Archaeology vids Petrie, Part B 626p30

Ancient Artifacts Channel
16 followers
Something that distinguished Petrie's work in contrast to earlier
archaeologists and collectors was the extent to which he kept detailed records.
The trend had been for people to simply explore looking for complete museum quality artifacts
and then to discard anything else that was found, broken pot sherds or disfigured pieces.
Instead, Petrie insisted on logging everything that was found. In addition, he took care to
engage in photography. He had a particular camera that he used. It was simple in style and even as
years progressed he kept using his simple camera and developed some very excellent plates as a
In the top figure you can see his use of a mirror. This is one of his own photos,
as is the one below. The use of a mirror to portray both the back and the front of this
figurine. Notice the careful use of a bright background in the lower collection in order to
show in clear relief the shape of each particular artifact. It's worth being aware that at this time
Flinders is working without remuneration from any foundation. He's connected with what's known as the
Egyptian Exploration Fund, which was a group of people back in Britain who were interested
in antiquities from Egypt and for some projects they had funds but not for him.
He was perhaps at that time an untested commodity. So he's working off his own dime
or funds that his family can give him. He's not being supported by a foundation. While he is
based at Giza, and it's in this time frame that you see in the upper left 1881 to 83,
he takes a trip upstream along the Nile to the region that you see in the red circle. This is
Thebes, and two primary temples that you find located here are Karnak and Luxor. Then on the
west side, the sunset side, which then is the death side, that's associated with all that
symbolism is at work within the Egyptian mythology. On the sunset side, the west side of the Nile,
is a necropolis, that is a city of the dead, city in a loose sense of the word, a collection
of mortuary temples. Here's a Google Earth representation. Easy way to think of Karnak
or to recognize Karnak, Luxor, Thebes, those are all overlaying each other, is to look for this
bend in the Nile and then just look to the lower edge of that bend. Again, keep in mind
the Nile is flowing from south to north. Closing in on that region then, you can see
the Nile River, and to the right, the bottom portion is Luxor, that's the upstream temple,
and then Karnak is another temple complex that's relatively close to it, downstream.
Across to the left, to the west then, you see several sites that we've identified
as mortuary temples. Going from the bottom left, the lowest one that's identified in this
collection is Medinet Habu, that's the mortuary temple of Ramses III. Just above that, a rather
lateral, long, tan section is the mortuary temple of Amenhotep, including the Colossae of Memnon,
the very large, large statues. And then above or north of that, mortuary temple of Merneptah,
and above that, the Ramessium of Ramses II. Above that, in a tan field, you find the mortuary
temple of Hatshepsut, the last two of which, then the Ramessium, and the mortuary temple of Hatshepsut.
This is where we located the disfigured artifacts that were seen earlier. Mortuary temple of
Hatshepsut also goes by the name Deir el-Bahri. Here's a close-up then on Karnak. That would be
the northern, the downstream temple. It's just an awe-inspiring sight if you ever have the chance.
I encourage a visit. These columns incised with their hieroglyphs are really stunning.
Upstream then is Luxor, another very extensive and ancient temple site. These complexes,
incidentally, Karnak and Luxor, we look at them now and we imagine all facets of them were built
at once. That's not the case. One ruler would add one temple portion. Someone else, another ruler,
would come along later and add another portion. It reminds me of what we learn of the Louvre,
the museum in Paris. Ruler after ruler has added to various facets of the museum. Well,
they were doing that in temple fashion centuries earlier in Egypt. Here's a photo from one of the
resources dealing with Flinders Petrie presenting Karnak. The purpose for showing this is to
appreciate conditions when he arrived over against conditions today. So we'll show you a before and
after picture. For orientation, notice this beautiful column that will show up in the
modern picture as well. In addition, notice this statue and flanking it is another identical
statue. So these border and entryway. Now the green box with the X in it is where the next
photo will be taken from. So it's on the far side. It looks like it's on the lap of the statue. It's
actually on the far side of the right hand statue looking in the opposite direction.
So here you see that left hand statue. That was the right hand statue earlier and the column.
Notice how tidy and welcoming and very attractive are the ruins of Luxor.
Going deeper into the Luxor temple, here is what we have. Again, this is what it looked like
much earlier on. Back to Petrie and his initial exploration in the Necropolis. This is the area
then on the west bank. So imagine, if you will, Flinders Petrie is down on the lower left corner
in the Medinet Habu Ramesses, the third mortuary temple region. And he relates that he walked up
approaching the hill. So moving off to the right and upward up into the hills behind the Necropolis,
the mortuary temple complex. And he writes, I had a splendid climb to the top of a peak of the Theban
Range, about a thousand feet. And from there I saw all over the Theban Range. On the one hand,
with the Blue Nile winding and doubling in the Green Valley. So that's looking off to the east,
to the right. And on the other hand, the wild and parched rocks of the Valley of the Tombs
of the Kings. You can locate the Valley of the Kings at the very top left portion of the screen.
