I reacted to Aaron Boone saying the Yankees have the fewest baserunning mistakes

Jomboy Media
138 followers
#mlb #baseball #yankees #sports #coaching
Use code JOMBOY2025 for 10% off your next SeatGeek order*: https://seatgeek.onelink.me/RrnK/JOMBOY2025. Sponsored by SeatGeek. *Restrictions apply. Max $20 discount
Follow all of our content on https://jomboymedia.com
BUY MERCH! https://shop.jomboymedia.com
LEAVE BREAKDOWN SUGGESTIONS HERE: http://bit.ly/BreakdownSuggestions
FB: https://www.facebook.com/JomboyMedia/
TW: http://www.twitter.com/jomboymedia
IG: http://www.instagram.com/JomboyMedia
Jomboy Media
Midtown Station
P.O Box 345
New York, NY 10018
#JMBaseball
Little different style breakdown today.
We're taking a look at the base running
of the Yankees because manager Aaron
Boon was on WF and he said this which is
turning a decent amount of heads.
>> Mistakes seem to continue throughout the
course of the year.
>> They seem to. I hear a lot of feels like
and seems to. Our base running has not
been an issue. like we've made out of 30
clubs, we've made the fewest pour outs
on the bases in Major League Baseball.
The fewest
>> that he's saying with certainty, the
fewest. Now, I looked up these stats a
while ago for our podcast talking Yanks,
and I just think it's interesting. And
if you're a fan of another team, you'll
see where your team stands in all of
these base running stats that we have
available to us. This breakdown is
brought to you by SeatGeek. The reason
why people are like, "No way. That's
true. That can't be true. We've seen the
games. Is because when the Yankees do
make base running mistakes, they are
dumb and they are loud. And the
announcers usually say, "What the hell
was that guy thinking?"
>> Tongue to third. That's the inning. It's
a double play. What was Chisum thinking?
Whatever Austin Wells was thinking. My
goodness.
>> Bad base running by the Yankees. You
can't do that with two ops. What a
mistake by BBas.
>> Goodness gracious.
>> Oh my.
>> That cannot happen. A lot of that cannot
happen on Talking Yanks. We've been
counting how many times they say that
cannot happen. It's up to 5 and a half
on the year. Let's go take a look at
your traditional base running stats.
This is Fan Graph's base running metric,
BSR. Milwaukee is the best. They have
15.1 BSR. And Minnesota is the worst.
just a little worse than San Francisco.
The Yankees fall 19th, which is okay.
It's not the fewest mistakes, but this
is take into account positive base
running as well, which Boon wasn't
claiming they are good. He's saying
we're not making mistakes. Let's take a
look at how the Yankees rated out last
year because last year they were
genuinely an awful base running team.
Sodto, Verdugo,
Clayber, Rizzo,
DJ at times were all pretty slow and not
good. So last year they rated out in Fan
Graph's base running as the worst club.
They were 30th out of 30. So they've
improved. If you go to baseball
reference, they're base running. And
then they have runs via extra bases,
runs via stolen bases, total attempts,
blah blah blah. Brewers again, number
one, and at the bottom is it the it's
the Pirates. Then the Giants 29th again.
So the Twins get better in uh baseball
so the Yankees are 17th. So again, not
not top half, but not bottom half. And
uh last year, if you want to look at
this metric, the Yankees wereun
dun 29th. Thank you, Blue Jays. Okay, so
they have improved base running
according to these metrics. Now, Boon is
saying they have made the fewest
mistakes out of 30 clubs, and he's
right, but it's a little more nuanced
than that. Uh I'm also just interested
thrown out. Let's see. Did they get the
Yankees get thrown out a lot? Thrown
out's interesting because teams that run
are usually good and then you take
chances, so you get thrown out. Um,
those are kind of weird. So, I'm going
to go to another website that is kind of
it's behind a pay wall, but they have a
ton of stats and they organize it. It's
called Eclipse, which called Inside
Edge. They have look at these metrics.
So if I click base running here, all
right, they have all of these negative
plays and then caught stealing, picked
off, runner overslid the bag.
I'm not going to count that as a poor
play. It's poor sliding, I guess, if
you're like habitual at it. Real quick,
let's see which player overslid has
overslid the bag the most this season.
And you can go to leaderboards and we
can go to um runner individual player.
Here's your leaderboard. Which player
has overslow? Is there one guy that
we're going to be like, "Whoa, dude.
Slow your roll." No. See, Neto's done it
twice. Young's done it twice. La's done
it twice. And that's that's the most
like Let's see. Is there a team? If we
go team, is there like a a team? The
sliding coach is teaching them wrong.
