A Gentleman Revealed

Classical Artwork Conservation
262 followers
5 Video Views·Aug 29, 2025
Jan 10, 2022
The first 1,000 people to use this link will get a 1 month free trial of Skillshare: https://skl.sh/baumgartnerrestoration...
--
Sometimes it's nice to have a project that won't brawl, wont stretch belief and won't result into a slow descent into madness. Yet even the simplest seeming projects can sometimes be surprisingly rewarding.
Support me on Patreon
/ baumgartnerrestoration
Official Baumgartner Merchandise
https://teespring.com/stores/bfars-store
Follow me on
Instagram - / baumgartnerrestoration
Facebook - / baumgartnerfineartrestoration
Support for this video comes from Skillshare, which offers thousands of inspiring classes
for creative and curious people on topics including illustration, design, photography,
video, freelancing, and more. Every now and again, it's nice to take on a project
who won't brawl with you, whose work will not be of titanic proportions,
and does not need to be salvaged. A painting that's beautifully executed,
but in need of attention. This copy of a Gilbert Stewart painting definitely fits that bill.
It's incredibly dark. Lots of discolored varnish and grime rest atop an otherwise
gorgeously painted picture. Now it's been lined, and we'll have to see what lies beneath.
But hopefully, with a little bit of care and attention, we'll find a gentleman revealed.
Now I mentioned this painting was a copy of a Gilbert Stewart portrait, and that's how
artists often learn. By going to museums and copying other works. And that's how we used to
do it. But lately, doesn't seem possible. Luckily, Skillshare has you covered.
With thousands of classes online, there's surely something to spark your creativity.
Like Drawing and Painting Portraits, a guide for artists by Gabrielle Brickey,
where she'll walk you through her techniques for creating beautiful digital portraits.
From start to finish, understanding how faces are organized, using techniques to guide the
viewer's eyes through the painting, and giving you a better understanding of the human anatomy,
so that your portraits will look as good as possible. But maybe you've already mastered
the basics. In which case, level up your portrait drawings. Practical approaches
to advanced concepts with Chris Hong might be for you. You'll follow along the process
of creating emotionally-laden, dramatic portraits with analog materials. You remember pencil,
paint, and all of those wonderful things that we used to use. And the great thing about Skillshare
is you can follow along at your own pace, and join in with others just like you to develop a
community of like-minded, creative people. The first 1000 people to use the link in the
description will get a free one-month trial of Skillshare, so you can find what fascinates you.
Now the first step in most projects is removing the painting from the support,
be it a strainer or a stretcher. And generally I start by removing all of those tacks, but I'm
noticing here that the lining is really not very well bonded to the painting, and many of these
tacks are rusted. Now I'm not going to save the lining, so there's an easier and faster way to
remove the painting from the support. I can simply cut it off. Now this doesn't seem...
Now this may seem pretty radical, but in fact it's not. None of the old lining canvas is going
to be saved, none of the old tacks are going to be saved, and the time it takes to remove all of
them... well, I can do that while the painting is under treatment somewhere else. During downtime,
let's say. Now when the canvas has been completely cut, I can just lift off the
painting from the support and deal with the support another day. Now I can start focusing
on this lining, which as we saw was really just tenuously placed on the canvas. I suspect there
was an old rabbit skin glue lining, but it has failed, probably because of age, and it probably
wasn't that good to begin with. As you can see, I can just peel it off. There's almost no
resistance. This is one of those cases where lousy or mediocre work is of great benefit to the
conservator. This is not going to take me much time to remove, there's not much scraping that
needs to be done, and so because somebody just didn't do a great job, well it makes mine that
much easier. So I suppose I should tip my hat to the previous conservator for phoning it in.
And wouldn't you know it, there's something written on the back of the canvas.
An inscription. A name. Could it be the artist's signature? Well, we know it's a copy of a famous
Gilbert Stewart painting, so it looks like this is the artist. It's always a wonderful
surprise to find a signature. Now this old lining canvas is still pretty good. I'm not going to use
it for lining, but I will save it and use it for inlays on old canvas when I have to repair them.
Now among the other things that need to be removed is this paper tape that was wrapped
around the tacking edges and onto the face of the painting. This is something that framers often do,
and sometimes conservators of the past, to tidy up the edges. But it's totally useless,
totally pointless, and it just creates a mess. So I don't do it. Luckily here it's very brittle,
and it comes off very easily. Now it's on top of the old varnish, and that's what's kind of
turning to dust as I scrape. And now I'm going to turn my attention to cleaning this painting.
I'll deal with the back later, but I want to see what this painting looks like and get it
cleaned before it goes on the hot table. I'm using a paste that I mix, and this is very mild.