This shot is taken right within the Valley of the Kings, so you can see how desolate
it is. Petrie writes, the path goes down a cleft in the rock with merely footholds and many places
to step on. And I found it rather awkward with a camera and measuring rods. The sense of barrenness
is evident from this shot as well. What you're looking at here is Deir el-Medina, which is the
village occupied by the experts, both in hieroglyphics, in excavation and architecture,
who were responsible for actually manufacturing the tombs that were tunneled into the Valley of
the Kings. So the craftsmen lived here, and just over the hill from them was then the Valley of
the Kings, to which they would trek on a daily basis for their craftsmen work. But notice how
barren it is. Here we're back in the Valley of the Kings. This is actually the entryway to one
of the tombs. Behind us is the tomb, if I recall correctly, this would be the tomb of Merneptah,
when we had the opportunity to visit. When you walk down the tunnel into one of the tombs today,
not surprisingly, there are electric lamps that make it possible for you to proceed without
stumbling. But imagine doing it with a candle. Petrie writes, it is more like a realized nightmare
than anything you ever saw, to go alone without anything to distract you, and only one candle
just showing group by group. And there I'm sure he's referring to the paintings on the walls.
He describes those as awe-inspiring, as paintings of vast serpents folding their green bodies along
the walls, the interior of the channels of the tombs. As that period of work in Egypt came to a
close, Petrie discovered that he was smitten by this place. He was addicted. He had to come back.
He went back to England in 1882 and then returned back to Egypt subsequently. One of the features
that I found interesting about his relationship with the work in Egypt was how he enjoyed
the nationals that were there. Petrie writes, I never spent two months more smoothly than while
heading our desert camp. Yet the people had not much to content them. They came, and here he's
referring to the workers that he hired, they came without any shelter and nothing but what they wore.
They had dry bread to eat and brackish water to drink, and they worked for six pence a day, most
of them but five days in the week, as they had to walk 25 to 40 miles to fetch their food.
Their shelter they made up partly by digging a hole in sand mounds, partly by booths of thin
tamarisk bushes. A merry party they were. Excepting one or two older men, there was hardly a lad over
20 or a girl over 15 in the whole lot. Each night a blazing row of campfires flickered,
their yellow flames up into the starlight. All along the line of booths which skirted the canal
banks, mounds of sand tufted over with tamarisk bushes back to the line, while the distant ruins
of the qasr showed dimly on one side and the gleam of sluggish canal on the other. But, he writes,
I like it better than most civilized places. One lives with the people more,
and the ever-fresh desert air and living in a tent doubles one's contentment and peace of mind.
Neither Gardner nor Griffith would appreciate it, I fear. They neither of them like having to do
with the people, and would prefer an immense excavating machine to do their work. And now
reflecting on the nationals, to me all their by-play and jokes and songs and wills and ways
give a color and an interest to life here, which no one will ever reach in staid, school-boarded
England. Admittedly, at times he had to make accommodations for the heat. One day, a colleague
of his, Rev. Archibald Sayess, who was a specialist in Hebraic studies and seriology, came looking for
him. It was noon. The thermometer stood at 120 degrees, Drower writes, and Petrie was nowhere
to be seen. When Sayess inquired, someone pointed out, he's over there, standing in the water. And
sure enough, there he was, in the canal, standing like a buffalo, with water up to his neck and an
umbrella over his head. Although he was content with the crowded conditions, they were confining.
He writes, I dare say many folks think it's a very pleasant and easy sort of life in a tent,
and so it would be if room was unlimited. Imagine an ordinary bedstead six and a half foot long,
and a space for, say, one's bed and nothing else. But besides bed, I have nine boxes in it,
stores of all kinds, basin, cooking stove and crockery, tripod stand serving as clothes stand,
bag and portmanteau, and some antiquities. And in this I have to live, to sleep, to wash,
and to receive visitors. The consequence is that if by any chance merely a few things get out of
place, the whole affair seems choked, and it is only by rigorously shoving everything out of the
way, the moment it is done with, that I can get on at all. As time progressed, Petrie's relationship
with the Egypt Exploration Fund deteriorated to the extent that when in 1890 he received an
invitation to come to Palestine, to him that seemed a good idea. In addition to transitioning
from the Egypt Exploration Fund to the Palestine Exploration Fund, PEF, he was intrigued by the
opportunity this would give him to search for links, connections, between objects that he had
found in Egypt that had a foreign look to them. And now he could be in Palestine, testing some
of his theories whether or not they came from that direction. After a brief visit or survey to
Umm Lakis and Ajlan, he determined that Tal al-Hassi would be a more promising site to explore.
He records his experience of paying a visit first to the primary sheikh of the area. Petrie writes,
I found him a pleasant fellow, sitting under an enormous flat tent, with a number of his following.
I did a deal of silence, for that is orthodox, and in the interval stated my business. Soon after I
arrived there was a chorus of dogs, and a man came up bearing a wide wooden bowl on his head
with the midday meal. It was set before us, and we gathered around, about half a dozen at once.