No, the most is six. So, I don't think
that's a stat that when Boone is
calculating poor plays, he's putting
that into the metric. So, I'm not going
to look at that one. Um, runner ran into
an out unnecessarily.
That definitely would go into poor base
running. Runner should have run but
didn't. I think that is also poor base
running. Um, they also have coach
impacted runner poor senden but it
doubles up. So, like runner ran into
unnecessary out, that play is also going
to be in bad send.
Not every unnecessary out is going to be
in a coach's fault, but all of the ones
that are coaches fault also. So, I'm not
going to click that one. Um, and then
pick offs and caught stealing. So, let's
just look. Runner ran into unnecessary
out. And we can search this and look at
the leaderboard by team.
And you can see that the Pirates have
run into the most unnecessary outs on
the year according to Inside Edge. And
then as you scroll down, where do our
Yankees land? They land 21st. 11
unnecessary
outs. All right. So, that's not the
fewest in baseball like Boon was saying,
but
it's not the most. it's not enough to
have this narrative they do have about
them. Uh what I did was I copied all
this info and we watched some videos and
then I put them in a Google sheet. So we
have the caught stealing, the picked
off, ran into unnecessary outs, should
have run but didn't. And then I combined
them into poor plays. Now I talk to
Aaron Boon once a week on Talking Yanks.
I know how his brain works and I
somewhat agree with him that a caught
stealing
isn't bad base running. You want to try
and steal. Now, obviously you can pick
apart like don't try to steal third with
two outs unless you're guaranteed to
have it. Like you can pick apart caught
steelings, but I think the way that
Boone and the Yankees analytics
department is calculating this is they
are saying no. If you're trying to steal
and you get thrown out, that's the risk
you knew you were going to take. It's
not a mistake. It's not bad base
running. So, they're not counting that.
So, I think what the Yankees are doing
when they're counting this stat is
they're counting how many times we been
picked off, how many times we ran into
unnecessary outs, how many times have we
should have run, but we didn't. All
right. So, I tallied up those three
categories and we're just calling it
poor plays. And the interesting thing we
find is when you say who made the most,
it's the Orioles. And when you scroll
down to who made the least, it is your
Yankees
and Athletics tied with 12. That's the
number that they are getting at. But but
but
the A's have zero. Should have run but
didn't. The Yankees have one. So I would
guess now after I did this that they
aren't counting should have run but
didn't. And if I take that out of the
equation and we take 12 and we minus the
one, it gives them 11, which would give
them the fewest poor base running outs
in all of baseball. Exactly what Aaron
Boon is saying. But there's an issue
with that. It's not a big issue, but
there is an issue with that because this
says the Yankees have been picked off
zero times. zero times. And I made a
whole video on this last year, Jimmy's
three things, because I was like, wait,
the way we count pickoffs and stolen
bases and catcher steals and catcher
throwing is just all wrong. Like all the
data is not what you think it's telling
you. If you've watched the Yankees,
they've been picked off. A lot of the
can't happens are times when they've
been picked off. Here's where it gets
interesting because you've got plays
like this play.
That's bad base running. And in our
brain, he got picked off. And even the
announcer says pick off. But if the
runner gets thrown out trying to
advance, it's not a pickoff. So the
Yankees have never gotten out trying to
dive back to the base and be safe at
first. If they're on first, second of
luck, they always just take off for the
next base, which means those plays go
down as a caught stealing, which the
Yankees and Boone do not count as poor
plays because trying to steal is good.
Uh, and zero pickoffs,
which is interesting. You can see the
Red Sox had the sign here. You can see
the catcher's glove just dropped. You
see that catcher's glove drop? That's
the sign where the catcher is telling
him, "Go, he's got a lead. He's about to
steal." So, he was trying to steal
there. They just caught him flatfooted.
The next play, this one is when
Dominguez got caught sleeping and he
forgot the amount of outs and gets
thrown out. That goes in the book as a
caught stealing, which means it does not
go in the book as a pickoff nor a ran
into unnecessary out. Same with this
one. It's three and two, two outs. So
Wells is taking off on the pitch. He
leaves too early. He gets Vulpi in a
rundown and he's out. That does not go
down as a ran into unnecessary out. Does
not go down as a pickoff. It goes down
as a caught stealing which the Yankees
are saying are not poor plays because
caught stealing is a risk you take. So
that's where the caveat is there. You
have this one. Judge got technically
picked off but he's stealing. So that's
a caught stealing. Vulpi had one against
the Pirates earlier in the year where
same thing I think you see the catcher's
glove just drop. Uh, actually it just
kind of closed and that's the catcher
saying boom, pick him off and he's off
and running. And then you had this one,
which I don't know why this one doesn't
go down as a catcher pickoff, but it's
not in the book as a catcher pickoff,
but that's another one where Rice is
kind of just taking too big of a lead
for no reason. So,
if you add them, that's five plays. If
you were to add the five plays to the 11
that the Yankees have, then they would
get 16, which would make them have the
third best at
not running into poor outs, not the
first best or whatever, however you want
to say it. If you want to see where your
team stands, let's see. The team that
has been picked off the most is the
Orioles. I have um I have the bottom
eight teams in red, the top eight team
or bottom six teams in red, top six
teams in green. Um and these aren't
really they're not really insightful
because it's just your team makeup. Like
the Brewers run a ton so they get thrown
out the most. It's like an averages
game. Um run into unnecessary outs.
