Trying something slightly new by including less editing (mainly because I have less time this week than usual). If anyone’s reading this, let me know what you think...
Superman 2025 has sparked a lot of debate around its box office and whether it should be called a success. Some say it needs $700 million to break even, others argue it is already profitable. In this video I break down the numbers, James Gunn’s response to critics, and why the domestic vs international box office matters so much for DC right now. I also share my own thoughts on the movie, how it compares to Man of Steel, and what this all means for the future of the DC universe.
TIMESTAMPS: 00:00 Break-even point explained 00:17 Superman 2025 budget and marketing 00:45 James Gunn responds to box office expectations 01:27 Is Superman 2025 already a success? 02:16 Domestic vs international box office 03:27 Why weak international numbers are a problem 04:25 DC’s upcoming movies and risks ahead 05:08 Supergirl release concerns
The general rule of thumb when deciding if a movie made a profit or not is taking its
budget and multiplying it by two and a half.
This accounts for things such as marketing and just the other general costs that comes
with making a movie.
And the reported budget of this most recent Superman was around $225 million, but Variety
says it also had another $125 million towards marketing globally.
So it either needs $350 million on the low end, or if you include the two and a half
multiplier with the $225 million reported budget, then it needs more like $560 million
to break even.
But the critical thinkers of Twitter and social media have called out James Gunn in saying
this needs more like $650 million to $700 million to break even, or to be considered
successful for DC.
Those seem like two different things for me, and it's kind of hard by some people's wording,
but overall people are thinking that it needs even more to be considered like this big success
for this new rebooted DC universe.
James Gunn has probably responded to some of these comments, both directly on Twitter
and also just interviews, saying things such as, this is not the riskiest endeavor in the
world.
Is there something riding on it?
Yeah, but it's not as big as people make it out to be.
They hear these numbers that the movie's only going to be successful if it makes $700 million
or something, and it's just complete and utter nonsense.
It doesn't need to be as big of a situation as people are saying.
He has also responded in saying that it doesn't make any sense logically for a first movie
in a franchise to be fighting against such high numbers to be considered successful,
that it doesn't need, because overall it doesn't need anywhere near $700 million to be considered
successful.
But either way, and taking James Gunn on his word, you can call this movie a success by
most standards because it's gained a pretty healthy $600 million so far in the box office
at the time of this recording.
And in general, I think it's a fairly liked movie with, I would be giving it like an eight
out of 10 average across everything.
I personally loved it.
I gave it a 4.5 out of five on Letterboxd.
I've never been much of a DC person, Superman person.
I like, I don't really remember Man of Steel, but I think I saw it at one point, but I love
this.
I loved every aspect of it.
However, I think those things are where the good news kind of ends.
Like all the Zack Snyder fanboys will be happy to know that this has not made as much money
as Man of Steel, which made around $670 million worldwide during its box office release.
But Superman 2025 is also still in theaters right now.
It could potentially catch up, but I mean, it's, it's kind of an uphill battle to get
to that level.
And it's already available on streaming.
Like you can buy it on your TV.
I don't know if it's actually on like streaming services, but you can buy it like for rent
and most people in this modern world are going to choose to do that over going to theaters,
especially for a movie that's a couple of weeks old at this point.
Man of Steel also shows that one of the biggest weaknesses of this Superman's release is it's
poor international numbers.
Actually between the two movies, they pretty much switch the percentage importance of domestic
and international.
Like this Superman has a stronger domestic in comparison to its total box office than
Man of Steel, but it had weaker international where Man of Steel had a higher international
percentage in comparison to its total box office number.
Now you could also argue that this movie, this Superman having a higher domestic number
than Man of Steel is equally a good thing.
It kind of counteracts the international of the Man of Steel, which I guess I couldn't
totally argue against.
I mean, logically that does make sense.
And I'm always happy for people going to theaters.
I mean, having good, strong domestic numbers is I think always a good thing for a homegrown
market.
But just knowing how badly the US movie industry is struggling right now, like AMC and, you
know, theaters and with China on the rise when it comes to their movies, I mean, they've
just released the biggest animated film of all time, having over 2 billion, I believe
domestically just, I mean, just in China.
So having weak international numbers for a big budget superhero movie is kind of a bad
thing.
Like we've already seen a lot of Marvel flops so far, despite having good reviews, but they
kind of have weak international numbers and they just, they can't make up for it because
the domestic market is just not there.
The theaters are not there.
So for DC that's trying to reboot, trying to start a completely new universe under James
Gunn, it's not a good sign that you're not pulling in the international numbers that
you would need to kind of survive in this market.
I mean, this is something like Fast and the Furious knows very well.
They have been seeing worse and worse domestic numbers, but they still kill it in places
like China.
I don't think you could argue most of their movies would be flopped.
I'm pretty sure none of them would be, maybe some of the spinoffs, but I'd have to go back
and look.
But again, if anyone can do it, it's probably James Gunn.
I love Guardians of the Galaxy.
And Superman, again, I think was really good and it is making a profit.
So it is a good sign and maybe people will connect more with these movies and if they
can start pumping up good domestic numbers on each film and just in general making good
movies where I think Marvel is kind of slipping a little bit, maybe it will somewhat swap
with the, I mean, Marvel has been with Endgame and everything.
The Avengers have been the superhero people that maybe now that they're kind of losing
their grip and making worse movies, James Gunn can come in, make good movies and dominate
more of that field, especially with some of the future movies coming out.
And clearly the Superman performing has already shown good signs for them because they're
already fast tracking a new Wonder Woman film and a Supergirl movie comes out in June of
next year.
Certain things must be going right that they feel like, you know, we'll sail ahead.
Batman part two is also coming out.
Their script got done and I think that's going to come out in around 2027.
But after that, I don't really see anything that's a clear home run, which also has me
a little worried.
Like Batman seems like the only clear thing that will make money.
Like there's a Clayface movie coming out next year.
I'm not sure about that.
A Robin animated organ story.
Maybe it's like, it's a toss up.
I mean, obviously like things like Guardians of the Galaxy, not very well known brand,
but James Gunn made great movies and they became very popular, but it seems like they're
kind of trying to do that multiple times over, which I don't know if it's sustainable, but
I guess we'll see.
Going back, Supergirl is coming out in June of next year and is the next film in this
new universe.
But even that is coming out at a time with Toy Story 5 coming out the week prior and
Minions 3 coming out the week after.
Amongst other things, I think like the Odyssey is also coming out the month after.
It's going to have struggles when it comes to the legs of having the box office performance.
And I think it would kind of do weak to start with.
I mean, a Supergirl movie right after Superman, I don't know, like especially after Superman
not being super popular.
Like they might have the delay, I feel like with Toy Story 5 and Minions 3, they're going
to get a lot of that kid audience, which obviously adults watch superhero movies.
I mean, I saw Superman, but it's a tough spot to be in around that time of year.
But yeah, I think that's all I got.