The mixture was bread in sour curds, think yogurt, and plenty of butter melted amongst it,
with a layer of pieces of fat mutton on the top. I smelt the sourness, and judiciously grabbed a
good bit of plain meat, which kept me in play as long as the others. It was amusing to see
them grasping handfuls of the fearful mixture and stuffing it in their mouths. After coffee,
I bid goodbye, slipping a Napoleon into the sheikh's hand, as a smoother for future business.
Here's a more current aerial view of Tell al-Khesi, north at the top. The following account from
Drower helps us appreciate that this was not just a simple walk in the park,
forging into these areas for archaeological exploration.
She writes, On the second day, they took a rough path over the hills toward Dahriyeh. When they
had gone some way, Petri, striding ahead with a camel, was ambushed by four men armed with swords
and a pistol, handkerchiefs tied over their faces below the eyes. With presence of mind,
he backed up the slope, leaving them to plunder the baggage, and was able to drop his purse and
bag of coins into some bushes, leaving only small change in his pocket. Petri writes the following,
So when all four armed men closed in on me and grabbed my windpipe, breaking its top ring,
I went limp and let them rummage. End of quote. Having turned out his pockets and taken his
revolver, they took a suit and a couple of shirts from his suitcase, then let him go,
returning to give him his watch, which had an identification number, his measure, and his
handkerchief, as well as his precious notebook. Petri resumes, Altogether, I think the business
was conducted as pleasantly as such affairs ever are. End quote. When they had gone, he writes,
I dropped in the grass and bewailed my losses, while I grubbed about for my purse and gold,
put them in my pocket, and we went on. Trauer notes that his throat never quite recovered from
the injury, to which he subsequently attributed a slight hoarseness of voice. In 1891, he returns
to Egypt, again takes up residence in a cave, and then in 1892 makes his way back to England.
An encouraging development takes place at this point. Amelia Edwards, a long-time friend of
Petri, arranged that at her death, a particular position should be funded at the University of
London, a chair in Egyptology. And she arranged the particulars for hiring someone to that
position in such a way that, basically, only Petri would qualify. So, he now has an academic
position, chair of Egyptology at the University of London, 1892. Subsequently, Petri returns to
Egypt and resumes excavation at various sites. When we come to 1896, we want to focus on his work
in the necropolis across from the Karnak-Luxor complex. At this point, a colleague named Quibel
is working in the Ramesseum. It's a very impressive complex. Looks a lot like Karnak
and Luxor, doesn't it? But now we are across the valley, across the Nile, on the west side. This
is one of the mortuary temples, this one established for Ramses II. Here you see a
cartouche with the name Ramses. Our guide is pointing to that. A little further in,
it's intriguing to see some of the original paint still visible. Now, draw your attention
to the brick caverns that are in the distance between these two beautiful columns.
And now a photo of those same vaulted magazines from the era of Petri. And notice the caption
to this photo from Drower's book. Here we are at the western end of the Ramesseum,
and in those magazines, Petri and his team lived during these excavations. So, imagine just setting
up camp in these ancient vaulted storage chambers. Here's a closer look. I wonder if a modern
archaeologist could find debris left not by the pharaohs, but by Petri and his team.
As indicated earlier, that territory, the Ramesseum, was under the excavation
directorship of Quibel, so that's not a place for Petri to work. Instead, he worked a little
further south. In particular, he concentrated on the mortuary temple of Amenhotep III that you see
in the red oval. One of the commanding features of that is the enormous, enormous statues.
This again from the time frame of Petri. Do you notice the reflection of water?
That is fitting for this place. Let's just back up a bit. Petri observes that the Amenhotep
mortuary temple is, as he calls it, out of alignment. If you draw a line from the Ramesseum,
top center, straight down to Medinet Habu, Ramesses III, on the lower left, you'll see that, for
example, the mortuary temple of Manepta is along that line, but the temple of Amenhotep sticks out.
Notice also the color of the territory around it. It's green. This is modern. These are fields
because this is a fertile territory, and back then,
before there had been more control of the flooding by the Nile, this would routinely flood,
and that accounted for deterioration of the Amenhotep site. It was built too much into the
floodplain, and other mortuary temples were further up the slopes beyond the reach of the Nile's flood
waters. Now focus your attention just on the upper left of the red oval where it says Mortuary
Temple of Manepta. If you study closely, you can see that there is a rectangle and some remnants
of foundations there. When archaeologists first noticed it, they saw it in connection with the
mortuary temple of Amenhotep and thought it was just part of a large Amenhotep complex.
Subsequently, however, they found out that was not the case. This was an independent temple,
one to a descendant, not a direct, but a several generations removed descendant of Amenhotep,
another pharaoh by the name of Manepta. This statue of Manepta is located in the Louvre in Paris.
Among the various artifacts that Petrie retrieved during that excavation in 1896 is this stela of
Manepta. What is remarkable about it from the point of view of biblical studies is that it
preserves the earliest extra-biblical written reference to Israel as a people group. It's
helpful to realize that this stretch is about 10 feet tall, so it's a very, very imposing
slab of black granite.