It is non-solvent based, and what it will do is start to break down the surface grime. The dust,
the dirt, the accumulated particulate, the cigarette smoke, all of that stuff. And you
can see it quickly turns from white to brown. Yep, that's nicotine. And it smells, well,
just how you would expect it to smell. Now using a cotton ball, you can see just how much brown is
on the surface. And that's all grime, cigarette smoke, pipe smoke, all stuff that shouldn't be
there. Now this paste will not affect the old varnish, so if I just wanted to remove the surface
grime and leave the old varnish, I could stop now. But I do want to remove the old varnish.
And this is an important step to doing so, because if I were to try to remove the old
varnish with solvents, they wouldn't penetrate through this layer of grime, particularly given
how thick it is. And that might cause me to use more aggressive solvents, and more aggressive
solvents still, to the point where I would be using a solvent so powerful that it would cut
through this surface grime, cut through that old varnish, and probably cut into the paint layer.
So taking a two-step approach, first removing the accumulated surface grime,
and then removing the varnish, ensures that I'm using the most mild of solvents and approaches
possible. You always want to go mild. There's no benefit to getting a heavy hand right from
the start. We can always increase the strength, we can always change techniques, but we can't
go back if we make a mistake. So with the entire painting cleaned, I have left the face for last,
because obviously it's the most important part of the painting. Oftentimes in videos I show the
cleaning of the face early on because it's quite dramatic, but that comes only after extensive
testing and experience working on the rest of the painting. One never starts with the face. Even with
small tests, we leave that to the end. So you can see, even just with removing a little bit of that
surface grime, that face is going to be quite different. I mean, anything is better than what it
looks like now. It's really not all that impressive. Now I'm using a soft bristle brush here to apply
the paste and agitate the accumulated surface grime and the paste as they soften up. I found
that using a bristle brush allows me to get into the nooks and crannies of the painting,
the impasto, the texture of the canvas, without using too much force. If I were to use a cotton
swab or even a cotton bud rolled up onto a little stick, I might have to press too hard,
and that's something I want to avoid. Now once it's all soft, I can come back with a cotton ball
and just lift off all of that grime. I could make multiple passes if I wanted to keep this old
varnish, but I don't, so I don't need to worry about leaving the slightest of residues. Now with
all of that surface grime removed, I can turn my attention to the varnish. And I do want to
remove it, so I'm going to be using a solution that I have mixed based on tests that I've made
in and around this painting. I don't assume anything, and every painting will get tested
for the appropriate solvent mixture. Even two varnishes of the same composition on different
paintings may require different approaches. Some may need more exposure to the solvent, some less.
Some may need a soft rolling technique, and some may need to be scrubbed quite aggressively. Every
painting is different, and so every cleaning must be tailored to that painting. Now as this varnish
comes off, we can see just how yellow it is. There are hints of white, bright white, underneath
all of this old varnish. What I'm also finding is that the painting looks to have been abraded or
skinned during the past cleaning. And that's when an approach is too aggressive. Maybe the solvent
too strong, maybe the swab was rubbed too hard, and the peaks of the paint that are sitting on top
of the canvas are removed. And that's permanent. There's no way to undo that. Unfortunately,
that's the case here, and the only way to correct it is with retouching.
Now using the appropriate solvent, we can see that I'm not removing any paint, just the old
varnish. And that's a critical difference between the way I'm cleaning and the way this was cleaned
before. And as I move throughout the painting, cleaning the varnish off of various colors,
well, it's a treat to see what lies beneath. This part of the coat that looked green is not.
It's blue. And that's because the varnish layer was so thick that over time, as it yellowed,
it changed the color that we were seeing. Effectively, we were looking through a yellowed
film of glass. Not the way the artist wanted this painting to be seen. And this varnish was so thick
that it had started to crack. On top, you can see where the varnish has been removed, and on the
bottom, you can see all of that varnish cracking. And now, of course, with the entirety of the
painting cleaned, we turn our attention to the face. Always the last thing that gets cleaned.
Not only because it's the focus of the painting, but because an artist's technique on the face
may be different than, let's say, the background. There may be more glazing or thin layers of paint.
The artist may have painted wet on wet, and the binders may be thinner. So we always take extra
care when working on the face. And to that end, I've switched from using a pure liquid solvent
to a gelled solvent. And the benefit here is that it slows down the evaporation rate,
and allows me to use a bristle brush to agitate the varnish out of the texture of the canvas.
I don't have to scrub with my swab. In addition, I can have a weaker solution that, because it
doesn't evaporate so quickly, will achieve the same effect as a strong solution, but slower,
and running less risk to the paint layer. Now, once I have broken down and agitated
the varnish enough, I can come back with a dry swab and lift it off. Being dry,
it will absorb all of this solvent and varnish mixture much better than if it was full of
solvent itself. In addition, I don't need to continue to expose this painting to solvents,
because the gelled solvent has done the work for me. So this swab is really just cleaning up,
coming in and lifting off all of the residues. And boy, what a difference. I can just imagine
what his cheeks are going to look like, and what the eyes are going to look like when we get all
of this varnish off. Now, Gilbert Stuart was a painter of portraits primarily, and he painted
high society, he painted aristocrats, he painted people who could afford his paintings. And of
course, Gilbert Stuart is most famous for painting the stunning portrait of George Washington.