You're also you got the Pirates up
there, but you have the White Socks and
the Athletics down here. The Yankees are
down here. Yankees are the worst of good
teams. Then the Astros 13. Some teams
don't run cuz they bashed the ball. Uh
should have run but didn't.
Rangers station to station.
So it's kind of interesting because the
Yankees have so many plays that made you
go, "What the hell is that?" The montage
I showed you at the beginning highlights
them. The other really bad plays are
included like when Jazz did this and got
doubled off thinking that he had figured
out the bluff and was going to bluff the
bluff and then just got doubled off.
That is part of ran into unnecessary
out. Also, uh, Bbos when he forgot
Ronald Akuna Jr. has a great arm and
just didn't run hard the whole way and
didn't slide and got thrown out. That is
included in one of the poor plays they
have made. So, I just wonder if it's
because they're the Yankees, it's
louder, or it's because the the quality
of bad they provide when they run into a
pore out is just so much bigger than any
other team when they do it. This one was
crazy. Like, Sodtorm doesn't have a good
arm. Vulpi thought he could tag up from
second to third on him and he just
triple hopped it. And then this one,
obviously, Wells forgets the outs and is
caught sleeping and is out. That counted
towards the bad plays. So, I just
thought it was interesting because Boon
says that he says it so matterof factly.
Where's he getting his numbers from? I
think that's where he's getting his
numbers from. Let's go watch some of the
other teams bad plays. That I think is
interesting. Runner ran into unnecessary
out
submit.
Leaderboard.
I wonder if there's if there's one
runner that has done it the most.
That would be kind of interesting to me.
There's one runner that has done this
far and away more than anyone else. You
would just think it's a speedster. No.
Toen has five, then Isbull has four.
Okay, let's let's um let's do it by
team. So, the Pirates have 20. They have
the most runner ran into unnecessary
outs on the team.
Let's watch them and see if we can find
any that are as gap
as the Yankees.
That's just Yeah, I mean Yeah. trying to
advance to third. Okay. Five nothing
game. Runner on first.
This ball is off the wall in the gap and
he's going to try and score. Fam
rounding third. The throw home.
So, they're just saying he shouldn't
have went home. It was kind of close.
That's not as
It's not like a mental mistake.
[Music]
Thought the throw was going to throw go
to third. It went to second. He's out.
That's
still kind of a Oh, got a freeze on the
line drive. Was he off on the run? Cut
up again. Three nothing game. Runner on
second. Ground ball to short. Same
thing. Why are they doing that?
Is that the same runner, too? It is.
And here's another one with Horowits.
Here's another one with Horitz. Let's
see this one. Is this going to be the
same thing, too?
No,
he's just going home on a good arm. No,
not even him. See, they're baiting a
throw there. I think that's something
they try to do. So, none of these for
the Pirates have been nearly as bad as
the Yankees. Like big blunders.
What was that?
He just didn't think that was going to
get caught. That one's pretty bad.
Okay, here we go. Runner on second. No
outs.
The throw comes in again. and trail
runner thinking they're going to throw
it and get the lead runner and they get
the trail runner. Really actually just
it's just good defense to take care of
the trail runner. What's this? Oh, what
a play, dude. That was I forgot this was
early in the season. That was such a
good play.
Faked him out.
No, that's just again like Trail Runner
trying to get there. I guess the Pirates
haven't learned that certain teams will
throw out the Trail Runner. Didn't
freeze on a line drive. That seems to be
an issue. Maybe they just get way too
big of leads for line drives.
Here we go. Runner on second. Padres's
we come up throwing. Cruz has speed and
the trail runner again. So the P the
Pirates it's all freezing on line drives
and the trail runner. The two Horitz
ones just running the third on a ball
shortstop were bad. What's this one
trying to tag up on Tioscar?
I think he was trying to catch him
sleeping. Cruz on second cut batting
and just takes off on contact to third.
These feel more like the pirates don't
have a scout
to stop them from doing this or they're
just part of their fabric. It's just
trail runner again.
