prize-winning scientists we know the precise rate that it deteriorates at. Now things get
complicated in 1950 because of course humans started messing around with atomic structures
and we added a lot more carbon into the air with industrialization and also radio radiation with
the atomic bombs and nuclear testing so anything post 1950 is really difficult to date but of course
we're not dealing with something post 1950. So as things are alive they exchange carbon with
the air through the carbon dioxide exchange. Now when they die they stop exchanging carbon
and that's when the carbon 14 starts to decay. So this cotton canvas at one point was a plant
cotton and at one point it died when it was harvested and that's the point at which it starts
decaying and that's how we can tell approximately how old it is. Now the same thing with wood. Wood
is a tree and it exchanges carbon dioxide with the atmosphere and when it's cut down
it stops exchanging carbon dioxide. So I want to start with the wood and I want to show you the
chart the graph that the lab sent to us. All right sounds good. And so you can see that
it's kind of a mess. On the bottom axis we have the AD date and on the left axis we have the
radiocarbon age. So what we have is a concentration of the radiocarbon age at around 140 150 and then
we have on the AD date we have peaks all over the place. So this needs a little bit of
interpretation. Luckily the lab does that and this is the interpretation of the lab results of
the wood. And so right at the bottom they say the median probability is 1809. Now we knew that this
wood wasn't original to the painting. We kind of fully expected that. We knew the painting had
been conserved at least once probably multiple times in the past and so seeing a date of 1809
on the wood is kind of completely what we expected. Now on to the canvas. So the same test for the
canvas reveals a much simpler chart something that is a little bit easier to understand. In the bottom
we have Cal AD and then on the left we have radiocarbon age. And radiocarbon age is the date
from 1950 prior. So 1950 is when they that's the baseline from which radiocarbon testing is set and
whatever date they determine whatever radiocarbon age it is that many years prior to 1950. So we
have something like 260 270. We have a cluster range in that area. Now we have two peaks in the
which is the human layperson's interpretation of when the testing falls onto a regular calendar.
We have one at around 16 maybe this is 40 right and then we have another in between 15 maybe 20
and 15 50. So if we look at their analysis we can see that they determine the median probability
as 1636 which is not what we were expecting. It is the decay of carbon is non-linear in cases like
this and of course though the lab does extensive cleaning of the product to remove any contamination
such as the old rabbit skin glue or any other materials there is always the possibility that
there is contamination. Now I don't know if this date is 1636. I would say that the earliest we
could possibly expect this painting to have been painted based on the radiocarbon dating
would be 1529 which is really really old but it is not 1450. I guess it changes everything
or maybe nothing and I'd love to hear what you have to say about that. Thank you so much for
explaining that information Julian. I think that's a really interesting outcome and maybe not one
that we necessarily expected. I was kind of expecting it either to be much later or exactly
on the point you know. I didn't want to get my hopes up one way or the other and I think that's
a really interesting outcome and one that I would love to investigate further. Yeah I mean these
dealing with artwork and science is an interesting marriage because
as you see in this case we can get really conflicting pieces of information and ultimately
who's to say which is correct? Is the date correct? Is the radiocarbon dating correct?
There have been many cases where the radiocarbon dating has been found to be incorrect.
There's also plenty of cases where it's spot on and the painting is incorrect. Ultimately this
is one where we now have several pieces of information. We have lots of dots and now we
have to figure out how to connect them. Absolutely you know I just enjoy researching these things so
much that I have no doubt that I'll investigate it further and see what art historians have to say.
Well yeah I mean to some degree it isn't what we expected or perhaps even maybe what we had hoped
for but if I'm being philosophical here and in the face of adversity sometimes that's the
the best approach. Had we gotten conclusive results well that would be the end of the story.
We would know precisely when the painting was painted. We would know who painted it and who it
was of and that would be it. So maybe the conflicting results leave it open-ended and leave room for
more investigation, more interpretation, and leave the mystery still evolving. The story isn't over
it's in a way just beginning. Yeah absolutely I think that it very well could just be beginning.
There's so much more history that we need to uncover and figure out and I'd be happy to keep
you updated with what I find. Well I would expect nothing less McGregor. This has been a truly
interesting and exciting, challenging, frustrating, but really rewarding project and even though this
final chapter is a little bit ambiguous I think that makes it well at least from my perspective
exciting and I fully expect you to keep me updated with emails, photos, and whenever you do
write the end chapter I want to know exactly what you find out. Absolutely I'll keep you updated.
Well McGregor it's been an absolute pleasure to work with you, to Zoom with you, to get to know
you a little bit, and I expect to hear more from you in the future and to follow along with
everything you do and wherever your journey takes you in the world of art. Yeah thank you so much
it's been so much fun talking to you on Zoom. I really appreciate your time. Thank you. Well with
that I will let you on your way and let you start the next chapter in your art sleuthing.
So take care McGregor.