He actually painted several portraits of George Washington, but the portrait of George Washington
is a Gilbert Stuart. Now this is a portrait of Joseph Anthony Jr. from around 1795 or so. He was
a silversmith in Philadelphia, and he was quite talented and quite wealthy. And his dress and his
confident pose reflect that. Now, Stuart was a master of capturing the likeness, not only visibly
of his sitters, but who they were, their attitude, their personalities, whether they were kind and
soft, or whether they were abrasive, brash, whether they were timid, or in this case, quite confident.
And so it is a natural choice for a young artist to want to paint a copy. Learning how Stuart
achieved his results by studying the brushwork, the colors, all of the formal elements that go
into creating a painting, the movement of light, the movement of shape, the way that we travel
through the painting with our eyes, is really a masterclass. One can read about this, one can hear
about it from a professor, but trying to do what another master has done, well, you are literally
walking in their footsteps and hoping that some of their technique, some of the way that they did
things, will rub off on you. That your hand will develop a muscle memory for their technique.
And it may seem easy to go and copy another artist's work. It may seem, oh, I don't know,
derivative or something like that. But it's really, really hard. And once you start doing it,
you realize why there are masters. Because what looks so easy, a portrait of a gentleman,
is incredibly difficult to execute well. And now, on to the eyes. Of course, I leave the eyes for
last, for many reasons. Chief among them is the technical. I want to gather as much information
about this painting, about how the paint reacts to the solvent, to my swab as possible,
before I approach the eyes, which are arguably the most important and most delicately painted
part of this painting. No margin for error. But there's also some poetry that gets me through
the drudgery of cleaning the background, or boring paintings. I like to imagine that I'm
the first person who is seeing this painting as the artist imagined it, since it was created.
That my eyes are now taking in the true painting, just as this portrait sitter is peering out
from behind that dirty varnish, for the first time since he was painted, since he was born.
The idea that we're both seeing the world fresh for the first time, well, sure. It's corny.
This is, after all, an inanimate object. A copy of an inanimate object. A painting of a person,
not a real person. But if executed well enough, any painting can capture us, can transport us,
and even if for a brief moment, we can start to see some life in an otherwise still object.
Now, before the cleaning, I mentioned I would have to deal with the adhesive on the back of
this canvas, and that time has come. But instead of using a gel or a solvent to soften the adhesive
and scrape it off with a scalpel, I'm just using a stiff nylon brush. There is so little adhesive
on here, and it is so brittle and deteriorated, that I can simply brush it off. There's no reason
to expose this canvas to extra scraping when a nylon brush will do it. Now, once all of the
adhesive is removed, I'll transfer the painting to the hot table, where I'm going to do a treatment
to flatten and relax the canvas. There are some distortions, not many, and I want to make sure
that they're all removed before I re-stretch the painting. Now, I envelop the painting in a piece
of PET film, which is temperature safe and moisture resistant, and I'll install my through-bag
connectors, which align with the cot webbing that surrounds the painting. I'll turn on my vacuum
pump, extract all of the air, and bring the painting up to temperature. A soft balsa wood
brayer will allow me to go over the painting and make sure that it's completely flat. Now, at one
point, this painting had tacking edges, but they were unceremoniously cut off when the painting was
lined during the last conservation, and this won't suffice because I need those tacking edges in order
to put the painting onto a stretcher. So, I'm going to do what is called a strip or edge lining.
Instead of adding canvas to the entire painting, I'm just going to be adding canvas to the edge
to give me something into which I can drive my tacks and secure this painting onto the
wooden support. So, after ironing on the film and cutting and preparing my canvas, I will peel off
the release layer that is on top of that film, and I will align my strip of canvas onto the edge of
the painting, going in very minimally, and then I will secure it with my iron. A simple pass over
the canvas with a weight, and it's secure. Now, the canvas is frayed for two reasons. One, it gives
more surface area for the adhesive to contact, ensuring a better bond, and two, it makes sure
that that edge is a little bit softer and not as crisp so it doesn't transfer to the front of the
painting. I'll work my way around the canvas, ensuring that all four sides receive the same
treatment, all at the same distance from the edge, and then once I'm done, I'll be ready to move on
to the stretching. Now, if you remember back to the beginning when I cut the painting off of the
support, I mentioned that I would clean it up during downtime, and that's precisely what I did
when the painting was on the hot table. I removed the glue, the paper tape, and the old nails and
generally cleaned it up, and now I'm squaring it up. Once I have it squared, I'll use some nails
and drive them through the joint to hold it secure. I want to make sure that as I handle
the painting and the stretcher during the stretching process, this support doesn't distort
and become a parallelogram. So once I have it all secured, I'll place the canvas onto the support,
and then using some three ounce blued steel tacks, I'll begin stretching. And I start in the middle
of the canvas and work my way to the corners. There is some debate among artists about what way
is best to stretch a canvas, and for a raw canvas, this approach may not be best. It might
cause overstretching in the center and then distortion in the canvas, but for a conservator,
this is a fairly common approach. Starting in the middle and working out makes sure that the
center of the painting has tension equal to the outer corners, and if there is some distortion,
we can move it to the corners, which we can remedy with keying. It's much easier to key
out a painting and remove distortion from a corner than it is from the center of the painting.