Wow.
Got 10 to six game, two on. Wow, that
was a nice stop. I thought it was going
to roll past the outfielder and I think
so did the runner. And that was an
unnecessary risk. I agree with the
label, but I I don't hate that one.
What was that?
We're just going to try and take an
extra bag here. No, it's the Trail
Runner again.
Pirates. What the [ __ ]
Don't get Don't tell me this is going to
be another Trail Runner. It is. It is.
No way. They have to be being coached
this.
That's so many.
Did he think this was going to be a home
run and then he has to bust it to second
to get his double and then he's out?
Seems like that's the case.
All right. 3-1 pitch, two-1 game.
And all right, so the Pirates boil down
to three things. They never think the
the team is going to get them if they're
the trail runner trying to advance on a
throw to another base or they just think
they're always going to throw to the
lead base.
They just run to third on contact even
if the ball is hit to the left side and
they take too some of them take too big
of leads on line drives and get doubled
up. None of those were headline worthy
as headline worthy as the Yankees who
have like forgotten the outs four times.
Dominguez,
Wells, Jazz,
and then Rice has two,
five and a half times the Yankee. So,
Yankees have five and a half that are
headline worthy, but their their
collection isn't that large where like
the Pirates have the most, but none of
those are like baffling. They're just it
as a group they're kind of baffling.
Let's watch the Orioles.
See if any of these are going to baffle
us. We got 19 from the Orioles. I'll
speed through it.
So, he took off on contact. Runner on
third. Kind of a contact play in the
11th inning. It was a line drive, so he
gets doubled up.
So, baseball explanation for it.
Another contact play and just ran out.
Two two pitch.
What was that?
Why is he going back?
He takes a huge lead.
Why does he commit to the slide? Why
doesn't he get in a pickle?
That one's kind of weird. It's not a
brain fart,
but but kind of weird.
This has got to be Holiday just trying
to stretch it to a double cuz he's fast
and he gets thrown out. Yeah, you can't
hate on that. It was a close play, too.
Like, technically, yes. Oh, look. The
Yankees stop someone. Is it the same
thing? Just get by. Um
Oh, goes to third. And this was actually
a nice play by Timmy Hill. Side side
wind
and then Jazz gets him. Yeah, not
horrible. Not great
line drive. Too big of a lead. Doubled
up. That's common.
First and third. What the [ __ ]
Oh, that's greedy. That's just greedy by
the Orioles.
Here we go. Ball to left field rounding
third and trail runner.
Oh, and then he that's when he tried to
get in the way. I forgot about that.
That was funny.
Hot shot. Runner on first. He tried to
go to third. Do they get the trail
runner here?
No. Whoa.
just really slow
deep fly ball. No one on base. So is he
trying to make this a triple
then he's just out
again? Not nothing like forgetting the
outs or what Jazz did. That's a nice
play.
Why do they have that?
Where's the bad base running there?
Kirst stops running on his way to first.
Oh, that would be frustrating. Why' he
do that?
What?
Okay. Kirstad
clean it up.
Pass ball. They tell him to run. Smart
by the catcher. Throws out the trail
runner, not the lead runner. Gets the
out.
Base is loaded. What happens here?
I did a breakdown on this play. They
didn't know if he caught it or not.
That is such a good play
hard contact. You're trying to score on
that. I don't really hate that.
I mean, did he catch that or did he not
catch that? I think that's the confusion
that they rule it not a catch and then
they're all confused and they get out.
So far, the Orioles have not had any
that are as blunderous as the Yankees
five.
Just taking the extra base. See what
this one is.
Runner on first out the right fields. He
was stealing on the pitch. He gets
doubled up.
No one on and he just didn't run out of
the box. Or does he try to take the
extra? Oh my goodness. Way to go. Kirky
and Sherzer.
That's awesome.
Line drive didn't freeze. So, after
watching all of the Pirates and the
Orioles who have collected the most
unnecessary outs, I think the reason the
narrative exists is because I think if
you take your top five biggest blunders,
each team takes their top five biggest
blunders on the base paths, no one even
stands a chance against the Yankees top
five. The Yankees have the least. They
only have 11. Every other team has more,
but their top five,
they'll take any other team's top five
down as [ __ ] awful base running. And
thanks for sticking around if you did. I
know this one was different. I got a
bunch of others queued up. Lip readings,
ejections, the works, but sometimes I
like doing just baseball stuff and this
was a little baseball stuff. It's
brought to you by SeatGeek. You can get
10% off any ticket by using code jambboy
2025. That's code Johnboy2025 at
seatgeeek. Appreciate you. Send it to
your friend who loves base running
blunders and base running insight. Your
friend that loves base running data the
most. Share this with