Once the painting is all stretched, I'll flip it over and using some one and a half ounce steel
tacks, I'll fold over the excess canvas from the strip lining, and then I'll simply tack it in
place. I'll fold the corners in, which not only makes it look tidy, but also is important because
as the painting is keyed, this makes sure that the corners don't come undone. Sometimes I'll use
new keys when necessary, and other times I will turn to my bin of old salvaged keys and choose a
couple that fit and look the part. Once I've gotten them selected, I can simply hammer them
into place and, like I mentioned, remove any slack from those corners where I've stretched it
out to when I did the stretching. I'll secure these keys into place with some fishing line and
a small tack. I'll trim off the excess, and then the stretching process is all complete,
and I'm ready to take the painting over to my easel and begin the retouching process.
This painting did not have any catastrophic damage to it. There was no major tear,
no flaking, no major paint loss, but that doesn't mean that it doesn't need retouching.
There are some areas that, well, if you remember, were skinned during the last cleaning,
and those little areas of skinning, those little white spots, are incredibly distracting,
particularly in the face. I mean, this is the thing that we are looking at.
So making sure that they go away is imperative to enjoying the forest, not the trees. Now,
these are very small areas of damage, but when present, they're distracting. We focus on them
as opposed to the overall painting. So simply touching them up with little dots of color,
making them disappear or go away, makes a huge difference. We can now see the smooth transition
from the bridge of the nose to the cheekbones, as opposed to seeing the canvas texture.
And this really is what retouching is about. Making the damage go away, or making it go
away enough that our eyes and our brains no longer process it as damage or distraction.
There are many different approaches to doing this, and every conservator has their own.
What works for them, what works for the painting, and most importantly, what works for the client.
And in a case like this, where the entirety of the area has been skinned, well, I'm going to
try to hit as many of these little high spots as I can to get rid of this flattening effect.
You see, when we see the surface of a painting, and we don't see the content of the painting,
well, the depth is ruined. It becomes about surface. And while that may be what the artist
wants with an abstract painting, on a painting like this, a portrait, the artist is not looking
to make it about the surface. This is about the image. And so touching up each and every one of
these little areas of damage lets our eye pass over this area of the painting and view it as
whole. And now onto the eye. Clearly, all of this damage needs to be retouched. And as I looked at
this painting, I wondered if any of these little white spots were the glint in the eye, that
reflection that gives the eye so much life. And they aren't. I took a long, close look at them.
Every one of these little spots that I'm retouching, well, that's raw canvas, where
the paint has been removed. This sitter's eyes are dark, inky, almost black. Mysterious, in fact.
With the retouching all complete, the last thing to do is varnish the painting.
And the varnish is important because not only does it literally protect the paint layer, it's a
physical application of synthetic resin that sits atop the painting, from fingerprints, dust,
dirt, ultraviolet light, because this varnish has a UV stabilizer. It prevents the UV light
from getting through the varnish, corrupting it, turning it yellow, and also to the paint
and damaging it. But varnish also makes paintings come alive. You can see, beforehand, the painting
was a little washed out. Beautiful, but flat. But with the application of the varnish, everything
gets richer. Everything turns to 11. Now, as the varnish starts to dry, the solvent evaporating
from the resin, I will continue to brush out the surface. This is a gloss varnish, and I want to
mute that sheen. And instead of adding things to the varnish to create a more matte appearance,
I'm using my brush to create a microtexture on the surface, and that's going to scatter
the reflection of light and give an absolutely gorgeous, velvety appearance. A simple,
cooperative copy of a masterpiece that did not require much, but with a little bit of attention,
has given back so much. Whomever the artist is, they should be proud of this work and consider it
a masterpiece of their own. Thanks for watching, and if you had any questions about this or any of
my other projects, join me over on Patreon, where in addition to ad and sponsor-free videos,
I take questions and answer them in a follow-up epilogue video, exclusive only to Patreon.
